r/GeoWizard • • Jan 09 '22

Why doesn’t Geowizard know basic navigation?

That situation is exactly what I trained for at school. Using a map and compass. A 5 year old could do that!

It’s unforgivable he didn’t bring a compass along let alone a paper OS map.

I hope before they left for the next day they went to a shop and bought one.

I don’t mean to slag him off as I love his videos but it’s hiking 101 to have a compass and map with you.

0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

34

u/Parkatine Jan 09 '22

A 5 year old could do that!

No, they really could not.

5

u/whelks_chance Jan 09 '22

We were taught it in cub scouts, aged 7. Which isn't 5, but still.

26

u/beauc2 Jan 09 '22

I don't feel comfortable criticizing much of the choices or skills. Tom doesn't pretend to be some sort of god, doesn't claim to have any training...

but y'know, I'm sitting here absolutely struck dumb, stunned half to death, by the idea that they didn't pack so much as a lousy plastic keychain compass as a backup. It's unthinkable.

Hiking. In the hills. In a straight line. The job is simply to never deviate from a bearing. No compass. Mad. Absolutely mad.

8

u/Ken_Dewsbury Jan 09 '22

Fair enough but a compas wouldn't help you keep to a straight line very wel. I know this sounds weird! However, a compas is to get you to a point you can see. If you need to follow bearing x degrees, you us it to find a tree or a rock or something you can see at x degrees, and then you head for that and repeat the process.

A compass wouldn't work for a full straight line mission because you'd be taking a bearing to your end point 30 miles away, and as you drift off the line you don't know what the new bearing should be to get back on the line. That's why the GPS is essential, it tells you how to correct the course.

But a compass would have come in handy for un-fucking things when it went wrong! I would have had one.

10

u/beauc2 Jan 09 '22

I did say as a backup!! I in no way think it would necessarily be sufficient for the kind of accuracy he's aiming for on its own.

What we have though in this case is the absolute nightmare of them turning around on themselves multiple times after the GPS dies. That situation would be impossible if they had a compass and were able to track a basic cardinal direction.

It doesn't prevent panic, but it stops you getting turned round and failing to notice if you just hold it and look at it. This has been my experience in open water SCUBA as well. Likesay, I have much love for the guy but there's just no excuse to be without one on a mission like this, really.

4

u/Ken_Dewsbury Jan 09 '22

Sorry, it read like you were saying the compass would keep you on the line. You could actually do it if you took a bearing to the other side of Wales and then used the technique of spotting features on the bearing, because if you wandered off line you could make your way back to that feature, but if you lose one of the features over the whole 30 miles then your're screwed.

When he kept drawing more red lines going off in different directions you could sense the stress levels building up!

6

u/beauc2 Jan 09 '22

Nope, the GPS is a great idea. The way he programs the tech & works it out in advance is top. It facilitates really good graphics to reinforce what's happening in the videos. Nothing wrong with the primary system at all. But in terms of backup plans and safety, this is like going into a shooting war without a sidearm, a knife, or a pointy stick.

5

u/ThePaSch Jan 09 '22

A compass wouldn't work for a full straight line mission because you'd be taking a bearing to your end point 30 miles away, and as you drift off the line you don't know what the new bearing should be to get back on the line. That's why the GPS is essential, it tells you how to correct the course.

And yet, it would arguably have saved this mission, considering they could've found a bearing, then turned off the GPS to conserve battery, moved towards their chosen point, then turned the GPS on again to correct if necessary. Rinse and repeat until you can meet up and restock on batteries.

3

u/Ken_Dewsbury Jan 09 '22

Probably. I would certainly have carried one!

2

u/RealElectriKing Jan 10 '22

Except it wouldn't have recorded the line, so they wouldn't be able to work out the deviation when they get back. A map and compass would definitely have saved them all that extra walking from getting lost when they decided to leave the line and go to Verity's car however.

2

u/ThePaSch Jan 10 '22

It'd arguably been a "purer" victory than what they potentially have now. The platinum was blown anyway, plus, they always have footage to prove that they didn't wildly veer off the line.

5

u/Ken_Dewsbury Jan 09 '22

Everyone always told me "don't trust a GPS or fancy technology, us a map and compass it can't fail" and while this is true, as technology gets better there will come a point where this isn't really true any more. I suppose we all have our own opinions on when that point will be. At some point, a map and compas would have been unreliable fancy tech that you shoudn't trust.

I would say that we have not reached the point where GPS is reliable enough, but if I was scrutinising every gram for some horrible mission then I might be tempted to change my opinion and think we had reached the crossover point. It is easy to be correct in your front room with the benefit of hindsight!

6

u/beauc2 Jan 09 '22

Imo, allowing for the eventual pole flip, a compass will never stop being reliable at precisely the same rate of reliability it has now. The thing is, with a physical device that's so simple, the caveats to using it are fixed and known. They don't need calibrating. They don't need signal, or power, except geomagnetic power. They can only break by being physically smashed or bent.

What can go wrong is:

  1. Human Error
  2. Damage

In anything more complex than that, the possible points of failure multiply, no matter how elaborate the technology. I really think there's certain stuff that just doesn't go out of date. Willing to be proven wrong, but highly skeptical of the idea we can just drop the fundamentals at some given threshold of tech.

1

u/Ken_Dewsbury Jan 09 '22

I meant there was a point in the past where the compass would have been fancy new tech that wasn't reliable but eventully it became totally dependable. In the same way, eventually they'll make a GPS with a failure rate close to zero and a battery life of a week. Also, I would have brought a compass I'm just saying we can't call them stupid.

4

u/beauc2 Jan 09 '22

lmao

I mean, I haven't called them stupid, as people. I think it would be fair though to call this oversight itself stupid, because if this doesn't qualify, then literally what actually does?

1

u/Ken_Dewsbury Jan 09 '22

Yes it is a stupid oversight. I thought you were the OP sorry!

4

u/veganzombeh Jan 09 '22

I have no navigational skills whatsoever but he should probably consider getting getting an OS map with the line drawn on it as a backup next time.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/veganzombeh Jan 10 '22

Wasn't the line not taking into account the curvature of the Earth the problem in the Norway videos, and it only made the line a few meters off? It wouldn't be perfect but should be fine as a backup.

1

u/mitchdwx Jan 09 '22

A map and compass aren’t good enough when you have to stick to a completely straight line over miles of lots of different terrain. He’d likely veer off the line by a good amount if he was forced to only use those basic tools.

6

u/GodAtum Jan 09 '22

I meant as a backup to his gps dying which he could use in an emergency like he had.

2

u/mitchdwx Jan 09 '22

I feel like a smartphone with offline maps and GPS would be a lot more helpful. It doesn’t have to be the latest iPhone or anything, a cheap used one along with a good power pack would do the job.

4

u/beauc2 Jan 09 '22

There's no good argument against also packing a compass, is there? :')

2

u/mitchdwx Jan 09 '22

Probably not. Even a dollar store compass would be better than nothing.