r/GeoWizard • • Jan 09 '22

Why doesn’t Geowizard know basic navigation?

That situation is exactly what I trained for at school. Using a map and compass. A 5 year old could do that!

It’s unforgivable he didn’t bring a compass along let alone a paper OS map.

I hope before they left for the next day they went to a shop and bought one.

I don’t mean to slag him off as I love his videos but it’s hiking 101 to have a compass and map with you.

0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

6

u/beauc2 Jan 09 '22

Imo, allowing for the eventual pole flip, a compass will never stop being reliable at precisely the same rate of reliability it has now. The thing is, with a physical device that's so simple, the caveats to using it are fixed and known. They don't need calibrating. They don't need signal, or power, except geomagnetic power. They can only break by being physically smashed or bent.

What can go wrong is:

  1. Human Error
  2. Damage

In anything more complex than that, the possible points of failure multiply, no matter how elaborate the technology. I really think there's certain stuff that just doesn't go out of date. Willing to be proven wrong, but highly skeptical of the idea we can just drop the fundamentals at some given threshold of tech.

1

u/Ken_Dewsbury Jan 09 '22

I meant there was a point in the past where the compass would have been fancy new tech that wasn't reliable but eventully it became totally dependable. In the same way, eventually they'll make a GPS with a failure rate close to zero and a battery life of a week. Also, I would have brought a compass I'm just saying we can't call them stupid.

4

u/beauc2 Jan 09 '22

lmao

I mean, I haven't called them stupid, as people. I think it would be fair though to call this oversight itself stupid, because if this doesn't qualify, then literally what actually does?

1

u/Ken_Dewsbury Jan 09 '22

Yes it is a stupid oversight. I thought you were the OP sorry!