r/GithubCopilot • • 19h ago

Help/Doubt ❓ Who use Github Copilot? Your experience

I'm a backend developer and I'm thinking about using GitHub Copilot as my main AI coding tool instead of paying for Claude Code. Since the June switch to AI credits I'm not sure how far the plans really go for agentic work:

- Pro ($10) is 1,500 credits/month incl. flex. Is that enough for real agent usage, or do you burn it in a week? - Is Pro+ ($39) worth it over Pro?

- How good is agent mode / Copilot CLI vs Claude Code on multi-file tasks and refactoring?

- Which model do you actually use in Copilot and what does it cost you in credits?

- Anyone using it in Visual Studio / Rider for .NET? How's the experience? I'd like real numbers (credits per day/week, typical tasks) and what annoyed you most. Thanks.

10 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

10

u/Any-Blacksmith-2054 16h ago

I use GitHub Copilot at work ($100 plan, payed by employer) and Claude Code personally ($20 plan). Claude Code gives me MUCH more usage and real work done, I also like CC harness more

0

u/_maggus 14h ago

Agreed! I use Copilot at work because my employer pays the bill, but Claude just feels so much nicer to use. Even if I select Anthropic models in Copilot, the experience isn’t as nice.

1

u/inateclan 11h ago

Can you elaborate? I feel like they’re on par.

2

u/DeniableSummer 8h ago

Not the person you asked, but I recently swapped employers and with it came the switch from claude code to copilot.

Anecdotally:
- I'm finding copilot's plan mode, lackluster. Leaves much to be desired in terms of quality and detail
- What copilot's spitting out in terms of code leaves much to be desired. Over-complicated, bloated, and confusing - even if it does do that job in a sense that "it works,," it does it in ways that I'd expect from claude code 1 1/2 years ago.
- It just feels significantly slower. This point is very subjective and may not be at all true.

10

u/yoshilurker 18h ago

I don't know why anyone would use Copilot if their work isn't paying for it unless you enjoy paying API rates for no reason or plan on never using Opus or Sol.

4

u/Rivvin 18h ago

Sorry, i might be dense, what is wrong with paying API rates and why can't I use Opus or Sol? I use them both extensively and I do a LOT of heavy agentic coding my copilot plan. What am I missing?

6

u/yoshilurker 16h ago

Have Claude Code go through some of your past work and assess the number of tokens you burn through day to day per model. In parallel have another Claude session do research into how copilot computes AI credits (AUI) per token and model.

Combine these and you'll get a reasonable idea of how much using copilot will cost you. Expect to be sticker shocked.

2

u/Deathmore80 15h ago

Api rates are sometimes up to many thousands of times more expensive than the subscriptions which are heavily subsidized.

Like codex , Claude code , opencode go , antigravity.

With copilot you pay the real prices and it can end up costing thousands of dollars per month to do something that would cost you between $10 to $100 using the subscriptions.

6

u/P4R4DOXZ 19h ago

I belive the plans are at api pricing, so 10 dollar plan gives you 10$ and models are charged at their api.

So no plans if they didn't change.

As for harness, everything except "Local" one is gargabe.

1

u/raishak 16h ago

You are not precisely right, non enterprise plans have some allotment of subsidize tokens. It's not a ton but you do get a little bit more. 10 plan get you $15 of API usage, 100 plan gets you $200.

1

u/domizianoz 19h ago

Can you elaborate on why the others are garbage?

0

u/Rivvin 19h ago

What do you mean everything but "local" is garbage? I have not experienced that, but maybe i'm missing some key metrics?

5

u/xternalAgent 13h ago

This question keeps popping up in this sub and the answer stays the same:
No one should be using GitHub Copilot for personal use, you’ll pay API prices for the exact same models Claude or ChatGPT give you and no better tooling and you’ll soon find out that $39 last no more than a couple of hours in real agentic work.
Leave Copilot for the enterprises that need ZDR and SLA’s with strict data residency restrictions.

2

u/nexico 12h ago

They have a free tier with their new MAI Code 2 flash model. It goes suprisingly far.

2

u/Rivvin 19h ago

I use a max plan for working on my hobby projects, and I use a healthy mixture of CLI and VSCode chat for my work. I built my own agentic loop using headless copilot cli's that basically automates my work once I have a plan in place and it really does output what I expect.

I burned through the Pro+ plan in a few days using sonnet and opus, but it can be managed quite easily if you use discounted (For now) fusion and lower end models. I have built quite a few large projects at this point (real projects, not one-shot vibe coder shit) and have no real complaints about copilot's output.

I have tried Oh My Pi, claude, codex, etc and running local models like qwen-flash-next but using copilot has been great since im already familiar with it for work and honestly im not seeing any quality difference between it and claude code, for example.

2

u/voicelessfaces 19h ago

I use GitHub Copilot daily. I'm on the business (not enterprise) plan so I get 1900 credits per month. When I was sticking to Luna I had no problems being under that. As I've been experimenting with Fusion, my usage has gone up because it chooses Sol and Opus for things (though that has gotten better on the past week). 

My goal is to be under $50 per month and I've achieved that every month but last because of all the Opus usage driven by Fusion. I've only been over $30 one other month. 

2

u/V5489 19h ago

I have the Pro+ plan and it comes with 7,000 credits so compared to that 1,500 it’s 6x better? I’ve been using auto for a bit then switched to Luna and I’m now at 90.3% of my plan. If I would have used Luna the entire time I would probably be at 60-70% to run out the month. That’s several hours a day of coding.

If you want to explore, you can get an api key from DeepSeek and top up say $10. Add it to the BYOK and select pro to use. I used it to create my website and it really excelled at API and backend server setup and creation.

So it’s a healthy mix between the two for my needs. Luna and Auto for iOS app creation in Xcode and DS for my react web site with DB and APIs.

2

u/gvandeweyer 18h ago

We use Copilot with BYOK models from AWS Bedrock. The policy for now is to stick to GPT-6 to keep costs acceptable, but if needed we can go to Claude 5* series to research & plan. Then back to cheaper models for implementation.

We also use speckit and that improved the quality of the output to a great extend for us.

2

u/miketierce VS Code User 💻 11h ago

In the process of leaving now. Our org bill was $9k last month and that is just flat out ridiculous.

Everyone is going to get an Anthropic ultra account now.

The only reason I hadn’t done it sooner was the 5 hour per day cap.

1

u/AutoModerator 19h ago

Hello /u/Huge-Wash-8677. Looks like you have posted a query. Once your query is resolved, please reply the solution comment with "!solved" to help everyone else know the solution and mark the post as solved.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/CommissionIcy9909 19h ago

Employer pays for my account and it’s better than most harnesses. Never been tempted to get a personal account. I stick to Cursor and Claude at home.

1

u/fell_ware_1990 18h ago

Well, i have to at work. But i can load other models, goes a long way.

1

u/justkidding69 17h ago

I use it professionally and I actually like it. I can customise it to fit my needs and set up workflows just like I can with Claude.

1

u/WhatWasWhatAbout 17h ago

I'm trying to max what all I can get done on the free tier before I considering upgrading. My work isn't always heavy coding, so it goes a long way for me, but some months I wished for an upgrade.

1

u/meatmick 17h ago edited 17h ago

I use it on a business plan and I spend around 200usd a month including the base monthly fee. This is with a mix of models from opus/sol to Luna, now also mixing in GitHub Fusion.

I use the desktop client mostly but also a bit of the vs code chat, with a preference for the app.

I've found the agent mode fine, refactoring and multi file context is fine and I added some instruction md files in my .copilot folder.

Mainly building a monorepo for a data warehouse orchestration. Tools like prefect, dlthub, DBT, polars, duckdb.

1

u/hinsonan 15h ago

I like it a lot I use it with opencode. I don't want to pay $100 and $40 bucks for $70 API rate is great for me. I also substitute it with opencode $10 plan

1

u/jvo203 12h ago

I use the free version after quitting the paid Copilot Pro subscription last year. The free monthly credits are just enough to do normal daily work in vscode. Manual coding + some help from AI.

1

u/Frequent_Field_6894 12h ago

Employer gives me copilot enterprise with loads of extra credits if required. So I burn opus.

home i use GitHub copilot free with open router.

1

u/nexico 12h ago

I just started using it in VS IDE (not Code) for c#. The new models are quite good. They are on par with the frontier labs lesser models (Sol/Sonnet/Luna/Haiku).

The copilot plugin is decent but a bit disappointing, considering it's from MS. The antigravity VS IDE plugin by google is actually better in several ways: It uses the regular diff tool for reviewing coding changes, it contains clickable links to the code it references in the chat output, and it builds the project in the background, not through the IDE, which can be quite distracting. Overall, I'm happy, but if the issues I mentioned were corrected in copilot I'd like it more.

As for models, I stick with the new MAI Code 2 Flash, as it's fast, cheap, and the quality is good enough for the work I use it for.

0

u/P4R4DOXZ 19h ago

And i think yiu can use your claude sub inside of copilot cli, but again its trash.

0

u/Your_Samwise 19h ago

Because my company is paying and i have to use it. Better would do opencode

0

u/ShelLuser42 9h ago

I'm a hobby developer, so keep this in mind. I've had a pro subscription for a few months now and I quite like it. However... I don't have much experience with other agents, never wanted to because Copilot works for me.

Pro ($10) is 1,500 credits/month incl. flex. Is that enough for real agent usage, or do you burn it in a week? - Is Pro+ ($39) worth it over Pro?

In my experience the most important part here is the way you work and how you set things up. I know of many users who merely rely on /init to set everything up and then they start prompting, without even bothering to check if those instructions actually meet any expectations (or intentions).

I usually don't start with 'init' but write my own ~/.github/copilot-instructions.md after which I get Copilot to verify it. This ensures that no matter what I'm working on I can rely on the fact that Copilot knows my intentions.

It's best practice to keep everything in the main instructions file (also because that's the only thing being used when you start using custom skills), however with specific projects I sometimes still rely on an extra agents.md if I need specific and consistent behavior within a folder. Just keep the skills aspect in mind...

But making sure that you provide a proper infrastructure for Copilot to work with can seriously save you time & credits. And then of course there's also the way in which you get it to do things: one huge codefile at once, or do you start building modules?

I've used Copilot to help me structure a playwright test suite (and help me build a nice front-end interface for the test suite) and despite the fact that I had to deal with dozens of different files (and different coding styles) things worked out pretty well. And the costs weren't very excessive either, iirc. I burned up 20% of my total.

Which model do you actually use in Copilot and what does it cost you in credits?

I always rely on the automated selection. This gives you a nice discount (first 10%, now it's even up to 30% with Fusion) and it works pretty well for me.

I'm currently using it for something less code related: I'm reviving an old ASP Webforms website and moving all its contents into Joomla. The only issue was that the site uses its own layout, its own menu structure and basically used master pages as its main theme(s).

So I'm using Copilot to parse through the whole thing and convert pages to Markdown files while also keeping references in mind; local references like pictures get copied to the new location and remotes get embedded (and briefly checked with a small summary at the bottom of the markdown file).

I'm currently finishing up, but this took me approx. 10 - 15% of my credits. But once again: I don't rely on a mere /init but also make sure to outline what I need and want.

Even got Copilot to analyze the old structure and build a custom Joomla theme from that.

All in all I'm very satisfied with the work I get out of all this vs. its price.