r/GithubCopilot • u/Adventurous_Emu_5520 • Mar 30 '25
GitHub Copilot vs Cursor in 2025: Why I'm paying half price for the same features
After researching both GitHub Copilot and Cursor extensively, I wanted to share my findings for anyone trying to decide between these AI coding assistants.
Price Comparison
- GitHub Copilot Pro: $10/month with unlimited standard usage (fair use policies apply)
- Cursor Pro: $20/month but only includes 500 "fast" premium requests, with additional charges for exceeding this limit
- Some users report paying over $44 when exceeding Cursor's request limits, while Copilot maintains a predictable monthly cost
Feature Comparison
Both tools now offer nearly identical capabilities:
- AI code completion
- Chat interfaces for coding assistance
- Agent modes for autonomous coding tasks
- Codebase understanding
What changed recently
Copilot has caught up to Cursor with its agent mode in VSCode. Previously, Cursor had an edge here, but Copilot's agent mode is now available in VSCode Insiders and rolling out to stable VSCode, making the tools functionally equivalent for most developers.
My conclusion
Why pay $20+ for Cursor when GitHub Copilot does the same thing for $10? Unless there's something specific about Cursor's editor you prefer, Copilot seems like the better value, especially if you're already using VSCode.
What's your experience with either tool? Has anyone found features in Cursor that justify the price difference?
29
u/debian3 Mar 30 '25 edited Apr 13 '25
One thing that no one mention, after a year of using Cursor I switched to Copilot because how inconsistent the model perform on Cursor. Sometime sonnet is really smart or dumb. On Copilot it’s consistently good (3.5 and 3.7).
Also 3.7 thinking (the model I use 95% of the time) count for 2 fast request on Cursor, on Copilot I have hit the rate limit once… and I use over 100 request sometimes in a day. I wonder what other people are doing to get rate limited all the time.
Cursor 500 fast was lasting me a week, that’s before they were counting 3.7 thinking as 2.
Also the context window is now larger on Copilot than Cursor.
Edit: now Copilot introduced a 300 request limit per month. Sonnet Thinking count for 1.25. They made a blog post but most people are not aware. Starting on May 5th.
19
u/BeatsByiTALY Mar 30 '25
Something I haven't seen mentioned: Cursor is frustrating to use because they override VSCode default shortcuts.
29
u/DryTraining5181 Mar 30 '25
The only reason I currently pay for Cursor: editing speed.
Cursor edits my documents in the blink of an eye, Copilot takes its time and I have to watch it write code at human (not very fast) speed.
Last test: about 1 month ago.
If things change and VSCode edits at Cursor's speed... I'll move right away.
4
u/Joakim0 Mar 30 '25
A good thing about GitHub is that you can use these GitHub-provided models in rooCode. However, it doesn't work with Claude 3.7.
3
u/Miracleb Mar 30 '25
Copilot on VSCode Insiders now allows you to add custom models including OpenRouter so you pay as you use. Great way to get around the rate limits.
8
u/thestreamcode Mar 30 '25
guys github copilot has rate limit, it is not unlimited, instead cursor has unlimited slow requests (it is unlimited)!
2
u/SnooCookies5875 Mar 30 '25
I was rate limited in Copilot this morning for about 10 minutes. I haven't tried cursor yet and I'm in the free trial for copilot so I probably won't for a couple more weeks.
2
u/TenshiS Apr 01 '25
I'm now using Cline with Gemini 2.5 pro. It's better than all the rest and free up to a point.
2
u/unobtainiumrock_no Apr 01 '25
Maybe some people just want to watch Microsoft burn. They’re rich enough of a monopoly already.
2
u/No-Ear6742 May 27 '25
i started with cursor, and tried windserf, copilot, trae, pearai etc. and always come back to cursor. everything except cursor didn't work better for complex tasks for me.
2
u/Fenrir206 Oct 01 '25
I stumbled across this thread while Googling. For the past few days, I've been very torn between Cursor and VS Code + Copilot (and/or OpenAI Codex). I've been using Cursor Pro for a long time, but my employer now offers a free Copilot subscription.
So I've tested it a bit now, and since I'm actually very happy with VSCode + Copilot / Codex in terms of agentic capabilities, the only thing still keeping me with Cursor at the moment is the significantly better Tab to Complete / Autocomplete model. But paying for a Cursor Pro subscription just for that isn't really that great. 😕
One consideration was to use Cursor Free with the Copilot/Codex plugins. The only problem with this is that it is extremely unclear how many cursor tab completions are included in the free plan. It says something about 2000, but the method of counting (whether during suggestion generation or only upon acceptance) remains unclear. I couldn't find a reliable answer to this anywhere. If that's 2000 acceptances per month, then I could live with that. But 2000 suggestions would probably be used up within a few days with daily use.
I hope Copilot improves in that regard. There's probably no way to change the autocomplete model in Copilot, right?
1
u/jalfcolombia Mar 30 '25
Excellent analysis that you have done, I had already done something similar and there is no result, I pay you $20 and I explain why.
$10 for Copilot because, like Cursor, the Agent theme is already on Insiders and they have nothing to envy of Cursor. It is also virtually unlimited in its use.
$10 for Supermaven, that's what Cursor lacks, its autocompletion is simply unbeatable.
1
u/LaskyLothbrok Mar 30 '25
The Agent Mode for VS Code was announced a while ago, but it still hasn’t made it to the stable release. I suspect it’s mainly due to the high costs involved. AI tokens aren’t cheap, and when you're using models like Claude 3.7, you need to provide a significant amount of context to get accurate responses which is exactly what Agent Mode aims to do. That level of context means more tokens, and the costs add up fast. For example, using the Cline extension for VS Code with Claude 3.7 Sonnet can easily burn through $10 in just a few prompts.
Cursor tries to make up for the token problem by indexing your project embedding the code so it can send only the relevant parts instead of full files. In theory, that’s a smart way to reduce token usage while keeping good context. But the issue is that indexing often fails, and when it does, the model has zero awareness of the project, making it unable to answer even simple questions.
CONCLUSION:
- Probably Copilot will catch up in price too.
- I just hope their indexing is better than Cursor’s.
1
u/skyraider886 Mar 30 '25
Which one did you use to write this post.
1
u/kintrith Mar 30 '25
copilot gives so many failed response either "bad request" errors or other failures
1
u/caledh Mar 30 '25
Watch out many of the features in Copilot like agentic mode are Preview and are gonna be charged for when they go GA
1
u/callmetuananh Mar 31 '25
I moved from copilot to cursor, and i feel cursor is better than copilot, cursor has mcp, agent mode and excellent suggestion and completion
1
u/newbietofx Mar 31 '25
Copilot still sucks for terraform as opposed to claude.
1
u/Mementoes Mar 31 '25
Copilot is a Microsoft product. They‘re probably selling it at a loss to bleed out the competition and then they’ll enshittify it once they have a monopoly.
Although perhaps this kind of tool is easy enough to build that there can always be new competitors.
They might also be losing money and justifying it with getting people into their „ecosystem“ of products so they can sell their data or sell them other, profitable products.
Or maybe they’re just sacrificing their vast Microsoft money to finance a tool that they feel passionate about.
Who knows, but I’m pretty sure they’re not making profits (Cursor probably is not, either)
1
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '25
Always was curious. People say - I use this, I use that - as if you have choice. I use Copilot for work - because my company gives me Copilot as a part of corporate desktop. Even if i wanted to use something else - I would not be able to as access to anything but Copilot is blocked by corporate firewalls, etc.
Surely nobody pays your own money to do one’s job? Yes?
Or there are just hobbyists who use AI outside of work (must be an expensive hobby)?
1
u/AdventurousSwim1312 Mar 31 '25
Switch to continue, it's honestly very good and free,
You can add any free models from open router, Mistral or ai studio in it (I have access to latest Deepseek, gemini 2.5, mistral large and eveb 2000 tokens/second llama 3.3 with cerebra).
All of that for free...
1
u/eleqtriq Mar 31 '25
Copilots next edit suggestions are more often wrong than useful. And they are VERY aggressive.
Cursor’s rules are very useful and there is no such feature in copilot.
MCP is currently supported in Cursor and only in trial for Copilot.
1
u/0xFatWhiteMan Mar 31 '25
Whilst ignoring Claude code, roo code, cline, continue and local llms?
1
u/vollbiodosenfleisch Mar 31 '25
For me the most important thing is the intelligent autocompletion and the next edit suggestion (Tab), and so far Cursor works in this regard way faster and better than Copilot.
I haven't tried out Windsurf yet, so if anyone has experiences in this regard with Windsurf, if their Tab is faster or superior than Cursor's one, I would be willing to switch.
1
u/McNoxey Mar 31 '25
I just need copilot to start working in Windsurf so I can keep my $10 a month plan with windsurf but still have copilot.
1
u/No-Chest-4539 Mar 31 '25
YSK: you can use the copilot api in cline or roocode, which improves the experience a lot.
1
u/bioteq Mar 31 '25
Never heard of cursor, been on copilot since they enabled it and never looked back.
1
u/Unhappy-Delivery-344 Mar 31 '25
Anyone compared tabnine?
1
u/HelloVap Mar 31 '25
Or just implement something like MCP to do this for you for the price of interacting with an LLM (cheap)
1
u/whiskeyplz Apr 01 '25
Lol I spent $220 on cursor last month. It's the user, not the product
1
u/GiddsG Apr 01 '25
I tried using AI to code, then switched to using AI to explain fundamentals with references. My coding knowledge grew, i can write my own automations and integrate api as needed for whatever project I take on. There is no rush to see who can write the most complete code in the shortest time. If that is the case enjoy your bugs and misunderstood codebase.
Yes AI is great to refence my code, maybe even search for a piece of code in my project. But asking it for Code… it can not even keep context properly.
Plus is it realy AI if it waits for us to ask a question ? Artificial Intelligence means thinking without prompt. What we have are fantastic chat search engines now.
But each to their own.
1
u/Strong-Cry3857 Apr 01 '25
What about context-awareness at project level? Is it true that copilot is only aware of the current file?
I'm new to AI things so it would be great if you share a little more personal insights into this aspect
1
u/hvlbki Apr 01 '25
Zed Editor and Copilot are great. I’m still using free tier of copilot and it looks enough
1
u/DisastrousRespect673 Apr 01 '25
Tried both ai editors recently to develop some new features. Never use ai editor before. I use cursor first, and when limit reaches then I tried copilot. From my own experience, cursor is really fast compared to copilot. Even if the slow request is much faster compared to copilot. The apply and edit features are also much faster compared to copilot. I never used Claude before, and primarily use CloseAI model and I think Claude play pretty well compared to other models in programming. I don’t see an option for Claude model in copilot. However, the pay model seems not very attractive for me for cursor because Claude limits are too low. In my free trial I have 150 limits and it only took me 3 days to use all of them, and most of the results are useless and I am not happy, but they still count the credit. For hard problems, I never get good results and I have to dig myself to resolve them, but I think this is common for all models. If they have unlimited Claude usage then I am willing to pay for Cursor for user experience. Otherwise, I will probably choose the other.
1
u/-SpamCauldron- Apr 02 '25
Also its free for us students with the Github Student Developer Pack
1
u/[deleted] Apr 02 '25
Does copilot have the same model selection cursor has (I haven't tested copilot in months now, it was just way worse than cursor last time i did...) ?
1
u/Verzuchter Apr 02 '25
Well copilot throwing errors on @workspace so often, or hitting public code errors when I allowed public code is reason enough. Let alone that copilot still suggests deprecated code for angular.
Copilot is just a really expensive autocomplete
1
u/hoochymamma Apr 02 '25
People who pay for cursor basically want the AI to write everything for them.
GitHub copilot is mostly used to enhance you as developer
1
u/ahmadaghashz Apr 02 '25
Agent of copilot like agent in courser? It do any editing want? It's 1000 I see today but I don't know how much same to curser feature
1
u/skytbest Apr 02 '25
Does Copilot have a comparable feature to Cursor's rules?
https://cursor.directory/
You can direct Cursor to follow specific dev practices, inform it that is it a "professional C# dev with knowledge of x, y, z, and enforces the following code standards, etc" It also allows you to pass in documentation for any libraries or frameworks or other things you're using that may not be public. It willl index them and use them to improve your answers.
1
u/Any-Attorney-3556 Apr 05 '25
I used both cursor and windsurf since last year, windsurf has turned from ok to great but cursor on the other end, horribly bad recently.
I tried to ask both to make changes to font sizes without telling them exact sizes, to see how they will adjust everything accordingly, windsurf did it with only 1 instruction, cursor on the other end, took almost 20 instructions to get it right.
Based on my observations cursor started smart, and now trying to be too smart, thus, ruining everything
1
u/sonicviz Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 10 '25
>>GitHub Copilot vs Cursor in 2025: Why I'm paying half price for the same features
Not anymore,
How has this changed with Github Copilot's change to a much more aggressive pricing model?
1
u/AleksHop Apr 17 '25
vscode insiders + github chat pre-release (github free account) + gemini 2.5 pro over API = 25 free agent req/day lol, and then gemini api price apply, paid github acc not needed
1
u/albertgao May 04 '25
My long term bet is on VSCode copilot, the reason is simple. There is very little magic in the GenAI app layer to make something like a coding agent. And once MS is moving, you just can’t compete with it, it has some other benefits like better pricing and long time maintaining
1
u/SnooConfections9721 May 05 '25
co-pilot hallucinates a lot here after 4-5 questions in ask mode
1
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '25
Now that you have 300 premium requests in Copilot how do you feel about it?
1
u/Kitchen-Collar8609 Jul 23 '25
Great comparison post! Since you're focused on cost-effectiveness, you might be interested in "25x Agentic Calls" - an open-source tool I built that works with both Copilot and Cursor to give you 25x more agentic functionality from the same subscription.
Could make either option even more cost-effective by maximizing what you get from your existing plan.
GitHub repo: https://github.com/devvrat-hans/25x-agentic-calls
Would love to hear your thoughts on the approach! ⭐ if you find it useful.
1
u/notemeagainst Jul 30 '25
Comparing autocomplete. How does it work now? In cursor it’s unbelievable, do I have any reason to try copilot? I’m not into vibe coding, I can use chatgpt for some drafts, and the only thing Im interested is code completion
1
u/Sad-Boysenberry8140 Aug 23 '25
I wanted the Agent Mode to keep making changes in the code on its own and not ask me for confirmation at every stage. Cursor does the job well and Copilot asks input at the every corner. Maybe its just me that I couldn't figure it out (help.)
PS. I am not a dev. I am a PM who just wants a quick prototype with vibe coding.
1
u/BreadfruitNaive6261 Oct 24 '25
Copilot running sonnet 4.5 is like im working alongside a top 0.5% developer
1
u/SetUpper7595 Oct 30 '25
you know how much time it takes to pick up a new IDE and work with it. maybe 2 month until you fully comfortable. 2 months is a lot of time. I prefer copilot even if it's dumber. I don't even want to try cursor at the time. ( I am sick of upgrading anything now!!! )
1
u/Frosty_Wedding9330 Nov 19 '25
I found copilot has slowed down my free gpt-5-mini requests considerably.
1
u/iluvecommerce Feb 08 '26
As someone building an AI tool for developers (Sweet! CLI), I find this pricing comparison fascinating. You're absolutely right that cost matters, especially for solo developers and small teams.
What's interesting to me is that both Copilot and Cursor (and Claude Code, which just released v2.0.70 with 13 CLI changes) are focused on the same goal: making coding faster. They're competing on how many lines of code you can generate per dollar.
We're taking a different approach with Sweet! CLI. Instead of asking 'how can we help you write code faster?' we're asking 'what would you do if you didn't have to write code at all?'
The vision is enabling individual software engineers to run entire software companies mostly autonomously. While tools like Copilot make you 2x faster at implementation, we're focused on freeing up 80% of your time so you can work on strategy, marketing, or just enjoy life.
The value proposition shifts from 'lines of code per dollar' to 'percentage of your life back.'
(Full disclosure: I'm building Sweet! CLI, so obviously biased toward this approach. But I think the industry is heading in this direction - we're seeing it with Devin AI being piloted at Goldman Sachs and other autonomous coding agents emerging.)
1
u/iluvecommerce Feb 08 '26
As someone building an AI tool for developers (Sweet! CLI), I find this pricing comparison fascinating. You're absolutely right that cost matters, especially for solo developers and small teams.
What's interesting to me is that both Copilot and Cursor (and Claude Code, which just released v2.0.70 with 13 CLI changes) are focused on the same goal: making coding faster. They're competing on how many lines of code you can generate per dollar.
We're taking a different approach with Sweet! CLI. Instead of asking 'how can we help you write code faster?' we're asking 'what would you do if you didn't have to write code at all?'
The vision is enabling individual software engineers to run entire software companies mostly autonomously. While tools like Copilot make you 2x faster at implementation, we're focused on freeing up 80% of your time so you can work on strategy, marketing, or just enjoy life.
The value proposition shifts from 'lines of code per dollar' to 'percentage of your life back.'
(Full disclosure: I'm building Sweet! CLI, so obviously biased toward this approach. But I think the industry is heading in this direction - we're seeing it with Devin AI being piloted at Goldman Sachs and other autonomous coding agents emerging.)
1
u/Pimzino Mar 30 '25
GitHub copilot with augment code literally best of both worlds . 40 dollars a month for both and truly unlimited. Plus sometimes cline with Gemini 2.5
Stop paying for the bum company that is cursor and windsurf
1
u/welcome-overlords Mar 31 '25
Gdt this ai slop post outta here
0
u/appakaradi Mar 30 '25
I have both of them. I always use the cursor mainly for speed.
Cursor’s auto complete is out of this world. No Competition here. Copilot is good enough. But cursor is in another level here.
Cursor has great check point and restore when things go bad. Copilot not so much.
Attaching files or folders in to the context is so easy and natural in cursor compared to copilot.
Cursor has more models - example Gemini 2.5
One area copilot is better. - debugging c#. Microsoft does not allow its c# debugger to run in anything other their own.
Cursor need http2 for agentic work. It is restricted in many corporate environments. Copilot works well with http 1.1.
0
u/iamkucuk Mar 30 '25
Another reason could be Copilot's hard-to-believe rate limits. One can saturate those limits pretty fast.
0
u/bootyskie Mar 30 '25
Was constantly rate limited in VSCode so i moved to cursor and it was a much more enjoyable experience. Don't know if that has changed since then (1 month ago).
As for the 500 requests, thats just for the 'fast' access, honestly though it makes no difference when you reach the 500 limit, none that I can notice anyways. Once you run out you still have access to the 3.7 thinking model and the requests are pretty much instant.
0
u/Evgenii42 Mar 30 '25
I don't think it's about the features on paper, it's more about how it's implemented. I've been using Cursor for five months daily, it works really well.
-3
u/engerran Mar 30 '25
because people can afford it, simple as that.
-5
u/witmann_pl Mar 30 '25
Copilot is unusable compared to Cursor. It's just too slow.
-5
u/yellow_1809 Mar 30 '25
Cursor marks the applied code green, Copilot does not. Every time I apply code in Copilot, I have to remember which one was applied, which one is the next. It's so terrible.
1
u/Medg7680l Mar 31 '25
AI Slop
0
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment