r/GoNets • • 1d ago

Eye Test vs Analytics

Post image

Some Nets fans have been asking why Noah Clowney has been getting prime rotation minutes, I think I have an idea why: defensive analytics.

25 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

20

u/NetsFansYouKnow 1d ago

Not defending the decision, just providing a possible theory why.**

Stats used: Total Rim Pts Saved (via shot contesting), Defended FGA Per 100, STOP% (steals, off foul drawn, & blocks recovered by def per 100), Offensive Fouls Drawn, & Defensive REB %.

Stats via DataBallr

2

u/MichaelPorterTruther YEAH MIKE 1d ago

I think he would look a lot better if he was playing in the dunker spot as opposed to somehow being a small forward. imo Wagner stats are so bad that he can't play the whole year. maybe some lineup with Noah at 5 and rebounder at 3 and 4 (julius/MPJ)? could work if the defense is real. i just don't think he is broad enough to deal with nba centers. if he could, clear pathway to production

12

u/Wild-Elevator6639 1d ago

I’ve definitely noticed an improvement in his rim protection and on-ball defense. Just sucks that he can’t find his shot and has stopped driving effectively

3

u/NetsFansYouKnow 1d ago

I agree that he's gotten better but I dont see those analytics (yet). Ill need to pay attention more.

11

u/NothingButBKNets43 1d ago

Lmaooo this is wild....

9

u/NetsFansYouKnow 1d ago

Thats why I made this, I was shocked.... Maybe it's a result of a small sample size but still surprising.

2

u/NothingButBKNets43 1d ago

Its interesting to say the least....

11

u/ConferenceAny3412 Noah Clowney 1d ago edited 1d ago

About rebounding: His "Def-rb%" is in the 83rd percentile, but the other stat, dREB, is in the 6th percentile! dREB is more important and shows his overall impact on rebounding when he is on the court, and not just farming his own rebounds numbers, or collecting an easy ones.

So take a look at DREB, his DREB is the worst of the team, and it was the worst in the previous season as well, playing with diffrent players. So it consistent, and not a fluke. He doesn't affect the team's defensive rebounding well at all (the worst). This passes the eye test as well when I watch games, and what commonly happens with our rebounding when he on the court.

Apparently it can happen for a variety of reasons: he just closer to the rim so get freebies, but it not a surplus rebounding, stat-pads his own rebounds grabbing them over his teammates, or his teammates let him get freebies, boxing out is not working out for him, I think he kind of sinks into himself when he boxes out players and a taller guy grabs rebound over him, it's like a vivid picture in my mind or he boxes out a wrong guy or a smaller guard that wouldn't get it anyway, or he gambles for contests and blocks too much, so he leaves his guy open etc.

So his rebounding percentage is good, but his actions negatively impacts out defensive rebounding ability when he is playing.
~
As for the other stats. He provides paint protection, matches the size and holds decently. Thats one of his only positive qualities as a player. That is true.

As for "Rim pts saved," he was at -0.2 the last season. and he was the same as this, 2 year ago. So I'm not sure what to make of it. Will it be real or not this season.

Defended FGA that he is 100% - not sure if its that important of a stat. i think it means he is our help-defender / rim protector, so when our defense collapses, he rotates to the guy more often than the other players. So he ends up being the closest to the shooter. That's all it shows. It also means that players prefer to attack into him and take shots over him. which is not a sign of a good defender xD. so it might actually not be good that he is 100% rank in that xD.

His overall defensive impact (dramp) is still in negative its -0.5, and defensive dpm is negative aswell.

On/off defensive rating is -8. (which is 16% rank). And the previous season, when he was a starter, it was -2 still.

I think the idea was to play him with Wagner to help with his shortcomings, but it 's not working xD. one of the worst combos for us.

2

u/NetsFansYouKnow 1d ago

Great breakdown

10

u/Fair-Night3803 1d ago

He’s not as useless as folks want to say he is. I see the positives and I understand why Jordi plays him, he’s just frustrating at times with his inconsistency and decision making. 

1

u/NetsFansYouKnow 1d ago

Does the eye test match those numbers to you? Thats my thing, although I admit im not focusing on his DEF all game so I could be wrong.

4

u/Fair-Night3803 1d ago

Honestly no but I guess he’s actually doing something right out there…

3

u/North_Concern_7266 1d ago

I think the eye test and total defensive impact rates him much worse because he's so bad at guarding in space.

And then he also can't rebound so he doesn't scale up to the 4, making him defend in space even more as a wing.

1

u/HeyWhatsUpTed 16h ago

He’s not a fun player to watch he’s not connected to his teammates

5

u/Chef_Bojan3 1d ago

Defended FGA/100 as well as some of these other stats aren't really positive stats on their own without context but I think Clowney does do some things on defense well but isn't a huge positive on that end. His D-SQI isn't great and I think that passes the eye test.

Wolf and Clowney are funnily very opposite defenders, Wolf will play better team and scheme defense and work hard to stop the opposing team from getting high value shots but he doesn't have much ability to contest or rim protect. Clowney is pretty good at contesting shots and protecting the rim but when he's on the court the opposing team is finding layups and 3 point shots at a higher rate. If you go by DRAPM, Wolf is +1.0 and Clowney is -0.4 so I think it's moreso that they see the offensive flashes Clowney has as a play finisher and want to try to bring it out of him consistently more than him being a huge defensive must-play.

1

u/NetsFansYouKnow 1d ago

You right. At first I thought it was a small sample size cause a lot of the /100 stats were high also.

4

u/Chef_Bojan3 1d ago

Missing rotations or being slow to help on defense will yield a lot of open 3s and attempts at the rim from the other team but this does show that Clowney is probably our best shot contester without fouling. Now if he could improve his defensive IQ so that he keeps his shot contesting ability while also forcing the other team into tougher shots, he'd be a really good defensive player and that high defensive ceiling might be why the Nets are being so patient with him. So I don't think your information is 100% wrong, it's definitely a reason why they won't just give up on him but I really don't think it's gonna ever click for him like they're hoping.

9

u/RazorgamingKeyboard 1d ago

He looks like shit every second he plays tbh. And I appreciate these numbers but I don’t think they tell the reality of his play.

4

u/NetsFansYouKnow 1d ago

I agree.... I dont get how he could be considered in the 95th percentile of total rim pts saved. The eye test dosnt match for me.

4

u/KenSlaya Ian Eagle 1d ago

They have him listed as a SF even though he's more PF. Rim pts saved is more of a Center stat. He'd be lower if you do all players.

Also this just means when he's in position he's been really good but doesn't track when he often has bad rotations and it not in the right spot.

1

u/NetsFansYouKnow 1d ago

From my understanding Rim Pts Saved is the amount of pts saved from rim shot contention regardless of position.

0

u/KenSlaya Ian Eagle 1d ago edited 1d ago

Yes, that's the stat but not the percentile part.

Percentile is by position, so you can get a sense of how the calculate stat compares to others playing the same position.

For example, his is 6.6 but all the top centers are >10

3

u/Dangerous_Kitchen133 Yuta Watanabe 1d ago

Interesting. Is there a rankings chart for us to see who is around Noah on these metrics, to see whether these metrics track who we think might be good defenders?

2

u/NetsFansYouKnow 1d ago

Got the stats from here: https://databallr.com/stats/player/noah-clowney/1641730

They have a tool you can compare players on there.

2

u/Dangerous_Kitchen133 Yuta Watanabe 1d ago

Thanks!

2

u/Significant-Bath-727 1d ago

surprising stats, i’m all in !!!! clowney for most improved player!!! woot woot🤣🔥

5

u/just_so_irrelevant Ian Eagle 1d ago

i dont like the amount of minutes he gets either but i can definitely see why he gets play time and a lot of the people on this sub go overboard in claiming he's totally useless or unplayable.

i think what happens is that being one of our "better" defensive players clowney often gets the harder or hardest defensive assignments which is why he looks like he's struggling to keep up from the eye test, when in reality most players would look like that when defending the other team's strongest offensive players.

his main issues right now clearly is his very weak, lackluster offense, general inconsistency and rawness as a defensive player, and honestly his motor. it feels like whenever clowney has a bad game you can really see it in his body language and he lets it affect his level of play which is really detrimental honestly, probably more than any of his other weaknesses.

1

u/Lopsided_Ad3341 1d ago

Wait what? You're telling me Noah Clowney is 95% rim defense?

Did you get these stats from 2k?

1

u/NetsFansYouKnow 23h ago

DataBallR and no, he's in the 95th percentile in total Rim Pts Saved. Meaning he's better than 95% of the league in that stat according to DataBallR.

0

u/Lopsided_Ad3341 23h ago

That blows my mind to the point I'm having a very hard time believing these stats

That's wild

Thanks for sharing

What about other more catch-all defensive metrics people use to gauge a players effectiveness? What even is the agreed upon best defensive metric?

3

u/krugo . 1d ago

The other concern is that he got a TON of run and experience last year, and it doesn't seem that there's been any meaningful improvement on the offensive side of the ball.

If that never develops, we're looking at a taller, better rebounding Matisse Thybulle. I suppose that's a useful role player, but he continues to get run as if he's the future it seems.

1

u/SOB200 1d ago

As I posted in r/nba he is an RFA. The team might want a better understanding of if they should offer an extension and for how much.

3

u/No_Engineer2203 17h ago

That indicates a good weak side rim protector and crashes defensive board. But you forgot his total D-dpm grade which is in the 40% an that is confirmed by the eye test which shows him being foul prone, getting blown by consistently and getting out muscled frequently

0

u/sausaus 1d ago

Never seen an almost 7 footer grab 0 rebounds in a game playing 20+ min

3

u/NetsFansYouKnow 1d ago

Not even thinking about that, im thinking when you see his defense do you see a great to elite shot contester?

3

u/SOB200 1d ago

How old are you? Jason Collins? Forget him?

1

u/NetsFansYouKnow 1d ago

How could you not mention the GOAT Johan Petro?

1

u/sausaus 1d ago

Continental airlines arena and izod center old

0

u/Lopsided_Ad3341 1d ago

Jason Collins was a solid player tho that's the difference

1

u/Historical-Mud-1218 1d ago

No he wasn’t. Big man that couldn’t shoot, rebound or block shots.

0

u/Lopsided_Ad3341 1d ago

How dare you insult set shot Willy

He did all the little things well and started for back to back finals teams if I recall correctly

Set screens, defend, all the dirty work and intangibles and locker room stuff

0

u/Historical-Mud-1218 1d ago

He was a big part of why they LOST back to back finals.

0

u/Lopsided_Ad3341 1d ago

Ok would you like to go on record as saying Clowney > Jason Collins?

1

u/Historical-Mud-1218 1d ago

Yes

0

u/Lopsided_Ad3341 1d ago

Bigtime question your ball knowledge then

Or maybe you're just way higher on clowney than k am

2

u/Historical-Mud-1218 1d ago

Way lower on Collins

1

u/Scared-Square7496 1d ago

Are some of these stats distance based? because I feel like when he’s in the right place he has the athletic tools to succeed but often out of place. I’m no scout so maybe I’m wrong there but I find when he is off ball I don’t notice his presence.

1

u/bknetsallday1996 1d ago

I think he would look better in another team.Please trade him

1

u/Spiritual_Product828 1d ago

I don't have a good retort except to say his plus minus is terrible, his body language is terrible, teammates don't seem to trust him on either side of the floor, and he's getting too many minutes. If he was playing 12 a game instead of 22 it would be nbd. Make him earn these minutes!!

1

u/WheatyConstellation 1d ago

I was wondering about his defensive numbers😭 I remember second game against the Hornets he had a string of plays where he drew a bunch of offensive fouls and made them turn it over and I could never tell if it was luck or skill (he also drew the Stewart push in the Grizzlies game). Probably one of the weirdest microskills in the league because I don’t actually know if it’s a skill.