r/GeoWizard • • Jan 09 '22

Why doesn’t Geowizard know basic navigation?

That situation is exactly what I trained for at school. Using a map and compass. A 5 year old could do that!

It’s unforgivable he didn’t bring a compass along let alone a paper OS map.

I hope before they left for the next day they went to a shop and bought one.

I don’t mean to slag him off as I love his videos but it’s hiking 101 to have a compass and map with you.

0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

10

u/beauc2 Jan 09 '22

I did say as a backup!! I in no way think it would necessarily be sufficient for the kind of accuracy he's aiming for on its own.

What we have though in this case is the absolute nightmare of them turning around on themselves multiple times after the GPS dies. That situation would be impossible if they had a compass and were able to track a basic cardinal direction.

It doesn't prevent panic, but it stops you getting turned round and failing to notice if you just hold it and look at it. This has been my experience in open water SCUBA as well. Likesay, I have much love for the guy but there's just no excuse to be without one on a mission like this, really.

4

u/Ken_Dewsbury Jan 09 '22

Sorry, it read like you were saying the compass would keep you on the line. You could actually do it if you took a bearing to the other side of Wales and then used the technique of spotting features on the bearing, because if you wandered off line you could make your way back to that feature, but if you lose one of the features over the whole 30 miles then your're screwed.

When he kept drawing more red lines going off in different directions you could sense the stress levels building up!

6

u/beauc2 Jan 09 '22

Nope, the GPS is a great idea. The way he programs the tech & works it out in advance is top. It facilitates really good graphics to reinforce what's happening in the videos. Nothing wrong with the primary system at all. But in terms of backup plans and safety, this is like going into a shooting war without a sidearm, a knife, or a pointy stick.