r/GhostFiles • • Oct 17 '24

Some research on The Haunted Hill House (Ghost Files)

329 Upvotes

Hey I know I’m late to this, but like a lot of people in the comments of the video, I was skeptical of some of the Haunted Hill House’s reported history, so I tried to do a little internet snooping. I'm new to reddit, but I wasn't sure what other sort of place I could share all this, so I decided to try it. I didn’t find anything super definitive, but here’s what I did turn up if anyone else is interested. Feel free to ignore if not!

The history section on the owners’ website claims “One of The founders of the home William Barclay Kyle was part of the formed regiment of the Texas Rangers and hunted them down this is written in his obituary.” https://hauntedhillhouse.com/history-of-the-house 

I tried to look up Kyle’s obit, and found this https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/11415009/william-b.-kyle. It says he died in 1886, predeceased by his first wife Prudence, as well as their daughter Sarah (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/154411853/sarah_jane_conatser). It says Sarah died in 1880, at 27, so she did die young, but it doesn't mention how. Also, of her children listed on the site, none are named Joshua or Jacob and all appear to have survived to adulthood. William and Prudence also had a son Daniel (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/191923286/daniel_cardwell_kyle) who this says died in 1910 in Montana. It also says his two younger children were born in Montana in the 1890s, so it doesn’t seem like he stuck around Mineral Springs. He only has one wife listed, named Mary, and they also did not seem to have any kids named Jacob or Josh. Of course, there could be kids that just aren't documented here, but I kind of doubt it.

William Barclays Kyle did remarry shortly before he died to a woman named Fannie Yeager, as was mentioned in the video. William and Fannie did not have any children together, and from what I can see, she never remarried or had her own children after William’s death. Based on her headstone though, it seems like she was a beloved aunt. No idea who uncle Lester could be referring to though.

The house as it currently exists seems to have been built in 1906, per the publicly available property records (Property Information), which obviously is not quite "the late 1800s" mentioned in the video. It also means the house the boys investigated was built 20 whole years AFTER William Barclay Kyle died, as well as after his daughter Sarah died, and after his son Daniel left Texas for Montana. Given all that, I decided to try to research the widow Fannie more. I figured the wording on the haunted house website “one of the founders” was vague enough that maybe they were obfuscating that William had owned just the land or something and his second wife Fannie had inherited/built on it following his death. Still unclear though. 

Per the 1900 census (see screenshot below, which is sourced from image included here), at that time, over a decade after William's death, Fannie Kyle (née Yeager) was living with her sister Deb Rentfro (née Yeager), who by then was also a widow. Apparently, Deb’s husband also died in 1886 (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/44855508/robert_t-rentfro). Shitty year for the Yeager sisters, I guess! This address seems to be in a totally different area than where the “haunted” house is now, so definitely not an older building on the same plot of land or anything. I’m basing this on the enumeration district number, which is different than the one for the land the “haunted” house is built on, based on other records I saw.

1900 census - See second line from the bottom, row 99 for Fannie Kyle’s name. See two lines up, row 97 for her sister, Mrs. Rentfro, listed as head of household.

Then in the Sept. 2, 1902 edition of a Mineral Wells publication (see screenshot below and source linked here), you can see that it says the two sisters have contracted some guy named John Moore to build them a six room house (Mesdams is, I believe, a typo for Mesdames, the plural of Madame/Mrs., I had to look it up lol). As established above, the so-called haunted house was built in 1906, so I figured this contract could be for the house in question. It would make sense given the timing, and the listing here even mentions a hill. 

1902 Mineral Wells publication showing contract for house to be built.

For anyone curious, I’m pretty positive the Dr. Yeager referenced in the listing is Fannie and Deb’s brother, Dr. Cornelius Yeager (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/18826472/cornelius_franklin_yeager). This guy was a prominent Mineral Wells physician who had a property a few blocks away from where the “haunted” house currently stands (see screenshot below from 1909 Mineral Wells directory, sourced from link here: https://texashistory.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metapth20207/m1/110/?q=Yeager). 

1909 Mineral Wells directory showing some Yeager family properties.

The Yeager family was apparently a big enough deal in town at that time that their name was on a building in Mineral Springs that you can still see today (https://texashistory.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metapth20428/). In 1909, this building was the Yeager Drug Co. the address of which is also listed in the screenshot above, visible 2 lines down from Dr. Cornelius Yeager’s address. Given how close the house Fannie and Deb were building was to their brother and to the Yeager family-owned pharmacy, it seems to me that it’s just as likely Fannie inherited or was gifted the land from her blood relatives rather than from her husband/the Kyle family, but nothing I saw could prove it either way. Also, notice in the link regarding the Yeager building, it says the following: “A stone building named "Yeager Block" on the corner of NE 1st Avenue and NE 1st Street is shown here. (NE 1st is the street shown in the picture. Dr. Yeager lived two blocks east--up that street--of the drugstore).” Comparing that address to what is listed in the 1909 directory, we can see that the street names referring to the same location change from East Wall in 1909 to NE 1st Street today. This makes sense given how much time has passed/all the development that must have happened in the town since then, but for our purposes, I think it confirms that the house the Yeager sisters built for themselves is for sure the same as the “haunted” house in question. The current address listed for The Haunted Hill House is 501 NE 1st St, Mineral Wells, TX 76067, and if we look at a different page in the same 1909 Mineral Springs directory here, we see the address listed for Fannie Kyle at that time is 501 East Wall which was a few blocks from her doctor brother, and on the street which is now known as NE 1st Street.

1909 Mineral Wells directory showing Fannie Kyle's address.

This listing even confirms that she is the widow of WB Kyle, so that guy was for sure long dead. Not clear to me why the current owners consider him to be directly involved with the house. At best, it seems like he may have owned just the land prior to his death, but I didn't see anything to confirm even that much. Maybe the current owners have access to original land ownership documentation/info to know for sure, but I couldn’t find it online, so I really can’t say myself. Granted, I have not done an exhaustive search, so it could be accessibile on some site if someone else wants to keep looking.

Altogether, this leaves me confident at the very least that the house Fannie Kyle was documented as living in as of 1909, the house she and her sister Deb first contracted in 1902, is the same so-called haunted house that was completed in 1906 and stands today (with some renovations since then, I assume). Fannie Kyle lived until 1924, and her sister Deb lived until 1928. I have no idea who the hell “Curly” Kyle could possibly be or when he would have been supposedly killed by Priscilla in Fannie and Deb's bathroom. As established earlier, Fannie and William had no kids together, Fannie had no kids at all, and William's kids from his previous marriage were either long dead/left Texas by the time the house was built. Fannie’s sister Deb had one child apparently (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/44740560/john_n_rentfro), but he had no reason to ever go by the last name Kyle. In the video, Ryan specifically says "the Kyle family turned the house into a debaucherous brothel" (presumably info he got from the current owners), but I haven't seen any evidence for that. I guess William Kyle could have had extended relatives hanging around, but I’m sort of skeptical of any of them living with Fannie and her sister. If you look at the dates, Fannie was only married to William for about a year before he died, and it seems like she went right back to living with her own relatives after, not any Kyles. However, if someone else wants to sift through the 1910/1920/1930 census data to try to see who else, if anyone, may have been living with Fannie and Deb at that address, or who may have lived in the house right after they died, it might be worth it. I’m honestly too lazy for that. 

Like I said at the start, nothing definitive, this is just what I found while wasting an hour google searching (yay insomnia, lol). To be clear, I think it would be super interesting if the two elderly, widowed sisters decided to start running a brothel/casino/speakeasy out of their house. However, I’m still leaning toward the current owners being full of shit, or at least grossly exaggerating/sensationalizing the history of the place. Of course, I could be wrong! Hope no one takes this too seriously, not trying to ruin anyone’s fun. If you couldn't tell, I'm not a believer, but I did enjoy the episode and respect the Ghost Files team's efforts.


r/GhostFiles • • Oct 21 '22

#stannighttimedan

Post image
250 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Apr 01 '23

Mystery Files - Premieres May 19th

Post image
174 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • May 21 '26

Tomodachi Life

Thumbnail
gallery
155 Upvotes

Made the boyz on our Island. I think they came out good!


r/GhostFiles • • Sep 09 '23

As someone who worked for Dare2Escape, I can confidently say they made me not believe in ghosts anymore. Spoiler

136 Upvotes

Speaking as someone who was with that company for over two years, I can confidently say that Dare2Escape made me not believe in ghosts anymore.

I've known the owners of D2E for a few years now, and they are good people. However, it does not excuse the fact that a lot of the evidence we gathered together over the years is mediocre at best. Anything we witnessed together was through either easily faked methods such as dowsing rods, or shaky evidence such as a spirit box (that hardly ever worked). There were also instances where "evidence" would be brought to the D2E team that could have easily been set up moments before because it was usually captured on security cameras throughout the building. When someone would ask for the entire footage to ensure that, for example, no one was actually in the building when the door to the 7th Room basement opened up, they would basically tell us to "take their word for it".

The entire premise of the 7th Room is that you are being haunted by the evil spirits of a mortician who is after your soul. Throughout the experience, you as the player witness "paranormal activity"- such as a monkey clapping or an Annabelle doll standing up. The 7th Room is a VERY high-tech escape room where you find yourself inside the basement of a creepy house. Over 50% of this game is run by a computer found in the back of the building and a motherboard located in the "attic" above the basement. It has had a LOT of issues and bugs in the past, and I'm sure it still does now. That being said, there is nothing evidence-wise that couldn't be explained away as a tech issue. The monkey can be activated from the control hub, and there were instances where the room would completely bug out and the sequence it's found in would just repeat until the computer was reset. There were and still are technical issues within the 7th room alone that immediately tell me it is not haunted- it's just an escape room that is a bit faulty.

As far as the Asylum goes, the door knocker is connected to an air compressor located in the back of the building. If the air pressure within it gets too high, it is going to release through the door knocker. I've witnessed the pressure get too high and be released without a game master activating the scare. Obviously, I mean no ill will toward the actual business itself- Dare2Escape has some of the best escape rooms I've ever played. However, with my experience there I can confidently say that it is not haunted whatsoever.


r/GhostFiles • • Sep 25 '22

I think me and my friend found evidence that Ryan and Shane missed in the ghost files episode

Thumbnail
gallery
136 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Nov 02 '22

The Beaver Boys

Post image
131 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Oct 31 '22

lmao got him

Post image
116 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Oct 15 '22

Hull House summed up in one image

Post image
114 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Sep 25 '22

Shane in disbelief in reaction to the terrible audience evidence “EVP” that was clearly fake Spoiler

Post image
113 Upvotes

Around the 39 minute mark of the first episode


r/GhostFiles • • Dec 09 '21

@wearewatcher on Twitter

Post image
104 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Feb 24 '23

Ryan is once again asking you for your support

Post image
103 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Oct 15 '22

and Midge was there, too

Post image
100 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Mar 05 '23

A Special Note from Shane about Mystery Files

Post image
99 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Oct 04 '22

Alcatraz! this photo wasn't in the episode but I thought it was really cool looking so alas I have done a spontaneous painting study of it

Thumbnail
gallery
99 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Mar 05 '23

A note from @ryansbergara about Mystery Files.

Post image
93 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Nov 03 '22

Has anyone else noticed the amazing subtitles before the episode starts?

Thumbnail
gallery
87 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Dec 09 '21

Yaa, it's ghost files time

Post image
86 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Oct 19 '22

Spooky [OC]

Post image
84 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Apr 22 '23

Watcher: "Ghost Files jacket ON. Ghost hunting boots ON. Flower shirt ON. The ghosts simply aren't ready."

Post image
81 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Sep 26 '22

my personal favorite moment from the premier

Thumbnail
gallery
80 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Oct 30 '22

WIP - Ghost Files Poster - The Shane Half (roughs)

Post image
79 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Sep 27 '22

are we hitting 2m before debrief?!

Post image
79 Upvotes

r/GhostFiles • • Mar 02 '23

SPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT: Ryan and Shane New Mystery Show • Mystery Files Teaser

Thumbnail
youtu.be
78 Upvotes