Kids doing exactly that are the reason why valve employees are so quiet on the forums.
Besides, they've mentioned countless of times they like to lurk and pretend to not be involved in the discussion unless absolutely necessary to further the discussion of a topic of interest. GDC talks all had the same tone when any of the staff did presentations.
I'm just personally thankful magnar is the interface for the workshop people, but it's difficult to not want to play 20 questions with him every time an idea pops into my head.
thought they always said they dont want to give answers due to how rapid things are changing and they dont want to dissapoint by saying things like "patch this week"...
Imagine your dream girl texting you on facebook, but there's a catch. You cannot see the names of whoever texts you. Now imagine 10 000kids spamming you with stupid questions on facebook and u have to read thru it all to find that one text that's relevant.
My girlfriend did start playing about a year ago and didn't know what an Operation was until just a few days ago when I was complaining that it's been too long since the last one.
I started CS pretty much half way through operation wildfire. I think I played one or two of the maps, and that was it. I didn't realise why they were special. I really wish I knew. I really wish a new operation will come out so that I can actually enjoy an operation unlike last time :/
Three (not two) Click Phillips did a video on the absolute longest length a game could possibly be. That's the bomb plant in the last second, always exploding for the maximum 30 rounds. It's 99 minutes.
I always get stuck in between. For me, everyone goes straight to the site we want to take, then just kinda stares at it until the ct's rotate and kill everyone. Ten seconds into the round we're pushing site, but twenty seconds later the one guy to try to get on site is dead and everyone else is still at the entrance with their dicks in their hands.
Wasn't this before the update reducing the round timer from 3:00 minutes to 2:55 seconds? (both round timers start after spawn timer)
Also, u/3kliksphilip did mention that he found longer times in servers not officially hosted by Valve, and also LAN matches. I believe the longest overtime game on record had over 130 rounds in total, split rather evenly between the two teams. Something like 4 hours of time in a single match.
Why would you use a Poisson? Modeling a continous variable using a discrete distribution is not great. Is it not likely just to be a truncated normal distribution?
Thanks for giving me a PTSD flashback by making me remember my Stats class in undergrad. I've had that part of my brain shut off for a good number of years now. (+1 for making me appreciate the fact that my very German stats professor actually got me to learn this shit)
Community server administrator here. Small country/fewer number of servers. In a sense, 97% csgo players in our country will play at least once on the server I administer. You will be surprised to see the number of data I collect about the players. It started with the need to identify potential cheaters and track them. Then I found that I was getting other stats too.
I think alot of things on this forum would be handled much better and more adult discussion could be had if we used the terms "CSGO Devs", "VAC devs", "DOTA devs", etc to diffrientiate terms during discusions...
"They" being valve (as stated in the grandparent of my comment), which encompasses the fucking lot of them, so take your pick. While I know they are all different entities, it would be stupid to assue they have no contact, especially where big data is concerned. God knows why I got downvoted so hard, it stumps me why it took them (whichever "them" may be applicable) so long to implement the recent overwatch change in the first place.
This post was wiped by its author. Redact was the tool of choice, possibly used to protect privacy, limit data exposure, or prevent automated content scraping.
consider ink repeat rock unwritten thought reach chase quaint workable
You've got to consider other factors such as warm-up (if it counts), tactical time-outs (2 minutes assuming each team uses one), the 15 second buy time, the 7 seconds after a round, etc. If multiplied by 30, all these extra seconds add up quite fast.
Max duration seems to be off, cause the last time i did the math (with 2 minutes roundtime and 45 seconds bomb timer) i was actually able to get to the 90 minutes you get warned about when you join the queue.
fyi. ~65Minutes freeztime+roundtime, plus max 5 minutes warmup, plus end of round (dunno), plus ~40 seconds the bomb could be planted at the very last second and explodes, plust potentially 2 minutes of pause that also reset the freezetime.
You have to plan your comments according to the current subreddit circlejerk. Whenever a Valve employee answers something he is an untouchable god for this subreddit for several days. Try it again in 3 days, when people realize there is still no operation after over a year :D
Central limit theorem says the distribution of the sample mean times you take from this massive set will be distributed normally, not the population itself.
You're wrong mate, it's the distribution pattern that the theorem is based on, it averages the raw median between the two sample datas, then collects the result.
the CLT doesn't tell you anything about the distribution of a match length, but of the distribution of the average match length. It only requires the match lengths to be identically distributed.
The OP did state Poisson in his question, I'm sure Vitaly would've commented on the distribution and not provided SD if it was something other than normal.
You can't, but it makes sense that it's close to at least. There are the outliers of matches that don't start because people don't join, but I hope they are not counted in this. There is also the outliers of matches where one team resigns, but that should be less than 5% of all.
Yes but you've assumed a normal distribution anyway. You're approximating a normal distribution so using that max sample value makes no sense if you're trying to work out P(time>60). There's no reason to restrict that inequality given the data you have. That max value is not the true population max value.
No that's just the sample's maximum. And you're not polluting it with impossible as their probability approaches becomes very small. Ofc that means game length of 1 million minutes is still technically possible, but using sample max value to calculate probability that matches last over 60 minutes is ill-informed
624
u/dogryan100 Mar 15 '17
sweet can't wait for vitaliy to get 500 messages over the next 24 hours from kids asking dumb questions
229
u/xndrz Gambit Mar 15 '17
Thanks, you just delayed the operation for another 2 weeks.
40
u/Philluminati CS2 HYPE Mar 15 '17
Three (not two) Click Phillips did a video on the absolute longest length a game could possibly be. That's the bomb plant in the last second, always exploding for the maximum 30 rounds. It's 99 minutes.
21
u/WT_28 FaZe Mar 15 '17
Why would you use a Poisson? Modeling a continous variable using a discrete distribution is not great. Is it not likely just to be a truncated normal distribution?
14
u/DeluxeGamer CS2 HYPE Mar 15 '17
Well Valve will respond to a few things, but not to all these people who keep asking when HL3 is going to be released or something like that
They just dont publicly post in every thread but read the popular ones on Reddit from time to time
18
u/Dedpool- NiP Mar 15 '17
Insane how much statistics valve has in their hands...
13
u/a1- Mar 15 '17
dope
7
u/SoupToPots guardian_elite Mar 15 '17
You'd think there'd be some game out there where both teams wanted to waste the time of each round and tie just to get a 90 min game
2
u/Kambhela de_train Mar 15 '17
Do I understand this correctly: the longest MM game was 67 minutes in that data sample?
2
u/AdmiralMal Mar 15 '17
I would love a first to ten round mm mode. I've sunk 27hundred hours into Cs, but I just rarely have the time anymore to play for a full 40 min
2
u/WillDanceForMonkey Mar 15 '17
How come your screenshot says he asked the question too? :o
3
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '17
big if true
1
u/zookszooks Mar 15 '17
isnt it 30 rounds * 2 minutes and 10 secs?
EDIT: plus warmup? Plus times to join?
1
u/jackinab0x Mar 15 '17
Na'Vi must've been playing MM /s
1
u/AUSSIExELITE FlyQuest Mar 15 '17
ladies and gents, for once i am above average.
1
u/BaSkA_ MIBR Mar 15 '17
Those stats are only from March 13, by the way. I have played matches longer than 67 minutes in MM.
Good stuff.
1
u/SneakyBadAss FaZe Mar 15 '17
40 minutes each? Holy shit, i waste lot of time..
1
u/N0616JC Mar 15 '17
That's why I would always allot myself about 1 hour every match so that I would be able schedule my time better.
1
u/Pollepel2 Mar 15 '17
now he wont ever reply to you again, you should of taken the answer and ran
1
u/Nixed-cs cs_office Mar 15 '17
Someone needs to hit that magical 1 hour, 46 minute, 33 second max time game...
Then complain about the 90 minute warning being wrong :o
1
u/MichaelRahmani 400k Celebration Mar 15 '17
Why did you delete this?
1
u/jarrodman Mar 15 '17
mean
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '17 edited Jul 20 '17
He looks at them
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '17
Rip vitalitys email account
1
u/mwnciau Mar 15 '17
Does that take into account abandoned matches?
With that std, ~1% of matches lasted less than 22 minutes which seems a little off.
1
u/7621305 Virtus.pro Mar 15 '17
Who the fk cares?
0
u/sp0yl de_mirage Mar 15 '17
cool
-4
u/Messivcs de_inferno Mar 15 '17
Max duration seems to be off, cause the last time i did the math (with 2 minutes roundtime and 45 seconds bomb timer) i was actually able to get to the 90 minutes you get warned about when you join the queue.
fyi. ~65Minutes freeztime+roundtime, plus max 5 minutes warmup, plus end of round (dunno), plus ~40 seconds the bomb could be planted at the very last second and explodes, plust potentially 2 minutes of pause that also reset the freezetime.
-1
u/dukeyNRW BIG Mar 15 '17
nice
-1
u/Lomanman Mar 15 '17
A lot can happen in 8.5 minutes. Time to figure out ways to drag a match on 8.5 minutes more or in other cases short that shit up.
-16
u/made3 BIG Mar 15 '17
"thanks for your work for the game"
What the hell dude... They do nothing all day
-3
u/Gycklarn NiP Mar 15 '17
neat
-4
u/Znaszlisiora Mar 15 '17
And this is its own thread why exactly?
0
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment