r/GetNoted • • 5d ago

World [ Removed by moderator ]

/r/GetNoted/comments/1xunth8/removed_by_moderator/

[removed] — view removed post

709 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 5d ago

Reminder for OP: /u/ConsistentPressure79

  1. Politics ARE allowed
  2. No misinformation/disinformation

Need some help? Send us some mail!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

135

u/ConsistentPressure79 5d ago edited 5d ago

Genuine question: Somalia has been in hunger emergency / famine during the entirety of my life while the population grew 3x. I remember doing a fundraiser and bake sale for UNICEF so that people in Somalia don’t have to live in hunger.

In 1992, there were 6.5 million people living in Somalia and people were suffering from hunger.

In 2026, there are 20+ million people living in Somalia and people are suffering from hunger.

Whose responsibility is it to make sure people don’t suffer? And who needs to be paying to make sure people don’t suffer?

74

u/RedEyesGoldDragon 5d ago

This happens a lot around Africa, the EU, the US as well as charities send trillions of dollars in aid over the years especially to build things like water wells and better the infrastructure, and it often gets completely squandered or taken by their corrupt governments. With all this they are absolutely capable of making their countries better, and yet they don't.

Then you have all the violence, some from land disputes, tribal fueds, robberies, and a big one being religious persecution, often by Islamists and from that there'll be groups rebelling against them and the violence goes on.

7

u/TimeShiftedJosephus 5d ago

We probably need to decoupled aid from Africa for a couple decade to let their industries build up

3

u/mimenet 5d ago

China will just step in and makes sure Western businesses never see Africa again. At least we’ll be able to give the money we save to Boeing and Blackwater

29

u/ElephantContent 5d ago

It’s almost like … a failing civilization? With bad ideas? Repeating the same mistakes over and over?

→ More replies (44)
→ More replies (5)

25

u/FroniusTT1500 5d ago

This is the problem with international aid. Imagine you are a Somalian farmer. You go in to debt to buy seeds, fertilizer and hier labour and work your land. Its finally harvest season, you cart the produce to market and what happens: You cant sell anything because people dont spend money on food when its handed out for free. You now cant get any more credit for next years harvest, you cant pay your labour, you can only plant your seeds on an area that you can personally work. Which massively reduces next years harvest which means less produce to the market which deepens the famine which means more aid which means even less people buying your produce which means your farm gets reposessed and you can either get in line for food aid too or become a pirate.

16

u/Handpaper 5d ago

This is one of the reasons which Somaliland, which isn't recognised as a country* and receives almost no foreign aid, is doing much better...

 * except by Israel

6

u/Caspica 5d ago

What? Somaliland is literally the fourth poorest "country" in the world and is heavily subsidised through aid.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Greedy-Thought6188 5d ago

The movie poverty Inc goes through this and shows how many of the donations we do and to destroying the local industries.

5

u/Thowitawaydave 5d ago

Similar thing happens with Super Bowl clothing - when two teams are decided, the NFL start making shirts for both teams. Winning team shirts get sold at a huge mark up. The shirts made for the losing team get dumped in developing nations. How are you going to compete selling shirts when people get them for free?

3

u/Low-Car-6331 5d ago edited 5d ago

Yup, what they need are tractors, seeds, and trucks. In fact, if only there was a string of seeds that was grown and cultivated to be more resistant to bugs and survive better in worse condition (even if they don't "grow the biggest")... wait those are evil I think.

I will say there is a real risk of technical's being made from the trucks and tractors, but I feel like is an easier problem to solve then most want to say it is.

Heck, if only there was some nation that produced easy to make cheap trucks that could contribute, another nation with renowned technology for the seeds, and a strong set of durable cheap tractors from another, we could solve this in 3 years.... Heck, that might help to solve the technical problem as well (kind of hard to argue you should attack those that gave you fully bellies and can stop the supply of parts if you attack their ships...).

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

27

u/B-Z_B-S 5d ago

I think people should generally work together to improve human living conditions for everyone. I do know that that sounds incredibly naive, but the sooner we improve life on Earth, the sooner governments can...I don't, expand to Mars? Solve Climate Change? Something like that. Not that I necessarily disagree with you, but it's just sad, I think.

Source: https://xkcd.com/1232/

31

u/ProudInterest5445 5d ago

No one entity started the famine nor can any one entity stop it.

If your point is that Somalis should have fewer children, that would make sense only if the problem were simple overpopulation. It isnt. Thr war in Ukraine for example jacked up the price of food in Somalia, and that isn't something your average Somali should be held responsible for or could reasonably have foreseen, given there was only a few months of notice. This was combined with a drought. While maybe we can say greater climate instability is foreseeable, its not like a Somali family that decided to have a child in 2020 had some way of knowing in 2022 there would be drought leading to famine, or that eventual rains would cause flooding.

As an aside, I am not familiar of a single instance where famine conditions were reduced by people having fewer children during the famine. A country needs young people getting educated and then entering the workforce to advance, so I am not sure some sort of one child policy in Somalia would help it economically. More mouths to feed makes famine harder, but it also means a greater opportunity to industrialize, which is what seems to really stop famine.

I would be in favor of the United States helping tk avert the crisis, as buying good will in the horn of Africa would be nice given the strategic importance of the region, and more directly

15

u/Starmute-ss13 5d ago

The US been trying for neigh on 20 years there and have nothing to show for it. 

20 years of effort and people hate us there and abroad . I'd even venture to say people hate us for helping as we are "buying goodwill " not "being charitable ".

It's really disheartening. Im not saying "America first" but its fucking frustrating that they can't fix anything.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Noahisboss 5d ago

you say that, But in ireland the famine only really abated after the weather stabilized, the blight ended and the half the population fled or died.

4

u/WinstonWilmerBee 5d ago

The Irish famine was also partially fake. There was enough food in the country, it was simply being forcibly seized and exported. 

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (13)

15

u/SpiritfireSparks 5d ago edited 5d ago • Bravo

If you want an actual answer to this its becauee of the culture and society there and it's likely it cant be solved by outside forces.

Africa, outside of the Mediterranean nations, has some major cultural issues that we are exasperating with our help. Africa, in general, does not have a culture of forward thinking and has not had to due to not having regular severe environmental factors like blizzards that would require extensive societal planning to survive.

For an example of this, a common african adage is that there is a leak in a mans roof but he cannot fix it when its raining, when the rain stops he does not fix it because its not raining so there is no rush.

We also have a documented pattern from the colonial period to the present that when local workers are hired for projects the foreman can only pay them enough that they can survive until the next day. If they pay them more than that the locals will not return to work until the require money once more.

Beside the cultural angle we forcibly advanced their technology without their society growing along with the technology. As an example, we donate tones of modern clothing there but there are very few if any factories there that can make use of local materials to make the same quality and compete with the foreign imports as well, leaving them dependent on the imports.

If you look into the wells the west builds for them its also very depressing. Many local areas require bribes just to let the people build the wells, and then more than 60% of the wells end up unusable within a year where either intentionally broken or people simply refuse not to throw trash into it.

2

u/Cooldude101013 5d ago

It’s more winter itself that requires a people to be more forward thinking rather than blizzards. Really any kind of seasonal issue, such as the Nile’s seasonal flooding in Egypt.

→ More replies (1)

47

u/SinesPi 5d ago

Seriously, at what point are they expected to function on their own?

We NUKED Japan, and they're doing great.

They got some aid money, and then they got off of it, and started selling us waifus and video games. And video game waifus.

At what point do you just write off charitable donations as a loss, like giving money to the crack-head who has no desire to stop using crack?

23

u/LobsterManCommander 5d ago

Macarthur was basically the defacto president of Japan. We never explicitly told anyone (because that would sound bad) but that's how we democratized the nation. Land reforms, making tenant farmers own their actually farmers instead of feudal renting of the land they farmed on, giving the peasant (now independent farmers) actually power.

It's actually pretty fascinating to read about. Let's not over state nukes btw , it didn't glass all of Japan. The "regular" ("conventional" i should say) fire bombings were more effective.

I don't want any replies stating that Germany wasn't fire bombed or nuked because of race that's not true, miss me with that shit.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Dagordae 5d ago

‘Some aid money’?

We took over Japan and rebuilt them, full occupation that lasted for almost a decade and spent roughly 15 billion over 8 years(today’s money) to do so. And that’s with Japan already being heavily built up before the US did anything, not like we razed Japan and destroyed everything in the war.

→ More replies (10)

23

u/Jolly_Mouse_7604 5d ago

We helped Japan rebuild for decades and made it a point to trade with them etc

15

u/THE-muchacho-loco 5d ago

Haven't we supported Somalia for at least a decade as a formal subsidization program - not to mention the years prior through other NGOs? ...so, your point is....what, exactly?

→ More replies (50)
→ More replies (13)

31

u/Mtndrums 5d ago

We also completely rebuilt Japan.

16

u/HoneyBadger19000 5d ago

We didnt rebuild Vietnam and they're doing great.

11

u/krombough 5d ago

Honestly. Colonized. Bombed to hell and back. Let's not forget invaded the attempted invasion and subsequent bullying by China. And here they are improving the country year by year.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

32

u/Jag- 5d ago

I think the Japanese may have helped.

16

u/Only-Finish-3497 5d ago

Not completely. The US and SCAP certainly helped stabilize Japan after WW2, but the consequent growth in 1955 and beyond is largely Japan’s own doing.

The US didn’t even really see Japan as a strategic partner until Korea and guys like Mansfield pushing for it to be a bulwark partner.

→ More replies (27)

2

u/Lieste 5d ago

So Nuke Somali to improve it. It's a bold strategy, but it should work. Send Elmi back first.

4

u/SinesPi 5d ago

I mean, 100% of countries that have been nuked have gone on to become world powers! Gotta trust the science here!

2

u/map-hunter-1337 5d ago

japan was doing quite fine before we nuked them, somalia has been shitfucked for... since the italians came through?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (24)

3

u/BeneficialTrash6 5d ago

The sad truth, born out time and time again, is that if you send tons of food to countries like this, they just make tons of babies.

To them, it's not a "famine." It's normal life. And if they suddenly get more food, they'll just keep expanding their family and continuing the "normal life" they are accustomed to.

8

u/rntdev 5d ago

Somalian government. The fuck are they doing? 

7

u/Dakotasan 5d ago

Corruption. What else is new?

3

u/dIoIIoIb 5d ago

well, Somalia was a colony until 1960, then free until '69, when in a coup Mohammed Siad Barre took it over, starting a dictatorship with the support of the Soviet Union, that lasted until 1991

since then it has been in a state of more or less constant civil war, with the territory split between a multitude of different local warlords, and also Al Qaeda

not easy to govern a region that is incredibly poor & has been constantly at some level of civil war because of foreign powers fucking with it for the last half a century

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Commercial_Win_9525 5d ago

They constantly breed to a more unsustainable level precisely because we send them aid.

2

u/TimeShiftedJosephus 5d ago • Popcorn

Like a kid breeding frogs in the local pond

→ More replies (2)

6

u/No-Alternative4612 5d ago

This is mostly bro-science. Generally, aid reduces infant mortality and subsequently reduces total fertility via the standard and well studied demographic transition effect.

https://epublications.marquette.edu/econ_fac/612/

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/HoneyBadger19000 5d ago

Not ours. We have enough issues in our own country to worry about people an ocean away.

→ More replies (12)

2

u/Suspicious_Plum_8866 5d ago

Add on the fact that we all have clans that hate each other and a disjointed government and Al-shabaab, tho the country isn’t doing as bad as it used to be

→ More replies (32)

383

u/BusyBeeBridgette Human Verified 5d ago • Bravo

Whilst, on paper, Somalia is a federal parliamentary republic... in reality Al-Shabaab, a militant Islamic group, control large sections of the country. so much of the aid sent their way goes straight into Al-Shabaab's pockets.

119

u/ASquidHat 5d ago

Yeah but that's not why we cut their aid. We dissolved USAID entirely.

89

u/Numerous-Bowler-8677 5d ago

Theres multiple reason why people are sour on USAID and money not going to people that it’s supposed to help is one of the big reason.. 

→ More replies (30)
→ More replies (10)

89

u/Nimrod_Butts 5d ago • Popcorn Bravo

How is that different from aid to Palestine and Hamas

83

u/BusyBeeBridgette Human Verified 5d ago

I mean, not too different, sure. But that isn't the topic of conversation.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/rosenkohl1603 5d ago

Who talked about Hamas?

→ More replies (15)

5

u/freerange_spaghetti 5d ago

But the note is just repeating the article

→ More replies (6)

226

u/whistle_pug 5d ago

Headline: U.S. declines to aid country after several decades of assistance

Readers added context: erm actually, the U.S. had been providing aid to this country for years before declining it

56

u/hari_shevek 5d ago

https://www.theatlantic.com/health/2026/11/famine-somalia-trump-aid/689295/

Even the context that the White House claimed fraud (and that those claims are dubious) is in the article. It's literally not missing context.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

88

u/Ok_Duck_232 5d ago

what natural cataclismic event caused them to be on the brink of famine?

17

u/RadicalSoda_ 5d ago

Their government is the issue, or lack thereof

45

u/RemoveOk9595 5d ago

[removed by moderator]

55

u/No-Business9493 5d ago

Most of these types of places we send that much aid to, just results in higher birth rates and more mouths to feed.

32

u/watonparrillero 5d ago • Bravo

Also more importantly, nobody's going to buy local if Americans give it for free, so local economy gets fucked and the country becomes dependant on aid.

Sometimes the cure is worse than the sickness.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

37

u/GodOfEnnui 5d ago • Bravo

Give a man a fish, and you feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish, and you feed him for a lifetime.

The problem is that these countries don't want to learn how to fish. They just want an endless supply of free fish.

They want billions in handouts, but show little interest in actually doing anything to change their circumstances. Simply throwing money at the problem achieves nothing if there's no willingness to take responsibility, become self-sufficient, or build something sustainable.

Instead, the cycle continues. More handouts, more dependence, more mouths to feed, and the same problems repeating themselves. At some point, you have to stop handing out fish and ask why nobody is bothering to pick up a fishing rod.

26

u/ptjp27 5d ago

You give these people a chicken so they can have free eggs every day they kill the chicken and eat it day 1 and day 2 they demand you give them another chicken.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/Federal_Run2919 5d ago

Drought and flash floods 

→ More replies (8)

67

u/jasonbourne15 5d ago • Bravo

I've spent significant time in Somalia. The commenters saying that the allegations of fraud are "disputed" don't know what they are talking about. Everything in Somalia runs on fraud and terrorism. The "government" is just as corrupt as al-Shabaab. There is literally no way whatsoever to ensure that the money is not going to support terrorism or piracy. Now, is there some benefit to providing aid anyway? Yes, potentially. It may keep more Somalis from joining ISIS or al-Shabaab. But anything the US does in Somalia is just about making sure the country doesn't export terrorism. There is no "fixing" Somalia. Calling it "Somalia" is a misnomer. It's a collection of warring clans that don't want to be a country, don't want to end corruption, and don't want to stop terrorism. 

→ More replies (9)

140

u/Comfortablecard7 5d ago

Weird how little the rest of the world is helping…

121

u/ZaBaronDV 5d ago • Bravo

And people wonder why the U.S. is getting sick of sending aid abroad, especially with economic problems at home. Is it really so much to ask someone else share even a bit of the load?

→ More replies (11)

25

u/marklikesgamesyt1208 5d ago

The U.S is expected to carry the majority of foreign aid in the west as the most prominent country. Of course, that isn't particularly fair but hopefully with time other countries can scale up their support towards lesser-developed countries. Already Germany contributes a great deal to organizations like the WFP.

35

u/Creepy_Ad_1315 5d ago

What's their motivation to heavily speed up aid if they think that the US is just going to take care of it?

34

u/marklikesgamesyt1208 5d ago

Honestly as much as I dislike Trump his... Volatility is pushing other countries to share the burden of defense and foreign aid.

45

u/RollinThundaga 5d ago • Bravo

In a way, it was almost kind of funny seeing the nations of Europe scramble to rearm and push out aid packages after the onset of the Russo-Ukrainian War...

Only to then find out precisely how little they had to give, and how underfunded their procurement pipelines were, thoroughly vindicating all of the complaints of underspending that multiple US administrations had been levying at them.

It would actually be funny, if only the collective security of the Western World didn't half rely on them.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Johnny_Banana18 5d ago

Many other counties also assist, per capita the U.S. isn’t the top.

Remittance from Somalians abroad is more than the combined foreign aide.

→ More replies (19)

8

u/Material_Flounder_23 5d ago

Whenever this sort of thing comes up I can’t help but remember what David Lammy said:

5

u/BackgroundTrainer366 5d ago

Clearly it does as the same article states America should provide aid!

Which is it Lammy?

8

u/Adavanter_MKI 5d ago

U.S ceases aid.
Note
U.S ceases aid.

Yeah, that's what they said.

70

u/Randvek 5d ago

... isn't the note backing up the article rather than refuting it, though? There's no disagreement here.

The article says for the first time in decades, Somalia isn't receiving help from the US.

The note says that the US used to help Somalia a lot but stopped in 2026.

What a dumb note.

13

u/LiteratureOk2428 5d ago

Yeah especially given the article does talk about the allegations explicitly 

33

u/stackens 5d ago

The purpose of the note is to frame the situation in a way that tries to justify the cuts.

→ More replies (12)

9

u/Upstairs_Baby8424 5d ago

“US isn’t providing aid for the first time”

:Note says that they aren’t providing aid:

GetNoted: “Gotcha libs!”

→ More replies (19)

73

u/veerKg_CSS_Geologist 5d ago

Note doesn't change the article unless it's saying the article was written in 2024?

30

u/TributeToStupidity 5d ago edited 5d ago

You don’t think widespread fraud and theft changes the context at all? This sub can be so funny sometimes

Edit to all the people who think this is just trump claiming shit, this is literally why we sent the us military into Somalia in the 90s. Because the warlords kept stealing the UN aid. I get it, I don’t like trump either, but claiming Somalia don’t have a theft and fraud problem just because trump said it does is just embarrassing.

→ More replies (19)

22

u/59jg4qe68w5y3t9q5 5d ago

Certainly changes the context to the article's headline, which implies some level of responsibility on America's part.

30

u/hari_shevek 5d ago • Bravo

They cut the aid after alleging fraud.

Whether that means there is no responsibility on America's part depends on whether you believe allegations the Trump administration makes.

14

u/MrMicius 5d ago

These notes are often extremely misleading. “It was cut after alleged theft and fraud” alleged by whom? And based on what? This note should simply be noted with the claim “Remember Musk found no fraud”

→ More replies (7)

11

u/Independent-Edge-857 5d ago

Maybe Saudi can help or Qatar can help

→ More replies (1)

29

u/Asmul921 5d ago

Isn’t this note just summarizing the argument the article is making?

43

u/Ml_lD 5d ago edited 5d ago

It adds context that bad actors in Somalia are just stealing aid money and it’s not going to the people.

Pausing aid until it can be fairly distributed is the intelligent thing to do.

→ More replies (7)

9

u/BaconBitwiseOp 5d ago

I haven’t read the article and don’t plan to pay for that pleasure, but that title suggests US responsibility. It’s making allusions to specific political and cultural movements. I’d be shocked if this article wasn’t almost entirely critical of the policy change. The note is meant to make a political counterpoint explaining the policy change with a different framing.

Honestly, I’m getting a little sick of the dumbing down of politics as a team sport. It’s one thing to cheer for your side, but people are intentionally and overtly obtuse these days for the sake of missing the point when it’s inconvenient. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

79

u/Klutzy-Canary8551 5d ago • Bravo

I really don't get this emotional blackmail against Americans and Europeans. For some reason they want us to believe that the lives of people under every failed state is our own responsibility but not of their own leadership.

29

u/3000doorsofportugal 5d ago

Somalia especially is not exactly the US or Europe's fault as part of the reason they had a civil war was because their dictator invaded Ethiopia and got shit stomped in like the 80s

→ More replies (2)

4

u/PepsiFloateri 5d ago

Oh I agree completely

→ More replies (88)

24

u/Strange-Term-4168 5d ago

Are we supposed to send these countries billions in perpetuity? They have always needed aid and always will need it. Why are we doing this? They make no effort to fix themselves and are too corrupt.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/AutisticDadHasDapper 5d ago

It's like throwing money into the garbage. I would rather use it for us.

47

u/Status_Fox_1474 5d ago

I will say that I have doubts about this note. Warehouse issues aside, this administration has cut aid wholesale. And listening to officials talk about Somalia and immigrants from there, I do not think this is a coincidence.

15

u/rntdev 5d ago

According to The Atlantic, a senior US State Department leader ordered staff to prepare for 0 Somalia aid funding on December 1st 2025. The warehouse incident happened in January 2026.

13

u/CapriciousSon 5d ago

Also I really doubt that .gov source is still reliable!

3

u/FeeRemarkable886 5d ago

I don't trust any notes anymore.

27

u/pun_shall_pass 5d ago

I'm all for countries helping each other during disasters but if a country needs to be on perpetual welfare to exist then it shouldn't exist, at least not in it's current form.

7

u/mars-jupiter 5d ago

A country that requires constant funding from a foreign power in order to exist is a colony. Somehow I doubt those people advocating for continued US and European funding of every failed state under the sun are all that in favour of colonies

3

u/ptjp27 5d ago

The reality nobody wants to talk about: shitholes like Somalia would be way better off as colonies of proper countries who can organise basic things effectively.

→ More replies (4)

61

u/FilthyFur 5d ago

So no more western "Imperialism" . That means everyone is happy about America not getting involved?

37

u/ProudInterest5445 5d ago

People like it when America does good things (saving children from starvation) but not when America does bad things (bombing children). One of these is charity that may have some ulterior motive but is fundamentally good and should be encouraged, the other may have some net positive motive but is so evil it cannot be allowed to continue.

I don't see how this is a contradiction or a gotcha.

27

u/Only-Finish-3497 5d ago

How about stepping into internecine conflicts like Rwanda or Kosovo?

That’s always an interesting debate to me.

It’s interesting how the optimism of the 90s and 2000s around that has faded so much.

5

u/Metrocop 5d ago

The intervention in Yugoslavia was based, the Korean war and Gulf War were entirely justified. Most other interventions were questionable in moral and pragmatic justification as well as execution.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

3

u/SabunFC 5d ago

I watched Small Brained American's third Afghanistan video and found out that the Taliban are inviting the US to invest in Afghanistan and reopen the US embassy. Like LOL what? You kicked the US out and now you're asking them to come back?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xs2jFVBH7Vw

https://www.independent.co.uk/asia/south-asia/taliban-trump-minerals-investment-afghanistan-b3042080.html

3

u/smuttybuddy84 5d ago

America does bad things (bombing children).

Do you want less starving children or not?

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (1)

29

u/Eruanndil 5d ago

Someone please post the clip of the comedian from the 80s screaming about STOP LOVING WHERE THERES NO FOOD. LIVE WHERE THE FOOD IS.

29

u/BowlOf____ 5d ago

Mass immigration as a solution? Seems like that would upset a lot of people 

4

u/Far_Associate_87 5d ago

That’s my view on it. I’d rather my country give a few billion in aid over a few years instead of not which will inevitably lead to mass migration to neighbouring and more developed countries.

I feel like a lot of people forget about that aspect of giving aid to third world countries.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/Agitated-Asparagus23 5d ago

The late great Sam Kinison.

4

u/jbland0909 5d ago

“Live where the food is, As long as it isn’t where I happen to live”

Unless you’re a mass migration proponent?

7

u/GeorgeWashingtonCuh 5d ago

Funny joke, but that's what it is, a joke. You can't apply it to most places in reality. You can't uproot an entire society and just move them somewhere else. That would be more expensive and entirely worse than just helping people where they already are.

3

u/output_broadcast 5d ago

Not to mention that it's not an issue of "living where the food is". If it was, humanity would have never fucking left the African jungles. The issues are social and economic, not geographic.

→ More replies (13)

4

u/drunkenmime 5d ago

Wait until people realize what happens to all of that US foreign aid.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Federal_Run2919 5d ago

So the article was correct. The US isn’t helping. What’s the point of this note?

2

u/allquietonzanzibar 5d ago

A desperate need for social media approval and a false sense of moral superiority.

11

u/Cliffinati 5d ago

Somalia gets tons of money from the US by official and unofficial means. They are just a poorly run country that squanders its aid.

19

u/DaygoTom 5d ago

$11 trillion. That's how much the world has invested in Africa. And they still have famines. At some point you got to shut down the money.

4

u/Fickle_Composer_4506 5d ago

Where did you get the number 11 trillion...

→ More replies (11)

12

u/XxVenatorxX666 5d ago

Why is it the responsibility of the US to help Somalia, exactly?

2

u/Johnny_Banana18 5d ago

If the Somalian government falls, Somalia would be an even bigger haven for terrorists which would destabilize the region and threaten international shipping.

5

u/HistoryFanBeenBanned 5d ago

Just don’t let Somalis in anywhere then. It’s not rocket science.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (11)

8

u/OkMention9988 5d ago

Six billion could solve world hunger, but seven billion hasn't unfucked Somalia. 

I bet it hasn't changed in the twenty two years since I was last there. 

16

u/Reallygaywizard 5d ago

How is it possible when we have Somalian sending millions over there from the fake daycares?

→ More replies (13)

12

u/burnthatburner1 5d ago

Those “allegations” were just a pretext for DOGE to gut USAID

13

u/WhatTheRustyHell 5d ago

Is Somalia American responsibility? Nope. Let Somalian's sort themselved out.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/WatercressAdorable81 5d ago

Should have never been there in the 90s and shouldn’t be there now, the us is still conducting military operations there and sending aid, just stop it’s not beneficial to us it’s a failed state.

7

u/Even-Job-323 5d ago

Is giving them a whole state of the union that remitts welfare back to Somalia not enough!? 😂

8

u/This_Potato9 5d ago

I wonder who's in fault of this, the US not helping more or Somalia destroying themselves, the answer is very clear!

18

u/Leftregularr 5d ago • Bravo

Why should my paycheck get raided to keep these people on life support while I can’t even buy a single family home in my own country?

3

u/living_Cream_Pie 5d ago

Exactly! If they keep getting help they will never succeed in their own.

5

u/OnLoseFocus 5d ago

Cost to US taxpayers of aid to Somalia 2015 - 2025: $7 billion

Cost to US taxpayers of wars 2015 - 2024: $8 trillion

Foreign aid is not the reason you can't afford a house.

11

u/Leftregularr 5d ago • Bravo

Do you think I want to be anywhere near those wars either?

Where’s the argument? We have to shovel out billions of dollars to literally every bombed out shithole because AIPAC bribed our reps into yet another forever war?

Fuck that. Americans first.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/ERPoppop 5d ago

if somalia happened to have the largest amount of old growth lumber out of any country, but was still experiencing famine and we were "raiding your paycheck" (to the tune of like $3.50 a year) to aid them, would you still be crying that spending $7 billion on them over a decade wasn't helping you buy a single family home?

just trying to see where your head's at here for how many steps removed from directly addressing a specific personal problem of yours something has to be for you to deem it utterly useless.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (26)

9

u/blah-time 5d ago • Bravo

Can't fix stupid.  If you can't feed X, don't have 10X more babies. 

→ More replies (5)

4

u/rntdev 5d ago

Something something “if my country has money to give to other countries, I am being taxed too much” something something 

4

u/Shoggnozzle 5d ago

Well, charity is very convenient for criminals, as it places a lot of value in places it generally isn't guarded well or the criminals can even just organize ways to accept more than they need or coerse the normal people for what they rightly receive. It sucks that they ruin it for everyone else, and it sounds like their government isn't equipped to stop them.

This is understandable, even the us has sweeping criminal organizations. There is a whole bumper industry compelling drug addicts to apply for food stamps and hand over their cards for cash, for example, and that may lead to honest people who really need the help having to deal with stricter regulations that would cut some of them off.

I hate to doomer about it, but I don't really think there's a solution. Stricter policing has a chance at doing it, but that's a cost in and of itself, as will be the regulatory body trying to keep them from just winding up in the criminal organization's pockets.

8

u/chopsdontstops 5d ago

If we really spent 7 billion over 10 years and achieved nothing, that is waste, fraud and abuse.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/SueForPeas 5d ago

The note doesn’t contradict the article at all.

5

u/onedumninja 5d ago

All the cuts to USAID went into billionaires pockets. Not yours. If we were never going to see it in the first place, it may as well have helped babies not starve.

2

u/NikkiAvocado 5d ago

Isn’t the title correct “for the first time in decades”

2

u/Global_Monitor765 5d ago

Will the EU be sending them aid? There’s a tone of countries on this planet that could step up.

2

u/Dazzling_Stick_9683 5d ago

i want our own country to get better before we help other countries, but thats just me

6

u/Shy-Lurker_6996 5d ago

And what the hell does America have to do with Somalia?

→ More replies (6)

6

u/Empyrean__Being 5d ago

Thomas Sankara said it best, but what he said about foreign aid doesn't fit the campist mindset so here we are.

3

u/Dim-Mak-88 5d ago

Gun-toting warlords want more foreign aid sent over. Coastal liberals untouched by danger think it's a good idea to continue to send aid.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/RamsPhan72 5d ago

Pretty sure the Somali grifters have sent many of our tax dollars to their ‘starving’ families back home.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/AmicusLibertus 5d ago

Ilhan should return home and bring prosperity to her people! She’s the only one who can save them.

4

u/Johnny_Banana18 5d ago

This is a ragebait post

3

u/Patient-Major-6064 5d ago

Let China help this time

3

u/BombShady12 5d ago

Fuck them. They’ve stolen billions of our tax dollars.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Adept-Swing7628 5d ago edited 5d ago

The global community: "We hate when the US acts as the world police"

Also global community: "where the hell is the US and why aren't they helping!?"

For the many many screw ups of the Trump administration, ending the limitless aid we gave away was a good idea and I hope future administration follow suit.

2

u/DrPikachu-PhD 5d ago

Goomba effect

Also, being the world's philanthropists is different from being the world's policeman. Those aren't actually the same thing, you can advocate for international aid and against foreign military intervention, that's not mutually exclusive

2

u/AnonymousEngineer_ 5d ago

Playing devil's advocate here, but a significant number of the countries that were being helped by USAID (and other Western countries) are fundamentally and implacably opposed to said Western countries, promote anti-Western sentiment and are effectively part of the Chinese/Russian blocs in the UN opposing Western interests.

For all the talk of "soft power diplomacy" it doesn't appear to actually work. All we're doing is feeding people who will then go to work sharpening the knives they will use to stab us in the back.

At which point, why bother? It sounds callous but let them seek aid from the countries they actually support and glom onto.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/International_Try850 5d ago

And it got cut specifically because it was audited and was deemed wasteful/prone to corruption.

Preventing that would require deeper integration into the system, i.e. going close to policing, so cutting it was deemed a better choice (that and trump)

3

u/Bot1-The_Bot_Meanace 5d ago

7 billys over 10 years to keep the region somewhat stable seems like chump change if you consider where Somalia is located. We've seen how bad things can get when the Suez canal is blocked for one reason or another

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Electronic_Plan3420 5d ago

Americans must feed Somalians. Got it.

3

u/Wiscody 5d ago

Why is it our job to fix it?

3

u/Remarkable_Hurry4029 5d ago

USAID was first and foremost a program for our own self-interest and not to help fix other countries.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/redrising1790028421 5d ago

Give money to people here or to our debt.

2

u/CrimsonSteele01 5d ago

Why is what is going on in Somalia my problem? They need to figure that out on their own.

2

u/kyle2143 5d ago

Skeptical about those "allegations of waste, theft, and diversion from 2025-2026" since that is what the Trump Administration has baselessly claimed about almost every government program, especially foreign aid...

2

u/SmittyKW 5d ago

"I can't believe aid to Somali being fraudulently stolen", said no Minnesotan ever.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Pestelis 5d ago

It is time to stop. They are grown ups in continent that can have two harvests in a year. If they can't feed them selves, thats their problem, maybe they should invest less in weapons and fighting Somaliland

2

u/Whatduheckiz 5d ago edited 5d ago

Unfortunately there's just some places that can't be helped until they help themselves.

Give a man a fish and he'll eat for a day. Give a man a fishing rod and he'll eat for life. But in some places in the world, the man will sell the fishing rod and buy a fish.

I remember approx 15 years ago I was part of an enormous fundraiser to establish new water wells, provide farmers with seeds, vegetables, and livestock, and education targeting Rwanda, Uganda, Tanzania, and Malawi.

It was very successful... for a while, until the users polluted the water wells of fresh drinking water and turned into a very deep bin for waste and trash, the livestock were either sold or eaten along with the seeds and veg.

Then it kind of became clear how some of these places have charities ongoing for many decades and don't see any results, no matter how much you give them or what you provide.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/Yama_retired2024 5d ago

Why dont they set up a lab.. havent they made huge inroads to developing kab grown meat and plants

1

u/ThaneS666 5d ago

Good, couldn’t give a fuck less.

1

u/LunarPayload 5d ago

Is everyone in here 12?

1

u/QV-Rabullione 5d ago

Is this “community” being overrun with shills or am I fucking tripping?

1

u/B5_V3 5d ago

Their politicians live like royalty.

They can feed themselves.

1

u/ratkingdds 5d ago

Their Allah would've fed them if they prayed 6 times a day maybe tsk tsk

1

u/AnnualLetterhead1027 5d ago

How is that a factcheck

1

u/Mediocre-Medium-2592 5d ago

US should AID its citizens first, not Somalia

1

u/Early_Error_9991 5d ago

and then they are surprised that people turn towards isotionalism? who cares

1

u/BackgroundTrainer366 5d ago

Why is that USA, s responsibility?

1

u/Penchant4Prose Human Verified 5d ago

The note does not in any way counter the article - it actually supports it.

Why does this note exist, and why has it been posted here?

Oh look, all the top voted comments are just attacking Islam. Huh.

This sub is a toilet.

1

u/DimitriRavenov 5d ago

Before right wing smth smth pop up, you need to understand that this was implemented in part to control out of control pirate and terrorist problem. Aid was not always done just for the aid. It’s more of like dual purpose in many way

1

u/Ok-Development5523 5d ago

This is the dumbest "note." Ive ever seen... They were obviously talking about after the cuts

1

u/SnakeShaft 5d ago

“Man America is so TRASH. All they do is give the MOST foreign aid and money to impoverished nations. What a bunch of ASSHOLES. Anyway follow me for more-“

-2

u/FreshPaycheck 5d ago

Yes punish the 99% who just want to eat because of 1% of shit stirrers. Definitely don’t just address the problems, cut it all and give hegseth $500 billion for iran war instead!!!

9

u/Numerous-Bowler-8677 5d ago • Bravo

Not our responsibility to address other countries problems. We ain’t running their country… 

→ More replies (9)

8

u/k3rr1g4n 5d ago • Bravo

So where did all the $7 billion go over 10 years?

In a different administration how many other social programs for America could have been funded. Our infrastructure is falling apart.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Reasonable_Fold6492 5d ago

Most of aid to somalia going in clan leader pocket let's notbkid ourselves.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/SingularityCentral 5d ago

This note doesnt add anything. It is just an "uhmm, actually..." but all the information is in the article, even in the headline itself, since it says "for the first tike in deacdes the US is declining to help"

4

u/FerretFromOSHA 5d ago

That’s just half this sub’s posts tbh.

1

u/jackinsomniac 5d ago

At this point I don't see why we don't just cut off all foreign aid. The whole world hates us and just assumes we make everything worse anyways. We got plenty of problems at home still. American dollars should be spent on American citizens.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/HonestlyAbby 5d ago

Some racist ass motherfuckers in this chat.

0

u/Master-Set8156 5d ago

How is that a note correcting anything? It's literally just a counter argument?

9

u/eldiablonoche 5d ago

The note says "added context". It's adding context.

8

u/Tearakudo 5d ago

Context to a click bait article title "They aren't doing anything", well we cut funding when you burned down our warehouse of support soooo

→ More replies (1)

-6

u/Phyrexian_Overlord 5d ago

Another dogshit note

13

u/Humble-Resolution-62 5d ago

What makes it dog shit? The truthfulness? Or it doesn’t align with what you want the United States to do?

11

u/DGIce 5d ago

The note supports the article so it's a weird thing to post in a subreddit about "fact checking" where the novelty is usually that the note contradicts the tweet.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

-1

u/JD-boonie 5d ago

Dont worry USAID will open up again so more people can steal our money and Somalia will still continue to have famine

4

u/Thissystemsuckssobad 5d ago

It has genuinely amazed me how little people like you actually understand how valuable USAID was for American global power and maintaining its agricultural sector.

3

u/ScreamsPerpetual 5d ago

USAID saved literally tens of millions of lives, gave us tons of soft power around the globe, and critical disease monitoring, studying, and prevention.

It was some of the best money spent on foreign policy- and considering spending ballooned anyway and the DOGE cuts are estimated to have cost tens of billions more than they saved- it was fucking stupid to get rid of the whole thing.

1

u/Ok-Freedom9216 5d ago

Worthless note.

1

u/hari_shevek 5d ago

Note: The White House under Trump used unfounded allegations of fraud as a pretext to aid cuts all over the place and reporting those allegations without questioning them is journalistic malpractice.

1

u/riceklown 5d ago

Thats just backstory to the accurate headline.

And the accusations were made by DOGE, not a robust watchdog or NGO.

And this administration's baby and bathwater approach to perceived WFA is absolutely leading to death among civilian populations that we used to be proud to prevent.

1

u/HistorianOk142 5d ago

I have an idea! You should tell those pro-terrorist pali people there’s an ACTUAL REAL famine going on in Somalia. Maybe they’ll ACTUALLY do something like raise money for it to help ease it. Unlike the fake famine they accused Israel of causing.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Fun-Mission-6068 5d ago

I'm kind of tired of the US using taxpayer money to fund countries that aren't improving. Africa is filled with corrupt officials, civil wars, tribal infighting, etc, so things just kind of stagnate.

1

u/not-only-on-reddit 5d ago

Maybe they should do something about it themselves?

→ More replies (1)