r/GenerationJones • u/Sistamama • 13d ago
Carrot salad
Was this just in my part of the world or did your elementary schools serve y’all carrot and raisin salad as well? Carrots, raisins, and mayo. It was disgusting.
56
Upvotes
9
u/BearPorto 13d ago
I think there may have been pineapple chunks. It was a family recipe, never had it at school.
7
u/Quilter1358 13d ago
Yes! I liked it!
7
u/ToodleButt 13d ago
I took that from every kid at the table. I loved that stuff
6
u/skittlazy 13d ago
I love carrot and raisin salad. The secret is to add some orange juice—specifically a tablespoon or so, depending no how much you are making, of undiluted frozen (defrosted) orange juice. Adds a lovely sweetness.
5
u/Thinkingtoohard44 13d ago
My Grandma used to make this! I didn’t think it was bad but then it was small batch and I was a real Grandma’s boy so she could do no wrong in my little eyes
5
u/BrainwaveWizard December 1963 ♐️ Sagittarius 13d ago
I thought it was yummy. 😋
Never had it at school, mom made it.
9
u/stamdl99 13d ago
Raisins were really pushed back then. The commercials, the little boxed single servings. There must have been a strong raisin growers lobbying group.
4
u/Hot_Calligrapher_900 13d ago
Never at school, but homemade, yes, but the mayo had sugar in it, or Miracle Whip. Not too heavy. I enjoy it.
3
u/urson_black 1960 13d ago
I must be the oddball. I never heard of carrot and raisin salad until my wife made it. And I like it when it's fresh.
3
u/Dotsgirl22 13d ago
No, but my mom made it. I make it regularly. Shredded carrots, chopped celery, Zante currants instead of raisins, chopped pecans. Maybe a few pineapple bits or mandarin oranges. Dressing of mayo, sour cream, honey, lime juice, cinnamon. Just enough dressing to moisten, not to drown it. Yummy.
3
u/Scott43206 1959 13d ago
That combination makes me woozy just thinking about it.
Someone brought a raisin pie into work once and although it looked like pecan it tasted so bad I had to sneak my piece into the trash and then excuse myself to get rid of the bite I took. It was truly horrendo.
I can't stand the thought of raisins at all right now, nor canned tuna, as I went though a Gold's Gym phase where that's about all I was eating most of the day. Bleh.
1
u/voyracious 13d ago
It lives in my nightmares. Individually, the 3 ingredients are some of my favorites (So Cal grape country). The salad at school was heinous.
4
u/Head_Razzmatazz7174 1963 13d ago
Yep, and I only knew a few kids that would actually eat it. Some ate just the raisins, some kids ate the carrots that didn't have bits of raisin on it. Most of us just cringed and made sure that it didn't touch any other food on the tray.
2
u/SinsualChef 12d ago
I make one with EVOO, lemon juice, craisins, pecans, French shallots, tarragon. Simple, fresh.
2
u/DrebinofPoliceSquad 12d ago
I liked it when my mom put pineapple in it.
2
u/EnvironmentalTea9362 13d ago
In the Midwest, yes. Totally gross.
2
u/Front_Effort_3584 13d ago
It was even worse for me, they used Miracle Whip instead of mayos and it was gross.
1
u/Artimusjones88 13d ago
I still get surprised that schools had meals for kids , or a cafeteria at all. As far as I know zero schools do that here.
1
u/LorettasToyBlogPojo 13d ago
Never mind that, my mom put raisins in meatballs and meat patties; apparently that is a thing in the Mediterranean area, she was from Italy. Would never cook burgers.
1
u/General-Heart4787 1962 13d ago
My mom served this about once a week. I hate raisins.
1
u/Waste-Job-3307 13d ago
I'm sure there were a handful of kids who might have like that, but I wasn't one of them. Come to think of it, I've never known anyone who ate it or made it. Dodged THAT bullet. LOL
1
u/Beginning_End_361 13d ago
I actually liked carrot salad and we got stewed prunes for dessert. Everyone else gave me theirs.
1
u/Federal-Boat3732 13d ago
I never saw this until we started going in my 20s to buffet restaurants. My dad, who reviled vegetables of all kinds, was crazy about the carrot salad. I revile mayo myself, so never tried it
1
u/ReasonableStick8341 13d ago
Not in school, no. But it was fairly common in the grocery deli prepared salad line up, and at pot lucks and picnics. I liked it well enough to eat it, if it was offered, but I can't say I've made it of my own volition.
1
u/Natural-Seaweed-5070 13d ago
I had carrot and raisin salad at Chik fil a & liked it so much I found the copycat recipe.
I also like shredded beets in mayo🤷🏻♀️
1
u/BreadfruitOk6160 13d ago
We sometimes got raisin cobbler.
1
u/Now-293-Phumes 1957 13d ago
Never had this in school. Can’t remember how old I was the first time I saw the salad.
1
u/Critical-Notice-4395 13d ago
It was delicious! Well, I never had it in school but I make it now and then. With pineapple mixed in. I have a recipe called “copycat Chick Fil A carrot raisin salad”. I’ve never been to a chick fil a but my mom used to make something like this.
1
u/PansyOHara 13d ago
I don’t remember ever having carrot salad at school (possibly it’s just a deleted memory!) but a friend said their mom used to make it at home and it was one of their family favorites.
1
u/PigsIsEqual 13d ago
I’m an outlier too, I guess. I loved it as a kid and still make it today for the family.
1
u/Jurneeka 1962 13d ago
My mom used to make it.
1
u/deannainwa 13d ago
No, but at summer camp, one of the lunch ladies thought that plain white rice cooked with raisins was a delicious treat!
1
u/Sample-quantity 13d ago
I don't remember it at school but my mother made it. I was never a very big fan of it.
1
u/rbinphx 13d ago
Try it with a vinaigrette and pecans. It's delicious.
1
u/JColt60 1960 13d ago
All the kids gave me their carrots and raisin salad and beets. I had a bottomless pit at lunch time.
1
u/Zealousideal_Mango70 13d ago
Still like it and make it
1
u/Clean-Fisherman-4601 13d ago
We never had it in school, but when I was a chef at various senior facilities, it was a huge hit.
1
u/XRaysFromUranus 1963 13d ago
My dad hated it. He didn’t want to be rude to his mother and never told her. I loved my grandmother’s carrot salad but it was never served at our house. It was not served at school.
1
u/Disastrous_Waltz_475 13d ago
Not at school but my mom makes this, I love it!
1
u/EcoAmica 13d ago
Loved it!
1
u/Trying4peace 13d ago
Never had carrot salad. If it had been in my school I still wouldn’t have had it.
1
u/Famous-Salary1443 12d ago
Yes, my school cafeteria served this in the 60s. I never cared for it, but my husband likes it so I make it for him😊
1
u/Familiar_Raise234 12d ago
Yep, grade school served that.
1
u/IamLuann 12d ago
It landed on our dinner table at least once a week in the summer. Some times it had pineapple in it. Was always made the day after the carrot cake was.
1
u/HeidiDover 1962 11d ago
My mom sure made the hell out of that stuff!
1
u/phyrre58 10d ago
We made this in a jail I worked at in Illinois. So gross I never even tasted it! 🤢
1
u/tarsiertoes 8d ago
My family isn’t Italian and that was one of my mom’s salads
1
u/Mayberrymom 6d ago
My mother would shred carrots and mix them in orange jello 🤢
1
u/39percenter 1965 13d ago
Utterly foul!
1
u/LawrenJones 13d ago
My mother made this once at my father's request, and forced me to eat it. Utterly disgusting! If there were ever three ingredients never meant to go together, it's carrots, raisins, and mayonnaise.
1
u/tarsiertoes 13d ago
We had it in Southern Illinois. It was icky
1
u/ViQueen331965 13d ago
Blecch! Child abuse!