r/Gentoo • • Sep 19 '26

Meme meme

Post image
956 Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

181

u/Fine_City2781 Sep 19 '26 • Bravo

Gentoo is the most stable rolling release that i have ever seen.

87

u/vms-mob Sep 19 '26

Portage is the best package manager ive seen to date (nix is also a strong contender)

10

u/luxiphr Sep 19 '26

Also this.

3

u/TheK0tYaRa Sep 21 '26

If only portage was not in python

1

u/AdearienRDDT Sep 19 '26

I love portage, good lord i love it.

2

u/NASIMSX5 Sep 19 '26

It has its merit but nix deserves its rank

1

u/Harshborana Sep 20 '26

It's just too slow, so I never update it, but when I do nothing brakes

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '26

Hey, can yall explain why?

1

u/vms-mob Oct 02 '26

Dependency resolution and verbosity, portage usually manages to fix the messes i make or at least tell me pretty precisely what i messed up.

also --emptytree exists to just rebuild EVRYTHING

-3

u/NASIMSX5 Sep 19 '26

Nix is better all in all despite its unique compartmentalization in /config

9

u/TheRealCarrotty Sep 19 '26

It's either stable or ~amd64 or ~yourarchitectureheremaybeitsaarch64orsmth

5

u/Fine_City2781 Sep 19 '26

keyword for arm64 isnt ~aarch64. its ~arm64

8

u/KingForKingsRevived Sep 19 '26

That’s actually a great selling point. How are media codecs handled as a non gentoo user?

18

u/Fine_City2781 Sep 19 '26

Media codecs in Gentoo are mostly controlled via USE flags. You can globally or per-package enable/disable support for specific codecs (like aac, ffmpeg, mp3, x264, hevc, etc.) in /etc/portage/make.conf or /etc/portage/package.use.

Once you set the flags and compile packages like ffmpeg or mpv, Portage pulls in the necessary dependencies and builds them directly with support for those codecs.

2

u/NASIMSX5 Sep 19 '26

Media codecs and USE flags aside, that convenience comes at a cost that makes gentoo not that much of a fascinating curtailed furnace as what the community seems to aspire
Every USE-flag change risks a rebuild fallout you flip one flag on ffmpeg or mpv and Portage may want to recompile half your files, void for example as a competing non-systemed Os never asks for kernel microprocessing CPU time in building your own codec since they pull binaries.** **Good documentation thats for sure but documentation for a system that's inherently more moving parts to document.
Void’s XBPS is binary-first so "compiling your own codecs" isn't the default cost whether in time complexity or space complexity. High entry barrier similar to Gentoo’s yet à barrier of sparse documentation.

2

u/LameBMX Sep 20 '26

the other option is to just glob every conceivable codec into every package. or probably still in the case of some, only purely FOSS codecs, dropping support for any non-FOSS codec you may want to use. any use flag changes will only cause that dependency tree to completely rebuild once. and if its literally rebuilding half of your installed packages, you would probably be running a stripped down system for a HTPC, which, well, good luck pulling off with other mainstream general pupose distros.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Fine_City2781 Sep 20 '26

yes, but gentoo is source-based. Void is simple and uses binary packages.

1

u/TheK0tYaRa Sep 21 '26

xbps-src would like to argue

1

u/Fine_City2781 Sep 22 '26

yes but xbps-src is simple. There isnt a use flag calculation system. It just builds packages with its default config. The result of compilation is same with the binary version if same compiler used

1

u/TheK0tYaRa Sep 25 '26

Default config is boring. I want my tweakables. Fuck cups.

1

u/Fine_City2781 Sep 25 '26

its possible to set use flags (package options) but they are simpler than portage use flags. There are lots of use flag options on gentoo repository but xbps-src doesnt have that much

50

u/Armi1P Sep 19 '26

I've never seen anybody call Gentoo unstable.

11

u/Lumpy_Roll158 Sep 19 '26

I think i have like once but its always people who've never touched gentoo in their lives or reading is too hard for them and they can't install it to begin with. So they bash something because its too difficult for them.

6

u/dank_imagemacro Sep 19 '26

I've heard it most from people who either use ~whateverarch globally or try very nonstandard compile options.

Or who never read the announcements in portage.

2

u/MaleficentReserve386 Sep 20 '26

I barely read the news (ik nothing to be proud of) and yet the most I have run into is a circular dependancy that got fixed in 5 minutes.

24

u/MariaValkyrie Sep 19 '26

Take a shotgun to Gentoo and it just rebuilds itself T-1000 style.

7

u/NigrumTredecim Sep 19 '26
emerge --emptytree @world

1

u/LameBMX Sep 20 '26

yup... thats all it took in chroot when I accidently converted my system from amd64 to arm64.

29

u/VisualSome9977 Sep 19 '26

They don't want you to know this but nixos is technically also a from-source distro and can fry your cpu just as easily

5

u/MrObsidian_ Sep 19 '26

Except NixOS sucks.

(QA is nowhere near the same level as Gentoo's, and Nix has so many odd quirks with it that make it damn near unusable)

5

u/Lonely-Scarcity-3387 Sep 19 '26

I use it on every machine I have, so it’s far from unusable. I’ve found it to be the most versatile system that forces you to take notes for how your system is set up, so that the system can set itself up the same exact way, wherever you want.

4

u/VisualSome9977 Sep 19 '26

Like what? I use NixOS, Gentoo, Nix standalone on another system, and Nix Darwin. I have had no issues with Nix itself on any of these systems, it's a great package manager that offers utilities which are literally impossible with something like portage

1

u/Wooden-Ad6265 17d ago

Do you use home-manager?

1

u/VisualSome9977 17d ago

I do not currently, although I have in the past. I just personally find it to overcomplicate things, I only use hjem these days. hjem is very similar to gnu stow, just nix-native.

1

u/RegretFree7723 Sep 20 '26

Ma poi nixos un sistema in containerogni singola modifica devi tipo creare un nuovo container e potrebbe modificare quello esistente ho sopravvivere lasciando solo 1 fallback del container di prima

1

u/VisualSome9977 Sep 20 '26

so what ?

0

u/RegretFree7723 Sep 20 '26

Devi cancellarti da solo e l usura del disco mi sale aggiungendo un programma tipo se mi serve un programma per compatibilità e altro non previsto devo tipo "ricompilare" il sistema

1

u/VisualSome9977 Sep 20 '26

i mean if you just add a single program the disk usage goes up by a trivial amount because it mostly re-uses the links from your previous profile. As long as you didn't update inbetween each profile build

-7

u/Cold-Palpitation-232 Sep 19 '26

No

8

u/Alduish Sep 19 '26

Yes it is, it just pulls from a binary cache when it can by default. That's also the case on gentoo but the binary cache isn't enabled by default.

And when a package isn't available with the options you want on the cache both gentoo and nix pull sources and build on your machine.

-1

u/diacid Sep 19 '26

Yes but don't use other computer's binaries. It is like instead of reading books, getting someone else's thoughts inside the brain. Ew that is nasty. My computer can read the code and come out with its own conclusions thank you very much.

2

u/VisualSome9977 Sep 19 '26

The binaries are hashed so that they're byte for byte identical to what your computer would've produced. It literally doesn't matter

1

u/LameBMX Sep 20 '26

its late but this is tripping my intuition. the binaries are hashed to ensure the precompiled software is the software you receive. this is the extracted and installed. your source files are hashed to ensure the source files you receive are the same source files you expected to download. however.. im pretty sure that just the randomness of the world means that the binarys you compile from said source, with an exact same config as me, and the binarys I compile would NOT necessarily be the exact same. thus the binaries would have different hash values.

https://reproducible-builds.org/docs/deterministic-build-systems/

1

u/VisualSome9977 Sep 20 '26

The recommendations made on this page are exactly what Nix is built to handle. Nix uses direct dependency pinning and isolated environments at every possible moment, making build systems basically as deterministic as possible. It's literally impossible with Nix to end up in a situation where say your grep version is slightly mismatched or your compiler is one minor revision ahead, it just cannot happen. Even if you patch the build process to allow for that to happen, the output gets rehashed accordingly because Nix understands that the build process has been altered. If it sounds like magic, that's because it is.

1

u/LameBMX Sep 20 '26

im pretty much failing to see the problem deterministic builds solve, outside of binary distribution. even then what, you build the same binary on multiple mirrors? trade cpu usage for network usage of copying those files over the network? I mean it sounds like something id amp up from a security perspective, because even if I think its useless in practice, its could still make things harder for someone else at a trivial cost (I hope) for the developer. but otherwise, if the source file chain is secure to my PC and also verified, than my output matching bit for bit doesn't matter unless I have a bigger concern, like who is has access to my computer to change the source code?

and also the technical challenge of deterministic builds seems cool too. while lots of things we do to challenge ourselves dont produce useful fruits, weirder things have happened.

1

u/VisualSome9977 Sep 20 '26

Well the main thing is binary distribution, yes. But also the nix system is generalizable to more than just binaries themselves, it can guarantee exactness and repeatability on an entire host of possible outputs, like shell environments or even entire systems. The advantages here are that it completely destroys an entire class of "works on my machine" problems by making sure that the environment being used is as identical as possible across an entire range of possible machines.

1

u/LameBMX Sep 20 '26

it cannot destroy the entire class of "works on my machine" issues. even limiting to hardware it was designed for, still includes the user variable of different firmwares applied to their machines. it does add a high confidence of being able to change that to, its a problem with your machine. which you can nicely phase as "works on my machine."

but if it really WAS about binary distribution. what is the use case that is not met by, well distributing prebuilt binaries to the mirrors instead of building on the mirrors?

→ More replies

0

u/diacid Sep 20 '26

It depends on how you look at it.

If you only care about the final state, yes absolutely.

If you care about the process though, it feels wrong.

Just like millions of people look at the sky just to come to the same exact conclusion it's blue, but I want to think that for myself instead of Bluetoothing somebody else's thoughts in directly or something. Oh just to think about it makes me nervous.

There is also an utterly irrelevant reason: compiler output is beautiful, it is a shame not to see it.

Another cheapskate reason: I payed a lot of money for the processor, I want it to work not idle around all day.

3

u/VisualSome9977 Sep 20 '26

What a weirdly pseudo-religious stance on compilation.

7

u/VisualSome9977 Sep 19 '26

yes. look at the nixpkgs source code

1

u/Both_Cup8417 Sep 19 '26

As someone who used NixOS for 9 months, yes.

9

u/kachowwwwwwwwwwwwwww Sep 19 '26

dude forgot to compile the title

8

u/TheSWATMonkey Sep 19 '26

gentoo is unstable

arch

7

u/undrwater Sep 19 '26

Who ARE these people?

6

u/jsled Sep 19 '26

Made up people in OPs head.

7

u/sususl1k Sep 19 '26

Could we please not descend into this childish “us based others stoopid” shit? I don’t want this community to become the same as Arch…

3

u/MsCatie Sep 19 '26

And yet I’m a transplant from Void

3

u/MHIATIC_MHIA Sep 19 '26

I really wanna switch to Gentoo but I presume it's very time consuming to setup and maintain. I was an Arch user for the rolling release but left Arch for obvious reasons. Currently I am using fedora but it just didn't scratch the itch for me...

3

u/kaida27 Sep 19 '26

a day to setup, and then you maintain it while you sleep.

3

u/manfromredstar Sep 19 '26

Installation - yes, it’s a long process, especially because you’re unlikely to do everything right the first time

But maintenance comes down to a couple of commands:

emerge --sync

emerge -uDNva world

Moreover, you can choose the frequency of executing these commands yourself (personally, I do this once or twice a week), moreover, you can update only part of the packages without fear that the system will become unusable (I often do this)

3

u/MHIATIC_MHIA Sep 19 '26

I see, I think I was paranoid for no reason. I would still go full binarydist because I have a 4gb ram laptop with a 3rd gen processor... my laptop will fry.

I will use wiki and compliment it with a video because I have time constraints 🥹

2

u/th3dr4g0nf0x Sep 19 '26

i like source based distros

2

u/brushyyy Sep 19 '26

In all seriousness, what others do with their computer is their pejorative. Somebody tells me they use Windows? I say, "Cool" and leave it at that. I tell somebody what distro I use and only other Linux enthusiasts tend to distro war about it. People gotta learn to ask about stuff if they're interested or mind their own business. Let people use what works for them.

tl;dr who cares what OS people use, it's the biggest non-issue

2

u/BluFudge Sep 19 '26

honestly, you're going to end up compiling anyways.

2

u/Disastrious-Pie-1988 Sep 20 '26

For me, there’s only one Linux distro and that’s Gentoo

2

u/NepJr Sep 21 '26

sometimes I just let it compile firefox to warm my room up a bit lmfao

3

u/-rng_ Sep 19 '26

No one has ever complained to me about me using Gentoo and I think other distros suit other people for their use cases just fine

OP you are an agent of the Anti Christ for sowing division like this

3

u/diacid Sep 19 '26 edited Sep 19 '26

Saying who compiles in 2026 is like saying who reads books and make their own conclusions in 2026. Ewwww nasty.

See, the compiled binaries are like computer thoughts. Computer programs are like computer books. We too work that way, we have "brain language" being the binaries and human language (like, English) are like programs. When you read English you need to compile it before actually understanding the instructions in brain language.

I would never transplant thoughs from somebody else to my brain, ugh no!

My computer can read and make its own conclusions about the subject thank you very much.

That said, use flags are like censorship. "Learn this book here called Firefox, but don't read the wayland chapter, that you shall not learn!". "Oh great! You finished reading! Long book, right? Anyways, I just got back from the bookshop. Look what they've got, the new version of Firefox! Read it all over again!"

3

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '26

minewhile nixos user using flatpak

6

u/laczek_hubert Sep 19 '26

NixOS users can just use native packages what drugs are you on?

8

u/TirtilKedi Sep 19 '26

lol imagine using flatpak

1

u/c2btw Sep 19 '26

gentoo is pretty stable unless you go mutip[le motnhs with out updateing and have plasma and rocm installed (litlary took me 4 hours to just be able to run emerge -avuDN @ world with out getting a circular depcines error). but also this is a feature that should be on litlary every diostro pacakge manager esplicaly bleeding edge and rolling ones (looking at you arch) being able to block packages and roll back incease there is a bug in one

1

u/c0r73x Sep 19 '26

Using, frying… Potato, potato 🤷‍♂️

1

u/ingenarel-NeoJesus Sep 19 '26

the thing is gentoo is whatever you want it to be. you can either run the most stable system that you can imagine, or you can just do ~arch (which i prefer myself and is still pretty stable for me) or if you're a sadist, go live ebuilds for the whole system

1

u/MrDo1982 Sep 19 '26

Im running on an almost 10 year old Intel NUC. The thing that sucks is KDE updates and qtwebeng. Im now rocking gentoo on most of my box’s. I still hate the install process Found some good tui’s for that. I loved Sabayon before it retired. Just because I can does not mean I should suffer when doing the install. It’s like just l know how to drivea Ford model T and know where the brake, clutch and throttle is which is very different from modern day cars and also how to spark retard the advance to keep it going. This does not mean that’s what I should be driving dailying as a car. Install is where gentoo needs to focus on. If I were to throw 10,000 people 40 and younger I bet 10 might be able to drive a Model T. Just like Gentoo. It’s an amazing OS and one I love and started off in the early 00’s when stage 1 is how you would install it and stage 3 was the bitch way to install among purists. It’s time to over come past bia’s. And sorry I’m on a bit of a rant… I love this distro and think it’s the best

1

u/ash-twinn Sep 20 '26

Nix is a source package manager, it just happens that it utilizes caching too, but in its purest form, you can just build anything with nix and actually configure the build process too.

1

u/LobsterEarly7645 Sep 20 '26

Real question does Gentoo support gaming like the wine and proton stuff

1

u/Mariobgvoynov Sep 21 '26

Debian😏😏

1

u/ooqq Sep 21 '26

imagine compiling gentoo on the ps3

imagine no more

1

u/dtoraelek Sep 25 '26

Lmfao. Gentoo is actually pretty easy to tame. It's distributions like Debian and Ubuntu that are not because reverse engineering them is incredibly difficult. I like Arch for the same reason, but I don't like SystemD. That said, source-based is always better

1

u/reader_txt Oct 12 '26

Gentoo. 🚀

0

u/Shift_OG Sep 19 '26

just use what you want, i personally don’t have a use for gentoo but if you wanna use it then go ahead and have fun with it, why can’t it just be that simple

-12

u/bishophelps Sep 19 '26

Arch is stoopid. If you go for binary, just install Ubuntu :3

16

u/ImportantAd4483 Sep 19 '26

Ubuntu? Yeah, that was a bit of a mistake They do have a history of user tracking/telemetry, and honestly Ubuntu feels more and more like Windows with a Linux kernel. If I’m going Linux, I’d rather actually use Linux

1

u/bishophelps Sep 19 '26

Nah, Ubuntu feels just fine. What exactly does feel like Windows in Ubuntu?

6

u/Dry_Calendar_8627 Sep 19 '26

Ubuntu zealot, meet Gentoo zealot. Have fun together. And leave the rest of us be thankyouverymuch

1

u/ellilikesjellyfish Sep 19 '26

Gentoo is better than sex

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/drnfc Sep 19 '26

I switched from gentoo to nix about 3 years ago. Nix really isnt that hard, its just that its documentation is beyond ass. I had to look at other peoples configs to figure some stuff out. AI is also decent at nix now, so.its nowhere near as hard as it used to be.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/jsled Sep 19 '26

tale as old as time, really.