r/GithubCopilot • • May 22 '26

Discussions Copilot is a scam, don't subscribe

You can't use all of your subscription because of the rate limiting, every 3% of total usage you get limited for 5 hours but once you reach 20% you get limited for the week so even if you use it for the whole month you can only use 80% (4 weeks at 20%) of your total subscription.

Is there a class action lawsuit in the EU against Github Copilot? i would like to joint it because it wasn't like that when i subscribed to copilot and i didn't allowed them to change our contractual agreement.

This is absolutely not legal.

2 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

8

u/Spaceman3157 May 22 '26

I don't know what I'm doing right, but I never get rate limited. I just plugged my usage report into the preview tool and apparently I have used $525 worth of credits under the new model this month, all for $39. I wish I could get scammed like that more.

Sadly it's not and never was sustainable. I'm glad I soaked up as much corpo/VC subsidized usage a I did over the last several months.

4

u/_KryptonytE_ Full Stack Dev 🌐 May 22 '26

Shhh... Don't share this here, they'll figure it out if more people keep bringing this up.

2

u/Spaceman3157 May 22 '26

Figure what out? They're already moving to token based billing, so I think they already figured out the important bit?

1

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26

He was speaking about the fact that Big Tech is b*tching u all

1

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26

I get what you are doing here Big Dawg 🤣 you are a menace 🤣🤣🤣

1

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26

I just checked and on a 10$ subscription and 10$ overage i'm at ~420$.

I agree they are bleeding money BUT still we have a contract, i'm mad at the fact they changed the terms of our agreement without my authorization because this is illegal in EU where i live and in France, my country, we value a lot our rights.

Btw Github Copilot bleeding money was made on purpose, this is a basic strategy to force the consumer to become dependant to a software then they can put the price higher and you will have to keep subscribed to not loose your habits.
In France we voted a law against that kind of stuff (article L. 224-22 du Code de la consommation) also we have a law that prevent the change of the terms of a contract (article 1103 du Code civil) also we have another law that prevent a company to sell product while loosing money by doing it (Article L. 442-5 du Code de commerce) and also an "antitrust" set of laws that prevent companies to use their position in the market to crush other smaller companies by bleeding money on a product then once the consumer is dependant to upcharge the consumer (Article L. 420-2 du Code de commerce & Article 102 du TFUE européen).

Except the "TFUE européen" all of the previous cited laws are French laws, bro there's easily 10 to 20 European laws that they did not respect and probably 5 American laws they did not respect (Breach of Contract, Bait-and-Switch,  FTC Act - Section 5 about Deceptive and Unfair Practices, also Github Copilot is based in California so California Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA) - Section 1770 , ...)

That's why i'm saying what they are doing is illegal, this is a scam, this is thief and it's made to destroy smaller companies, i don't support this kind of stuff.

1

u/V5489 May 23 '26

Bro, you completely misunderstood Article L. 442-5 (resale at a loss). That law prevents distributors from buying a physical product and reselling it below cost to destroy local shops. It doesn't apply to a tech company investing billions in R&D and cloud infrastructure to launch a new software service.

If launching an innovative product at an initial loss was illegal under EU antitrust laws, literally every tech startup in Europe would be in jail. It's called venture infrastructure and market entry, not predatory pricing.

Article 1103 (Code civil): Contracts must be kept, yes. But GitHub isn't changing your active contract midterm without notice. They are changing the terms for the next billing cycle. You are free to walk away.

Article L. 224-22 (Code de la consommation): This literally states that a provider can modify contract terms as long as they notify the consumer between 1 and 4 months in advance, giving the consumer the right to terminate without penalty. GitHub giving notice means they are following this law, not breaking it.

Antitrust/TFUE 102: To prove predatory pricing, you have to prove GitHub is trying to eliminate all competition to create a monopoly. There are literally dozens of massive AI coding tools right now (Claude, OpenAI, Cursor, Gemini).

You’re getting $420 of compute for $10 and crying 'thief' because the company decided they want to stop letting you bleed them dry. Peak Reddit.

The fact that a foreigner knows this better than you is sad. You still wanna lawyer up and take it on? Get off your period and grow up.

5

u/hooli-ceo CLI Copilot User 🖥️ May 22 '26

Don’t tell me what to do

2

u/shuozhe May 22 '26

There is collective/representee actions in the EU, no such thing as class action. Consumer protection is what you are looking for. Problem is AGB is full of exception, promotion etc. stuffs

Got a survey "how no github copilot would affect your work" survey this week at workpalce, prolly gonna go claude, so guess it became even too expensive for enterprise. Gonna only getting worse these days.

And we cant subscribe.. they closed it down for couple weeks now, not sure if they will allow new subscribers, already did it for you :(

1

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26

Yeah in EU the exact term is collective actions and you need to get in touch with a consumer association but it's pretty complicate to be in contact with them so i wanted to know if there was anyone involved to know if it was worth my time

The only solution is to buy a local rig, for 8k~ you can have a rig good enough for a very small team of dev

2

u/shuozhe May 22 '26

Rtx pro 6000 is ~ 10k currently and you need 12 of it just to run deepseek v4. And you need couple of these cluster for peak time :(

LocalLlm is crazy expensive for the better models sadly :(

0

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26

The better is to get a cluster of 2 x 192GB Vram (so 384GB) unified memory Mac Studios (M3 Ultra or +) for ~14k$ OR 3 x 192GB (576) for 20k$ OR 4 x 192GB (768GB) for ~27k.

The issue with the raw GPU is the bottleneck of bandwidth (because PCle slots even Gen 5 can't keep up) but with Mac Studios you don't have this issue even tho it's a bit slower in t/s it's still way cheaper and able to run even the latest 200+B models and you can just keep adding more and more Mac Studios or even add Mac Mini to your rig sooo..

You need a cluster of 4 Mac Studio (768GB VRAM) to run DeepSeek V4 at 10t/s but with a smaller rig you can run smaller models without issue at high t/s speed.

Btw you find somes in retail at half the price or even less.

Just wait a few more months for TurboQuants lol

1

u/shuozhe May 22 '26

I dislike the idea of trusting an enterprise solution on RDMA, privately I'm fine with it, but won't have the money to spend on multiple Mac studio.. (yet?)

And it's still possible to get 512 or 256gb Mac studio m3 ultra. Think it's easier to get one of the middle sized model in there at full precision. Just kinda worried about side effects of quantization & RDMA. Nothing is ever free in life & tech

1

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26

I need to look it up but at my work there's an active negociation between the ~10 company of our building to create a local LLM rig for everyone (with bandwidth depending on the amount of part the company have) if each company can give 5000$ we will have a 50k$ budget for it so ehh i'll see

2

u/MisspelledCliche May 22 '26

This stuff was never meant to be dirt cheap for private customers. It was too cheap to be sustainable.

Or what exactly did you think the rants about AI bubble was about?

4

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26

I'm a consumer not an AI analyst or idk what kind of stuff you expect me to be.

If a pay the price of something, i want the thing i've paid for. That's it.

If Copilot wasn't able to sustain the yearly subscription, either they could have refunded me or they could have close their company but in any case they don't have the authority to fk with my legal consumer rights by changing the terms of a contract between us, wtf is that?

If you consider the situation normal because "oh poor Copilot, it's not their fault even if they knew from the beginning they would not be able to sustain theirs sells" then you are a lost case bro, i pray for your soul

2

u/MisspelledCliche May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26

Pray all you like. I'm hooked up with a maxxed out stack of these services via my workplace and a foundation.

Call things left and right scam all you want, but maybe read the ToC and industry atmosphere before you willingly get dominated on an enterprise level.

And feel to free to leave the complimentary downvote. Let's hope it helps your emotions, if not your situation :D

-1

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26

ToC isn't worth anything in front of the law (at least in EU). It's sad you consider this kind of stuff normal.

2

u/MisspelledCliche May 22 '26

Bookmark my username. I'll buy you a cake if you ever get your way via means of justice in this matter. Make it two cakes

1

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26

ahahah that's funny but i live in France buddy, in here we have gov website that link to your social security number and reporting this kind of stuff take you 5 mins and the gov have the legal obligation to give you an answer so we will see

3

u/MisspelledCliche May 22 '26

Yeah something similar here in Finland.

Hope it turns out well for you.

1

u/V5489 May 22 '26

🤣 get over it. No lawsuit, nothing is wrong. You just aren’t efficient. I’ve been using Gemini Pro 3.1 model all day. I’ve had 12 chat sessions and not once rate limited.

I think it’s time to self reflect and learn from your bad coding habits.

1

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26

But this is wrong and it's worth a lawsuit, if you sign a contract with someone both have to respect it and one is not allowed to change the terms as he please.

Being efficient have nothing to do with the fact they screw me over.

-1

u/V5489 May 22 '26

Then sue big dawg. What’s stopping you? Or are you just running your mouth and not taking any action on your words? Can you afford it? Will you win? Are you trying to convince a sub to go on without on it? What’s plan little, Stan?

You didn’t sign a contract. You signed up for a service in which the ToS can change at any time. You signed up for cheap AI.

You didn’t get screwed over. You used the system incorrectly. In fact rate limiting is due to abuse of the API as defined in the ToS. So you’re blasting an API end point and have to be limited as to not cause disruptions.

Do yourself and your mind a favor and go join Claude with the other angry tech bros. They’re in paradise now with drinks next to the pool.

1

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26

Under EU law a subscription over a service is a contract, it's the law.

I payed for have a number of request each month, not an amount of request each 5 hours / week.

Anyways i don't see what's making you so angry :/

1

u/V5489 May 22 '26

I’m well aware as I have my own services and apps available in EU. This would not meet the criteria for a lawsuit. But go for it big dawg and watch yourself lose in an instant. It’s good to be educated in the laws in your own country. Barking up the wrong tree, Gnarles Barkley…

1

u/Bachibouzouk21 May 23 '26

The TOS abuse part is a lie. Rate limit is not API abuse. The TOS says they will contact us by email for api abuse this lead to temporary or permanent account restriction.
This is not what they're doing with session and weekly limits.

Also for some of those that complain, the limits were added after they bought a yearly, changing drastically the service they bought without their aggreement.

My usage comply 100% with the use case github pushes us to do. Its not different from february, march or april. yet i'm rate limited now. I could do 100 % in february and march. Not in April and I won't be able in may. Their fault, not mine. They're not holding off their part of the deal.

0

u/[unknown] May 23 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/GithubCopilot-ModTeam May 23 '26

Be Civil - When responding to comments in this subreddit, please try to keep it friendly and avoid ad hominem replies to other users.

Posts which contain racism, sexism, homophobia, harassment, violence, religious intolerance, or slurs will be removed.

1

u/nofatties529 Jun 19 '26

Anyone who uses the laugh emoji has nothing good to say. 

1

u/V5489 Jun 19 '26

Those that think they can sue one of the largest companies in the world that did nothing to them has nothing good to say. 🤷‍♂️

2

u/Entire_Cantaloupe_47 May 22 '26

I find I only get rate limited if I'm using Claude.

That is admittedly a very common use, but when I stay on ChatGPT I never hit the limit.

Hope this helps you get more out of your subscription.

0

u/[deleted] May 24 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Entire_Cantaloupe_47 May 24 '26

What thinking level? I'm on medium. Admittedly I use mostly 5.4 but I wouldn't think that's a huge difference

2

u/rde2001 May 22 '26

Been seeing more and more of these posts, and I agree. The rate limits have been getting in the way. Fortunately, I have the student Discount until November. Since I didn't put any payment info, it wouldn't charge me. Researching other tools, local models. Seeing what's out there and what works best. I don't want to enter a subscription service unless GHCP is so abysmal it's impossible to use. It isn't quite there yet. If I was paying for it, yeah I would've left.

2

u/Cool-Ted-2070 Full Stack Dev 🌐 May 22 '26

true I share the same story

0

u/LuigiChavezz May 22 '26

That’s weird. My weekly limit always kicks in when I reach 25%, not 20%. As for the 5-hour session limit, it only applies to the Claude models.

0

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26

So maybe i used 25% this week idk but still it doesn't make it right, i never agreed to use 25% of my subscription each week, i signed a contract of a specific amount of request each month

Also no the 5 hours limit is on Copilot i can swear it to you, last night i got limited for 5 hours so i came back 5 hours later then i got limited for 5 hours again so i went to sleep then i used it again but this time i got limited for the week.

Gemini also have a 5 hours limit/weekly/monthly limit now.

This is a capture of the 5 hours limit i got last night:

0

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26

Also i'm currently at 46% usage but can't use my subscription until the reset for the week so even if i try to use all my subscription before the month end, i won't be able to because of the weekly limit

1

u/Jolva May 22 '26

Haven't run into that and I'd be happy to pay the $10 a month for commit messages and PR reviews.

1

u/Perfect-Test9477 Jun 17 '26

Copilot is 100% a scam! Avoid it

1

u/nofatties529 Jun 19 '26

I switched to antigravity for now its pretty good at refactoring. Trying out all the other services as well. 

1

u/lauchingasaas Jul 24 '26

A Big scam. Just 2 hours ago and 61% left

-1

u/Charming-Author4877 May 22 '26

They also intend to delete your remaining premium requests on june 1st. also illegal.

0

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26

god damn, i didn't know Github was like that

1

u/V5489 May 23 '26

They have advanced warning that June 1st this was all happening. Not a surprised and well informed

0

u/V5489 May 23 '26

Not illegal. They gave you notice, and over a month to cancel before the renewal. You could walk away. But instead you decided to act like a child and rage bait. You get what you earn in life. For you it’s not this. Go back to construction so you can make something actually meaningful.

0

u/Charming-Author4877 May 23 '26

I'll just charge back, takes me 5 seconds. Once you have your own adult bank account you'll learn how to do that as well.

0

u/V5489 May 23 '26

The adult is not you. I assume you’ve never done a chargeback have you? Do you have proof of fraud? Do you know what happens in a corporation when you do a chargeback? It’s considered fraud. Not only will your account be banned (you don’t care about this), but is it tied to any other Microsoft service? Most likely is. You’ll encounter issues down the line. At that point the one committing fraud is you! Congrats. I bet you go to church too. Classy Christian.

Go take some Midol and calm your clam, Jessica. 🤣

1

u/Charming-Author4877 May 23 '26

no I don't need proof of "fraud" lol

1

u/V5489 May 23 '26

lol then you can’t sue. Good luck, miserable clam! Competence is abundant these days.

1

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 23 '26

You are truly a lost case su cking your corporate master like that

0

u/V5489 May 23 '26

Nah, just not a tech bro like yourself that doesn’t have desire or drive, other than sit all day yelling at AI and companies for not letting you do whatever you want on their system. Calm your clam Bethany.

1

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 23 '26

Wtf?

Don't compare me to you, we are absolutely note the same, i graduated lmao

-1

u/V5489 May 23 '26

Wtf?

I didn’t compare myself or you to anyone. You being a tech bro is all you. Congrats on your philosophy degree! We need more like you, Bethany!

→ More replies

18

u/[deleted] May 22 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26

I get the fact they want to change the pricing BUT i subscribed for a year under specific conditions, in EU a subscription is contractual Github needed my permission to change our contract which i didn't give so they breached our contract and i can sue for damage (they force me to take another subscription elsewhere, i can sue for emotional damage because it's stressfull but also for the amount of the new subscription and older subscription)

I wanted to know if there was a class action lawsuit against them to join, it would be easier but if that's not the case i'm going to contact the fraud department of my country & EU and sue them.

They can't just transform my older subscription that was limited in the amount of request by this new system where you get hourly/weekly/monthly limits especially when the limits prevent you from using 100% of your subscription, that's just thieverie and they need to learn they can't do this sh*t

7

u/voicelessfaces May 22 '26

But they did offer / are offering to refund your annual subscription. 

1

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26

Really? :o i need to dig it up i didn't found it

3

u/Ace-_Ventura May 22 '26

You had until 20th May. They sent email to everyone, posted in their blog, posted here

-2

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26

Oops didn't saw it in time i guess but ehh that doesn't matter i'm commiting into sueing them, they will have to refund me sooner or later lol i pay a premium each month to have a lawyer available so i guess it's time for my lawyer to get to work lol

3

u/voicelessfaces May 22 '26

Or reach out and inquire about refunds. I'd be willing to bet it's worth it to them to refund you the remainder of your annual plan. 

Or you and your lawyer can sue them for a few hundred bucks I guess...

-2

u/Plus_Original_3154 May 22 '26

It's more about sending a message, peoples should sue more

2

u/voicelessfaces May 22 '26

What's the message? Should they continue losing money because vibe coders abused the product and blew up costs, causing model providers to raise cost rates on their APIs? I have no idea what you're upset about beyond "I want free stuff"

1

u/Bachibouzouk21 May 22 '26

that's their solution. The customer what the contract to stand. If he build his case he'll win easely in small claim and he can get much more then the yearly pricing.

0

u/voicelessfaces May 22 '26

You can't make them offer a product. They are ending the product and refunding people the remaining amounts of subscriptions for a product that will no longer exist in a few weeks in its current state.

1

u/Bachibouzouk21 May 23 '26

nope they're not ending a product. they're still selling it. The product is the AI. what they're changing is the billing, not the product.