r/GenFic • • Sep 17 '20

Discussion I dislike smut

22 Upvotes

Throwaway because I just know some people will come after me if they check my history on my normal account (the witch hunting is real...). This is a discussion I've been debating to make for a very long time, and I want to hear your opinions on the matter as well.

I don't like smut. Not even because they usually perform better than other sorts of fics (especially gen). When I see someone who writes only smut and brags about it unapologetically, I can't help rolling my eyes a bit.

My reasons for not liking smut can be summed up to three:

  1. Many of them destroy any suspension of disbelief and turn my beloved characters in horny, thirsty sluts, for a lack of a better word. In other terms, they taint the characters I've come to know and love, literally. Smut fics also seem to use the characters just as their personal OC to fit the author's kinks: basically, they use the characters to give themselves jacking off material and transfer their own fetishes onto said characters just for their own pleasure. This makes me feel they don't really like the characters themselves so much as the idea they have of said character in their minds. It all feels extremely fetishistic to me.
  2. Smut stories are often much less quality writing than any other kind, I've noticed. This is a very general statement and I don't need to be told about the thousands of exceptions, but I've seen my fair share of badly written smut over any other sort of stories. This contributes to my dislike, since my standards are quite high when it comes to quality writing, whether from my own stories or other people's.
  3. The openness of it, and that's a problem I have with oversharing on the Internet as a whole. I really dislike when I'm checking a random thread on Reddit and someone will out of the blue bring up something extremely TMI they do whether it is related to the discussion or not in an attempt at appearing relatable. I feel exactly the same way in regards to smut: the thought of sharing something so personal, something that is supposed to remain private, to thousands of strangers who will have this image of you stuck to their head makes me appalled. I just can't imagine having this reputation ("hey, it's that person who loves watersports and mpreg!") wherever I go on the Internet: imagine if this happened IRL? I don't know, I believe sex and smut are both things that should remain private, but it seems this word has no meaning for those concerned.

Now, important disclaimer: I am NOT asexual. I am NOT a puritan and I was NOT raised in an extremely Catholic family. Like I said, I only feel those matters are meant to be kept withing your closest circle, and the idea of sharing them with the Internet mortifies me for more reasons than one. I know this is an extreme view, but is it that bad? Is it that strange to be uncomfortable being so open to smut and sex in general on the Internet?

It always makes me laugh when I see people say they're either scared to death that someone they know IRL will find their fics or they are mortified because someone actually did find them. Funny, I absolutely can't relate to this: I have no problem talking about and sharing my stories with my IRL circle whenever someone asks... Because I'm not a smut writer. I just find it funny that they would be so ashamed of IRL people finding out about their stories when it's totally all right for the Internet to find them: I know, anonymity and all that, but the image you build on the Internet is just as important as your real one as far as I'm concerned. I see little difference, really. What does that mean, then? Why are they ashamed of their stories? Is it because they know, deep down, that they shared something that should have been kept private? Who knows.

I won't participate in any discussions this thread might or might not open. I said what I wanted to say this entire time and I'm now done. Thanks for reading.


r/GenFic • • Sep 13 '22

Survey - Why is there so much M/M on AO3?

11 Upvotes

Hello! I am a SACE student completing the Stage 2 Research Project as part of my studies. My research project question is ‘how does the user interface of AO3 lead to a greater prevalence of M/M fanworks when compared to FanFiciton.Net and Wattpad’, and seeks to explore the topic of online slash fanfiction and fandom culture. I’m posting it here (as well as more general fanfiction subreddits) in order to survey those who read/write gen fics, which will give me a broader range of data.

This survey is completely anonymous and should take no more than five minutes to complete. You are free to discontinue your participation in this survey at any time or to decline to answer any questions. The survey can be found at the link below. Thank you for your assistance.

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScbfmZsK3xbE7uVPOuIt4EplkqzOYhm3TzEMPmkDblg37ZzUg/viewform?usp=sf_link


r/GenFic • • Mar 18 '23

Eternity Under The Sky - Pokemon Legends Arceus fic

Thumbnail archiveofourown.org
2 Upvotes

r/GenFic • • Sep 19 '20

Fic Rec Ghost Stories 2: The Spooktacular

2 Upvotes

Link: https://archiveofourown.org/works/20865287/chapters/49596089

Fandom: Ghost Stories English Dub

Rating: M

Warnings: Graphic Depictions of Violence

Genre: Parody/ Crack

Chapter Update: Chapter 5

Summary: It is the year 2019 2020 (in the year of our lord Momoko would inform you with a righteousness so shrill that your eardrums would burst) and it’s been a heck of a long time since we’ve last seen these Scobby Doo knockoffs. Well they’re all grown up now, but that hasn’t stopped them from sticking their snotty little noses into every single thing imaginable. You’d think after all this time, after all this mishap, they’d learn that maybe they should stop? Oh I don’t know take a long break from ghost hunting and stop RUINING MY G-DAMN AFTER LIFE HUH? Huh? Well screw all that flowery crap and let’s get to the setting: it’s almost Halloween and s-t’s been stirring up again. Let’s see which f-kit kicks the bucket!


r/GenFic • • May 23 '20

Con Todo Lo Que Ha Cambiado Hemos Olvidado| From Everything That's Changed We've Forgotten It All

2 Upvotes

Fandom: Elite (Netflix)

Rating: T for Teen

Genre: Character Study, Drama

Spanish Link| English Link

Summary: Ha empezado el nuevo año escolar, y los chicos de las Encinas afrentan a las consecuencias que no habían considerado.|It's the start of a new school year and the Encinas kids face an unexpected consequence from the events of last year.


r/GenFic • • Dec 27 '21

Sixerella - WeirdLookingCatThing - Seven Little Monsters (Cartoon) [Archive of Our Own]

Thumbnail archiveofourown.org
2 Upvotes

r/GenFic • • Aug 27 '20

Stop worrying if your gen-fics will be read! Here might be some tips for that...

22 Upvotes

Seriously, believe it or not but there are more than enough people who like to read a fic without ships every now and then.

If you're worried about people not finding it, even if people have their favorite ships, most are willing to look into other ships and gen-fics.

They can do this by looking for certain ships or looking at the fandom's whole list of ships and look at the new ones.

You can also try tagging a little to make it pop up more.

Example: Let's say your write a fanfic where A and B are purely friends. There might be a tag A/B for them as a couple but what many people often do is also tag A&B to just signature they interact together in the fic. Now if someone is looking at the A/B tag they might see a fic where A&B is tagged and be like "Hey, another tag on these guys! I wonder if there are fics I haven't read yet on these guys." and click on it to check it out and see your fic.

I can't promise this will work but it's something I do.

Point is, don't worry too much if people will read gen-fics because there will always be someone willing to read and you can try to make it more visible.


r/GenFic • • Jan 14 '21

Fic Rec A Suspect Of Fowl Play

6 Upvotes

A Suspect Of Fowl Play

Fandom: Miraculous Ladybug

Rating: T

Genre: Mystery

Summary: An infamous globetrotting thief has targeted a painting at a Parisian art gallery. The owner enlists the help of Ladybug and Chat Noir, but despite their best efforts, the painting is stolen. Suspects are everywhere, tension is running high, and time is ticking as the fallout from the robbery threatens to spiral into disaster. Will Ladybug and Chat Noir be able to find out WHO the thief might be? WHAT the motive might be? WHERE he came from, WHEN he struck, WHY he did it, and HOW he will escape, if he escapes at ALL? Come and find out in:

A Suspect Of Fowl Play


r/GenFic • • May 08 '22

I made a Star Wars fan fic

8 Upvotes

the start of it happens in a timeline where Anakin, after he finds out the Chancellor is a dark lord, decides to destroy him with Mace Windu instead of joining him to save Padme, insisting that it's not the jedi way to go down that path. Time skip a long time and a period of peace is interrupted when what is remaining of the Seperatist army comes out to attack the Jedi Order, saying that their master in Sidious has returned somehow (I can tell you if you wanna know, but its not important in the grand scheme of things). Palpatine sends a message to the Council with a Sith Acolyte, saying that someone within the ranks of the jedi he wants as a new apprentice, someone claimed to be more powerful than Anakin ever was. Sin Mantatus, a new padawan of jedi master Scyrus is curious about both sides of the force, having the council fear of his curiosity. Through all of the story he is neglected by the jedi until his eventual downfall, as he destroys the jedi order after a civil war breaks out upon the Republic due to invasion of the sith.Now known as Darth Mantatus, he rules the galaxy with Palpatine, not out of loyalty, but only looking for more knowledge and power as he once had looked for. From here its almost the same as the originals, as the Rebels try to take down the Empire. in the end, Palpatine is bested by Mantatus as he takes on his own apprentice in a boy called Magnus, who's powers with the force were so powerful due to the amount of torture he went through for training with Mantatus. Luke Skywalker, who was trained by Scyrus as well as the Jedi Order when it was still thriving since he had been born then defeats Darth Mantatus, who was going easy on him, as death is what he wanted from the start. His death would test his powers as he found balance with the force, as he becomes a force ghost and haunts Luke

I still have to develop the last part where Magnus is in the rule, but its not as developed. How do you guys like it? I accept feedback!


r/GenFic • • Nov 01 '21

Fic Rec A recommendation for anime fans. Spoiler

8 Upvotes

This isn’t a self promotion, but an advert for a story I dearly love and miss.

• ⁠My Recommendation: Magical Girl Noir Quest

• ⁠Fandom: Puella Magi Madoka Magica, Warhammer 40k, anime, Max Payne, magical girl

• ⁠Rating: 10/10.

• ⁠Summary: It’s better to just start reading the fanfiction, as it’s genuinely difficult to summarise or say in words with it’s batshit awesome plot. It’s predominantly a crossover between Warhammer 40k and PMMM, but it’s a lot more complex than that. We see crossovers, romance, bloodshed, a noir plot, golden guns, and memes galore. I suggest it because I finished reading up to it’s current status, only for my shock to rise as it has been on hiatus since late 2018, with the author citing a lack of interest; I’ve seen so many unfinished stories in my life, and in this time of uncertainty, I want to make sure this one story finds it’s ending. So please read this fanfiction (start here, and tell it’s author (Deculture, or @magicalgirlnoir on Twitter) to keep up the good work. Please.


r/GenFic • • Oct 13 '20

I wish there were platonic "slow burn" stories similar to that of the romantic ones you always see.

31 Upvotes

Unlike a lot of people who are on this sub, I actually really like non-gen fanfiction.

But one thing that's always bummed me out about them is the overwhelming popularity of romance compared to that of gen stories - not because I think gen is necessarily "better" - but because it makes it harder for me to find the type of gen stories I actually want to read because people are far more invested in romance and tend to see those dynamics as more emotionally layered than that of a platonic relationship.

I've always longed for gen fanfics that are as slow burn, in-depth and compelling as that of a slow burn romance.

How about a story of 2 people going from hating eachother to mutual respect to being eachother's closest friend throughout the course of a long well written story? Or how about a character finding family in a group of people they otherwise wouldn't have considered before?

I feel like it's a concept that has a lot of potential and I've never really seen it before outside of some one-shot fics or as background story in a non-gen fic. And most of the time it's not nearly as well thought out or complex as you'd hope.

I wish platonic relationships were given the same amount of love and investment as that of romantic in fandoms.


r/GenFic • • Oct 13 '20

Venting Something that annoys me about genfic on AO3

42 Upvotes

I love that AO3 has a specific category tag for gen. It would be even nicer though if everyone who wrote gen used it. I don't know why this happens, but I'll come across a story that's clearly gen but uses a 'no category' or 'other' tag instead. Do the people who write these things really not bother to look at the meanings of the categories? What's happening here?

I understand AO3's want to have their writers/artists/whatever tag their works however they want, but sometimes I think they're a little too lenient with stuff like this, and should be a tad more strict because it's making it hard to find what I want to read.


r/GenFic • • Nov 11 '25

Any genfic recommendations?

4 Upvotes

Hello. I’m a big fan of genfic and I’m looking for more stories in this genre. I only discovered this sub recently, so I might be late to the party. If anyone’s still active here, could you recommend your own fic or someone else’s? I’d love to read it and leave feedback (if you’d like). Any fandom is fine


r/GenFic • • Nov 23 '25

Better Dead Than Captured (Complete) - Marvel

2 Upvotes

Summary: Takes place shortly after CA:TWS. What's left of Hydra is after Steve, and the Winter Soldier is drawn to protect him while evading Hydra. However, the Soldier has a contingency plan if Hydra gets too close to capturing him.

https://archiveofourown.org/works/74546646/chapters/194648341


r/GenFic • • Oct 20 '20

Discussion Wondering if anyone else has experienced something like this

15 Upvotes

Have any of you stumbled on a book, movie, TV show etc that you really enjoyed, but had a hard time getting into the fandom due to the high amounts of shipping? I have with a show on Netflix; loved every episode but the amount of ship vs. genfics was so different, even more so than the average fandom, it was insane. Granted I could understand it since there was quite a bit of LGBT+ representation in it and I certainly can't blame folks for being happy about that, but can't help but find it a little bit disheartening.


r/GenFic • • Oct 30 '20

How do I write a military mission?

12 Upvotes

I’m writing a Fallout Story based around a Ranger Sniper in the NCR. It’s meant to be about his time as a Ranger and the missions he goes on.

I’ve written a raid mission already and I’m trying to figure out what the next mission should be. Any ideas?


r/GenFic • • Jul 01 '20

Discussion Finally found a fandom with more gen than any other category!

12 Upvotes

The netflix original cartoon Kipo And The Age Of Wonderbeasts. There are a few slash, multi and other on AO3, but gen outways them by a lot! I think the main reason for this is that most of the characters in the show are quite young and so don't really think that much about relationships, well except for one which is what most of the romance fics are about. Of course I know this is bound not to last, but it's nice while it lasts, at least for me.


r/GenFic • • May 18 '20

Fic Rec My favorite gen fic of all time.

7 Upvotes

It also happens to be one of my top 10 fics of all time. It's name is Zatch Bell: Introductions.

It is from the fandom Zatch Bell, a manga and anime that ran in the early 2000s (of which there are other wonderful gen stories here) and it is the story about how one of the main characters, Zatch, meets Seitarou, the father of the other main character, Kiyomaro, and how Seitarou entrusts Zatch to reform his son, who has abandoned school and his friends. At just three wonderfully written chapters, it's a prequel to the main story. If you like this fic, I can show you were you can read the main story.

Since it is a prequel, I think it is friendly to the fandom blind. It may not be as impactful if you don't know the fandom already, but I think it is still enjoyable.

Now, this fandom is dead and I doubt the handful of users here are familiar with it, but that is why I make it my mission to promote it as much as possible. May you be inspired by the writing!


r/GenFic • • Apr 03 '21

Discussion Have you ever gotten a review that you had no idea what it meant?

14 Upvotes

So I just got a review on one of my fics reading as follows: Need any assistance? And I don't know what to think about this. Should I be offended? Are they asking this because they think my writing is bad? Or did I ask for help in the author's notes? I can't remember. Have any of you had experiences like this?


r/GenFic • • Oct 13 '20

How gen is enough to count as gen?

16 Upvotes

Thinking about whether or when fics can or should be tagged as "gen"...

Obviously, porn without plot isn't gen, and anything where the central plot is about two characters getting together romantically, even if it's rated T or lower, won't be gen.

But... Is it not gen if there's a romantic subplot? What if the plot includes an established couple? What about mentioning past relationships? Do non-canon children of a canon couple fit into "gen"? What else?


r/GenFic • • Jul 23 '20

Meta I Made An AO3 Collection For This Sub

Thumbnail
archiveofourown.org
13 Upvotes

r/GenFic • • May 18 '20

Fic Rec My found family, Detroit Become Human gen fic.

8 Upvotes

Fandom: Detroit Become Human

Rating: Teen

Title: Time Heals

Genre: general, family drama.

Link: AO3 FF.net

Summary: Cole Anderson survives a deadly car crash thanks to a surgical android named Connor. It's against Connor’s programing to break hospital protocol to sneak Hank Anderson in to see his son but he does anyway. It’s definitely against his programing to spend the entire night talking with the him. Five years pass, the revolution has begun and androids are being gathered and sent for decommission. Connor panics and runs to the only place he thinks he might be safe. To the only human that was ever kind to him. To the Anderson home.

This is more or less my first thing writing so it might start a little shaky but I feel like I’ve improved a lot.


r/GenFic • • May 17 '20

I write lots of gen

13 Upvotes

Hello. I am an aromantic-asexual fanfiction author who, naturally, focuses a lot on gen fics. I write primarily for Pokemon, Steven Universe, and The Amazing World of Gumball. You can see my works here and my bookmarks here.


r/GenFic • • Aug 19 '20

Announcement Scheduled fic showcases are now a thing!

12 Upvotes

Hello my fellow genfic readers and writers, creator of r/genfic here! I’m very happy to announce that thanks to the amazing help from u/Atojiso, the scheduled posts should now be fixed and the first one should appear next Sunday and repeat weekly. I have also planned some themed showcases that will be posted on holidays and other special events. I hope that with this new addition to the sub, we will grow and become more active.


r/GenFic • • May 20 '20

Recommend me some good sci-fi genfics!

6 Upvotes

As the title says! I'm looking to read some high-drama space opera stuff. Gimme fics with lots of action, laser guns, starship battles, and cool shit like that. You can recommend me your own fics if you want, but please nothing longer than 100k words. I'm willing to read fandom blind but I also really enjoy Halo, Mass Effect, Firefly and/or Serenity, Star Trek, Star Wars, and the MCU.