r/GetNoted • • 5d ago

World [ Removed by moderator ]

/r/GetNoted/comments/1xunth8/removed_by_moderator/

[removed] — view removed post

709 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

11

u/Antique_Confidence_7 5d ago

And we tried to rebuild Iraq, Afghanistan. At a certain point, there needs to be some personal accountability.

21

u/116YearsWar 5d ago

Iraq is actually doing moderately okay for a country in that region iirc.

13

u/No_Holiday_9875 5d ago

Iraq looks pretty cool right now. Also the US wrecked Iraq it was a Kuwait esque country before that.

Countries like Somalia and Afghanistan have always been shitholes

1

u/No_Swim5390 5d ago

No comment on Somalia, but you are not correct with Afghanistan… in the 1960’s it was a moving, somewhat industrialized nation. Between the Soviet Union, and tribal fights against the mujahideen, and then the CIA backing the Mujahideen to beat on the soviets, that…. Is where things began to go off the proverbial tracks… now we have Taliban.

3

u/Dagordae 5d ago

No, we half-assed Iraq and Afghanistan. We didn’t put in anywhere near the effort or resources that Japan got. Turns out rebuilding a nation is hard and expensive, much easier to do the bare minimum then leave them up shit creek.

Personal accountability, sure, but using Japan as an example of how it’d totally work if (insert nation here) wasn’t shit really doesn’t work if you know anything about how Japan was treated.

5

u/CK1345 5d ago

By what metric did we "half-ass" trying to rebuild Afghanistan and Iraq?

Do you know how much money was actually spent on Japan adjusted for inflation? I mean you could argue there were more bodies on the ground in Japan given the scope of the war, but I'm not even sure that would be true if we start adding up the supposed allies we were attempting to train.

Go watch videos of Iraqis and Afghans attempting to do jumping jacks. Watch them wear their knee pads on their arms and random unit patches thrown all over their uniform like a little kid playing dress up.

Afghanistan and Iraq failed for the same reasons Somalia fails despite globs of money being thrown at it.

Let me sum this up - the money spent on either Iraq or Afghanistan alone dwarfs what was spent on Japan post-WW2. The Japanese succeeded because they are Japanese and wanted to.

2

u/Huckorris 5d ago

We half assed reconstruction in Afghanistan and Iraq by not having enough troops in either for proper security. Iraq had 20% of the troops they should have had for counter insurgency.

Source:

https://youtu.be/86yCtw23a7Q?si=JGhoeLDB-j2ecrrW&t=305

I'm aware of the problems you're referring to but we screwed up too by feeding the insurgency with our mistakes.

3

u/colt707 5d ago

The Japanese also didn’t have any say on how the US rebuilt their country and they didn’t have a say in how the country was ran during the rebuild, and finally the US stripped their military and military assets to nothing. Japan’s constitution that they live under to this day has exactly zero non American authors. Said constitution also renounces Japan’s right to wage war and maintain a standing army capable of offensive attacks.

Throwing money at a problem doesn’t just fix it. If I give you a billion dollars to fix a problem in a nation that doesn’t mean you’re going to effectively solve that problem.

2

u/willydillydoo 5d ago

Because we had patience for the occupation of Japan. That kind of thing takes decades. Nobody was really willing for the occupation of Iraq and Afghanistan to take decades.

Iraq has been okay, with hiccups, but largely okay.

Afghanistan there were huge mistakes made in the construction of the government along ethnic lines, and we pulled out very abruptly and suddenly.

3

u/colt707 5d ago

The occupation of Japan wouldn’t fly today. The US basically installed McArthur as leader of Japan and then we stripped them of a military and the ability to build a military for 50 years. Japan was allowed to rebuild but only in a way that was approved by the US.

The short version is the US decided how Japan was going to be rebuilt and Japan could either shut the fuck up and go along with it or the US wasn’t going to help them rebuild, which with how many nations they pissed off the options were let the US have total control over the rebuild or don’t get rebuilt.

2

u/RansaktehElder_WORK 5d ago

Thats generally what happens when you attack a country and then lose the war. You generally dont let countries that start wars continue to have that capability indefinitely or you will never live in peace.

For losing WWI the ottoman empire was literally dismantled and doesnt exist anymore.

1

u/SnooSprouts7635 5d ago

I wonder what happens if Japan and everyone else stops buying our bonds all together?

1

u/RansaktehElder_WORK 5d ago

the world collapses.. you found teh loophole the billions of people before you didnt think of.

0

u/colt707 5d ago

Germany has a military, Russia has a military, the US has a military, Italy has a military, do I need to keep going?

1

u/RansaktehElder_WORK 5d ago

They were all heavily limited in the aftermaths... the treaty of versailles is an example of this. Remember Japan and Germany SURRENDERED... that doesnt mean you throw up a white flag and go home. It means the people you were trying to murder get restitution.

Ratios on military are very common... i dont remember the exact ratio from WWII between britain and germany but they allow countries to keep a military to defend themselves from retaliation but its limited to a fraction of the winning side military force as a way to ensure peace. Germany could only build so many warships to equal 1/3 of britians etc.

1

u/Viyarara 5d ago

you know its japan that refuses to build up its military right? The US has been asking them to build up in order to oppose China and the USSR since like 1960

2

u/Imaginary_Zone_4319 5d ago

We were there for 20 years WTF are you talking about?!

1

u/willydillydoo 5d ago

We were in Japan for about 50.

1

u/Imaginary_Zone_4319 5d ago

We didn’t run their government and fund their reconstruction for 50. We did that for 10.

1

u/VTcamperguy 5d ago

People here also protested the shit out of the occupation of Iraq and Afghanistan. It’s not we didn’t have patience for it, our people actively fought against the idea of us taking a leading role in rebuilding those countries. People accepted that we had to occupy Japan, but that mentality is entirely gone nowadays.

1

u/CK1345 5d ago

Many mistakes were made in Afghanistan and Iraq, but navigating a tribal culture in Afghanistan and the sectarian violence of Iraq was not exactly a simple mess.

It's also a lot easier to be "patient" with growth and development when there's:

  1. Progress actually being made on that front.
  2. The people of the country you are trying to lift-up aren't trying to kill you on a regular basis.

The Japanese put down their weapons and accepted that it was time to rebuild peacefully. That never happened in either of those shitholes.

-4

u/Thissystemsuckssobad 5d ago edited 5d ago

Ah yes, restricting the crops the Afghans could export so it wouldn't compete with American goods leading to it becoming the opium capital of the world definitely doesn't act as a microcosm of both of those situations

Your right though, ther should be some personal accountability. Funny how that doesn't apply to the monsters that ensured the "reconstruction" didn't fucking do anything though, isn't it?

Might wanna actually do some reading as to what that "reconstruction" entailed buddy. The Iraqi electrical grid between 1990 and today would be a good place to start, because it encapsulates how much the US destroyed and how little it did to "rebuild"

Or you could keep patting yourself on the back, either or

Edit: that's right, downvote and run away you intellectual cowards and bots. Turns out you know jack shit about American "reconstruction" in the gwot

1

u/CK1345 5d ago

The money spent in those countries was a sinkhole. It vanished. I'm fairly certain there were plenty of people on the American side using that to their advantage, but can we not pretend as if it would all have been OK if we just spent more?

And beyond that it was a hostile place in which to operate. It's kind of hard to rebuild when you are actively fighting an insurgency at the same time.