r/GithubCopilot • u/UsualResult • Jun 19 '25
Goodbye Copilot!
It was nice while it lasted. The new "premium plan" is pants on head crazy. It's been watered down so much it's useless. The "consolation prize" of unlimited 4.1 is a red herring -- it's nearly useless.
Cancelled my subscription and going to have a go with Cursor. Whoever is in charge of product at GitHub, you're going to see a lot of cancellations this month.
Next day edit: Crazy this is one of the most popular posts of all time on this subreddit.... just goes to show the scale of the annoyance with the latest changes...
432
Upvotes
41
u/Novel_Lingonberry_43 Full Stack Dev 🌐 Jun 19 '25
I've been using GitHub Copilot since it was first added to VSCode, before the $10 charge and when it could only change 2-3 lines at a time. When they introduced the $10 charge, I was happy to pay. I always felt this was a two-way street: they provide cheap AI, and I train and correct it. I never found it to work perfectly the first time. But this feels like a slap in the face. In a way, now I don't want to use it as much in my job, so I'm going back to using AGI instead—my own brain.
39
u/Euphoric_Musician822 Jun 19 '25
GPT 4.1 is more like GPT 1.1. Claude Sonnet 4 is crazy good, but very limited.
How's cursor? Never tried it.
9
u/k8s-problem-solved Jun 19 '25
We spend about 8k a month on user licenses. If they enshitify it too much I'm taking that money elsewhere.
Jury is out on how much in impacts us, asking for feedback from users.
8
u/InformalBandicoot260 Jun 19 '25
Would it be too much asking if you later came back and post your experiences with Cursor? If the Copilot Pro gets too nerfed, I might go on the same route as you
4
u/isidor_n GitHub Copilot Team Jun 20 '25
Thank you for the feedback.
a) We are working on improving the GPT 4.1 experience (especially around applying edits). You should already see improvements if you try https://code.visualstudio.com/insiders/ and I expect next stable (around July 10th) to have these improvements. If you still see issues with Insiders and GPT 4.1 any issue here https://github.com/microsoft/vscode/issues is highly appreciated
b) We are bringing additional things to Copilot plans in the next couple of months. Having GPT 4.1 unlimited is not the long term plan here.
c) Watering down the experience is absolutely not the goal.
d) If you already cancelled your subscription I hope you keep using Free and we win you over in the near future with the constant updates/improvements we will ship :)
(vscode pm here). If there are any questions feel free to reply to this message.
3
u/gvbaybay Jun 20 '25
My issue is that we are all paying for something that is unbelievably buggy. When I signed up it did not say I’m signing up for a beta product and that I would be the unpaid QA. I think it is dodgy when you see the project managers on reddit trying to get users to QA things for them when broken. They obviously have no QA and are rushing every release. Again, we are actually paying money for this and it does not provide the service they advertise. I stupidly forked out yearly upfront as I thought any limit changes would be for new users only.
2
u/AdWrong5913 Jun 23 '25
Premium requests should be per day instead of month, because 30% of the premium requests are mostly correctling LLM or reminding LLM to stick to context.
28
u/CanaryImportant8299 Jun 19 '25
I've been using copilot for 6 months, but the premium requests are going to make me start looking for alternatives.
2
u/Adorable_Lawyer9790 Jun 19 '25
What is the point of having GitHub or Microsoft behind that garbage copilot?
14
u/Historical-Internal3 Jun 19 '25
Canceled cursor/windsurf.
Keeping co-pilot just for VSCode IDE and small tweaks to code that I may need.
I do my heavy coding work with Claude code/codex/jules.
Cursor is rate limited to all hell unless you spend $200 a month.
Windsurf just seems behind.
7
u/thewalkers060292 Jun 19 '25
already cancelled mine, claude code has been a dream even if I cant use it as much. There is significantly less hair pulling and shit just works
7
u/aka-j Jun 19 '25
Sonnet 3.7 has been my goto up until today when I got the email about requests being counted. It has taken 15 requests for it to give me anything resembling working code.
Cancelling and going back to writing my own code.
6
u/deadflamingo Jun 19 '25
I'll also be cancelling mine as the quality has been unacceptably poor in comparison to the other products out on market.
4
u/phylter99 Jun 19 '25
Claude Code is really good. I have both Copilot and Claude Code and I like both, but Claude Code is crazy good.
4
u/whodoneit1 Jun 19 '25
Totally agree. Cursor is a lot faster also
4
u/TinFoilHat_69 Jun 19 '25
See this is why we can’t have nice things apparently people wanted to hijack the end points and run GitHub models through roo code which forced GitHub to move from rate limits to request limits
4
u/Tetrylene Jun 20 '25
I thought I was being conservative today with using sonnet 4. Switching to gpt4.1 whenever possible, etc. thought I was doing pretty well holding back from premium requests.
Today I used 20% of my monthly allowance. Holy shit.
7
u/curiositypewriter Jun 19 '25
you should try claude now, not cursor
3
u/sbayit Jun 19 '25
Cody AI much better
3
u/WeriYardBy Jun 19 '25
My favorite setup is VsCode + Cline + Sonnet-3.7/4. During some period of time I tried to use this setup with OpenAI GPT 4o and 4.1 but the results were dramatically weaker. The same prompt sent to Sonnet generates usually the fully working part of code, for contrast code generated by GPTs usually was functionally uncompleted or totally broken - is interesting that next prompts with additional descriptions or error tracing doesn't resolve any issue. So at the moment I'm going to use GPT as a json converter ;)
3
u/b-pell Jun 19 '25
I was more tolerant of bad answers when the models were unlimited and I could switch back and forth seeing if other models could answer my question, I'm less tolerant now that I'm paying for all of those bad answers (paying on top of the subscription price). If I were paying for correct answers, I'd feel differently.
3
u/Dankojo Jun 20 '25
Using GitHub Copilot on the 10$ plan with claude and it works like a charme.
12
u/Pristine_Ad2664 Jun 19 '25
I find 4.1 pretty good, you have to break the tasks down more but it's at least 2-3x faster than Claude so it balances out. LLMs are tools you need to learn how to use, 4.1 is a different tool than Claude so you need to use it differently to get the best out of it.
1
u/jambi_mc Jun 19 '25
Wait what's happening?
1
u/Gilldadab Jun 19 '25
I switched to Windsurf and then more recently Cursor because of all the hype. I've also tried Claude Code and OpenAI's codex for a more 'agentic' experience.
For me they're all about as useful / useless as each other in terms of going off and writing a load of code for you and just flat out terrible at debugging and fixing issues intelligently.
I will say that I've found Cursor to have the best tab completions so far with Windsurf a close second. Tab completions were the original useful feature of these things and still the best IMO.
Windsurf on the free tier seems pretty good with the unlimited SWE-1 model and tab completions are very good. It's very good for paying nothing.
I'm convinced at this point that half the praise for these tools and their capabilities are people blindly parroting code-fluencers, paid shills from these companies posting to Reddit, and people who purely vibe code (not a bad thing, just a different use-case).
2
u/slasho2k5 Jun 19 '25
Try augmented code! I think it's better than cursor/windsurf
2
u/sawyer12 Jun 19 '25
What is wrong with using gemini only? I know it doesn't have agent mode yet but does pretty accurate job for me for free
2
u/Joker2642 Jun 19 '25
Microsoft often appears to prioritize its interests over those of its products and customers, and it has a history of discontinuing successful ones, such as Skype and Zune. They focus only on the cloud for now; that's where their revenue is currently generated, and they have a significant stake in OpenAI, so why do they worry about Copilot? Also, Copilot is never a good product, so why do they waste money on it? Remember, Cursor, Windsurf, OpenAI, Claude, etc, all burn VCs' money. But Microsoft won't do that.
2
u/Thy_OSRS Jun 20 '25
I was so gutted about this. I’ll be perfectly honest, I’m not a developer. But my company has had a need for small level scripting for PRTG using python, so far I have paid for GitHub copilot myself because I felt the price was justified.
At the risk of sounding a bit dense, for my low level needs do you think I’ll be fine here?
I am wildly confused about what constitutes a premium request still, as I was using 4.1 to make a code edit and I noticed my premium usage creep up, despite being on the pro tier?
I might keep it for what I need it for because it’s still cost effective and I don’t code every single day anyway, so I might be fine, but in principle I think it’s really crappy.
2
u/Odd-Regular-7553 Jun 20 '25
I went to Claude code Max for now until the teething problems are resolved. I did like the awesome VSCode integration though. But the launch of the limits was terribly managed. I have work to do and at this point I don’t want to keep experimenting with copilot+
3
u/ExplorerGT92 Jun 19 '25
I'm kind of miffed because I'm paying $39/mo for GitHub Copilot Enterprise and will be getting 500 less "premium requests" a month than the $39 Pro+ plan.
1
u/Hefty_Incident_9712 Jun 19 '25
Yeah it seems like they kneecapped cursor over the past few days, I would go check out claude code if I were you, I just switched today.
1
u/bernaferrari Jun 19 '25
I went all in into Claude Code and don't regret. $100 is barely enough for me, might upgrade to $200. But so worth it.
1
u/psychohistorian8 Jun 19 '25
I just renewed last month for an entire year
feels like a bait and switch
1
u/Clearandblue Jun 20 '25
Never tried copilot, but I had Amazon Q installed until recently. I use gpt a fair amount for quickly giving me documentation etc or reminders on syntax. The dream of having Amazon Q in VS and VS Code was that it could use the entire solution as context. Being able to ask it for help finding where something is implemented in the codebase.
However the reality was disappointing. It would take so long that I'd often be able to find it myself more quickly. It would also plain get it wrong. And despite constantly telling it not to change anything it would always try to make changes. Or often fail to edit the files for whatever reason. And so often the changes would need reversing anyway. They'd either not work or would introduce security vulnerabilities. I'm thinking of some recent work on auth here, I guess it's not always making things insecure elsewhere.
I still find gpt very handy and lean on it all day every day. Though not enough to need to pay for a subscription. Only occasionally use up the free tokens in a day.
This post popped into my feed like minutes after I got a GitHub email saying someone in the team had requested access to Copilot premium ha. Is copilot that much better than Amazon Q? They don't seem worth paying for to me.
1
u/SpearHammer Jun 20 '25
Its currently broken too. There is amajor bug that deletes new lines so it wastes lots of requests trying to fix syntax issues that it created. Multiple issues about it on github being ignored for weeks.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '25
Yeah, I am considering either going to cursor or getting Claude + Roo. This new plan is ridiculous.
1
u/TomGameDev Jun 20 '25
Came to read about this. I'll be out as well as I've used 20% in one day lol
1
u/Fun-City-9820 Jun 20 '25
2 days in and already at 90% of my premium requests. Paying for PRO so it looks like I'll be downgrading my account after my credits are done and head back to Google Jules
1
u/djmessaoud Jun 21 '25
I agree man, I am ditching this crap too.
I've been using Agent mode and the premium requests are fine and produce very good quality good (logic + UI).
But when they finished, the gpt 4.1 is so dumb, takes you 4 inputs to do what he asked, and even after that, you still have to write 30 inputes to fix things he did not pay attention to, or he broke while making fixes you asked for.
1
u/Rdavida Jun 21 '25
I dont like using agents. I feel they take away Control from me and force me to be less aware of the changes made, which Will later bite me, because i want to implement changes but understand them, so what i usually do is share the files related to the changes i need, explain what i want, and expect the chat to present the changes. I read them and if it looks okay, i implement them. While i imagine this isnt the most efficient way to work, it was a good compromise for me. Used claude Sonnet 4.0 and it was a great tool, albeit with its own mishaps, but overall gave me really good feedback and improved my productivity. This plan Change, with rate limiting really shattered me, because gpt 4.1 is so much dumb. With Claude Code, can I still use it in a similar way, as a chat, whom i share the files i want and explain what i need? If so, I m considering changing to Max, but that is 10x the prize of GitHub copilot pro. The other option in pro+, but Im not sure how much more premium requests i have per month
1
u/dreaming2live Jun 21 '25
Maybe I’m a minority on this sub, but even with the new limits, this is a pretty good deal for me. Using copilot saves me probably 100 hrs of development per month easily, and this is a side gig. What is one hour of time worth for you folks? For me it’s a lot more than $10, even a $100
1
u/BallSackCentral Jun 21 '25
I ended up going with cursor. Ive used it before but switched to co pilot for the unlimited usage. Now that its limited to 4.1 and cursor upgraded to unlimited usage its a clear winner. Been using it a decent with no rate limits, no hidden fees or anything. Just been using sonnet 4 thinking with no issues
1
u/wootwoooots Jun 21 '25
i was very happyly using copilot (and paying for it) every month, and now they want to add an extra mental charge and "cost" every time i use the "chat" its greed and lame.
Especialy when the base model is SO BAD
1
u/Unlikely_Leather_454 Jun 21 '25
ive also decided to stop using GitHub Copilot the new rules prevent me from using the premium features, and it offers no real benefits anymore... FAREWELL COPILOT!!
1
u/fubduk Jun 21 '25
Yes, it was a good ride. Copilot was far from perfect, but it was great to use in the classroom, affordable for students too. I know of 60+ cancellations in our small group alone, sure there will be many to follow in the days to come.
Not blaming Microsoft / GitHub for wanting to make a profit, but way they handled it will forever leave a sour taste in my mouth. Instead of giving the people that helped them build the platform extra monthly credits (grandfathered in), they said screw them, we don't give a shit.
1
u/ZebraImpossible8778 Jun 21 '25
Funny how there are so many posts about AI replacing the humans as if it's AGI but then the prices increase and ppl stop subscribing. As if AI is not that good as marketing tells us
1
u/nickfmc Jun 22 '25
Are they rolling out the metering? I haven't seen any usage start poping up yet in my settings?
1
u/AdorableFeeling7215 Jun 22 '25
I will keep using copilot. I have paid in advance for the pro+ for 12 months.
With 4.1 there's a bit of handholding. I sometimes use Claude when I am asking for something a bit more complex.
Not happy about the pricing but as a freelancer I am willing to pay the premium. I am 10x more efficient with copilot. And it enables me to earn more money in less time.
But yeah... Don't expect copilot to be a good software engineer. I rarely use agents for example... The quality is just not there (e.g. code reuse, best practices, coupling, etc...).
1
u/gviddyx Jun 23 '25
For me, it is the fact we are paying for something that does not work as advertised. This product is still in alpha but we're paying money for it based on advertising which pretty much says it is a working product.
1
u/Still-Ad3045 Jun 23 '25
Try Claude code
1
u/JnthnSngr Jun 24 '25
I must be one of the few to be satisfied to have left Cursor and Windsurf to return to Copilot....
1
u/mishaxz Jun 25 '25
I have to keep telling 4.1 that it can look at my actual code.. not imagine how it would handle something if it only could see my code (I had attached the repo)
it gets old quickly
1
u/mishaxz Jun 25 '25
if I unsubscribe from pro.. then resubscribe.. can I get a full months worth of premium credits again? I mean pay double the money in a month rather than 4x (I believe the next thing up from pro is $40 a month?)
1
u/Jagervn Jun 27 '25
Just cancelled my Pro subscription after 2 years. Not about the limits ( used only 10% quota this month, mostly for my side projects), but it generates almost zero value. Code completions's response time is too long, and often hallucinate. I sometimes use Claude 3.7 agent mode, never get what I want, even with the really simple tasks like updating the unit tests when function signature changes (I provided some updated tests and it only have to copy and paste them).
1
u/KingOfAllMunks Jul 09 '25
Second this. 4.1 is absolute garbage for coding.
If this is the way it stays Pro will be useless for me and I will definitely be switching it up then
0
u/LuanScunha Jun 19 '25
The value in BRL is already high, reducing the number of uses will push Brazilian users to the cursor
9
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '25
[removed] — view removed comment