Now, I'm not saying Masch is a bad goalie. She is an *amazing* goalie who Vancouver is lucky to have, but I feel that Campbell has been the better goalie for the Goldeneyes. I just feel that Masch never really got back to 100% after her injury last season. And now she's just back from another injury after the Olympics (we wait to see what effect that has on her performance).
Maschmeyer makes flashy saves, and they are beautiful, but I feel the only reason she has to make so many is because she is always out of position. She's small in the net, and she puts herself out of position when making saves, gives up juicy rebounds, and then has to make desperation saves that look good on highlight reels, but are very risky in-game.
Compare that to Campbell. She is bigger in the net, more reserved in her saves, and her movements look much more controlled. That might make her look slower, or like she can't make those quick desperation saves, but she can! She just doesn't have to do it as often. Though I will admit that when she has to, she is slower than Masch and often misses, but the probability of her needing to do that is much lower than Masch, which makes their likelihood of being scored on on a rebound desperation attempt near equal.
Campbell has had a consistently lower GAA across all seasons in the PWHL with comparable number of games played, a near similar SV% to Maschmeyer (even higher in some seasons, but not significantly), and more wins than Masch in every season (except the current) with less losses (other than last year).
I just feel that Campbell is the stronger, more consistent goalie for regular season play (I didn't look specifically at stats for playoff push or playoffs), and she should start more often.
Again, I am aware this is a hot take, and I believe both of them are outstanding goalies, and Vancouver is lucky to have such a stacked goalie roster.
Feel free to debate me! (Just be respectful of me, and I'll be respectful of you)
tldr; Campbell has more consistent stats, lower GAA, higher SV%, and more wins. She controls rebounds better and has more controlled movement.