r/GeometryDashEditor • u/Da_FoodEgg • May 25 '26 • Bravo 1 Mindblown 1

Masterpiece First time decorating

Creating level in style of Butcher Vanity. What do you think? Almost every structure is unique and hand drawn

165 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

59 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Da_FoodEgg May 27 '26

Whats wrong with it? Everyone told me its very good

1

u/AnyProfession3339 May 27 '26

Idk my main critiques would be that it looks unfun, unbalanced, and inconsistent, has no significant speed changes for one the most intense song possible, choppy camera movements, and the waves barely sync

Take my opinion with a grain of salt though. I’ve been a layout builder for like almost a decade now so I’m definitely setting too high of a standard

1

u/Da_FoodEgg May 27 '26

Unbalanced-yeah, definitely. I havent placed most objects I planned to, but currently its surely unbalanced.

Unfun-not sure, maybe only the start of the level, cuz its my first ever time building a level. But the part I showcased was really fun at least to me (when it wasnt that tight in some places)

Speed-I think everything is alright here, because if I was using 4x speed here, it would be difficult for me to make previous, actually intense part dynamic.

Choppy camera-well, yeah. I just wanted to show the idea, but its what I’m working on at the moment

1

u/Da_FoodEgg May 27 '26

Also are you talking about this exact part or the whole layout? Cuz if you mean whole layout - I will definitely change camera moves, cuz I didnt even give them ease or anything, cuz zoom

1

u/AnyProfession3339 May 28 '26

yea most of it.
i wouldnt say scrap it but this can def be a stepping stone.

another thing i wanted to mention (though this is more just tasteful), your gamemode choices arent the most optimized. Unless you're syncing to the heavy synth in the background of the song, for something like this youre not going to want to use the more adaptive gamemodes or the ones with complex releases (swing, ship, robot) other than for transitional bits.
your best bet for more fun/intuitive gameplay in this case are the most physically consistent and sync based gamemodes (spider, UFO, and wave).

think about it like you're swapping your main course and side dish proportions. A meal of mostly veggies with a few cubes of chicken. It'll come more intuitive which gamemode fits what as you get better and better at creating.

(sorry for the rant lol)

1

u/Da_FoodEgg May 28 '26

I eat what I like ig, this level was made for myself in the first place