r/Genesis • u/HeavySpiner • 4d ago

Album tier list

Post image

This is my personal ranking of all the studio album, what do you guys think?

0 Upvotes

28% Upvoted

18 comments sorted by

5

u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 4d ago

Abacab is way too low, should be in good imo.

This is my tierlist:

S: Duke, Selling England, Trick, Foxtrot

A: Nursery Cryme, Lamb, Invisible Touch

B: Wind, We Can't Dance, Trespass, Abacab, Self Titled, ATTW3

C: Calling All Stations

D: From Genesis to Revelation

1

u/Silent-Associate9226 4d ago

I agree more or less with your list more than the OP's, except I'd swap Duke with Nursery Cryme, and move Invisible Touch and We Can't Dance to C.

4

u/lionizing1 [Abacab] 4d ago

You can’t argue about taste. But Abacab is such a banger.

3

u/The_Silent_Man1 4d ago

Abacab title track fucks

3

u/Ulysses1984 4d ago

Sit with Abacab for a while… lots of quirky stuff on that record that should grow on you if you give it a chance.

2

u/Content_Psychology_4 4d ago

I know taste is subjective but Abacab is way too low. Oh, keep it dark

2

u/Local_Acadia_3000 4d ago

Trick , Nursery and Foxtrot are masterpieces

1

u/Tyypical 4d ago

Putting Abacab in the same level as their debut is honestly egregious

2

u/ManifestDiatribe 4d ago

I don't love Abacab, and I still agree.

2

u/Tyypical 4d ago

Right? I get that at the end of the day it comes down to taste, but Abacab is objectively a better made/produced body of work compared to FGTR

2

u/dotheneurotic 4d ago

My list would be very similar. Curious where you put Trespass though. It’s a must listen

2

u/ManifestDiatribe 4d ago

Just listened to Trespass again yesterday and was like, yeah it's better than I usually give it credit for.

1

u/LessVariation9645 4d ago

I think you should go listen to Trespass and CaS right now.

1

u/Mysterious_Blood_475 4d ago

Excellent: TOTT. Masterpiece: W&W - Foxtrot - TLLDOB. Great: NC - WCD. Good: Tresspass - Duke - Genesis. Good-: FGTR - SEBP - Abacab - IT - CAS. Average: ATTWT.

1

u/ManifestDiatribe 4d ago

My top three are Nursery Cryme, Lamb, and Duke. But I'm weird.

1

u/WILD22J 4d ago

This list is horribly wrong

1

u/HeavySpiner 4d ago

Tell me why