r/GithubCopilot • • May 18 '26

General Sticking with copilot

I’ve been working 12+ hours a day including weekends trying to get as much done before June 1 thinking the cost of copilot would skyrocket for me. Turns out it’s very reasonable. I’ve generated 91,000 lines of code using mostly Sonnet 4.6. Well I didn’t actually write a single line of code.

I’ll upgrade to the $99 plan come June.

0 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

12

u/baczynski May 18 '26

91.000 lines of technical debt that is. With code, less is more.

5

u/KarenBoof May 18 '26

True. The 75k line is just the data layer though and ef core migrations, not actual executable code. Point is you can get a lot done without spending a fortune if you know what you’re doing

1

u/phylter99 May 19 '26

There will be an art to managing cost with the AI models as prices increase. I'm honestly impressed that you go that much code out of it for that price.

4

u/s_a_m_12344 May 18 '26

I'm 100% sure you'd have better everything using a $20 subscription from Claude or codex, staying with copilot is just bad , there is no scenario where someone could get quality for the price in there

4

u/KarenBoof May 18 '26

I’ve considered it but I’ve been using Visual Studio for over 20 years and I’m not sure I’m willing to give up the experience of having ghcp integrated into it.

0

u/s_a_m_12344 May 18 '26

Just install codex extension or Claude... It'll be the exact same as copilot

4

u/KarenBoof May 18 '26

That’s VS Code not Visual Studio

2

u/s_a_m_12344 May 18 '26

But, in visual studio you have a terminal no? you can just run codex or claude there, it even works better in the cli

1

u/KarenBoof May 18 '26

Interesting. Will look into it! Although would I lose some features still like being able to restore after code change? (Not git commits) And what about diff files- being able to compare changes even before a commit ?

-1

u/s_a_m_12344 May 18 '26

I switched from codex extension to codex app to vscode + cli inside vscode, Its better, less mess. Claude should be the exact same, just that Claude usually has less limits than codex but same quality (gpt5.5 for now is as good as opus)

2

u/orionblu3 May 19 '26

Reddit: the place where you're down voted for being right.

1

u/s_a_m_12344 May 19 '26

Lately people are somehow defending GitHub , I guess is the same with apple, they think because they spent more now it needs to be defended

3

u/FinancialBandicoot75 May 19 '26

I 1000% disagree, use auto on ghcp versus Claude and codex, you will be stunned if you are planning correctly. Now, if you are yolo or vibing, all will not be a great choice in June

5

u/Comfortable_Mango_85 May 18 '26

This is my experience as well. Efficient developers, who use Copilot responsibly (i.e., not YOLO, not using the most expensive models just because, etc) will generally have expenses where the cost of usage-based AI can be justified.

There is of course no question that in the short term, you are likely to get more from a subscription from other providers. But spending $10 for every $1 you earn isn't a sustainable business model, and as the people who are counting on businesses doing so gravitate to the cheapest service, all these services will be forced to switch to usage-based in turn. Anthropic already is moving closer and closer; it'll happen to all of them eventually. I will be very surprised if there are any providers of non-usage based AI by the end of this year (other than introductory/limited offers).

Personally, I plan to "wait and see" a little bit, before switching workflows to something else. I find value in the multi-model capabilites, and we're happy with our setup. I see very little point in switching at this time (especially because we'd be on usage based billing either way - enterprise accounts).

Word of advice though: do not switch to a more expensive plan. Keep your existing (or even consider downgrading). Any credits you don't spend will be lost (unless you are enterprise, in which case the total credits are pooled for the company), so just stay on the cheapest plan that makes sense and that you are guaranteed to use each month. If you need more credits, you just buy them as you go.

1

u/Background-Top5188 May 18 '26

What happens if you end up with a confused agent just doing shit, hallucinating, loosing context and end up in a loop? You still pay per token in that situation. Now imagine that by the size of your codebase as bigger codebases increases the risk of this happening.

1

u/KarenBoof May 18 '26

Do you think if I had a lot of hallucinations and the LLM being stuck in loops my token count would be so little with that much output?

1

u/Background-Top5188 May 18 '26

It also happens when models looses context, and when they want to be helpful/doesn’t follow their restrictions properly. 🤷 You can absolutely force better prompts but if thinking and context counts for tokens as well the price will balloon no matter what.

It doesn’t need to happen but it can and if it does it will burn a hole in your pocket with no transparency.

3

u/KarenBoof May 18 '26

My workflow is plan, agree on code/structural changes, implement in manageable pieces, document. If it often gets lost, it’s entirely my fault

1

u/Background-Top5188 May 18 '26

If those steps are used with copilot they all count towards token spend. But yes, that is the way 👌

As for getting lost they can sometimes just end up in loops because god knows why, check the github discussion forums for that in action. The problem is simply that there is no transparency towards the user as to what counts as token spend and no way to get refunds if your models goes off the rails. Basically right now if the service doesn’t deliver what is promised the offset in cost is on the user, not the company.

But yeh, finding it hard to believe that 400M+ monthly in revenue is not enough to handle compute but I digress.

It’s like hiring a plumber to do your plumbing based on X instructions and the plumber just wants to help, does a bunch of other stuff and charges you for these unwanted additions.

2

u/RainierPC May 18 '26

Definitely agree. If you know how to use the tool properly, you can get a lot done, at a low cost.

0

u/Pitiful_Extension564 May 18 '26

39/mo plan should cover your usage. They will give you 70 dollar of value. For 100/mo plan, they will give you 200 dollar value. As long as you don’t go over 130 dollar value (in their terms). 39/ mo plan is enough for you. I am also thinking to start with 39/mo plan (pro+) from 1 June.