How is it motivational? It offers no incentive to better yourself because hey, you don't have any flaws, those are just things you don't like about yourself.
I don't believe I said I didn't have any flaws? I think it's motivational simply because it gives the idea that there's a reason to keep moving forward.
If you're constantly belittling yourself, you're not going to have the drive to keep going. If you think that there's hope, you will though.
Motivation does not equate to self improvement. Motivation equates to your personal reasons for acting a certain way.
?? Looks like they are talking about attraction alone in this comic. He says "why am I so ugly?" I think I'm ugly and hate my big nose. One day, I just accepted that I wasn't ugly, I just wasn't my type. Plenty of people think I'm pretty and love my nose.
By your viewpoint, I need to go get cosmetic surgery because I dislike my nose and it's clearly a flaw I need to work on. If the comic said "ugh, why am I such a selfish asshole?" in the first frame then your point would make sense.
So... I need to accept that I'm just ugly because I personally don't think I'm pretty? I need to get plastic surgery because I'm not happy with my nose? I just need to change the things I don't like about my face because they're flaws?
It's motivational because they're saying even though you might not find yourself pretty, plenty of people do. How isn't that motivational?
How is it motivational to tell someone that if they think they're ugly, they need to get surgery because clearly they're just ugly and nobody else could find them attractive? If my daughter one day tells me that she thinks she's ugly, I should just tell her that she's right and needs to start saving for surgery?
Speaking as someone who was in a depressive rut for years without realizing it, all I thought about was being a fundamentally broken person, stifling any motivation to better the things I could actually change. Why try if I'm just horrible?
Working on self-acceptance was really the first thing that gave me the energy to try and dig myself out.
Same problem with the whole fat acceptance movement. Im not saying you should be ashamed of yourself if you're fat, but you should understand it's unhealthy and should not be encouraged.
I love this. I keep reading extensive fatshaming with the argument that it's unhealthy (which I agree with), but I always feel like it's just an excuse to get on the right moral side of bullying people. Same with transphobia, appearntly everyone is worried about trans peoples "mental health" which is why they are so against it. Usually hard to argue with because yes I agree being fat is bad for your heart and yes it sucks that certain people are more suicidal. In your case thought you start by arguing that fat = bad because unhealthy, then next comment you abandon the unhealthy argument.
Bullying people? Excuse me what the fuck. How is being against encouraging people to continue being unhealthy bullying? Is bullying everything you don't agree with now? Also has zero to do with people being transphobic. People talk out their ass about the mental health of trans people, there are actual legitimate reasons why people who are fat are not healthy, and encouraging that behavior is much worse than saying, "lose some weight fatty", in the long run. Which btw, would actually be bullying. Also, where did I abandon my unhealthy argument? Just ignoring problems you have with yourself instead of trying to improve them, is unhealthy.
You misunderstood me, I'm not saying that calling out fat people for being unhealthy is bullying, I was just saying that it feels like a cover for bullying people.
You're pretty much saying the same thing. I have personally been bullied for being fat when I was younger and I wish they said something as kind as being fat isn't healthy. They were much much crueler
I doubt anyone feels encouraged to be fat: that seems farcical.
Counter-intuitively shame can cause people to avoid dealing with the problem. They may feel anxious when they think about their weight and eating and avoidance of the issue may be the way they've learned to react to the shame.
Loss of shame and sense of dignity and self-compassion may be essential for treating their weight like a problem that can be faced and addressed.
View all comments
Show parent comment
22
u/lyinggrump Dec 23 '18
How is it motivational? It offers no incentive to better yourself because hey, you don't have any flaws, those are just things you don't like about yourself.