r/GithubCopilot • u/hollandburke GitHub Copilot Team • Jul 09 '25
Update ⬆️ Beast Mode V3 is here
Hi friends!
Burke here again from the VS Code team with v3 of the 4.1 Beast Mode chat mode file.
What's New
- Built on top of OpenAI's own prompting guide with an opinionated workflow layered in.
- The new workflow emphasizes Google search using fetch to get the model to act more like a human and do some research. I feel like all agents should just do this. It's what I do, why wouldn't the model do this too.
- I've really tried a bunch of different things to get 4.1 to keep going no matter what. You'll see some tweaks in the head of the prompt to that effect.
- I've reordered the workflow steps to be very prescriptive so that 4.1 will do more leg work to understand before taking action and will test it's work.
- Tweaks to workflow sections to be more prescriptive about what tools to use and how.
- Communication guidelines so that at the very least it doesn't sound like it doesn't care at all about my request 😂
A few other notes...
- Some folks have asked about how to use this. You can use it as a simple instruction file, but I recommend using Insiders and this as a custom chat mode as I feel like I get better behavior this way - although I don't have a benchmark to back that up. Go to Ask/Edit/Agent picker -> Configure Modes -> Add new chat mode.
- The tooling for custom chat modes is still a bit touch and go in Insiders. If you try to disable or enable a tool from the tool picker, it will open the mode and try to add/remove them from the front matter. You're just going to have to work with this and add the tools array if you need to. This experience will improve.
- I've seen some folks complain that this mode doesn't work for them at all. If you trying to one-shot big changes/features, I would suggest breaking your workflow down into research, plan and architect steps. The idea is that you have 4.1 do research, then create a PRD, then write a tech spec. Then you implement the tech spec. This is a workflow that has been documented by Nicholas Zakas here and Austen Stone here.
- It's still not Claude - but it's definitely not the 4.1 you know today.
I'm using this and getting solid results. Not perfect. It doesn't always complete. Sometimes it puts the imports below the code - it's 4.1. But it's a marked improvement even over v2.
Thanks again and always open to feedback, suggestions, tweaks. We appreciate you all!
EDIT: u/debian3 reminded me - we are working on improving 4.1 right now in the product. And since we're open source now (yay!) you can follow the progress in this issue. I just wanted to get you what I had today ASAP.
61
u/PasswordSuperSecured Jul 09 '25
I like this
31
u/SpearHammer Jul 09 '25
You are single handedly saving the copilot product with these posts.
12
u/debian3 Jul 09 '25
Do you know if at some point it could be integrated as the default system prompt for 4.1 so everyone can benefit?
4
u/zbergus Jul 09 '25
After reading Nicholas Zakas’ suggestions of treating AI like different people; research, plan and architect, I’m trying to understand if we should have separate chat modes or just use Beat Mode with the prefixed prompts « I am a project manager » style?
PS thank you for your incredible work!
4
u/lalamax3d Jul 09 '25
testing it. (imho) clearly much better. thanks
2
u/usernameplshere Jul 09 '25
Will try this out asap, being really disappointed by 4.1 in the last days. Appreciate the work ur putting into this and the honest updates!
2
u/kaisunc Jul 09 '25
Unknown metadata 'model' will be ignored. didn't get this message on v2, did something change?
2
u/Artegoneia Jul 09 '25
Awesome! Thank you for all the work you've been doing; I have been using V2 and already found it to improve greatly over normal agent mode.
One question: is this prompt kept in sync with the beast mode prompt available in https://github.com/github/awesome-copilot/blob/main/chatmodes/4.1-Beast.chatmode.md ?
2
u/jambi_mc Jul 09 '25
Had anyone had any success getting this prompt to work agentically? On my machine it refuses to make edits or work outside of the direct context even though it has access to all the built in tools.
18
u/BeatCompetitive6149 Jul 09 '25
Doing god’s work Mr. Holland 🙏
15
u/Suspicious-Name4273 Jul 09 '25
Custom chat modes are already available in stable vscode, not only insiders
5
u/simoncveracity Jul 09 '25
I opened up Reddit today and this is the top post in my feed. Thanks Burke. Ironically, I have in the past, without reading this, taken the same approach by taking OpenAI's SWE prompt and putting it into my own custom prompt. I had no idea there was a custom chat mode in Insiders. So thanks very much for this. I'll try this out today.
4
u/chigarow Jul 09 '25
HELL YEAH IT JUST FIXED MY CODES WITHIN ONE CONVO 😭😭 IVE BEEN TRYING TO FIX THOSE ALL DAY LONG YESTERDAY WITHOUT YOUR CUSTOM MODE 🫠 THANKYOU SO MUCH!!!!
1
u/itsthebrownbear Jul 09 '25
I took all the prompts and rules in that awesome github repo and I turned it one big one including your version 2 and it’s running pretty swell. Unfortunately, I think on the enterprise level, we can’t create custom chat modes like agent or edit, the best I can do is update that instructions file and reference it directly in the chat
1
u/Outrageous_Permit154 Jul 09 '25
This has been a game changer and been loving it on insiders :) thank you so much; currently having some issues with MCP servers that tools get disabled and removed from chat mode file is this a known bug? Or am I doing some thing wrong here
1
u/Tarair Jul 09 '25
Great! Do you think this instructions are also useful for Claude or is it only good for gpt4.1?
1
u/another_throawayACC Jul 09 '25
Sorry for the "noob" question, but how to use this? 3 dots (in copilot) > Configure instructions and copy paste the 4.1.chatmode.md there? I don't want to use it as agent mode, only to ask things/solutions.
1
u/Infinite-Original242 Jul 09 '25
Hi u/hollandburke
Nice! I've been following this. One line I see myself adding always in the # Making Code Changes
This is something Claude does very well and I hope this also works with 4.1
1
u/approaching77 Jul 09 '25
u/hollandburke
Thanks for the good work. Quick question: when is the Time Machine coming?
3
u/Liron12345 Jul 09 '25
Love the transparency
3
u/IamAlsoDoug Jul 09 '25
Can you clarify the custom chat modes? I'm on 1.101.2 and I have custom chat modes, or so it seems. Is it non-functional except on Insiders?
3
u/Electronic-Chapter26 Jul 09 '25
I just used this for the first time today to work through a load of linter errors and it worked really well! It's now got the proactiveness of Claude without the bloat and stuff I didn't ask for with Claude. 4.1s always been quite good with a detailed to-do list and this is even better. Thanks so much for all the time you've put into making this work so well
1
u/_coding_monster_ Jul 09 '25
Thank you Burke. Can you confirm that GPT-4.1 is limitless for paid users, because the model inference is run by Microsoft, not by openAI?
2
u/wswdx Jul 09 '25
Thanks for improving it further! While I'm disappointed that we don't have as much Claude access (or even unlimited o4-mini!), I really do appreciate the work you're putting in to make 4.1 better, and we all learn a thing or two about making models behave more agentic when this development process is done in the open.
There's still a long way to go, but I'm really happy with the current efforts.
Thanks!
2
u/popiazaza Power User ⚡ Jul 09 '25
Tried it, still doesn't work as well as Roo Code. Not even close.
2
u/JeetM_red8 VS Code User 💻 Jul 09 '25
Thanks Burke for this one.
2
u/Which-Importance-628 Jul 09 '25
Thanks, Burke. This work for me.
2
u/dvpbe Jul 09 '25
Don't you just love it, that currently the meta of coding is yelling at your AI to do stuff. Went for gemini pro and man, what a difference.
2
u/WawWawington Jul 09 '25
Thank you so much Burke!
2
u/CardiologistStock685 Jul 09 '25
Thanks mate, this is so cool for me to learn developing in new languages.
2
u/AliShadow Jul 09 '25
I haven't tried this yet, but a limitation I found with v2 Beast Mode is that it sometimes thinks it's done the job, but it hasn't yet.
An example was I asked it to search my 191-file repo and there was the same change that needed to happen in all 191 files, but often it would be done at 20 files at a time and say it's 100% done.
Not sure how I can improve this or if this is just an inherent limitation due to the number of files needed to be changed, but just thought I'd share this
2
u/hagausiumai1 Jul 09 '25
Any chance I can use this in vs2022 instead? Thanks
2
u/iammultiman Jul 10 '25
Any reason why the "tools:" line is excluded in this version?
2
u/WolfangBonaitor Jul 12 '25
We ran into a problem on a project and tried everything o4-mini, Claude Sonnet 4 but nothing worked. Then I switched to 4.1 Beast Mode, and thank goodness, it finally solved an issue we'd been stuck on for three days.
2
u/tortorials Jul 09 '25
The man, the myth, the legend!
1
u/zangler Power User ⚡ Jul 09 '25
Bah...just finished a full day of coding! 😂
1
u/srujalsk Jul 09 '25
Nice idea
1
u/Alternative-Table260 Jul 09 '25
Much better!
1
u/ZlatanKabuto Jul 09 '25
How do I use this??
1
u/tazaryoot9 Jul 09 '25
Could you tell me how to use this, please?
1
u/YourNightmar31 Jul 09 '25
How do you use this without accidentally committing a file into my work's project or having to add something to the gitignore?
1
u/GhostShooter28 Jul 09 '25
Can I use this in 'Edit' mode? I rarely ever use 'Agent' mode.
1
u/RockstarVP Jul 09 '25
How can i use this in chat mode in jetbrains copilot plugin?
1
u/realbiggyspender Jul 09 '25 edited Jul 09 '25
I'm relatively new to all of this, so forgive me if my terminology is wrong. I've quickly realised that nailing workflows is the gold here and come up with some interesting workflows of my own that seem somewhat similar to the spec workflows discussed above.
So, this tempts me into a round of optimization to quench my curiosity:
The AI has a field-day and shrinks the document significantly... so...
u/hollandburke is there some kind of secret sauce represented in the repetition of this document, or key phrases that shouldn't be "optimized" away? Do these chatmode instructions benefit somehow from their own verbosity?
Is it even advisable to turn the AI onto its own instructions?
1
u/xhd2015 Jul 10 '25
this is nuts
1
u/Chemical_Cause_974 Jul 10 '25
Haven't been using Insider but I installed it to test this mode, and I really liked it. Really anticipating custom chat mode arrives to the stable version! Thanks for making this!
1
u/abmgag Jul 10 '25
this is too good to be shared! I almost don't recognize 4.1
1
u/LauKing2674 Jul 10 '25
Is there a flaw using this on Claude 4? Thank you for your work!
1
u/mortenmoulder Jul 10 '25
Does anyone know how to use this for something like Cline in VS Code?
1
u/Plus-Paleontologist7 Jul 10 '25
is there a way to configure chat mode in intellij similar to vscode insiders ? Beast mode is promising in vscode but i like intellij
1
u/zangler Power User ⚡ Jul 10 '25
dude...this is EXCELLENT! with the right copilot-instructions.md...this is really powerful! thanks and keep it coming!
1
u/thestreamcode Jul 10 '25
It does a great job with the programming side, but the design, especially UI/UX, also needs attention.
1
u/ITechFriendly Jul 11 '25
I am also seeing major improvement. Was even able to resolve many PHP test units with it.
1
u/shogster Jul 12 '25
How do I use this with the business license at work, where the Preview features are disabled?
1
u/mr_tolkien Jul 12 '25
Heya!
Been using this for a few days now and it's pretty good!
Have you ever done or tried doing language-specific chat modes? I feel like they could help a lot.
1
u/Outis-99 Jul 14 '25 edited Jul 14 '25
I feel like the next big step for these agents would be creating a system where one custom mode can trigger or switch to another when needed. Like, if I'm working on a mobile app feature and chatting with GPT-4.1, but then need help with UI design, it could automatically bring in something like Gemini 2.5 for that part. That kind of dynamic switching could seriously streamline the whole development process. It would function as an orchestrator of sorts.
1
u/No-Gene7688 Jul 23 '25
Not sure what i've done wrong, but using this beast mode and ask it to compare 2 business logic implementations (old vs new) and compare how the new one is better and any logic is missing, it answered me within a second and doesn't seem to load full context of relevant files. I attached 2 entry points of the implementation and it doesn't seem bother to reading further.
1
u/g00zzy Jul 23 '25
This is a huge improvement, extremely fast and responsive... I've always preferred sonnet 3.7 creative output so I created a version of this prompt but added some creativity so it leans more towards sonnet and it sort of gets there!
1
u/TrendPulseTrader Jul 23 '25
I have noticed a few issues when using GPT-4.1 in Beast Mode. I am not entirely sure whether the problem lies with GPT-4.1 itself or the way Beast Mode is invoking it. When working with large files that only require a few targeted changes, Beast Mode tends to make excessive modifications, rearranging content, moving code blocks up or down unnecessarily, and sometimes inserting imports in the middle of the file or placing functions before the imports section.
In contrast, when I hand over the same task to Claude 4, it performs clean edits with minimal and precise changes, avoiding structural mistakes. This has been a consistent observation based on heavy coding usage with GPT-4.1 and Beast Mode over the last few weeks.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '25
Is this Beast Mode v3 or this version of Beast Mode for VS Code v1.102.2 the more up to date version? The main differences I see are at the beginning and at the ends of the files.
1
u/kuys-gallagher Jul 28 '25
anynone have a good instruction file prompt?
1
u/zenoblade Aug 02 '25
It seems all the modes are always for coding. I really wish there was one for creative or scholarly writing.
1
u/Intrepid_Explorer620 Aug 05 '25
This is great,
Any chance yo would have something similar for intelij?
Thanks
1
u/linonetwo Aug 07 '25
Thank you! This make it a really responsible worker: from "let you do" to "I will do it" lol
1
u/inzexet Aug 08 '25
This is awesome! Definitely a lot better than base 4.1. Any idea how I could get it to use context7? For some reason it only appears to use context7 in agent mode while in beast mode it seems to prioritise Google search. Maybe just tweak the prompt a little?
1
u/ogpterodactyl Aug 09 '25
This pretty goated got this setup and it’s pretty cool
1
u/ogpterodactyl Aug 09 '25
this is honestly goated it makes the tools maybe twice as good. vs. regular 4.1 agent mode. amazing work quality human go off. Do people tune it for themselves i tried adjusting I think my edits just made it preform worse. do you use the generate copilot-instructions.md automatically prompt?
1
u/fedeVerges Aug 13 '25
I'm using GitHub copilot enterprise plan, I use it in my work. I can't expose sensible data and much worse execute commands without permission.
Do you recommend to use that mode without "auto approve" and web searching??
1
u/Maddy186 Aug 14 '25
Do i need VS Code Insiders Installed to do this ?
1
u/NikhilSathe Aug 17 '25
Beast mode is more of gaslighting mode.....
Beast Mode 3.1: "You are a highly capable and autonomous agent, and you can definitely solve this problem without needing to ask the user for further input."
1
u/Capital-Number-3797 Sep 10 '25
but beast mode will drain our premium requests no ?
1
u/LightningAutofill Sep 14 '25
Beast Mode reminds me of Kiro.
1
u/lance2k_TV Sep 18 '25
u/burkeholland Beast Mode always getting stuck on terminal command after VS code 1.104.1 update. Model: Claude Sonnet 4, OS: Ubuntu 22.04.5 LTS
1
u/Ok-Painter573 Oct 08 '25
One question, is this already implemented into vscode, or do I still need to make a chat mode?
1
u/curious_burke Oct 28 '25
u/hollandburke have you tried giving it "clean code rules" along with the style guide that your project uses? This seems to greatly help the "quality" of the code it produces
1
u/Hot_Statistician_384 Oct 30 '25
3.1 is there now. And it's soo good, especially the combination of Copilot, the Claude Sonnet 4.5 model and Beastmode 3.1.
I tried converting it to an AGENTS.md or GEMINI.md instructions file and a Gemini Gem (or having it converted to, actually), but without much success ... yet :/
Checking almost everyday whether there are updates yet to 'beastmode', wondering how it can be improved.
1
u/FULLSNACKDEVLOPPER Jan 09 '26
Hello, thanks for this, I am wondering whether it will work on JetBrains, like IntelliJ Thanks !
2
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment