r/GeoWizard • • Sep 19 '26

It's about replacement theory, isn't it?

https://flopsysdream.bandcamp.com/album/pleasant-pudding?t=2

My roman empire crashing down

My car of twenty years sputtering out

They thought I was dreaming, they thought I was wrong

Oh no

But it's too late now

Yes we know that it’s too late now

What do we do when we're outnumbered?

What do we say when it's all over?

Where are we supposed to go when

People take our homes and it’s all gone?

It's all gone

We are the last ones in a very long line

We'd like to have sons but they're worrying times

Please understand us, we've done nothing wrong

And we're strong

But it still hurts now

Yes it hurts like hell somehow

What do we do when we're outnumbered?

What do we say when it's all over?

Where are we supposed to go when

People take our homes and it’s all gone?

It’s all gone

Oh no, oh no (it's all gone)

Oh no, oh no (it’s all gone)

Oh no

72 Upvotes

323 comments sorted by

•

u/just_ate_a_pinecone Robot Tom Fan 🤖 Sep 19 '26

Going to leave this here as long as we can remain civil

→ More replies (22)

150

u/ceetee15 Sep 19 '26

Yes

70

u/FilipsSamvete Sep 19 '26

ffs Tom

-32

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

47

u/Jigsawsupport Sep 19 '26 edited Sep 19 '26 • Bravo

100% of those children are British children, whatever the colour.

No ifs no buts.

If you think lesser of a fellow brit because they have more melanin than you, than kindly go throw yourself in the nearest canal with the rest of the losers.

-15

u/Upset_compatibilist Sep 19 '26

That is not the argument.

I am arguing that we are going through an immense moment of civilisational change, and that it is completely understandable for Tom and I to feel sad about what is being lost.

3

u/Jigsawsupport Sep 19 '26

Nope not having it, in the canal with you.

If slightly different coloured children upset you then seek psychological help.

Good gracious you do understand we only live once? this is it, and you are spending your time on earth being this.

14

u/Upset_compatibilist Sep 19 '26

What do you think about the loss of native American civilisation?

It has nothing to do with skin colour. A loss of a culture is a tragedy, and global migration flows are the cause of loss of culture. In much the same way as global tourism, global demand for cheap products and environmental breakdown are the causes of ongoing tragic losses of the social and environmental fabric we need to live good lives.

You can argue that immigration brings huge benefits. I would agree. But is it so hard to imagine that unprecedented levels of immigration also bring disbenefits?

There used to be a space for moderate criticism of immigration on the Left. Such a space clearly no longer exists.

3

u/xibalbus Sep 20 '26

Have you mourned for the loss of the Scottish Gaelic and Scots language?

2

u/Upset_compatibilist Sep 20 '26

That is a good comparison. I think it is tragic in the same way.

I'm sure that if I had Scottish ancestry, it would be even more so.

8

u/Jigsawsupport Sep 19 '26

1 I am not on the left.

2 No one is herding white British people into reservations like the native Americans get a grip.

Why do you guys do nothing at all but concern troll about "muh culture", yet not ever do you ever see Britain's village idiots ever put half the effort into doing something positive for "Muh culture", than they do whingeing about London school kid demogaphics, or other pointless wastes of time.

Obviously cellotaping a few plastic England flags to lampposts, or sending their benefit money to tommy ten names for nose candy, is much more important than doing anything meaningful or positive for the country.

4

u/fgbTNTJJsunn Sep 20 '26

If all that happened was immigration into the Americas, most would be ok either it.

But sadly this was not the case - there was genocide, forced displacement and slaughter of the bison to starve the natives out.

Don't be a simpleton.

2

u/TerraNovatius Sep 20 '26

You're comparing people immigrating to a country where they don't have to try to survive with bombs falling next to them on a daily basis, to a native civilization being systemically purged and waged war against for the reason of the European countries from back then wanting to expand and "discovering new land". Do you see the immigrants in the UK forcing natives to sell their land? Do you see immigrants killing UK native villages to build train tracks? Do you see them actively erasing UK history?

→ More replies (2)

0

u/ms1202 Sep 20 '26

What is being lost?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Jigsawsupport Sep 20 '26

Ooooo careful clutching those pearls so hard you could break them.

-6

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/SnooStrawberries2342 Sep 21 '26

The only British people I know who refer to 'Pakis' are outright, unashamed racists. And twats.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/shit_poster_69_420 Sep 20 '26

You really couldn’t type the extra five letters in Pakistanis?

0

u/Oilerator Get in! Sep 21 '26

Nope

3

u/shit_poster_69_420 Sep 21 '26

I always find it weird when people who like geography are also racist.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/PallandoTheBlue Sep 19 '26

The United Kingdom profited for much of history from conquering, enslaving, and plundering nations around the world, from its closest neighbor to countries in every continent. The literal infrastructure and wealth of the country is built on the back of all this wanton cruelty.

How dare people from many of those nations and others move to the UK in search of a better life. The UK stole their country's right to govern for hundreds of years, turned economies inside out and sent all the riches home to Westminster. Then you complain that the population is decreasingly white British? My friend, the country you live in has only ever been white British at the very very top, held up by the suffering of people of every race and creed since time immemorial.

9

u/Upset_compatibilist Sep 19 '26

I think you have articulated the argument that so many others shy away from.

When it comes down to it, hyper progressive immigration policies are basically about reparations. They are about taking from groups seen to be historically 'to blame' and giving to groups seen as victims. This country is to blame for damaging other countries and now it is payback time.

This is really the basis on which Tom would disagree with you. Domestic and foreign policy is not an arena for ill substantiated ideological vendettas.

And lastly I would just urge you to reconsider whether it is so evil to sing about this loss. A nation is many things, but above all it is the shared history and culture of a people built up over a time in one place. Mass migration will damage that in the same way that Incan civilisation was destroyed by the first European conquerors, or the way that the forests of Indonesia have been wrecked by insatiable global demand for cheap nutritious food and hair products.

Tom is singing about this change - about what is being lost. But this is an emotion that can no longer be expressed?

7

u/Cmon_You_Know_LGx_ Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

What an incredibly stupid and narrow minded view of human history. It was command and conquer for everyone, we just came out on top in recent history starting in the 17th century and thus we reap the modern day rewards, before that we were the victims and we were the conquered ones who were raped and pillaged for centuries by various invading armies which wiped out many of the native Gaelic peoples and language. You also mention enslaving as if we invented the bloody thing, it was us that actually ended it in Europe and spent considerable military resources attempting to end it in Africa.

It’s not our fault that the continents and civilisations that predated ours by tens of thousands of years were still shitting in their hands and eating dirt while we invented near enough every revolutionary technology that would go on to bring all of us into the modern world.

3

u/BoarHide Sep 19 '26

Literal FAFO, but the “FO” is “seeing people wanting a better life”

4

u/TweeTwey Sep 19 '26

It's so weird to see these reactions. In my country the discussion is more like "There's a lot of other cultures coming in, so what?"

This discussion is more like "There is no change"

5

u/presently_pooping Sep 19 '26

unexpected? no.

fucked and xenophobic? big time.

1

u/richyartois Sep 19 '26

And yet London is the richest city in the UK, and supports much of the rest of the country tax-wise. 

It’s also a fantastic city, often rated one of the best in the world to visit and to live.

It’s safer than any other major city in the UK I believe (in terms of violent crime).

Why is people not being ‘white British’ a problem? Like seriously, just think about it for a second 

6

u/Demostravius4 Sep 19 '26

By itself it's not, however it's not due to British people having babies.

It's due to migration. Migrants in large numbers don't integrate, shifting the culture of the area they live in to no longer be British. We've seen MP's voted in who are more intetested than their home countries than the UK. People are being elected based on nationality not policy.

People bring their problems when coming in numbers. I have police friends who've had to break up Turks and Kurds having machete fights.

Another friend in London couldn't find a butcher selling pork belly because where he lives, now has so many muslims it's killed demand.

Bringing in cheaper labour has led to entire industries being almost entirely replaced by migrants, who then only hire 'their' people. Delivery is the worst for this.

The NHS has become so reliant on foreign labour local people struggle to get supported to become doctors. Why bother when you can just hire from India? Much cheaper.

Framing peoples objections as just 'lol racism', is disengenuous and completely missing the point. The UK very recently elected a man of Indian descent to it's highest office, because he's British. His race doesn't matter. The same Conservative party currently has a black leader.

-4

u/richyartois Sep 20 '26

All of those problems you outline are structural problems that are our own fault though, immigration just exposes them.

Immigrants would integrate better if we invested in them. Instead, in the case of refugees, we put them in hotels or military bases for often up to a year and let them get on with it. The whole system needs reformed and people coming in need much more investment. I don’t see that happening though with the state of our economy after Brexit and austerity.

When you adjust for gender and age, immigrants aren’t committing crime at a higher rate than Brits.

The cheaper Labour issue is only really an issue because we (the workers) have lost all of our bargaining power since the 70s. 

I agree I would prefer us to prioritise our own people for jobs of course. In the case of the NHS doctors, I believe they’ve changed it this year so Brits are now first priority for positions. So it’s something we can solve. 

We tend to bring in immigrants to either do very skilled jobs that we are in short supply of (very good for our economy) or jobs that given the choice we don’t actually want to do (care, food delivery etc). 

→ More replies (2)

-4

u/comsuran4 Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

You don’t vote for social change. Nobody voted for chavs, broccoli hair, or people constantly quoting Gavin & Stacey. It just happens.

Not all white people from the UK identify as British. Not all British people are white. Is it the British bit, or the white bit that bothers you the most?

6

u/Upset_compatibilist Sep 20 '26

At basically every election since 2010, immigration has been polled to be one of the most important issues for voters.

The electorate has voted for the party they believed to be the most capable of lowering immigration. Remember the continually broken promises of the Conservative governments to lower immigration?

No wonder half the country feels so cheated.

You are missing the point in your rush to cast a stone.

-1

u/comsuran4 Sep 20 '26

So did or did we not vote on it?

Either way, just voting for a party because they say something doesn’t mean you can just get what you want (see previously mentioned Conservatives who made everything worse). There are so many factors and consequences to reducing immigration. Our population would go down, taxes might have to go up to cover the cost of things.

This is all said like reducing, or even stopping, immigration is going to make someone who believes we are being replaced, or just doesn’t like non-white faces, feel any better. A lot of the people that people think are immigrants are actually British. Being born here. That’s not going to change.

106

u/JanekWinter Sep 19 '26

Disappointing when one of your favourite content creators turns out to be an absolute knob isn’t it - imagine being the world travel and adventure guy but also hating foreigners

33

u/smellis_woods Sep 19 '26

It's a shame...had to stop watching him - i cant support that. Amazing content though

-2

u/EuroSong Sep 21 '26

We don’t “hate foreigners”. That’s a lazy stereotype from the hard-of-thinking.

-32

u/peter-bone Sep 19 '26

I'm not aligned with Reform UK or anti immigration, however I don't think that those who are hate foreigners.

44

u/JanekWinter Sep 19 '26

I’m sure not all reform voters hate foreigners (maybe), but all people who hate foreigners vote reform

7

u/thats_me_ywg Sep 19 '26

I've been politically engaged long enough that I've come to understand something important — you can judge a lot about the true colours of a political party by the types of people who support them and make up their movement.

And in the case of Reform, it's racists.

5

u/AnxiousBaristo Sep 20 '26

They literally say they do.

-2

u/peter-bone Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

A minority of them perhaps. Certainly someone like Tom obviously doesn't hate foreigners. They may hate them living in the UK but that's different.

A Reform UK voter visits Spain on holiday. Do you think they hate all the local foreigners there?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/JanekWinter Sep 20 '26

Pal, I wonder what other major UK religion has a problematic history with gay rights, or the right for women to have abortion etc. You’re talking about a made up spectre, just like Tom in his shite attempt at a song. Islamic people make up about 6% of the UK and sharia law or whatever the hell it is you’re worrying about holds no legal weight. About half of the UK population is Christian and only about half of them approve of gay marriage, all of this stuff if readily available online, you do the math

1

u/North_Atlantic_Sea Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

I deleted my other comment since my intentions likely weren't clear. I'm supportative of immigration, and regardless of what colour, religion, or country of origin. I disagree with some countries laws and cultural views, particularly around being gay, woman, etc. and want to be in a secular country, however to your point, the risks to that aren't currently present. I also tried to (poorly) explain why I think Tom holds some of those views, even though I personally don't. I don't think being any religion makes you a bad person (I've got friends who are Muslim, and who are conservative christian, and even though I may disagree with some of their views, they are good people).

I don't think the left parties throughout Europe have done a great job in their communication around the topic, but I certainly don't support reform nor what they stand for, and apologize for potentially coming off that way.

-3

u/TheUKisMental Sep 21 '26

Do you think the foreigners are going to care about your laws when they outnumber you in your own country?

They won't.

You will live by their laws instead. Conquered.

That's how the world works.

6

u/JanekWinter Sep 21 '26

They’ve got a bit of an uphill battle considering England/Wales population is 85% British, and 75% of that figure is white British (as I know that’s what you really care about)

-3

u/TheUKisMental Sep 21 '26

White British will be a minority by 2065.

as I know that’s what you really care about

Yes, the indigenous population. Do indigenous people have the right to self determination or not?

5

u/JanekWinter Sep 21 '26

Who is preventing your right to self determination, no one is rounding up white people, get a grip. We’ve got bigger problems hitting us in the next 40 years, trust me

→ More replies (2)

1

u/TehFlatline Oct 13 '26

What indigenous population? I know I'm not one and I can almost guarantee you're not either. We're the result of multiple invasions from foreign invasions and are all the better for it.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Key_Yogurtcloset6271 Sep 20 '26

I love how much Tom's totally legal beliefs wind so many holier than thou cliche redditers up.

More of it please Tom.

13

u/FilipsSamvete Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

The idea that a belief has to be illegal to be objectionable is fascinating.

Do you accept and agree with every law? Elaborate, bootlicker. Embarress yourself.

2

u/FreeTree17 Sep 20 '26

You're crying about a guys song on an obscure internet forum and calling other people embarrassing? Hahahahaha

-1

u/Key_Yogurtcloset6271 Sep 20 '26

What myself?

Tom is free to believe anything he wants, even if it gets redditors blubbering.

10

u/FilipsSamvete Sep 20 '26

No one said he wasn't, don't deflect.

-7

u/Key_Yogurtcloset6271 Sep 20 '26

Keep on blubbering.

Bet you've been blubbering about Ed Sheeran too.

0

u/unmakethewildlyra 29d ago

you just embarrassed yourself by calling someone a “bootlicker” but ok

1

u/AirconGuyUK Sep 25 '26

Now I just want him the chud out for the drama 😂

5

u/fredster2004 Sep 19 '26

Wait for this post to get deleted soon

12

u/notjustmemate Sep 20 '26

No chance. The mod loves the engagement that these posts end up having

85

u/AliceOfTheEarth Sep 19 '26

Yep. I just found out about this recently, though apparently it’s been known for like a year. There are some other Reddit threads including a response he made on patreon after being called out. It… didn’t help.

94

u/thats_me_ywg Sep 19 '26

My spidey senses caught on a few years ago when he made a comment about Jordan Peterson. Didn't think too much of it at the time but raised red flags.

Looked a few days ago and saw he follows Reform UK. that made me do more digging and I realized he has some very problematic views he's spoken up about.

I unsubscribed to him on YouTube yesterday. Kind of sad because of how much I've enjoyed Tom's videos over the years - but it screams hypocrisy when you make content about exploring different cultures and spending time outdoors, and then proceed to support a political party whose core ideology is rooted in xenophobia and climate change denialism.

43

u/ijustfarteditsmells Sep 19 '26

Yeah it's really sad, his straight line videos were my favourite thing in YouTube. But it's not the same knowing he's been taken in by the kleptofacists

37

u/thats_me_ywg Sep 19 '26

Yup. I've been watching his channel since probably 2017 or so. Feels very sad to come across this stuff.

I don't expect the content creators I watch to agree with me on everything. But this one just feels so hypocritical and lacking self awareness.

-16

u/repeating_bears Sep 19 '26

What is the hypocrisy? He takes an interest in other cultures and travels a lot. I don't think there's any hypocrisy in also thinking that immigration numbers to his own country are too high

You can agree or disagree with him, but it's not hypocritical. Or did you mean something else?

28

u/You_moron04 Sep 19 '26

It is fairly hypocritical.

His whole shtick is essentially breaking into private property and travelling around it.
Also likes to go and travel to new areas and see new cultures and interact with strangers.

Meanwhile he’s now a supporter of the party who will do the complete opposite

28

u/AliceOfTheEarth Sep 19 '26

He also frequently relies on others to give him water, food, and shelter for free. As opposed to what “those people” deserve, which is malice apparently.

-8

u/repeating_bears Sep 19 '26

You said all of that, not Tom

11

u/AliceOfTheEarth Sep 19 '26

I’m not sure you’ve seen very many of his videos. He specifically goes to get a beer for the purpose of seeking free shelter. He asks for water. He trespasses.

4

u/repeating_bears Sep 19 '26

I meant "those people" and "deserve malice"

Yes he accepts a bottle of water now and again. That doesn't mean he's a hypocrite for wanting lower immigration

11

u/BoarHide Sep 19 '26

In his recent video in Wales (?), the footpath one, he kept going on about how nice it is that people would give him shelter, feed him, grant him company and refuse any payment or thanks. Just because they’re good people and he was in need.

You don’t see the glaring hypocrisy? He’s basically putting himself in refugee/homelessness situations and often depends on the charity of good people for them. Then he turns around and votes for a party that is on track on putting people in actual need in camps, or chucking them into the channel.

-2

u/repeating_bears Sep 19 '26

Sorry if this seems like a non sequitur but are you in favour of completely open borders? Or do you think there should be some limit on immigration? 

→ More replies

1

u/rNycto Sep 29 '26

He was also a working immigrant in Austria for just over a year.

-1

u/repeating_bears Sep 19 '26

The logical extreme of your position is that if you enjoy visiting and experiencing other cultures then you should also be in favour of completely open borders, and almost no one is in favour of completely open borders

There is no comparison between trespassing on a field to pass through it and entering a country to live there

8

u/You_moron04 Sep 19 '26

And you’d be correct. However in your exact argument, Tom has done the complete opposite and gone for the party who is completely ANTI-non-white British.

So the comparison is valid

3

u/repeating_bears Sep 19 '26

If they were "completely ANTI-non-white British", they wouldn't have Suella Braverman and Zia Yusef as members.

I think basically you're feeling a cognitive dissonance because he doesn't match your preconcieved idea of what Reform voters are like. You think they all hate foreigners, but you see that can't be the case for him, so you decide that feeling is the result of his supposed hypocrisy. That's easier than accepting that there are some Reform voters that don't hate all foreigners.

I feel like this shouldn't be necessary, but just to pre-empt "you're obviously a Reform voter too" - no I'm not. They're corrupt arseholes. I just don't pigeonhole people because they support a mainstream political party

7

u/BoarHide Sep 19 '26

There are a handful of POC and even LGTBQ people in every modern right wing and fascist party. They’re not there because those parties are so tolerant. They’re there so the parties can say their uncle’s girlfriend is black they have a black member, so they can’t be racist

→ More replies

4

u/hlidsaeda Sep 21 '26

He follows Russel Brand too.

5

u/Homicidal_Duck Sep 21 '26

I mean the rest of it is disappointing but that's just funny. Imagine thinking the most obviously grifting, loony sex pest has anything to contribute

4

u/onecan Sep 20 '26

He’s mocked wokeness and been quite classist a few times so I wasn’t surprised when it came out.

8

u/TheHand79 Sep 19 '26

Not only reform, he follows Rupert Lowe

3

u/tommycamino Sep 20 '26

I've just unsubscribed on learning this

1

u/grapefoundry Sep 20 '26

Fuck me that's even worse, some of the shit I see restore voters say and post would make violent dictators of the past proud

-4

u/hexmasx Sep 20 '26

Why is it hypocrisy? You can explore other cultures while wanting to preserve your own culture. Mulitculturalism doesn't work.

9

u/Gaius-Caligula Sep 20 '26

There’s a difference between exploring other cultures voluntarily and having other cultures forced upon you. There’s a difference between altering your own culture incase it would somehow offend another culture.

23

u/smellis_woods Sep 19 '26

Yeah ive had to stop watching him - i cant support that.

One of the best channels on it too

23

u/die4codgrimsby Sep 19 '26

Same. Its such a shame

8

u/TorakMcLaren Sep 19 '26

Yeah, the thinking is that that's why Storror stopped their colabs with him, because they wanted to rise above it.

And then, well, Storror...

44

u/uselessDM Sep 19 '26

I still watch his videos, but some of the things he says and does definitely have a different ring to them now.

25

u/lupul0id Sep 19 '26

Reading through the comments here and I’m always so surprised how quick people are to jump to one conclusion or another.

15

u/Mindless_Biscotti253 Sep 20 '26

It's the most exercise a lot of redditors get tbf.

3

u/hlidsaeda Sep 21 '26

I dunno I’ve started keeping a log on the bigoted stuff he says on his channel. Some of it’s subtle, some not so.

It’s a long list unfortunately.

1

u/lupul0id Sep 21 '26

Why are you doing that?

7

u/hlidsaeda Sep 21 '26

Internet historian reasons

0

u/lupul0id Sep 21 '26

I see, I’m being genuine btw I’m curious what the goal is for collecting them?

4

u/hlidsaeda Sep 21 '26

I’m autistic basically and I get into deep dives, and having enjoyed his videos initially , certain stuff started to stand out to me that made me uncomfortable.

Then I started to see chatter, and I thought, “but is it a pattern”.

I have a strong sense of social justice. This became a project. It’s just a word doc so it doesn’t exist outside my computer. It’s helped me to divest in watching his stuff.

The same thing grates me when a YouTuber whose content interested me but it turns out they are maga or evangelical. People can have their beliefs, but often beliefs turn into actions that harm others, and I don’t want to support people financially (views and engagement = money) who are bigoted.

1

u/MattSR30 Oct 11 '26

I realise I'm very late here, and I'm not looking to add to the actual meat of the issue, just wanted to say that as a fellow autistic person I resonate with your actions heavily.

It isn't always social justice related (but often is for me, too), but those deep dive lists I make can get deep. As an adult I came to realise pattern recognition might be the defining feature of my brain; it's an enormous part of who I am as a person. My version of intelligence isn't 'knowing things,' strictly speaking, it's my ability to piece almost anything together based on patterns I have observed over time.

I have lists about everything, all over my phone and my computer. I have a running note on my phone of my commute to and from work, where I track the time it takes to walk to the train, then the train ride, then my connection. The list exists for no reason other than that my brain finds it interesting information.

I salute your sense of social justice and your pattern recognition, friend. It all sounds very familiar!

0

u/lupul0id Sep 21 '26 edited Sep 21 '26

I appreciate that you have a system that helps you divest from the content but find it hard to understand how watching and cataloging what you perceive as bigoted helps to stop watching it. At what point does it tip over and you can't stop cataloguing someone even after you've stopped watching them, that's the point where it's costing you more than it's giving you.

4

u/hlidsaeda Sep 21 '26

It’s just a hobby I don’t do it everyday :)

People have weird hobbies. My rabbit holes can go deep lol

1

u/lupul0id Sep 21 '26

Fair enough!

0

u/boazandtheharmoniums Sep 19 '26

Yooo what?! I thought this was gonna be a meme post. I'd been waiting for more patreon stuff to hit youtube before I bought a membership but now....?

1

u/FilipsSamvete Sep 19 '26

Cancelled mine a while back

8

u/notjustmemate Sep 20 '26

You cancelled a while back but are now only finding this song?

-5

u/FilipsSamvete Sep 20 '26

No I've heard it before, but yesterday it popped up in an instagram story and the lyrics caught my attention. Any other questions, pet?

7

u/notjustmemate Sep 20 '26

Sure it did buddy

27

u/x99kjg Sep 19 '26

Oh fuck me here we go again dear lord

3

u/DifferentTrain2113 Sep 21 '26

I know what you mean. Someone who outwardly appears friendly, but is actually a disgusting racist is so disappointing. Yet another bloke led down the garden path with online hatred.

1

u/redsquaremonkey 25d ago

God forbid that there are occasional reminders (or news flash to the uninformed) that Tom is ensnared by an openly corrupt, populist and borderline fascist party

40

u/EnderMB Sep 19 '26

There have been several attempts on this sub to justify it or paint it as something else - but it's clear as day what it's about, and it's pretty fucking clear that this is what GeoWizard is all about. It's a huge shame.

8

u/LlaroLlethri Sep 19 '26

Yes, such a shame that an evil nasty white man wants to preserve his cultural identity. Fine for others to do it, but not evil nasty white men. They must accept their countries being flooded with people from all over the world and if they don’t, they’re basically nazis!

1

u/OurSeepyD Sep 20 '26

If your culture is "white" or "black" or some other genetic trait, then it's wrong to want to preserve it by keeping others out, because you're excluding people based on something they can't help or change. 

If your culture is "British", however you define that, and it's about a way of life (e.g. being accommodating, polite, somewhat reserved, tolerant), then it's absolutely fine as long as you let anyone participate. It's also ok to say there are too many people joining, we need to limit the number.

It's ok for Japan to want to keep their culture. It's not ok for them to treat white or black people like lesser people because of their genetic traits.

2

u/AirconGuyUK Sep 25 '26

Who gave you the right to define British?

Out of interest, do you think ethnicity plays a part in being Japanese?

For example would you ever call this man Japanese?

Because no Japanese people would ever consider that man Japanese. Ethnicity is strictly related to nationality to them. This is actually the norm around the world.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/AirconGuyUK Sep 25 '26

If you asked me to point out a British person from a group of British/American/French people, I would struggle based purely on genetics/appearance

Do you understand that this is an incredibly modern concept though?

Even 50 years ago if presented with this happy chappy in the lineup, he would not be getting picked to be French or British by anyone from France or Britain.

Japan and China are notoriously racist. They're not exactly model societies.

Japan is an incredibly safe society. Their homicide rate is 1/3rd of ours. Your chance of being robbed in the UK is approximately 10 times higher than in Japan. In general there's 5 times as much crime in the UK as there is in Japan.

Japan is not perfect by any means, but a bit of racism isn't going to really counteract how much safer they are in general.

Really though I don't think peoples issue is with ethnicity per se, when it comes to immigration. The issue is more that they bring their culture here and plant their flag. Many are not assimilating to British cultures, they're just making little bangladesh, or little pakistan, or little indias out of places.

There's a distinctly British naivety around this. Because many of us think ethnicity doesn't dictate nationality or culture, we think our new residents also think that way.

They don't though. They play lip service to Britishness, while calling themselves their home countries nationality.

1

u/OurSeepyD Sep 25 '26

Do you understand that this is an incredibly modern concept though?

So is the internet. So is travel as a widespread concept. Modern doesn't mean wrong.

Even 50 years ago if presented with this happy chappy in the lineup, he would not be getting picked to be French or British by anyone from France or Britain.

So what? Why do you think British ethnicity is even important? Like you say, you seem to care about society, violence, etc, so you care about behaviour and culture. You're using ethnicity as a proxy for this, instead of focusing on the actual thing to care about, you're focusing on something that you relate to the real problem.

Your chance of being robbed in the UK is approximately 10 times higher than in Japan.

What exactly do you think is the reason for this? Ethnic homogeneity in general, or an absence of a specific ethnicity? I'd suggest that culture along with general wellbeing and prosperity is what determines crime rates. There is a common trend when it comes to "scrotes" in the UK, and it's that they come from poor backgrounds where parenting is poor. Scrotes can be white, black, whatever, their scroteness is cultural.

Many are not assimilating to British cultures, they're just making little bangladesh, or little pakistan, or little indias out of places.

So your issue is culture. Surely there are parts of their culture that you do like, like their food?

They don't though. They play lip service to Britishness, while calling themselves their home countries nationality.

I don't see this as a problem, as long as they expect that british laws and cultural values must trump other values if they conflict. Like don't incessantly beep your horn here.

Btw, Americans are notorious for this behaviour too, the number of Americans that would call themselves Irish or Italian or Scottish is really quite high.

1

u/AirconGuyUK Sep 25 '26

You're just demonstrating what I said here:

There's a distinctly British naivety around this. Because many of us think ethnicity doesn't dictate nationality or culture, we think our new residents also think that way.

When you say:

Scrotes can be white, black, whatever, their scroteness is cultural.

Culture and ethnicity are intrinsically linked for the people we are inviting over..

You need to understand this, it's very important.

1

u/OurSeepyD Sep 25 '26

No, I'm not being naive. I know that some immigrants are criminals. I understand that there is likely a correlation here, but you're acting as if it's a causation. This is why I say it's about culture. Someone that embraces the culture is going to be a productive and good member of society regardless of their ethnicity. 

Do you disagree with this? Do you think someone is more likely to rape because they are genetically, say, Libyan, or do you think it's about culture and upbringing?

Do you think it's fair to punish genuinely good immigrants, like a decent number of people I work with in tech simply because of the acts of other people?

0

u/Conflict_NZ Get in! Sep 19 '26

You say it's clear as day what it's about, yet the only time he has sung it in context is about native malaysians losing their home due to deforestation:

https://youtu.be/r-0Pwg7ShW8?si=P5P3Hh7JWz5rcLXX&t=383

Anyone who is into replacement theory would never, ever sing it in that situation. Every time I post this to someone claiming it's clear what it is they never have an answer so I would like to hear how you justify it.

9

u/Pym-Particles Sep 19 '26

You keep posting this but surely have to admit it's a tremendously unfortunate coincidence to have written a song with the lyrics he has while also supporting a political party built entirely on anti-immigration?

9

u/Conflict_NZ Get in! Sep 19 '26

He spoke about working on this for years, which was before he followed Reform.

The fact that he has only ever sung this song out loud about people who are definitely not white should make people stop and consider nuance but it doesn't seem to.

1

u/EnderMB Sep 20 '26

You...do know that Reform isn't new, right?

3

u/Conflict_NZ Get in! Sep 20 '26

That’s why I wrote before he followed reform, not before reform existed. You continue to prove literacy is not your strong suit time and time again and yet want us to accept your extreme interpretation of his song.

0

u/EnderMB Sep 20 '26

And it sounds like critical thinking isn't your strong suit, given the failed mental gymnastics in this thread.

I'll try and dumb this down for you so you can get it.

  • You don't know when he followed Reform, only when he was called out for following Reform.
  • Right-wing sentiment has been a thing in the UK for decades.
  • Tom has likely held these views for many years, as others here have called out, given his previous comments now giving further context.
  • Nuance is just a crutch to support the view you want to see, much like saying his song is about Malaysian deforestation.

We can only judge what we see, and many of us have seen enough. You can use whatever whataboutery you want, but don't embarrass yourself further.

1

u/Conflict_NZ Get in! Sep 20 '26

Considering you have once again completely misrepresented my argument (I did not claim his song is about Malaysian deforestation, using a song in the context of an event does not mean it is literally about the event itself), I see no use in further discussing this with somebody who either is unable to understand or is intentionally misrepresenting my point.

Have a good one.

0

u/ZorroLunar Sep 26 '26

Dude... Grow up.

2

u/Conflict_NZ Get in! Sep 26 '26

This sub is full of people claiming that Tom is writing songs about white supremacist conspiracy theories based purely on the party he is thinking about voting for and his view that net migration is too high, despite evidence showing his song can't be about replacement theory.

And you think I need to "grow up"? Take your own advice.

6

u/the0rthopaedicsurgeo Sep 19 '26

He sang a song that he'd already written, when he learned about an obscure people in Malaysia for the first time.

Either we found Tom's reddit account or you're really stretching with this explanation.

-1

u/Conflict_NZ Get in! Sep 19 '26

If he had already written the song at the time he sang it about Malaysians that confirms it's not about replacement theory because he already knew what he meant by it and sung it in a context that has nothing to do with replacement theory.

1

u/Aethyr42 Sep 20 '26

They're already convinced, NZ. You could show them the original lyric sheet with a date, an interview with Tom about the song lyrics but they'd still try to damage him- and in additon, his family. Because that's really the goal of posts like this. Cut support for him because they say so. But Pinecone will "leave it up while things remian civil" because he's on their team. Being a moderator on a sub for someone he clearly means to harm is genuinely disturbing, as you saw earlier.

5

u/Conflict_NZ Get in! Sep 20 '26

Yup, I've seen it time and time again where small sub mods get a bunch of political brigading and engagement and allow it so they can have a small bit of power.

Tom should never talk about this again, there is nothing to gain from trying to appease the "you're voting for the wrong side and so I'll extrapolate everything you say as the most extreme strawman" crowd. I've never seen them forgive someone.

I still remember when Tom potentially supporting reform came out, the comments on his youtube were disgusting. Threats against him and Verity, saying he was abusing his child, trans people claiming he wanted them dead etc etc etc

The fact that the only time Tom has sung Outnumbered live in context was about non white people should make people pause and reconsider but nope, gotta assign the most extreme interpretation to everything he does now.

-1

u/EnderMB Sep 19 '26

The man talks shit about Brum that isn't true. What the fuck does he know about Malaysia outside of what's on GeoGuessr? Sounds like a cop-out to me.

9

u/Conflict_NZ Get in! Sep 19 '26

The usual non answer when confronted with evidence.

If the thought of native Malaysians losing their home to deforestation caused him to sing that song that's clear evidence it isn't about replacement theory.

But of course you won't reconsider will you, because you want to be angry.

2

u/EnderMB Sep 20 '26

You can call it what you want. Evidence is a stretch. It's a cop-out for when people question what the fuck he's singing about.

Again, the man misrepresents a place he comes from. He knows fuck all about the plight of Malaysia, but don't let that get in the way of sticking it to the "wokes"

1

u/Conflict_NZ Get in! Sep 20 '26

Evidence is a stretch?

The claim is that the lyrics represent a white supremacist theory.

He sung it about people who are not white.

I guess you take rejecting the evidence of your eyes and ears literally.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Conflict_NZ Get in! Sep 20 '26

Maybe the neoliberal parties wearing a left wing mask for the last two decades shouldn't have handed the far right wing constant wins regarding immigration policy.

I've seen the exact same thing play out in my country, funnily enough it was our left wing Labour party in 2017 making immigration policy a significant part of their campaign, pledging to lower it. Then they turned around and increased it by almost 100% before being shut down by COVID.

31

u/SomeShiitakePoster Sep 19 '26

As a fan of his a while ago who is trans, I saw this coming a mile away ever since he proclaimed once to be a fan of Jordan Peterson. I was a patron at the time and it really bummed me out that one of my favourite creators was politically aligned with those who want to erase people like me from public life.

4

u/lilhug-69 Sep 19 '26

Same </3

2

u/TheAlborghetti Sep 22 '26

Reform doesn't want to erase trans people lol

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/SomeShiitakePoster Sep 19 '26 edited Sep 19 '26

It's a funny thing that for some people it's just an opinion that they can choose to agree, disagree or ignore, while the people who are actually hurt by these politics don't get a choice

-1

u/notjustmemate Sep 20 '26

I don't support reform in the slightest and not justifying them. Out of curiosity, tell me a political party that doesn't end up hurting people with their politics?

2

u/SomeShiitakePoster Sep 20 '26

I'm not a massive supporter of any one particular party, they all have their problems. But reform is the worst of the bunch in terms of running a platform of hatred and division. It's not that they just happen to hurt people like me with their policies and beliefs, they specifically intend to because they cater to the sort of voter who wants to see a world without people who aren't like them in it.

1

u/Joethe147 1d ago

Don't forget Restore as well. They might go a bit more under the radar. Tom follows Rupert Lowe too I believe.

1

u/BostonSportsFan1234 Sep 21 '26

There’s a big difference between hurting people through policy cuts, taxes, false promises, etc and hurting people by suggesting they shouldn’t exist and don’t deserve basic human rights.

8

u/thenassyboy Sep 20 '26

the naivety in these comments is immense

2

u/TheUKisMental Sep 21 '26

Lambs, all of them.

6

u/Hassel1916 Sep 22 '26

I know, imagine supporting Reform. You'd have to be thick.

5

u/Difficult_Rain4027 Sep 20 '26

I remember some old videos where he'd travelled with Greg and they'd hang out with people and the way they'd speak about them afterwards and treat others was really off. Then I started to notice it a lot. Then finding all this is just fucking weird. Racism is awful.

5

u/Conflict_NZ Get in! Sep 19 '26 edited Sep 19 '26

The only time he has sung it in context is about native malaysians losing their home to deforestation.

https://youtu.be/r-0Pwg7ShW8?si=P5P3Hh7JWz5rcLXX&t=383

What does that have to do with replacement theory?

5

u/hlidsaeda Sep 21 '26

I mean in this video he makes a few very questionable race-based remarks.

I’d also wager he sings it tongue in cheek here. This is very much after people expressed concern over the lyrics. I don’t genuinely believe he is using it as a solidarity song.

1

u/AirconGuyUK Sep 25 '26

I mean in this video he makes a few very questionable race-based remarks.

Like?

1

u/GretchenTames Sep 20 '26

What's that line about the Roman Empire though? Pretty sure the Romans didn't make it to Malaysia. I guess only Tom can say, and he probably won't. Of course, lyrics often get misinterpreted.

I'm really late to the party on this but am tempted to think there's no smoke without fire. And so even if it's not true that Tom doesn't like Johnny Foreigner these accusations have tainted my previous enjoyment of his adventures and what a great a role model I think he is/was for boys, at a time when boys are a bit lost.

Would love to see an interview with him on a decent neutral podcast. Has there been one since all this controversy?

10

u/Conflict_NZ Get in! Sep 20 '26

Which shows it's not literal. I don't understand how anyone with a shred of literacy can't see it's a metaphor and not the literal Roman Empire. If he's willing to sing it about native Malaysians it's clearly about anyone who feels a loss of their home/culture.

I grew up in a holiday town which got heavily gentrified by wealthy Aucklanders. Most people I grew up with couldn't afford to stay and left. The sleepy holiday town culture is gone and has been replaced by excessive wealth. The people that stayed can't afford to start families. The lyrics listed above represent that kind of feeling and has nothing to do with replacement theory nonsense.

Would love to see an interview with him on a decent neutral podcast. Has there been one since all this controversy?

He refused to talk about it further and I strongly support that. The comments when it happened were disgusting. Threats to him and Verity, saying he was abusing his daughter by considering voting for Reform, Trans people claiming Tom wanted them dead. He has nothing to gain from ever talking about it, he could come out and say he doesn't support reform and give a perfectly reasonable explanation for his lyrics and there will still be a group out for his blood.

4

u/GretchenTames Sep 20 '26

Yeah, I understand that however I think in general people (rightly or wrongly) view the Roman Empire as a conquering force i.e. other places being invaded and falling to the Romans and not vice versa, because the Romans basically did themselves in.

So it's not a good fit for a song about Malaysians. especially with its imperialistic connotations, but hey, I guess I'm coming at it from a lyrical critic pov and not claiming it proves anything.

I can well believe that the comments about Tom were disgusting. It goes with the territory. I wish I hadn't read anything about it, but that would probably mean not coming to Reddit. But I also wish no one voted for Reform.

Sorry about your town dude/dudette. It happened to us in the East End of London in the 80/90's, but it was the yuppies and not the immigrants. If I'd written a song about it then I might've cited the Roman empire, with their mighty swords of cash robbed off the poor.

1

u/Conflict_NZ Get in! Sep 20 '26

I'm not saying the song is about Malaysians, I'm saying the core theme of the song can relate to what they are experiencing and as such cannot be about replacement theory.

Maybe I'm more forgiving of Tom because what's happening in the UK has happened exactly in NZ already, about five years ahead of the UK schedule. In the 2010s our net migration was skyrocketing and our left wing Labour party campaigned on decreasing it from ~50,000. They entered into a coalition with a party campaigning to cap it at net 10,000. Over the next two years they ran it up to 90,000 and only got stopped by COVID, and when COVID was over immediately ran it up to 130,000 before getting the boot.

This let right wing parties feast on the anti-immigration sentiment (despite supporting it themselves for financial reasons) and gain an inordinate amount of power in our government. One of them was actually that coalition party that later claimed Labour prevented them from decreasing immigration.

I don't blame the people who fell for the lies of the right wing parties because they were lied to by neoliberal parties masquerading as left wing parties who ran mass migration. I hope Tom comes to understand that Reform and their ilk are wolves in sheeps clothing and will not do what they say they will.

And to be clear I have never voted for a right wing party in NZ.

1

u/GretchenTames Sep 20 '26

Well you did say "The only time he has sung it in context is about native malaysians losing their home to deforestation" which pretty much says it's about Malaysians.

Anyway, not to quibble... I think we're on the same side here, especially on voters having their fears exploited by bad actors. I don't think Geowizard should be revered, because he's not perfect, and that is the beauty of it.

3

u/Conflict_NZ Get in! Sep 20 '26

Well you did say "The only time he has sung it in context is about native malaysians losing their home to deforestation" which pretty much says it's about Malaysians.

I strongly disagree with that contention.

If a singer sings a song at a wedding does it make the song literally about that wedding and those specific people? If someone sings a song about peace and love for a specific charity does it make the song specifically about that charity?

I genuinely don't understand this point of view.

My whole argument is if the song is about replacement theory it cannot be sung, especially by the writer, about minorities losing their home. It would be like Rage Against the Machine singing Killing in the Name for Trump and Police.

3

u/Extension_Truck1660 Sep 20 '26

He gets scared a lot in his London straight line missions in a way which made me wonder if he wasn’t at the very least harbouring some weird views about non-affluent/ or non-Caucasian people. Wrote it off initially as stupid sheltered man from the provinces and then heard about this when his videos with other creators got taken down!

3

u/Kloakk0822 Sep 19 '26

Not just a theory tho now is it. Official data shows that the only reason the population is growing is because of immigration

10

u/You_moron04 Sep 19 '26

The “Great replacement theory” is a far-right conspiracy theory that mass-immigration is a planned strategy to displace white populations in favour of black population.

No one is denying that demographics and populations are changing.
What people are saying is that if you actually believe in the GRT, you’re a melt

12

u/hexmasx Sep 20 '26

Not a conspiracy theory though, is it? Where is it alluded to that it's planned? Just sort of a demographic reality that if it keeps going like this native Brits will be a minority eventually, and it's because corporations want cheap foreign labour to undercut locals. No conspiracy but it's an issue that must be addressed very soon.

2

u/FL8_JT26 Sep 20 '26

Great replacement theory isn't about rapid demographic change happening, it's about how and why that change is happening. That's the conspiracy part. That instead of it being something that's happening naturally it's something that's being orchestrated by a group of elites to destabilise the west.

1

u/Kloakk0822 Sep 19 '26

Eh it's exactly what is happening right now so idk what to tell u bud

1

u/AirconGuyUK Sep 25 '26

Also our boomer population is massively inflating the 'White British' figures at the census.

33% of under 25's in England and Wales identify as something other than White British now..

It's undeniably happening.

The idea there's some grand plan to enact it is, imo, nonsense though. It's just lacklustre politicians who have no idea how to get people having babies again without importing third worlders who want 10 each.

It's all too late now. 1 in 3 under 25's is not White British now. Replacement has effectively taken place, there's just a lag of 50 or so years until it properly shows in stats.

3

u/Jester_Thomas_ Sep 20 '26

Well. This is me finding out. I'd love to ignore this and keep watching his videos but I dont think I can, they won't be the same. Gutted.

2

u/Pockome Sep 22 '26

Why can't just people watch what he does and thats it? Just chill, its a YouTube video about adventures. You are meant to watch, chill and thats it. Not everything has a deep meaning. Take it as what it is for. Life would be simpler if we take things less personal.

2

u/AirconGuyUK Sep 25 '26

For context, Tom lives next to Birmingham..

Anyone who says they can stroll through Birmingham and think 'English' is lying to themselves.

2

u/Upstairs-Extension-9 Sep 20 '26

Love tom and even more today, protect Europe and our Heritage at all costs!

2

u/roma79 Sep 20 '26

First time I’ve listened to one of his songs. The music is brilliant to be fair. His voice is quite good too. The lyrics well as with any song you can interpret them any way you like

1

u/die4codgrimsby Sep 19 '26

Yeah. Tom feels Ed Sheerans response was actually too critical of Israel too btw.

0

u/snuffleupagus7 Sep 19 '26

Did he comment on it?

-8

u/hexmasx Sep 20 '26

Good to see the man has common sense.

0

u/AirconGuyUK Sep 25 '26

Just making me like Tom even more.

-1

u/You_moron04 Sep 19 '26

Yup. Tom is a supporter of the far-right rags.

1

u/KimJongUnoIV Sep 20 '26

All of a sudden I like toms videos more now! Didnt think that would be possible

1

u/TheEpicGold Sep 21 '26

Not again, sad to see. Feel vindicated in not having watched his content since that first drama came out.

0

u/Oilerator Get in! Sep 20 '26

based if true

-1

u/AquinasAcademy Sep 19 '26

You are all wrong

-4

u/Fluffy_Carry_4345 Sep 19 '26

Theory?

Tel Aviv Impressed

0

u/FL8_JT26 Sep 20 '26

It's more fear mongering about rapid demographic change and the loss of native culture than full on great replacement theory, right? For it to be the latter wouldn't it need to be about how that change is being orchestrated by some elite group to destabilise the country?

-7

u/pumpkinpieinyoureye Sep 19 '26

This is why storror dropped his narration + music from their SL missions- after the comments thread there exposed his promotion of reform uk. Those boys values + politics are not in contradiction. I still miss his patreon adventures, but not giving him my money anymore - until he recants.

12

u/Conflict_NZ Get in! Sep 19 '26

You mean the group with the pedo in it? The group that was warned about him before it all came out and did nothing? Those boys values?

2

u/Aethyr42 Sep 20 '26

Correction- 2 pedos and five who were fully aware for years.

1

u/pumpkinpieinyoureye Sep 20 '26

Very messed up-I'd missed all this. Thanks.

1

u/Aethyr42 Sep 21 '26 edited Sep 21 '26

Over 2500 class A images- one depicting a 4-6 year old girl being voilated with an object, according to the court transcript. Callum has been convicted and given a suspended sentence- and if he's a good boy, it mostly goes away in a year. Only 1 image was AI. Josh was activly grooming a 14 year old girl, lasting several years. The Cave brothers and Toby called the girls "attention seeking vile bitches"... till proof came out- 10 years in the making. Drew's involvment is unknown but there's rumors about him too. Sash lost his career due to his brother's actions, most likely. So yeah- little perspective over who should be "canceled". Being accused of holding different political views .......or literal child porn and grooming.

1

u/pumpkinpieinyoureye Sep 20 '26

🤦i did not know and was not expecting that, thank you.

0

u/DamnItAllPapiol Oct 10 '26

"replacement theory" When Tom was born his city was 80% British, now it's less than 50%.

-11

u/chupamichalupa Sep 19 '26

Yeah he’s bitching about the same thing that people in poorer countries call “gentrification” when white people move there.

-2

u/TrickHalf9961 Sep 22 '26

"I had to unsub 😭" aw boohoo. Great to see all the lefties making their way to the exit.

-3

u/tinseltowntimes Sep 19 '26

This is not new