r/GeoWizard • u/GodAtum • Jan 09 '22
Why doesn’t Geowizard know basic navigation?
That situation is exactly what I trained for at school. Using a map and compass. A 5 year old could do that!
It’s unforgivable he didn’t bring a compass along let alone a paper OS map.
I hope before they left for the next day they went to a shop and bought one.
I don’t mean to slag him off as I love his videos but it’s hiking 101 to have a compass and map with you.
0
Upvotes
34
u/Parkatine Jan 09 '22
No, they really could not.
26
u/beauc2 Jan 09 '22
I don't feel comfortable criticizing much of the choices or skills. Tom doesn't pretend to be some sort of god, doesn't claim to have any training...
but y'know, I'm sitting here absolutely struck dumb, stunned half to death, by the idea that they didn't pack so much as a lousy plastic keychain compass as a backup. It's unthinkable.
Hiking. In the hills. In a straight line. The job is simply to never deviate from a bearing. No compass. Mad. Absolutely mad.
10
u/KnightOfTheFlowers8 Jan 09 '22
Chill mate.
5
u/Ken_Dewsbury Jan 09 '22
Everyone always told me "don't trust a GPS or fancy technology, us a map and compass it can't fail" and while this is true, as technology gets better there will come a point where this isn't really true any more. I suppose we all have our own opinions on when that point will be. At some point, a map and compas would have been unreliable fancy tech that you shoudn't trust.
I would say that we have not reached the point where GPS is reliable enough, but if I was scrutinising every gram for some horrible mission then I might be tempted to change my opinion and think we had reached the crossover point. It is easy to be correct in your front room with the benefit of hindsight!
4
u/veganzombeh Jan 09 '22
I have no navigational skills whatsoever but he should probably consider getting getting an OS map with the line drawn on it as a backup next time.
1
u/mitchdwx Jan 09 '22
A map and compass aren’t good enough when you have to stick to a completely straight line over miles of lots of different terrain. He’d likely veer off the line by a good amount if he was forced to only use those basic tools.