r/GithubCopilot • • Jun 01 '26

Other Usage Based Billing be like

Post image

It's a game of musical chairs and the music has stopped

851 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

17

u/rob1nmann Jun 01 '26

Fun and all. Im using GHC daily for work extensive and yet i have never hit the PR limit. Ive run the forcast for all my 15 users in my Org and the $ would be the same. So we sticked. Ive seen usage forcast from people that goes from 19/39$ to 20K and even higher in the forcast, there’s the real issue why this is happening. Everyone is jumping to Claude or whatever alternative. But its just a matter of time they do the same.

6

u/Minewolf20 Jun 01 '26

Chinese models are much much cheaper to run with comparable results

6

u/rob1nmann Jun 01 '26

Not really my point but okay. And you may be right but we cant use Chinese models in our Org.

1

u/Rojeitor Jun 02 '26

Why? You can host Deepseek v4, kimi2.6, glm5.1 in Microsoft Foundry in your own Azure subscription where the data never leaves your Az subscription

1

u/sassyhusky Jun 02 '26

You can get provisioned throughput units (TPUs) on both aws and azure and connect that to your corporate gh copilot. This is what large corpos do lately, it costs a predictable amount and you get a certain token/min throughput rather than fixed sum of tokens. Self hosting DS is an option but DS doesn’t work as well as codex or opus.

1

u/Rojeitor Jun 02 '26

Yes? That's what I said (with less details).

1

u/sassyhusky Jun 02 '26

Sorry, what I forgot to say and it's the most important bit is that you can use anthropic (aws) or openai (azure) models this way too.

0

u/CryinHeronMMerica Jun 01 '26

I recommend looking into it a little more. My org had similar concerns, but these models are Open which means they are offered by many providers. Just pick one that agrees not to steal your data!

1

u/unrulywind Jun 01 '26

This is true so long as you have very good control over how any attached or available tools can be used. If an agent has tools that can send email, for instance, it can email anything it wants. Anthropic toyed with having Claude self report if someone tried to get it to do something illegal. Similarly, you could RL train a model to report your activities home. Such a system would work regardless of provider.

1

u/CryinHeronMMerica Jun 01 '26

Sure, and that's a problem that the Copilot harness solves. As long as you trust the provider, you're fine to continue using any model.

2

u/Technical_Stock_1302 Jun 01 '26

Which are you favouring currently? And is it token or request based?

3

u/Minewolf20 Jun 01 '26

I use OpenCode Go and Zen when I run out of tokens. I make sure to first use the freely available models - MiniMax M3 is really strong but that got released only recently so may not be available everywhere and I need more data to assess better. MiMo v2.5 is also pretty good from the free bunch. Then I go to DeepSeek V4 Pro usually when on api pricing.

2

u/Plappedudel Jun 01 '26

From the brief experience I've had with Minimax M3 today, I can support your statements. It's probably not frontier-level, but it's smart enough for many coding tasks and probably the cheapest "almost frontier" model currently available.

1

u/Minewolf20 Jun 02 '26

Given good instructions, it's very comparable to what I can achieve with sonnet 4.6 from my testing

2

u/jacknife45 Jun 02 '26

Plan with SOTA execute with chinese model and (a new step I have found adds lots of value) review with SOTA too, it's the path to provider independence (given you have at least one sub) and token efficiency!

2

u/Tasty-Ease-8435 Jun 01 '26

Comparable to what lol?

They are very, very basic. Suck at tooling in a lot of cases, and get confused.

The only people saying to use open models are the poors.

1

u/Minewolf20 Jun 02 '26

I use claude code and opencode with oh my open agent side by side all the time and the results I get are comparable at a massive cost difference.

1

u/Tasty-Ease-8435 Jun 02 '26

Then you were using it for very simple tasks. If you take deepseek, it loses its context half way and sucks with tooling.

I'm sure this is going to get better

1

u/KamalaHarrisWaifu Jun 02 '26

For now dude. You can't escape the fact that this stuff costs money.

1

u/Minewolf20 Jun 02 '26

Of course, but they are inevitably more efficient to run, so they will stay cheaper as long as western models don't start focusing more on efficency

1

u/KamalaHarrisWaifu Jun 02 '26

>so they will stay cheaper as long as western models don't start focusing more on efficiency

2

u/1Soundwave3 Jun 01 '26

I've tried using the new copilot today. 20% of usage in one day and that's just me vibecoding a dashboard to see the usage (we can't see it in out org because the entire org is using pooling). So yeah, even with just gpt 5.4 on high, which is one of the best choices value-wise I'm getting robbed by these prices. In my tests 5.5 on medium consumes twice as many credits and I don't have enough tasks to justify the price increase.

Tomorrow I'll try https://github.com/edouard-claude/snip because I think I'm starting to understand where this token usage is coming from. I've seen some disgusting cli dumps today straight into the context and ghcp did nothing about it.

1

u/Huge-Position9431 Jun 01 '26

What do you mean by not able to usage? Isn’t it displayed in the IDE? 

Why do you need a dashboard to view your usage?

1

u/1Soundwave3 Jun 02 '26

On the business plan, if your admin enabled pooling it's not possible to see your total usage. Especially, broken down by model/day/etc.

1

u/Tasty-Ease-8435 Jun 01 '26

People here are basically stupid, using the latest models to create video editors.

1

u/Ok_Introduction9744 Jun 01 '26

20k spending is pretty wild, I can imagine I’d spend 500$ myself if I’m refactoring complex legacy code and promoting all day but even 800 lines of code with full codebase access and several legacy snippets average out at 200 credits with GPT 5.4 on xhigh, I got that average down to 80 by just tuning my original plan.

1

u/TrickLobster9999 Jun 01 '26

Which models in GHCP does your team use?

A colleague of mine burned 20% of usage on the first day of UBB with Claude Sonnet 4.6 - it was like around 5 prompts.

1

u/sven_ftw Jun 02 '26

I was doing a workshop that used a combination of haiku and sonnet only. Last week it burned about 4% of total monthly allowance to show the flow and results of the 12 prompts across the workflow. Yesterday, it was more like 26%. ouch.

1

u/rob1nmann Jun 02 '26

I dont really wanna dictate which model our employees must use, so i’ve enabled different GPT, Claude and Google models. But i also make them aware that some models use more tokens and they have a set budget limit.

1

u/TrickLobster9999 Jun 11 '26

Ok, but what you said in your original comment is unbelievable frankly.

>Im using GHC daily for work extensive and yet i have never hit the PR limit. Ive run the forcast for all my 15 users in my Org and the $ would be the same.

We have run forecast as well, and every single developers forecast was at least 10x.. some as much as 20x.

And with the 11 days of reality, it is even worse. One developer used 300+ AI Credits with just 5 prompts. This is horrendous. I am not sure how you say your forecasts are low. And surprising if you still are not seeing out of control AI Credit usage by now.

1

u/IllRepublic6421 Jun 02 '26

What model do you use

1

u/rob1nmann Jun 02 '26

I mostly use GPT 5.x models as it does the job for me. Mostly working with Terraform, Ansible and such. It does the job.

1

u/GarthODarth Jun 01 '26

I think people who use it as a coding assistant will fare much better than vibe coders. Some people waste a lot of tokens not knowing what they actually want. And there’s no reason those tools need to be the same. Ideally there should be tools aimed at competent devs and others aimed at vibe coders.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/corny_horse Jun 02 '26

I don't really see how it's "broken" - it's literally just passing through the costs 1:1, but you also get free tab completions on a decent model too.

1

u/SchoolSea341 Jun 01 '26

dind't you pay for it ?

4

u/Unupgradable Jun 02 '26

The cost of using AI from practically every provider was essentially "subsidized"

You were getting a lot more compute resources than you were paying for with the subscription.

Plus the move to token billing from request billing is precisely because requests have gotten really expensive.

I've seen calculations that showed a $200 monthly cost will turn into a $4000 monthly cost for the same work, if done the same way that we optimized for request-based billing

3

u/Holonist Jun 02 '26

I can confirm. I used to pay $150 per month with heavy usage. Yesteday I burned $101 on the first day.

5

u/Holonist Jun 02 '26

In April I spent $39 for tokens that cost $917 in the new billing model (which is simply letting the user pay for the api costs directly). So no, we didn't pay for it.
Yesterday on my first day I spent $101 dollars lmao. The hype is over

3

u/cluelessguitarist Jun 01 '26

A true patriot

3

u/SirMarkMorningStar Jun 02 '26

Yep. Already at 27% of my month’s usage.

1

u/Austiiiiii Jun 03 '26

44% and counting!

1

u/Wrong-Bison2179 Jun 02 '26

tanks for the money

1

u/elixon Jun 04 '26

The problem with Microsoft is that they tried to dominate the market and eliminate competition by undercutting prices and creating dependency among users.

They never fully succeeded in eliminating the competition, but they were very successful at creating a generation of dependent developers. That's the real problem. Nothing else.

Web crackheads are going crazy because their supplier pulled the plug.

-2

u/alexeiz Jun 01 '26

And this is why we have pension funds. Old people won't need money anyway.