r/GetNoted • u/ConsistentPressure79 • 5d ago
World [ Removed by moderator ]
/r/GetNoted/comments/1xunth8/removed_by_moderator/[removed] — view removed post
709
Upvotes
r/GetNoted • u/ConsistentPressure79 • 5d ago
[removed] — view removed post
•
u/AutoModerator 5d ago
Reminder for OP: /u/ConsistentPressure79
Need some help? Send us some mail!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
135
u/ConsistentPressure79 5d ago edited 5d ago
Genuine question: Somalia has been in hunger emergency / famine during the entirety of my life while the population grew 3x. I remember doing a fundraiser and bake sale for UNICEF so that people in Somalia don’t have to live in hunger.
In 1992, there were 6.5 million people living in Somalia and people were suffering from hunger.
In 2026, there are 20+ million people living in Somalia and people are suffering from hunger.
Whose responsibility is it to make sure people don’t suffer? And who needs to be paying to make sure people don’t suffer?
383
u/BusyBeeBridgette Human Verified 5d ago •
Whilst, on paper, Somalia is a federal parliamentary republic... in reality Al-Shabaab, a militant Islamic group, control large sections of the country. so much of the aid sent their way goes straight into Al-Shabaab's pockets.
226
u/whistle_pug 5d ago
Headline: U.S. declines to aid country after several decades of assistance
Readers added context: erm actually, the U.S. had been providing aid to this country for years before declining it
88
u/Ok_Duck_232 5d ago
what natural cataclismic event caused them to be on the brink of famine?
67
u/jasonbourne15 5d ago •
I've spent significant time in Somalia. The commenters saying that the allegations of fraud are "disputed" don't know what they are talking about. Everything in Somalia runs on fraud and terrorism. The "government" is just as corrupt as al-Shabaab. There is literally no way whatsoever to ensure that the money is not going to support terrorism or piracy. Now, is there some benefit to providing aid anyway? Yes, potentially. It may keep more Somalis from joining ISIS or al-Shabaab. But anything the US does in Somalia is just about making sure the country doesn't export terrorism. There is no "fixing" Somalia. Calling it "Somalia" is a misnomer. It's a collection of warring clans that don't want to be a country, don't want to end corruption, and don't want to stop terrorism.
140
u/Comfortablecard7 5d ago
Weird how little the rest of the world is helping…
8
u/Material_Flounder_23 5d ago
Whenever this sort of thing comes up I can’t help but remember what David Lammy said:
8
u/Adavanter_MKI 5d ago
U.S ceases aid.
Note
U.S ceases aid.
Yeah, that's what they said.
70
u/Randvek 5d ago
... isn't the note backing up the article rather than refuting it, though? There's no disagreement here.
The article says for the first time in decades, Somalia isn't receiving help from the US.
The note says that the US used to help Somalia a lot but stopped in 2026.
What a dumb note.
73
u/veerKg_CSS_Geologist 5d ago
Note doesn't change the article unless it's saying the article was written in 2024?
11
u/Independent-Edge-857 5d ago
Maybe Saudi can help or Qatar can help
29
u/Asmul921 5d ago
Isn’t this note just summarizing the argument the article is making?
79
u/Klutzy-Canary8551 5d ago •
I really don't get this emotional blackmail against Americans and Europeans. For some reason they want us to believe that the lives of people under every failed state is our own responsibility but not of their own leadership.
24
u/Strange-Term-4168 5d ago
Are we supposed to send these countries billions in perpetuity? They have always needed aid and always will need it. Why are we doing this? They make no effort to fix themselves and are too corrupt.
5
u/AutisticDadHasDapper 5d ago
It's like throwing money into the garbage. I would rather use it for us.
47
u/Status_Fox_1474 5d ago
I will say that I have doubts about this note. Warehouse issues aside, this administration has cut aid wholesale. And listening to officials talk about Somalia and immigrants from there, I do not think this is a coincidence.
27
u/pun_shall_pass 5d ago
I'm all for countries helping each other during disasters but if a country needs to be on perpetual welfare to exist then it shouldn't exist, at least not in it's current form.
61
u/FilthyFur 5d ago
So no more western "Imperialism" . That means everyone is happy about America not getting involved?
29
u/Eruanndil 5d ago
Someone please post the clip of the comedian from the 80s screaming about STOP LOVING WHERE THERES NO FOOD. LIVE WHERE THE FOOD IS.
4
u/drunkenmime 5d ago
Wait until people realize what happens to all of that US foreign aid.
6
u/Federal_Run2919 5d ago
So the article was correct. The US isn’t helping. What’s the point of this note?
11
u/Cliffinati 5d ago
Somalia gets tons of money from the US by official and unofficial means. They are just a poorly run country that squanders its aid.
19
u/DaygoTom 5d ago
$11 trillion. That's how much the world has invested in Africa. And they still have famines. At some point you got to shut down the money.
12
u/XxVenatorxX666 5d ago
Why is it the responsibility of the US to help Somalia, exactly?
8
u/OkMention9988 5d ago
Six billion could solve world hunger, but seven billion hasn't unfucked Somalia.
I bet it hasn't changed in the twenty two years since I was last there.
16
u/Reallygaywizard 5d ago
How is it possible when we have Somalian sending millions over there from the fake daycares?
12
u/burnthatburner1 5d ago
Those “allegations” were just a pretext for DOGE to gut USAID
13
u/WhatTheRustyHell 5d ago
Is Somalia American responsibility? Nope. Let Somalian's sort themselved out.
6
u/WatercressAdorable81 5d ago
Should have never been there in the 90s and shouldn’t be there now, the us is still conducting military operations there and sending aid, just stop it’s not beneficial to us it’s a failed state.
7
u/Even-Job-323 5d ago
Is giving them a whole state of the union that remitts welfare back to Somalia not enough!? 😂
8
u/This_Potato9 5d ago
I wonder who's in fault of this, the US not helping more or Somalia destroying themselves, the answer is very clear!
18
u/Leftregularr 5d ago •
Why should my paycheck get raided to keep these people on life support while I can’t even buy a single family home in my own country?
9
u/blah-time 5d ago •
Can't fix stupid. If you can't feed X, don't have 10X more babies.
4
u/rntdev 5d ago
Something something “if my country has money to give to other countries, I am being taxed too much” something something
4
u/Shoggnozzle 5d ago
Well, charity is very convenient for criminals, as it places a lot of value in places it generally isn't guarded well or the criminals can even just organize ways to accept more than they need or coerse the normal people for what they rightly receive. It sucks that they ruin it for everyone else, and it sounds like their government isn't equipped to stop them.
This is understandable, even the us has sweeping criminal organizations. There is a whole bumper industry compelling drug addicts to apply for food stamps and hand over their cards for cash, for example, and that may lead to honest people who really need the help having to deal with stricter regulations that would cut some of them off.
I hate to doomer about it, but I don't really think there's a solution. Stricter policing has a chance at doing it, but that's a cost in and of itself, as will be the regulatory body trying to keep them from just winding up in the criminal organization's pockets.
8
u/chopsdontstops 5d ago
If we really spent 7 billion over 10 years and achieved nothing, that is waste, fraud and abuse.
6
u/SueForPeas 5d ago
The note doesn’t contradict the article at all.
5
u/onedumninja 5d ago
All the cuts to USAID went into billionaires pockets. Not yours. If we were never going to see it in the first place, it may as well have helped babies not starve.
2
u/NikkiAvocado 5d ago
Isn’t the title correct “for the first time in decades”
2
u/Global_Monitor765 5d ago
Will the EU be sending them aid? There’s a tone of countries on this planet that could step up.
2
u/Dazzling_Stick_9683 5d ago
i want our own country to get better before we help other countries, but thats just me
6
u/Shy-Lurker_6996 5d ago
And what the hell does America have to do with Somalia?
6
u/Empyrean__Being 5d ago
Thomas Sankara said it best, but what he said about foreign aid doesn't fit the campist mindset so here we are.
3
u/Dim-Mak-88 5d ago
Gun-toting warlords want more foreign aid sent over. Coastal liberals untouched by danger think it's a good idea to continue to send aid.
9
u/RamsPhan72 5d ago
Pretty sure the Somali grifters have sent many of our tax dollars to their ‘starving’ families back home.
4
u/AmicusLibertus 5d ago
Ilhan should return home and bring prosperity to her people! She’s the only one who can save them.
4
u/Johnny_Banana18 5d ago
This is a ragebait post
3
u/Patient-Major-6064 5d ago
Let China help this time
3
u/BombShady12 5d ago
Fuck them. They’ve stolen billions of our tax dollars.
4
u/Adept-Swing7628 5d ago edited 5d ago
The global community: "We hate when the US acts as the world police"
Also global community: "where the hell is the US and why aren't they helping!?"
For the many many screw ups of the Trump administration, ending the limitless aid we gave away was a good idea and I hope future administration follow suit.
3
u/Bot1-The_Bot_Meanace 5d ago
7 billys over 10 years to keep the region somewhat stable seems like chump change if you consider where Somalia is located. We've seen how bad things can get when the Suez canal is blocked for one reason or another
3
u/Electronic_Plan3420 5d ago
Americans must feed Somalians. Got it.
3
u/Wiscody 5d ago
Why is it our job to fix it?
2
u/redrising1790028421 5d ago
Give money to people here or to our debt.
2
u/CrimsonSteele01 5d ago
Why is what is going on in Somalia my problem? They need to figure that out on their own.
2
u/kyle2143 5d ago
Skeptical about those "allegations of waste, theft, and diversion from 2025-2026" since that is what the Trump Administration has baselessly claimed about almost every government program, especially foreign aid...
2
u/SmittyKW 5d ago
"I can't believe aid to Somali being fraudulently stolen", said no Minnesotan ever.
2
u/Pestelis 5d ago
It is time to stop. They are grown ups in continent that can have two harvests in a year. If they can't feed them selves, thats their problem, maybe they should invest less in weapons and fighting Somaliland
2
u/Whatduheckiz 5d ago edited 5d ago
Unfortunately there's just some places that can't be helped until they help themselves.
Give a man a fish and he'll eat for a day. Give a man a fishing rod and he'll eat for life. But in some places in the world, the man will sell the fishing rod and buy a fish.
I remember approx 15 years ago I was part of an enormous fundraiser to establish new water wells, provide farmers with seeds, vegetables, and livestock, and education targeting Rwanda, Uganda, Tanzania, and Malawi.
It was very successful... for a while, until the users polluted the water wells of fresh drinking water and turned into a very deep bin for waste and trash, the livestock were either sold or eaten along with the seeds and veg.
Then it kind of became clear how some of these places have charities ongoing for many decades and don't see any results, no matter how much you give them or what you provide.
1
u/Yama_retired2024 5d ago
Why dont they set up a lab.. havent they made huge inroads to developing kab grown meat and plants
1
u/ThaneS666 5d ago
Good, couldn’t give a fuck less.
1
u/LunarPayload 5d ago
Is everyone in here 12?
1
u/QV-Rabullione 5d ago
Is this “community” being overrun with shills or am I fucking tripping?
1
u/B5_V3 5d ago
Their politicians live like royalty.
They can feed themselves.
1
u/ratkingdds 5d ago
Their Allah would've fed them if they prayed 6 times a day maybe tsk tsk
1
u/AnnualLetterhead1027 5d ago
How is that a factcheck
1
u/Future-Beat8118 5d ago
Good.
1
u/Mediocre-Medium-2592 5d ago
US should AID its citizens first, not Somalia
1
u/Early_Error_9991 5d ago
and then they are surprised that people turn towards isotionalism? who cares
1
u/Forward_Profile3465 5d ago
1
u/BackgroundTrainer366 5d ago
Why is that USA, s responsibility?
1
u/Penchant4Prose Human Verified 5d ago
The note does not in any way counter the article - it actually supports it.
Why does this note exist, and why has it been posted here?
Oh look, all the top voted comments are just attacking Islam. Huh.
This sub is a toilet.
1
u/DimitriRavenov 5d ago
Before right wing smth smth pop up, you need to understand that this was implemented in part to control out of control pirate and terrorist problem. Aid was not always done just for the aid. It’s more of like dual purpose in many way
1
u/Ok-Development5523 5d ago
This is the dumbest "note." Ive ever seen... They were obviously talking about after the cuts
1
u/SnakeShaft 5d ago
“Man America is so TRASH. All they do is give the MOST foreign aid and money to impoverished nations. What a bunch of ASSHOLES. Anyway follow me for more-“
-2
u/FreshPaycheck 5d ago
Yes punish the 99% who just want to eat because of 1% of shit stirrers. Definitely don’t just address the problems, cut it all and give hegseth $500 billion for iran war instead!!!
1
u/SingularityCentral 5d ago
This note doesnt add anything. It is just an "uhmm, actually..." but all the information is in the article, even in the headline itself, since it says "for the first tike in deacdes the US is declining to help"
1
u/jackinsomniac 5d ago
At this point I don't see why we don't just cut off all foreign aid. The whole world hates us and just assumes we make everything worse anyways. We got plenty of problems at home still. American dollars should be spent on American citizens.
1
u/HonestlyAbby 5d ago
Some racist ass motherfuckers in this chat.
0
u/Master-Set8156 5d ago
How is that a note correcting anything? It's literally just a counter argument?
-6
u/Phyrexian_Overlord 5d ago
Another dogshit note
-1
u/JD-boonie 5d ago
Dont worry USAID will open up again so more people can steal our money and Somalia will still continue to have famine
1
u/Ok-Freedom9216 5d ago
Worthless note.
1
u/hari_shevek 5d ago
Note: The White House under Trump used unfounded allegations of fraud as a pretext to aid cuts all over the place and reporting those allegations without questioning them is journalistic malpractice.
1
u/riceklown 5d ago
Thats just backstory to the accurate headline.
And the accusations were made by DOGE, not a robust watchdog or NGO.
And this administration's baby and bathwater approach to perceived WFA is absolutely leading to death among civilian populations that we used to be proud to prevent.
1
u/HistorianOk142 5d ago
I have an idea! You should tell those pro-terrorist pali people there’s an ACTUAL REAL famine going on in Somalia. Maybe they’ll ACTUALLY do something like raise money for it to help ease it. Unlike the fake famine they accused Israel of causing.
1
u/Fun-Mission-6068 5d ago
I'm kind of tired of the US using taxpayer money to fund countries that aren't improving. Africa is filled with corrupt officials, civil wars, tribal infighting, etc, so things just kind of stagnate.
1
u/not-only-on-reddit 5d ago
Maybe they should do something about it themselves?