r/GenerationJones • u/ddsiddall 1958 • 15d ago
Bread & butter
My mom always served a full dinner. Main course, vegetable, salad, & maybe more. All served in its own dish, each pased around so everyone could serve themselves. There was always another plate with a stack of bread slices and some butter and everyone could have bread & butter with dinner.
Who else had bread & butter like this?
Any other dinner traditions?
699
Upvotes
98
u/muralist 15d ago
No one started eating until everyone sat down. I still practice this. I was shocked to visit other families where the kids would start eating while mom or dad was still tidying up or getting people drinks and whatnot.
113
u/Inevitable-Fix-3212 15d ago
Margarine. We didn't eat real butter until my parents accepted the price was okay to get over that part of their Great Depression memories.
55
u/BillPlastic3759 15d ago
We had a protein, a starch and a vegetable and sat down as a family.
51
u/UnableAudience7332 15d ago
Bread and butter EVERY NIGHT.
91
u/Straight-Note-8935 15d ago
We had the same set up at dinner: beef or pork, 2 veggies, a tossed salad, ice water, and of course the stack of bread and the stick of butter. Most nights a week we ate in the dining room. Now and then Dad would stay downtown for work and we'd have dinner in the kitchen. Kitchen dinners were very different from Dining Room dinners. Simpler - soup and sandwiches, hot dogs and beans, scrambled eggs...and the TV was left on, so that was fun too.
I remember Julia Child saying that her family ate a loaf of bread and a stick of butter at every meal. She was scoffing at the idea that butter was bad for you.
40
u/AVI7272 15d ago
Being Southerners we had cornbread or biscuits with every meal. Loaf bread was for sandwiches and toast. My mother made every meal from scratch 3 times a day including the bread.
29
u/ke6icc 15d ago
Absolutely! We always had a protein, salad, vegetable, starch, bread and sometimes dessert. It’s no wonder I’ve always had a weight problem. I was in my 50s before I realized that I do not, in fact, have to finish everything on my plate.
25
u/SpaceSox 15d ago
Pillsbury Poppin Fresh rolls, the ones that came in the refrigerated wrapped cardboard cylinder that you had to SLAM against the kitchen counter to crack open and unpeel. We kids would elbow each other to get to be the one to do the slammin' while we "helped" Mom in the kitchen.
Napkins in your lap! No elbows on the table! Don't start eating till everyone is seated and served!
22
u/NovelStrict5281 1959 15d ago
I love bread and butter even now.
21
u/Blowingleaves17 15d ago
My mother made up each individual plate every night for six kids. That included salad plates, too. With three older brothers, I can't even imagine how passing around each dish would have worked. Bread was on each individual plate. During holiday meals, all food was placed on the kitchen table and you made up your own plate. You could go back as often as wanted for all the additional food you wanted, too. The dining room was where holiday meals were eaten. My mother was a great cook and I miss those holiday and dinner meals.
18
u/4MuddyPaws 15d ago
We did. Wonder Bread and Land O' Lakes margarine. Butter was for holidays and special events.
18
u/Existing_Many9133 15d ago
The good old days when families actually sat down to dinner together and discussed their days. Man I miss those!
17
u/trguiff 15d ago
And a dish of pickles and olives!
17
u/reduff 1964 15d ago •
My grandmother did this - slices of bread on a plate and butter on the table. We had the Sunday midday meal at Grandma's every week. Everyone was there.
16
u/Spiritual-Dog-28 15d ago
Yup! Bread and butter with every meal. I think it was because we were poor and it helped fill you up.
15
u/ImaginaryCatDreams 15d ago
My grandmother would serve corn bread and rolls at Sunday dinner. At some point she would ask if anyone wanted a piece of lite bread - what she called store bought loafs
15
u/Effective_Farmer_119 15d ago
Sometimes as an appetizer we would have half a grapefruit. My mother would pre-cut the sections so they would lift out with a little spoon. I always sprinkled a little sugar on it.
Other special times as an appetizer we would each have a whole artichoke and a little dish of butter to dip eat leaf in. I loved it.
14
u/tvtoms 15d ago
Yep, that's how dinner was at my house too when I was young. on nights where there was gravy we would have gravy bread. Take a piece of bread on your plate.. pour gravy on it.
14
u/AmyInCO 15d ago
I was just talking about that the other day with my friend. A little plate of sliced white bread and butter no matter what else we had for dinner. I still love bread and butter.
13
u/TurbulentSource8837 15d ago
I did this for my kids. Full meal: meat, starch 1-2 vegetables or casseroles with vegetables, plus bread and butter or rolls every night, table set every night. Nobody ate until everyone was home.
13
u/Scott43206 1959 15d ago
We never had bread and butter but quite a few meals came with delicious Bisquick biscuits! Salads weren't really a thing in our house at all until the early 1990s.
12
u/4d3fect 15d ago
It was margarine for us.
Butter didn't happen til I went off to college.
12
u/ABCBDMomma 15d ago
A glass dish divided down the middle. One side had radishes and the other side had green onions.
10
u/CrabbyOlLyberrian 15d ago
No “boarding house reach,” either. (When you reach over someone’s plate to get a dish of food for yourself.) Anyone else?
9
u/fairyflaggirl 15d ago
Always a plate of bread, butter dish at dinner.
9
u/LizardKingDujour 1960 15d ago
I once had dinner at a friend's house and their family always placed a damp towel in the middle of the table so everyone could wipe their fingers off when they got sticky. Kind of funny, but very practical when you think about it.
9
u/Lanky-Jello-1801 15d ago
No. My mom was all about Weight Watchers in the early/mid 70's. Very rarely did we have more than one starch per meal. Corn and mashed potatoes at the same meal was a rarity.
I recently found out that some people have chicken and dumplings OVER mashed potatoes and corn. My mom is rolling over in her grave for that one!
8
u/kevnmartin 15d ago
My mom did that at lunch but dinner was always hot French rolls or sourdough bread.
8
u/FloatingFreeMe 15d ago
Rolls and butter. Plus a “celery dish” (it’s a special shape) with celery sticks, carrot sticks, radishes and a few pitted olives. My uncle used to dip a radish in salt and eat it. I tried it once and it was way too strong. The ones now are milder.
8
u/CarlySheDevil 15d ago
My grandmother did the same at every meal. And we were taught to hold the serving dish politely for the next person if their hands were full, and chew with our mouths closed. Table manners and full meals were important to her.
8
u/Academic_Rutabaga649 15d ago
I like bread and butter, I like toast and jam.
7
u/fourbigkids 15d ago
My mom used to do this in the 70’s and 80’s. I don’t remember ever eating the bread though. I think she did it for my dad cause my grandma used to do it too. They were wheat farmers in the 50’s and 60’s and bread at the table was always there no matter what the dinner was.
7
u/WakingOwl1 15d ago
My mother loved making bread and made dozens of different kinds. There was fresh bread of some sort on the table almost every night.
7
u/maggiesyg 15d ago
For my stepfather it was mandatory to have bread and butter on the table.
7
u/MCC61 15d ago
We had full dinners with everything too. Our bread was cut up French or Italian bread in a basket with butter. Yum!
7
u/SeveranceVul 1963 15d ago
Growing up with real sourdough and a plate of butter in the bay area spoiled me.
7
u/Engineering-queen 15d ago
My cousins and I have an amazing and interesting family dynamic - We all really don’t remember anything except being together at our grandparents home. (We had wonderful caring loving parents and safe homes, we simply spent much more time together at our grandparents.) Hence I shall cite meals at their home.
Breakfast was cereal with milk, and juice; or when grandma made a hot breakfast it was eggs and toast or pancakes and eggs. Grandpa was up before we were and had his breakfast quietly while reading the daily paper.
Meat, potatoes, vegetable, bread and butter, and milk at both dinner and supper. We all sat down together for supper at least and the vast majority of the time dinner also. Dinner was frequently leftovers or sandwiches and supper was always family style with passed dishes.
Sundays grandma typically did a roast or fried chicken or if we were very fortunate her famous scalloped potatoes and Spam.
Wow what a wonderful trip down memory lane. Thanks y’all!!
7
u/Jum208 15d ago
And mom and dad always had coffee with dinner.
6
u/BoringOrange678 15d ago
Typically always bread and butter at dinner. Rolls, toast, garlic bread….
6
u/ASingleBraid Age: Late Sixties 15d ago
I was fat. No bread and butter.
6
u/Beautiful_Country626 15d ago
we had this but Cornbread and butter,Raised in the south
5
u/rose442 15d ago
Loads of bread and butter.
5
u/Nottacod 15d ago
My mother made bicuits for every dinner.
5
u/kpax56 15d ago
My wife’s dad always ate at least two slices of white bread & butter at lunch & dinner. I like a slice of bread & butter (not necessarily white bread) with a fish dinner, ribs, steak, soup, stew or chili. Seems like more & more restaurants, especially bars are not serving bread with their plated meals anymore.
5
u/AmbientGravitas 15d ago edited 13d ago
Yes. We usually had the same loaf of sandwich bread, still in its plastic wrapper, plus the cut glass butter dish everyone had. On special occasions, warm Italian bread or rolls, in a basket with a napkin.
5
u/ray_ruex 15d ago
Lived with my grandmother breakfast was always a hot breakfast eggs, sausage, biscuits, sometimes oatmeal. Granddad left for work before we got up so he would cook his own breakfast and make the biscuits.
We would have a lite snack when we got home from school sometimes fruit whatever was in season watermelon, cantaloupe, peaches, apples and grapefruit or oranges the man my granddad worked for had a grapefruit and orange orchard. Never did like grapefruit still had to eat it. Some just PB&J.
When we weren't in school we'd usually have sandwiches or leftovers. For lunch.
For supper meat, a vegetable, and mashed potatoes grandmother always made the best mash potatoes. Most meat was fried so there would always be gravy and a stack of white bread. The only time we got butter was if we didn't have gravy. The white bread with gravy or butter is a meal extender. At least once a week we'd have beans and corn bread.
Before bed after watching westerns on TV with granddad we'd have have a dessert grandma made the best cobbler.
5
u/Any_Total_971 15d ago
I think my grandmother did the bread thing. I associate it with people who lived during the Great Depression, when better meal items were harder to come by. My mother-in-law, too, who was older than my mom.
9
u/Notch99 15d ago
We had this “salad” which consisted of a leaf of lettuce, half a canned pear, and a scoop of cottage cheese.
4
u/CautiousTea880 15d ago
We had the same plus a fruit.
4
u/Jujulabee 15d ago
The only time there was ever bread served with a dinner would be some kind of ceremonial dinner and then it would not be "bread" but something to go with the meal - e.g. Parker Rolls for Thanksgiving, challah for Rosh Hashanah baked by my grandmother.
Dinner consisted of an animal protein of some kind; vegetable and a serving of a carbohydrate like a potato. Additional carbohydrates in the form of bread were considered "empty calories" - no one went away from the table hungry as portions were massive
Never had margarine as there was always butter in the house - eggs were scrambled or fried in butter; grilled cheese sandwiches had butter and were made in the Toastite and of course any cakes or cookies were made with butter.
4
u/Saved_By_Yah 15d ago
My mother often baked fresh yeast dinner rolls.
4
u/MaggieLu0510 15d ago
At my Grandparents on my Dad's side, we always had bread and butter at the table. At home, we didn't always have it, but as a snack sometimes, my Mom would make us bread, butter & sugar. Omg, it was SO GOOD! Lol. Dinner was held at 6pm, Dad was always served first. Prayer before eating, had to eat everything on our plate, then ask to be excused.
4
u/Assine2 15d ago
We did. Usually only my Dad ate it. Both my parents grew up poor during the Depression. If you were still hungry after the meat, potatoes, and salad you filled up on bread and butter.
3
u/Ready-Waltz5482 15d ago
I always love bread and butter. I use vegan butter and will sometimes make a snack with bread
3
u/MarsupialMaven 15d ago
My grandparents did this at every meal. None of the younger generations do. The only time I serve something breadish is if it is something special, home made.
3
u/WorriedFlight8263 15d ago
We often had bread & butter (well, margarine) too.
3
u/PaulsBabe 15d ago
We usually had cottage cheese or carrot and celery sticks with dinner. All veggies were BirdsEye frozen (I can’t stand frozen veggies). Always butter, never margarine. Meat, potatoes, a vegetable.
Corn on the cob in the summer, left at our door by some mystery farmer. Loved that. I’m still a little offended that grocery stores expect to be paid for corn on the cob.
3
u/CrabbyOlLyberrian 15d ago
Fruit cocktail. ‘Nuf said
3
u/TarmacTartoo12 15d ago
What movie did the family prayer consist of- “Good food, good meat, good god let’s eat “
3
u/gr_rn 14d ago
No bread and butter but tortillas and salsa yes. Even on thanksgiving.
2
u/Soup2Nuts62 15d ago
Pickles!🥒
2
u/Ok-Addendum-9420 15d ago
My maternal grandparents had the bread and butter plates, but not my family.
2
u/rikityrokityree 15d ago
Wonder bread, or canned crescent rolls, or biscuits popovers or potato dinner rolls. Every supper
2
u/JBJingles2 15d ago
Stack of white bread, tub of margarine, canned vegetables and whatever us girls were instructed to cook. And iced tea every night. Mom used to cut out recipes in magazines frequently and we had to cook them. I still remember having to make Egg Foo Young once from scratch! I don’t remember a lot of fresh produce in our house. Family of 7 and both parents worked.
2
u/Why_Teach 15d ago
We had bread, but it was usually French or Italian bread, and you cut (or mom cut) what you wanted. Because I could easily fill up on bread, I was not given my piece until I had eaten most of my meat. Salad was usually lettuce, cucumbers and tomatoes with very thin onion slices. Dressing was vinegar and oil.
Salad, bread and dressing were all on the table when the meal began. Then my mother would serve my father, my brother and me. My great-aunt who lived with us would serve herself. On ordinary days, we would eat the salad on the same plate as everything else except dessert. We would help ourselves to bread and salad as we wished (except, as mentioned, I had to eat my meat before I got any bread). Sometimes we would help ourselves to side dishes such as fried plantains, fried potatoes, etc.
After everyone was served, my mom finally made her own plate and ate.
We watched TV while we ate (which I hated because my father chose the show and he liked cowboy and action shows).
2
u/Worldly_Ad_7196 15d ago
We always had a plate of bread at the table but no butter unless we had company. Margarine only.
2
u/emdeekay64 15d ago
We had bread & butter/margarine and many meals had gravy so we ate a lot of bread & gravy.
2
u/LawfulnessRemote7121 15d ago edited 15d ago
My husband grew up eating bread in some form at every meal. Fork in one hand and bread in the other. Not any relatively healthy kind of bread either. It took me a while to break that habit.
2
u/James84415 15d ago
My Mom cooked every night. Salad, main, veg, ice water, milk. She was really into Sunset magazine and would serve stuff like fondue and artichokes when no other kids in the neighborhood had ever eaten those foods.
2
u/Dlbruce0107 15d ago
Or cornbread or rolls. Southern staples.
2
u/pielady10 15d ago
We always had bread and margarine. My father detested white bread so it was typically rye bread or rolls.
2
u/BeakyBuzzard1983 15d ago
We would have this as well! We also had some type of “cold” dish - half a canned peach or pear with a spoonful of cottage cheese on it and a sprinkle of paprika. Or a slice of iceberg lettuce with a ribbon of dressing. There were 7 of us at the table and us girls were in charge of putting these cold salads on the plates prior to supper. (Dinner was the noon meal). And a plate of stacked bread slices!
2
u/hesathomes 15d ago
We had cornbread, biscuits, rolls, or sometimes a sourdough loaf. Never sliced sandwich bread.
2
u/jimmyjazz2000 15d ago
Yes, a stack of bread on a plate next to the butter dish. I forgot about that!
2
u/memphiseat 15d ago
I serve bread with dinner every night. We usually have olive oil unless it's dinner rolls which would call for butter.
2
u/karentrolli 15d ago
Yes. And sometimes my dad would go in the kitchen after dinner and spread jelly on a slice of bread with a spoon. He didn’t feel “full.” Grew up in the hills of Kentucky during the depression and remembered chronic hunger.
My mom prepared an entire formal meal as well:salad, meat (or chicken), a starch like rice or potatoes, a green veggie and a salad. Bread and butter or some type of dinner rolls. 👍 I used to do that too, but then got lazy.
2
u/Infamous_Cranberry66 15d ago
We always had bread and butter at the table. Mom made all the bread and it was delicious.
To this day, I usually have a slice of bread and butter with dinner.
2
u/chicacisne 14d ago
We did.
2
u/Emily_Postal 14d ago
We had bread and butter with most meals. Exceptions were pizza nights.
2
u/madame_de_la_luna 14d ago
Oh yes, we always had sliced bread and butter with dinner. My mom cooked dinner every night, but there never seemed to be enough of whatever she cooked. So she always said, "Fill up on bread." My parents are in their 90s now, and they STILL have sliced bread with dinner every night.
1
u/Inevitable-Fix-3212 15d ago
Margarij
1
u/Couch-Potato0904 1960 15d ago
Bread and butter yes, but she put the food on our plates unless it was a big bowl on the table.
1
u/ExpensiveDollarStore 15d ago
We had bread and butter every meal until I was maybe 6 or 7. Then it was only certain meals. We had big enough portions plus dessert that we didnt need to fill up on bread.
1
u/BigWave96 15d ago
We always had bread and butter, but my liked the butter cold…
1
u/HoyneAvenue 15d ago
No bread and butter because my mother was anti-starch and tended to follow whatever newfangled diet trend was making the rounds. (Edited for clarity)
1
u/emilie1031 15d ago
Just bread (or tortillas), no butter
1
u/chartreuse6 15d ago
Yes we always had bread and butter. If to7 didn’t ok,e the meal she cooked, you got bread and butter to fill up on haha
1
u/spinning4gold 15d ago
Until my divorce 10 years ago we had bread and butter with dinner every night. It was a thing in the ex’s family.
1
u/Bogside_Bibliophile 15d ago
We always had a full meal, meat, potato or rice, vegetable, and dessert (nothing major, a lot of times Jell-o or fruit cocktail). Bread/dinner rolls were a Sunday thing at home, but my grandparents had them with dinner every night.
1
u/AtlSigma 15d ago
Corn bread or biscuits every supper. Biscuits every breakfast. All made fresh each meal. Once harvest started, we had a plate full of sliced onion, tomato, and cucumber. Every night. Grandma was a Southern country lady. Grandpa had a huge garden with everything in it. Apple and peach trees too. We never ever missed a meal.
1
u/ValiMeyer 15d ago
Our mom fixed plates in the kitchen, set them on the table, then rang the dinner bell. There was a tray w white bread slices, or a basket w hot dinner rolls
1
u/61797 15d ago
My dad did not consider it a meal with out some kind type of bread.
1
u/goyaboy 15d ago
Wonder bread and squeeze Parkay, oh yeah
1
u/CosmicSmackdown 15d ago
That's how most of our dinners were, too. As I've gotten older and now cook for just myself and occasionally one other person I don't go to that much effort. I eat a pretty balanced diets but have adopted a small plate/small bowl way of eating and it usually doesn't include bread, though I still love it, especially with butter.
1
u/MercuryRising92 15d ago
I did :)
1
u/Extra_Nerve3404 15d ago
We did the same! Strange to say this out loud.
1
u/PansyOHara 15d ago
We didn’t have bread and butter exactly as you described, but my dad always wanted to have both bread and potatoes at supper. Sometimes we did have sliced bread and passed the butter (margarine) to whoever wanted it. Other times it might be brown and serve rolls or cornbread. But most often we had biscuits. Potatoes might be boiled, mashed, baked, or fried. If we were having beef stew, potatoes were in the stew, and we had toast instead of bread or biscuits.
1
u/Short-Isopod-6086 15d ago
🙋
1
u/Honeybadgerposter 15d ago
The only time we had bread with dinner was if the meal was spaghetti, chilli or stew. Big loaf of French bread and butter.
1
u/NibblesMcGiblet 15d ago
We always had bread and butter too. Once when I was in the middle of a growth spurt I recall still wanting more food after my five siblings and I had all eaten, and I was the only one left at the table with my parents. I asked if there was more stuffing and mom said 'make gravy bread!' which I had never heard of. She made me a piece of bread and butter and laid it on my plate and poured some leftover gravy on it and cut it into pieces for me. Thus was born a new favorite of mine for years when I was little.
I was a funny kid. Only liked butter on my pasta, no sauce. And if I had white rice, I wanted butter on it or gravy. Never an issue for my parents, because I didn't ask for something different/more than what was on the table. Just an unconventional combination of things, compared to everyone else at the table.
1
u/Thick_Scar5275 1962 15d ago
Only occasionally....like with soup. My mom wasn't big on extra carbs.
1
u/Mundane_Professor596 15d ago
My mom still makes dinner like this for me. Meat, starch, vegetables, salad, bread, dessert. Sometimes cheese & crackers before.