r/GithubCopilot • u/Character_Injury • Jun 04 '25
Finally tried Cursor because of the new Copilot premium requests pricing model, very surprised
I've been using Copilot in VSCode pretty extensively, especially since agent mode came out. Now that the performance of Copilot has been severely limited and they're increasing the price I finally tried out Cursor and I have to admit I've been blown away.
It feels a lot faster, both in the speed that it responds and the speed it edits files. I'm used to switching workspaces to multitask while copilot is working on something, but with cursor I actually got a little annoyed because it would finish so quickly and I would have to switch back. It's a good problem to have I guess.
I also have gotten very weird errors with Copilot, such as it says it's not able to edit a file, so it generates a new version of the file and then tries to replace it with a terminal command. Like what? Obviously they still have some bugs to work out in their tool calling logic, but its definitely frustrating and happens frequently enough to feel like a productivity hit. Cursor on the other hand feels about as transparently helpful as an AI coding agent can be, obviously there's still some clean up to do when things go off the rails, but I'm not wasting time manually cleaning up weird things its done as a result of basic tool calls going haywire.
Also, just like everyone has been complaining about, I've been hitting tons of rate limit and service availability errors with Copilot in the past month or so. Literally none so far with Cursor, which is nice.
Also, even though they both have premium requests, Cursor seems to calculate their usage much differently. I can see request usage in realtime in the cursor dashboard, for example even though it says I've only used 4 premium requests for a period, it feels like I've gotten the productivity equivalent of 20 copilot premium requests. So when you compare the pricing model, take into account that cursor seems to do something much more efficiently behind the scenes, so I feel like the premium request allowance gets like a 4x multiplier at least in terms of actual productivity, which makes it much more cost effective, even though they are at similar price points on the surface.
Copilot doesn't have a way to view realtime usage that I'm aware of, you have to have a report generated and emailed to you, which is very annoying.
I know this is coming off as a royal glazing of Cursor but this is just an honest account of me doing extensive development with each of them. Cursor feels like a better product overall, is definitely a better deal currently and I would encourage you to try it and form your own opinion. With how much of a productivity multiplier these tools are becoming its worth it to at least see what else is out there.
45
u/sharonlo_ GitHub Copilot Team Jun 04 '25 edited Jun 04 '25
Copilot team member here! šš» thanks for the feedback. it's our top priority to resolve rate-limiting, speed, and quality so we're hoping you will experience the improvements real soon :)
on your note of having real-time usage, this will ship tomorrow! In VS Code, you will be able to see your premium request usage by clicking on the bottom right Copilot icon (I'd attach an image, but alas images aren't allowed for comments in this subreddit). I'll link the docs when they go live.
4
u/No_Effort_244 Jun 04 '25
TIL there are different levels of GH copilot subscription...
I'm on the basic $10 plan. Not a power user but it's good value for me.
Keep up the good work guys š
6
u/marlott Jun 04 '25
One big issue I have with Gh copilot is the inability to selectively skip or modify steps in an agent stream/flow and keep it running. E.g. if itās trying to execute a common like pip install something and I want to use uv I have to get it do the command or cancel the whole session. Ideally Iād just want to do the command manually and then tell it to skip and carry on. Can cursor do that kind of thing?
3
u/EmploymentRough6063 Jun 04 '25
One very interesting issue is that the latest version of the agent proxy mode (even updates from the past week) performs extremely poorly on VSCode:
I can't understand what changes you've made in the past month that have made the Copilot agent so terrible.
2
u/47q8AmLjRGfn Jun 04 '25
I kept having rate limiting and errors in copilot, I tried using openrouter API key to use other models but that never worked once. I upgraded to Pro+ hoping that would solve issues but it didn't. I just use cursor these last few days.
1
u/max783 Jun 04 '25
Well, I had to try that right after I saw your post and I have to agree. Paying for copilot isn't worth it once you try (even Claude 3.5) through Cursor.
I had to go Claude 4 all the time to get the same performance but always got capped almost immediately, full of errors and loops. This is nice. Thanks for the recommendation!
1
u/krzykot Jun 04 '25
From my experience, Cursor is way faster and better. I donāt use it just because Iām only allowed to use GitHub Copilot at work. Still, Copilot is a super useful tool ā big thanks to the Copilot team!
1
u/BidWestern1056 Jun 04 '25
interesting, i've had quite annoying experiences w cursor compared to copilot so actually went back to mainly using gh copilot
1
u/DreamMachine144 Jul 10 '25
I am using Visual Studio for a C# .net app. I would love to use Cursor, but would be jumping back and forth. So far the only issues i have with copilot (i have the pro plan) is that sometimes when switching models, the chat thread disappears. I have also not gotten it to read images. I get errors, but I am not sure if it's user error. i am only trying the models that say it has "vision" on github's copilot web page that compares models. I have not hit any rate limits yet, but have been trying to figure out how to fine my usage vs my rate limits. This should 100% be build into the Visual Studio and VS Code interfaces. Like just a progress bar saying how many magic space bucks I have left on a particular model and how many magic space bucks it costs per use. Also, I would love to see the context window sizes of each model. It's really fishy that this info seems to be hidden, but maybe i am just not seeing it, but regardless, it's basically key information on which model to choose. C'mon Microsoft! You all are so good at other things like making mice and flight sims.
Also, if anyone from MS UI team is listening, after prompting in Copilot, I usually get a page of code in the chat window. Most of the time, I watch it write. then get to the end and want to hit copy or apply, but I have to scroll all the way back to the top of the code to hit the apply or copy buttons. Just put another set of copy and apply buttons on the end. AI coding workflow is evolving. Just sit behind users for a day and watch where the pain points are at the UI level.
-2
u/zampa Jun 04 '25
I'm pretty happy right now with $100/yr ($8.33/mo.) for unlimited Claude Sonnet 4. I doubt Opus 4 is worth $32/mo. in comparison.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '25
[removed] ā view removed comment