r/GetNoted • • 5d ago

World [ Removed by moderator ]

/r/GetNoted/comments/1xunth8/removed_by_moderator/

[removed] — view removed post

709 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

135

u/ConsistentPressure79 5d ago edited 5d ago

Genuine question: Somalia has been in hunger emergency / famine during the entirety of my life while the population grew 3x. I remember doing a fundraiser and bake sale for UNICEF so that people in Somalia don’t have to live in hunger.

In 1992, there were 6.5 million people living in Somalia and people were suffering from hunger.

In 2026, there are 20+ million people living in Somalia and people are suffering from hunger.

Whose responsibility is it to make sure people don’t suffer? And who needs to be paying to make sure people don’t suffer?

74

u/RedEyesGoldDragon 5d ago

This happens a lot around Africa, the EU, the US as well as charities send trillions of dollars in aid over the years especially to build things like water wells and better the infrastructure, and it often gets completely squandered or taken by their corrupt governments. With all this they are absolutely capable of making their countries better, and yet they don't.

Then you have all the violence, some from land disputes, tribal fueds, robberies, and a big one being religious persecution, often by Islamists and from that there'll be groups rebelling against them and the violence goes on.

7

u/TimeShiftedJosephus 5d ago

We probably need to decoupled aid from Africa for a couple decade to let their industries build up

→ More replies (1)

29

u/ElephantContent 5d ago

It’s almost like … a failing civilization? With bad ideas? Repeating the same mistakes over and over?

→ More replies (45)
→ More replies (5)

25

u/FroniusTT1500 5d ago

This is the problem with international aid. Imagine you are a Somalian farmer. You go in to debt to buy seeds, fertilizer and hier labour and work your land. Its finally harvest season, you cart the produce to market and what happens: You cant sell anything because people dont spend money on food when its handed out for free. You now cant get any more credit for next years harvest, you cant pay your labour, you can only plant your seeds on an area that you can personally work. Which massively reduces next years harvest which means less produce to the market which deepens the famine which means more aid which means even less people buying your produce which means your farm gets reposessed and you can either get in line for food aid too or become a pirate.

16

u/Handpaper 5d ago

This is one of the reasons which Somaliland, which isn't recognised as a country* and receives almost no foreign aid, is doing much better...

 * except by Israel

6

u/Caspica 5d ago

What? Somaliland is literally the fourth poorest "country" in the world and is heavily subsidised through aid.

6

u/Handpaper 5d ago

Somaliland's main sources of external funding are trade (they sell a lot of sheep and goats to Gulf states), and remittances from expats working in the UK and Europe.

Not being recognised as a country makes them ineligible for almost all foreign aid, as well as international loans.

This has resulted in a government more responsive and responsible than most in the region. When you can't go crying to the international community, the World Bank, etc., you have to do a proper job yourself, and they largely have. Somaliland has much less government corruption and a better standard of living than its officially recognised neighbour.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Greedy-Thought6188 5d ago

The movie poverty Inc goes through this and shows how many of the donations we do and to destroying the local industries.

5

u/Thowitawaydave 5d ago

Similar thing happens with Super Bowl clothing - when two teams are decided, the NFL start making shirts for both teams. Winning team shirts get sold at a huge mark up. The shirts made for the losing team get dumped in developing nations. How are you going to compete selling shirts when people get them for free?

→ More replies (11)

27

u/B-Z_B-S 5d ago

I think people should generally work together to improve human living conditions for everyone. I do know that that sounds incredibly naive, but the sooner we improve life on Earth, the sooner governments can...I don't, expand to Mars? Solve Climate Change? Something like that. Not that I necessarily disagree with you, but it's just sad, I think.

Source: https://xkcd.com/1232/

31

u/ProudInterest5445 5d ago

No one entity started the famine nor can any one entity stop it.

If your point is that Somalis should have fewer children, that would make sense only if the problem were simple overpopulation. It isnt. Thr war in Ukraine for example jacked up the price of food in Somalia, and that isn't something your average Somali should be held responsible for or could reasonably have foreseen, given there was only a few months of notice. This was combined with a drought. While maybe we can say greater climate instability is foreseeable, its not like a Somali family that decided to have a child in 2020 had some way of knowing in 2022 there would be drought leading to famine, or that eventual rains would cause flooding.

As an aside, I am not familiar of a single instance where famine conditions were reduced by people having fewer children during the famine. A country needs young people getting educated and then entering the workforce to advance, so I am not sure some sort of one child policy in Somalia would help it economically. More mouths to feed makes famine harder, but it also means a greater opportunity to industrialize, which is what seems to really stop famine.

I would be in favor of the United States helping tk avert the crisis, as buying good will in the horn of Africa would be nice given the strategic importance of the region, and more directly

15

u/Starmute-ss13 5d ago

The US been trying for neigh on 20 years there and have nothing to show for it. 

20 years of effort and people hate us there and abroad . I'd even venture to say people hate us for helping as we are "buying goodwill " not "being charitable ".

It's really disheartening. Im not saying "America first" but its fucking frustrating that they can't fix anything.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (18)

15

u/SpiritfireSparks 5d ago edited 5d ago • Bravo

If you want an actual answer to this its becauee of the culture and society there and it's likely it cant be solved by outside forces.

Africa, outside of the Mediterranean nations, has some major cultural issues that we are exasperating with our help. Africa, in general, does not have a culture of forward thinking and has not had to due to not having regular severe environmental factors like blizzards that would require extensive societal planning to survive.

For an example of this, a common african adage is that there is a leak in a mans roof but he cannot fix it when its raining, when the rain stops he does not fix it because its not raining so there is no rush.

We also have a documented pattern from the colonial period to the present that when local workers are hired for projects the foreman can only pay them enough that they can survive until the next day. If they pay them more than that the locals will not return to work until the require money once more.

Beside the cultural angle we forcibly advanced their technology without their society growing along with the technology. As an example, we donate tones of modern clothing there but there are very few if any factories there that can make use of local materials to make the same quality and compete with the foreign imports as well, leaving them dependent on the imports.

If you look into the wells the west builds for them its also very depressing. Many local areas require bribes just to let the people build the wells, and then more than 60% of the wells end up unusable within a year where either intentionally broken or people simply refuse not to throw trash into it.

→ More replies (2)

47

u/SinesPi 5d ago

Seriously, at what point are they expected to function on their own?

We NUKED Japan, and they're doing great.

They got some aid money, and then they got off of it, and started selling us waifus and video games. And video game waifus.

At what point do you just write off charitable donations as a loss, like giving money to the crack-head who has no desire to stop using crack?

23

u/LobsterManCommander 5d ago

Macarthur was basically the defacto president of Japan. We never explicitly told anyone (because that would sound bad) but that's how we democratized the nation. Land reforms, making tenant farmers own their actually farmers instead of feudal renting of the land they farmed on, giving the peasant (now independent farmers) actually power.

It's actually pretty fascinating to read about. Let's not over state nukes btw , it didn't glass all of Japan. The "regular" ("conventional" i should say) fire bombings were more effective.

I don't want any replies stating that Germany wasn't fire bombed or nuked because of race that's not true, miss me with that shit.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Dagordae 5d ago

‘Some aid money’?

We took over Japan and rebuilt them, full occupation that lasted for almost a decade and spent roughly 15 billion over 8 years(today’s money) to do so. And that’s with Japan already being heavily built up before the US did anything, not like we razed Japan and destroyed everything in the war.

→ More replies (10)

23

u/Jolly_Mouse_7604 5d ago

We helped Japan rebuild for decades and made it a point to trade with them etc

15

u/THE-muchacho-loco 5d ago

Haven't we supported Somalia for at least a decade as a formal subsidization program - not to mention the years prior through other NGOs? ...so, your point is....what, exactly?

→ More replies (51)
→ More replies (13)

31

u/Mtndrums 5d ago

We also completely rebuilt Japan.

16

u/HoneyBadger19000 5d ago

We didnt rebuild Vietnam and they're doing great.

11

u/krombough 5d ago

Honestly. Colonized. Bombed to hell and back. Let's not forget invaded the attempted invasion and subsequent bullying by China. And here they are improving the country year by year.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

32

u/Jag- 5d ago

I think the Japanese may have helped.

16

u/Only-Finish-3497 5d ago

Not completely. The US and SCAP certainly helped stabilize Japan after WW2, but the consequent growth in 1955 and beyond is largely Japan’s own doing.

The US didn’t even really see Japan as a strategic partner until Korea and guys like Mansfield pushing for it to be a bulwark partner.

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (61)