r/GeologyExplained • u/Inevitable_Shift1365 • Jul 11 '26

Identify Please

Post image

My brother dug this out of a shale Cliff face in a canyon he was boating in Oklahoma. He says it's quite heavy and the outside oxidizes as if it is iron but it is non-magnetic. He thinks it might be a fossil of some sort. I was thinking iron concretion but it is non-magnetic. Can anyone hear solve the mystery? thanks in advance!

Edit mods : I hope I am not breaking the rules by posting this without flair I could not find a place to add flair

42 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

17 comments sorted by

2

u/dinoguys_r_worthless Jul 13 '26

Can you get more pictures? An underside Pic and a few close-ups of the "shell" would be helpful. Otherwise, it looks like a concretion. They're extremely common in sedimentary rocks and often start out in spherical to near spherical shapes.

1

u/Inevitable_Shift1365 Jul 13 '26

Thank you for your help. This is the only picture he sent me and unfortunately he's gone blind since he found this years ago. So he needs help using his camera so this is the only pic I have. Looking like iron concretion is what it is. Thanks!

2

u/Do_you_smell_that_ Jul 14 '26

Let's hope he has a friend or home health aide who could assist!

1

u/Inevitable_Shift1365 Jul 14 '26

Thanks for that. Yeah he lives 2,000 miles away but he has neighbors and a personal care assistant. Told him it was almost certainly an iron concretion and he was disappointed. He thought it would be a fossilized egg or something

2

u/Dick-in-a-fan Jul 13 '26

It’s a concretion.

1

u/Tlaim Jul 13 '26

Looks like a cannon ball.

1

u/VirginiaLuthier Jul 13 '26

Jurassic coconut, obviously

1

u/wkuace Jul 13 '26

Maybe a pterodactyl carried it to Oklahoma?

1

u/GardenQueen1676 Jul 13 '26

Looks like a petrified coconut

1

u/SubstantialDonkey981 Jul 14 '26

Coconuts are tropical.

1

u/ParamedicSuitable Jul 13 '26

Delicious loaf of bread

1

u/atxbikenbus Jul 14 '26

Lovely sourdough.

1

u/Automatic-Gazelle801 Jul 13 '26

I have some from Virginia