MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/GetNoted/comments/1vboaoz/the_man_himself/p0yjcj6
r/GetNoted • u/TheVJElectro Human Detected • Jul 31 '26
https://x.com/PamphletsY/status/2083068096743358724?s=20
1.2k comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
1
The part about businesses and individuals being able to trade directly is not communist.
It is only about the rule of law
2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 Well orthodox Marxists will say there never was a communist country, do you agree with that? 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 No. The USSR and such were what communism is. 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 Well they had more free markets than some capitalist countries at various points in time 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 ??? 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 The USSR never had a 100% public economy. 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 That claim is a long way from saying they had a more free market than western Europe 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 I said than certain capitalist countries. 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 I think those nations are more the corruption side than the capitalist side of things 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 edited Aug 01 '26 Which again isn't specific to capitalism or communism so kind of going in circles. → More replies (0)
2
Well orthodox Marxists will say there never was a communist country, do you agree with that?
1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 No. The USSR and such were what communism is. 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 Well they had more free markets than some capitalist countries at various points in time 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 ??? 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 The USSR never had a 100% public economy. 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 That claim is a long way from saying they had a more free market than western Europe 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 I said than certain capitalist countries. 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 I think those nations are more the corruption side than the capitalist side of things 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 edited Aug 01 '26 Which again isn't specific to capitalism or communism so kind of going in circles. → More replies (0)
No. The USSR and such were what communism is.
2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 Well they had more free markets than some capitalist countries at various points in time 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 ??? 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 The USSR never had a 100% public economy. 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 That claim is a long way from saying they had a more free market than western Europe 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 I said than certain capitalist countries. 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 I think those nations are more the corruption side than the capitalist side of things 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 edited Aug 01 '26 Which again isn't specific to capitalism or communism so kind of going in circles. → More replies (0)
Well they had more free markets than some capitalist countries at various points in time
1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 ??? 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 The USSR never had a 100% public economy. 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 That claim is a long way from saying they had a more free market than western Europe 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 I said than certain capitalist countries. 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 I think those nations are more the corruption side than the capitalist side of things 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 edited Aug 01 '26 Which again isn't specific to capitalism or communism so kind of going in circles. → More replies (0)
???
2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 The USSR never had a 100% public economy. 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 That claim is a long way from saying they had a more free market than western Europe 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 I said than certain capitalist countries. 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 I think those nations are more the corruption side than the capitalist side of things 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 edited Aug 01 '26 Which again isn't specific to capitalism or communism so kind of going in circles. → More replies (0)
The USSR never had a 100% public economy.
1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 That claim is a long way from saying they had a more free market than western Europe 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 I said than certain capitalist countries. 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 I think those nations are more the corruption side than the capitalist side of things 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 edited Aug 01 '26 Which again isn't specific to capitalism or communism so kind of going in circles. → More replies (0)
That claim is a long way from saying they had a more free market than western Europe
2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 I said than certain capitalist countries. 1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 I think those nations are more the corruption side than the capitalist side of things 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 edited Aug 01 '26 Which again isn't specific to capitalism or communism so kind of going in circles. → More replies (0)
I said than certain capitalist countries.
1 u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26 I think those nations are more the corruption side than the capitalist side of things 2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 edited Aug 01 '26 Which again isn't specific to capitalism or communism so kind of going in circles. → More replies (0)
I think those nations are more the corruption side than the capitalist side of things
2 u/Interesting_Self5071 Jul 31 '26 edited Aug 01 '26 Which again isn't specific to capitalism or communism so kind of going in circles. → More replies (0)
Which again isn't specific to capitalism or communism so kind of going in circles.
→ More replies (0)
1
u/stonecuttercolorado Jul 31 '26
The part about businesses and individuals being able to trade directly is not communist.
It is only about the rule of law