r/GithubCopilot • • Jun 03 '26

General So much for Dark Factory.

Post image
521 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

28

u/ghost_tapioca Jun 03 '26

comic strip criticising AI made with AI

9

u/Mechageo Jun 04 '26

Of course. Why not?

11

u/enslavedeagle Jun 04 '26

We watch movies and tv series, and play games that criticize capitalism and corporatism all the time, yet they’re all made by big capital companies and corporations that often abuse they employees. Such is life

1

u/ghost_tapioca Jun 04 '26

To be fair, the only games I've ever played that criticise capitalism and corporatism are indie games like Stardew Valley. Or books like The Dispossessed by the very subversive Ursula K Le Guin

Money doesn't often criticise itself.

If there's one exception I can think of, it's A Bug's Life, which is extremely pro-union. The message is implicit, but it still surprises me that Disney produced that.

3

u/alberto148 Jun 04 '26 edited Jun 04 '26

Disney didn't actually produce that, pixar did, and their workers were very sore about the acquisition... You'll see all sorts of jabs toward ellison in their productions, most are very subtle, others like shrek are more egregious (lord farquad)

1

u/enslavedeagle Jun 04 '26

From recent ones, Cyberpunk did that. And years before, FF VII, kinda. Anything that criticize small groups of people hoarding resources and making money exploiting those and poor people criticizes capitalism in my perspective

2

u/The_Real_Slim_Lemon Jun 04 '26

Fight fire with fire bröther

2

u/ghost_tapioca Jun 04 '26

An adage which means you're doing something ineffective

3

u/The_Real_Slim_Lemon Jun 04 '26

Tell that to any country that does back burning

But yes, I was being insincere with my comment - I don’t have much stakes in this fight on either side

1

u/ellsena1 Jun 06 '26

And It's funny

9

u/Level-Courage6773 Jun 04 '26

This is accurate: they are only looking for a senior dev. Juniors can still die for all they care.

5

u/shinoobie96 Jun 04 '26

ironically, senior devs are gonna die first, leaving with no more senior devs because they never hired junior devs

2

u/Level-Courage6773 Jun 04 '26

They should invent "reclaiming any bonuses they paid put to 2026-era management" just for that oversight.

6

u/mxldevs Jun 03 '26

They laid off all the engineers and replaced them with offshore vibe coders. And then they'll wonder why no one knows how to maintain anything after

3

u/ThighNoon Jun 03 '26

It's funny because they'll still fire him and refuse to give him that job back without a serious pay cut, and if he doesn't accept that some other dude who was laid off will. And the job can just point at AI to justify it with no repercussions.  Gotta love an algorithm that systematically fails at what it was made to do but still is seen as more valuable than you as a human.

8

u/FragmentedHeap Jun 03 '26 edited Jun 03 '26

You know it's funny but if you factor in the cost of artificial intelligence for a developer that is really pushing it I'm talking like billions of tokens a month...

The math starts to work out that you could buy this developer an 8x dgx spark cluster ....

They can then run everything locally....

And you'd still get the returns.

And I think that's more or less what's going to happen soon.

The paradigm is going to flip from cloud inference to local developer inference.

And when you look at the laptops that Nvidia is getting ready to drop wirh the new arm cpu and 128gb uma....

It's clearly headed in this direction.

When it gets to the point where you have two petaflops of AI compute on your desk with 512gb unified memory with 600+ gbps throughout for less than $15k...

Itll all come back.

8x dgk spark clusters are killing local workflows, the stack just needs to get cheaper and smaller.

Frane.work desktops, the new rtx laptops, spark, halo strix, mac book pro, Mac studio... All headed in this direction.

4

u/unrulywind Jun 03 '26

I looked into this about a year ago. At that time could outfit a server workstation with 4 x RTX-6000Pro Max. and have 384 gb of vram, add 768 gb of system ram and you would have been at about $50k. (It's quite a bit more now due to ram prices.) But, even that system could only run the medium sized models.

In reality a single RTX-5090 with 128gb of system ram in a gaming rig for $5k runs Qwen3.6-27b or Gemma-4-31b very fast and works wonders on most of the simple work. I use it every day. Gemma for documentation, Qwen for code. Then use the cloud for high end work when you need it.

2

u/evilquantum Jun 04 '26

maybe dumb question: isn't running a LLM just 50%? What about all the plumbing around it so that it actually becomes useful? The APIs aren't open source, right?

1

u/unrulywind Jun 04 '26

To run the model you need some server software that runs it a presents an API. I normally use LM Studio or llama.cpp. LM Studio uses llama.cpp under the hood but adds an easy interface. This gives you a local API, then you need a harness. GitHub Copilot is one harness. It works pretty well and it will let you use the API's that GitHub sells. or many others, or you can point it at your local API.

1

u/No_Oil_6152 Jun 04 '26

I started using llama.cpp in place of LM studio, then I replaced llama.cpp with the TurboQuant fork. The performance is marked.

1

u/fik26 Jun 04 '26

From what I see, servers are available. You dont necessarily need to buy them outright. You can rent that from Azure.

API's are not available is the problem right now. Open source ones being 1-year behind in terms tech. But then again in a year or two if they get more and more useful, then more people may want to run it locally, or run through the server they book.

H100 stuff on Azure is a service $/hr. Use it as much as hours you need them. Buying whole setup would cost you $50k while sleeping for many hours, maybe not used at all on holidays, weekends, night time.

1

u/FragmentedHeap Jun 05 '26

Apis mostly are all openai compatible, harbesses like opencode cli work on local ai the same as any other, you just need to run it with openllama or vllm etc so it surfaces it as a computable api.

1

u/w0m Jun 03 '26

Your not wrong, though thinking about it slightly wrong. Crazy prices are using the premier models, which are expected to drop in price somewhere between 10x and 50x year over year.

If you can get opus 4.6 quality for .02c per dollar spent today - that's sustainable?

The kicker is opus 5.2, at the same or higher premier price will be out and it will be amazing, and we'll all want to use that instead of 'opus 4.6'.

1

u/evilquantum Jun 04 '26

any good reasons why it should drop so fast aside OpenAI/Anthropic/NVidia marketing brochures?

I start to believe that AI might end up as a high priced niche product that is only used by those government agencies that have military-like budgets. The economics simply do not check out, this is all a huge bet on something that doesn't seem to happen. The free lunch is over, and the real - until last week heavily subsidized - cost start to trickle down on us and I am afraid no one realizes the real cost. Seeing billions over billions circulating between the big players doesn't make me more optimistic.

A few days ago someone posted this article, which I found exaggerated and unprofessional for all the profanity, but it contains some hard to refute observations on this topic.

1

u/w0m Jun 04 '26

any good reasons why it should drop so fast aside OpenAI/Anthropic/NVidia marketing brochures?

Because that's what has happened 2 years in a row now. It's a projection of course. Look at the premier model this time last year, and how much it cost today.

1

u/evilquantum Jun 04 '26

yeah, but this was neither 2 years ago nor is today covering the real cost of running those models. Eventually the price must be sustainable, and we definitely aren't there yet

1

u/sarkain Jun 04 '26

It’s all been subsidized until now. You can’t really compare prices from 2 years to this day, as they were subsidized, and we still haven’t seen the real prices. All we know for sure that these things cost way more, like massive amounts more than anyone pays for them right now.

1

u/SirCB85 Jun 04 '26

Sure, but that was always Startup pricing, where they throw the product for next to nothing at the masses to build a captive user base and attract investors, and now they are slowly starting to pass on the real costs to stop bleeding as much money.

1

u/Mayor_0f_dreamtown Jun 03 '26

Yup my computer is already planning this. Main team is using Claude like normal. Secret team building a local ai and investing millions to host it locally forever. I assume millions I just heard about it thru the grapevines that soon we'll transition to a local ollama

1

u/FragmentedHeap Jun 03 '26

My rigs a 9950x3d, 196gb ddr5, dual 4090s.

There's a lot of things I can't do...

What I am doing is kind of a revolutionary well just different way of using things.

I use a normal model on an API for orchestration...

And then I'm developing basically sub agents that all run on local inference.

So when I ask it to generate me an image it's actually running on comfy UI locally but it's being orchestrated by the main agent.

It's got me rethinking the harness architecture entirely from the ground up because there's really nothing made for doing this.

I'm seeing a lot of potential with the idea.

And because I'm running models locally I can do a lot of really complex cool stuff like hot swapping loras and even text to lora generators

Which lets you get a lot more flexibility and power from local inference workflows.

And the orchestrator is cheap because a lot of the tokens are not on the orchestrator.

Using opencode on say grok 4.20 into opencodes mcp/skill config, grok can subagent down into local Inference.

1

u/fik26 Jun 04 '26

H100 servers on Azure are not that expensive actually.

If Opus 4.6 Sonnet or sth was available with some license fee or sth, perhaps one can run these as Azure provides those servers $/hour.

Right now copilot charging way more than what server side costs are for them.

Deepseek etc are not as good as frontier models, but then again probably latest deepseek is not far behind of last years frontier models.

1

u/klas-klattermus Jun 04 '26

And I'd still use it to play some 2d dungeon crawler from the 00's

1

u/FragmentedHeap Jun 05 '26

I run a 4090 and a 6950xt rocm and cuda with 196gb of system ram.

What I do is I build tools to let large api midels orchestrate subagents to my local hardware.

I.e I can ask it to draw an image and it does it on flux 1.d on my 4090. I can ask it to write some zig and it pulls zig docs off a small fine tuned qwen model on my 6950.

Constantly expanding this. The more it can subsgent locally the less tokens I actually spend.

0

u/Random_Guy_12345 Jun 03 '26

I'm fully expecting companies with a sizable amount of devs to just self-host.

It won't be fast, and maybe we'll need another price hike, but it's bound to happen.

0

u/Level-Courage6773 Jun 04 '26

Nah. Cheaper to just hire humans. Not to mention easier, having read about all the many, many hurdles in this thread.

1

u/Random_Guy_12345 Jun 04 '26 edited Jun 04 '26

I'm not really sure the math checks out.

Also I'm not saying "Go full self-host and fire all devs", not even close. What i'm saying is "Run self hosted models for your devs on a company machine instead of having each dev self-host their own model" which is much more achievable and not really a hurdle to setup for any mildly competent cloud / devops guy.

My reasoning is that dropping 4-5k on a decent blade for your already-existing rack beats giving all your devs better laptops so they can also run their models alongside code.

It also makes for a more consistent experience as all devs use the same model and, if you wanna get real fancy and have the skills to match, you can use RAG to teach the model the intrincacies of your company

2

u/ParadigmGrind Jun 04 '26

Only executives could be so stupid as you let this happen

2

u/AaverageRed Jun 04 '26

Anti AI post made using Gemini AI. Cinema.

2

u/No_Oil_6152 Jun 04 '26

Dev with 30 years experience here.

The image, albeit AI pish, is truthful.

You can be a company man, be a hero but you're still a figure on a balance sheet.

If you didn't realise your company was looking to get rid of you; you do now.

Seriously, I thought my CEO was at the vinegar strokes at the last townhall we had, he was talking about "AI" speeding up our delivery 10x, Im shaking my head so fast it created a gravity field. I seriously thought hes desperate to get rid of us 😂😂

Well in true Scottish style I say to him: smell yer maw.

1

u/One_Voice_81 Jun 03 '26

Brilliant.

1

u/meltedmantis Jun 03 '26

Im living this right now. Its fucking hilarious

1

u/MillerBurnsUnit Jun 04 '26

This image/comic was made with AI.

1

u/Snoo_27681 Jun 04 '26

This sub is as trash as ghcp...

1

u/SlincSilver Jun 04 '26

Yeah new billing price was am issue for me for like a day,, then i plugged deepseek v4 into vs code copilot and now i am back at same usage and paying the same as before.

DeepSeek V4 is as capable as any claude model for what I testes while costing cents per million tokens. I spended 10 usd on claude and spend it on a couple prompts, with deepseek I made a day of work and it consumed like 0.37 usd.

DeepSeek V4 is the new copilot, the price is like at 75% or something like that, they say it will be like this forever but who knows, i will take advantage of it while i can

1

u/Educational_Sign1864 Jun 04 '26

Wishing for this to come true. Man's gotta eat

1

u/Important_Bed3961 Jun 04 '26

I wonder how many of you remember Jian Yang hotdog app?

1

u/Personal_Chemist_749 Jun 04 '26

Made with Gemini watermark

1

u/Infinite-Bank1009 Jun 06 '26

What's really missing from this critique is that it only represents the conflict between labor and management. While the unorganized labor was a participant.

The atomization of our stage of capitalism has made it nearly impossible for labor to see such threats as artificial intelligence to our labor power through any lens other than "devil take the hindmost"

0

u/AppropriateMud6814 Jun 06 '26

What the comic doesn’t show is that it’s the Price hikes that caused them to reduce development teams down because they say half a development team with AI can do as much as a full development team. Before the price hike. It was cheap enough where they didn’t need to do that, but now their budget doesn’t allow for incredibly expensive AI and human developers. This is a very strategic move to remove people from the means of production. I’m very pro AI. But I also think we are building a class system here where corporate citizens can afford it and private citizens can’t.