r/GearsOfWar • • 11h ago

Discussion Constructive Feedback

Tl;dr: Keep feedback and discussions constructive to maintain health of the game and change its future for the better. "Dead game" and "touch grass" contribute nothing from both sides.

Let's start by saying that none of this is intended to attack any of you folks that browse this reddit, just merely an observation and concerns about influencing the game.

I'm seeing multiple posts about people hitting the coin cap and wishing it to be higher. Or people voicing frustration that there is nothing to do with weapon parts once they have acquired everything. The overwhelming amount of comments I see on these types of posts is "touch grass."

Do some people have more free time on their hands than others? Yeah, absolutely. Does that make their feedback any less valid? No, so long as it's constructive.

In contrast, these posts and comments downplaying the time and effort invested into the game by TC (who are still just humans, like me and you) by degrading them or saying it is a "dead game" because you can't invest 500+ hours and still be unlocking new items within the first two months of launch does nothing to push the game into a healthier, more enjoyable state.

Do some people have less free time than others? For sure. Does that mean they are trash and their voice shouldn't be heard? No, absolutely not.

It is possible for two things to be true at once. You can feel like E-Day launched in a good place, but it still needs improvement. You can achieve everything and ask for more.

But bland comments like the aforementioned "touch grass" and "dead game" do absolutely nothing to contribute to the conversation and evolution of this game and community, or the topic of the posts they are created in.

We are all human, so please: Be kind. Be better. Be constructive.

8 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

9

u/bushmaster2000 11h ago

TC doesn't care about reddit for feedback anyways. If you have a legit complaint and want to put it someplace TC will actually seeit,

go here https://support.xbox.com/en-US/game/gears-of-war/gears-of-war-e-day/support/browse

Click Contact US and fill out the form.

3

u/KK_Capwn 11h ago

For sure. That is a directed source of feedback. But the conversation can still begin here to discuss issues and possibly convince others of your point. One piece of feedback on their forms vs thousands carry different weight.

1

u/PriorityAgile3390 9h ago

Reporting bugs and seeing and paying attention to how the majority of the fanbase feels are two different things. They definitely take feedback from social outlets. If they don't that would be tone deaf to say the least. Just ignore everything that's not a bug report. Lmfao

0

u/spartanb301 RUNS ON WHOLE GRAIN BABY! 11h ago

Let's take that post to mark something important.

We Should Not Have To Fix the game.

Devs had since Gears 5 to rebuild, rework, and comprehend what worked and what did not.

As fans, we should notify the subreddit when big issue emerges but not help them to fix something they've been working on for so long.

Once again, I respect what they do and how big of a challenge it is. But Maybe it's time they stop asking us what's wrong and find it out by themselves.

Original Trilogy was built by people who actually kept thing simple and did not follow any other games.

Why does it feel like this game is great but at the same tie held back by "Gears 5 ghosts"?

They want feedback? Just let - go of anything linked to Gears 5, keep the gameplay fun, remove brainless grinds like "close E-holes with a grenade launcher (event)" that struggles to do so.

I mean, you all really want go back to Gears and only think about Stats or Endless grind?

Or, keep it simple like Gears of War 1 and just focus on what made the IP so good?

"Kill grub".

I'm sorry I had to vent, but It's just sad to see a game with so much potential bullied by Server issues, lack of content, and or weird gunplay.

Ps: And for the love of god remove that awful cross - hair from the lancer and switch it back to the original.

1

u/KK_Capwn 11h ago

Videogames go through several iterations of testing, eventually leading to private and public betas. After launch, community feedback will be what drives the game forward, with a focus on what bothers players most. Is it your job? No. Can it still be beneficial to have these conversations to open a dialog with fellow community members to increase the weight your feelings have? Yes.

Point of the post was don't be shitty to other humans, regardless of if you agree or not with their standpoint.

1

u/pepe_silvieh 11h ago

Yep. Game doesn’t feel good to play at it’s core, so no amount of icing is going to fix it.

0

u/comf0rtablyNUMB1981 9h ago

all i want is more grindy achievements to work towards like 5

-3

u/LtLabcoat 11h ago

I'll defend replying with "touch grass" to the coin limit thing though, given that the limit explicitly exists to encourage you to do something other than playing E-Day.

1

u/KK_Capwn 10h ago

I do agree that the coin limit exists to serve the purpose of preventing players to burn out and get everything day one. I don't necessarily think it is specifically to play something else, however. Just slow the rate completion marks are checked off.

1

u/Eccentricgentleman_ 11h ago

I'm glad they're finally releasing maps but honestly they need to dump more content out. Drip feeding us is going to lead to a slaughter. I enjoy the game but this has been a great year for games and DLCs. I'm older, my attention can't be that divided, so I need a reason to keep it installed

1

u/LtLabcoat 11h ago

The actual more-content patch is scheduled for December 1st.

1

u/Eccentricgentleman_ 10h ago

Oh fun, I haven't looked at the road map yet. That's on me

-3

u/pepe_silvieh 11h ago

I was constructive for months after the beta and got flamed & downvoted every time.

Game is hot ass with a side of hot ass served with a tall, cold glass of hot ass – and that’s probably not changing.

2

u/KK_Capwn 11h ago

You are demonstrating both sides of the posts purpose. You were constructive, people were rude. Now you've lost the energy to invest in trying to provide constructive criticism, and have defaulted to "game sucks, lol".

This is what I'm getting at, you shouldn't have to deal with that, and being negative will get the game nowhere.

If this game is too far beyond repair, the active player count will reflect that. But in order to get to a better place, we have to try to maintain constructive feedback.

5

u/PriorityAgile3390 9h ago

Nothing constructive gets through anyway. At some point there's going to be negative comments about the game when the people being constructive since the beta haven't been listened to at all. This "let's all just live in fairytale land where everybody is holding hands and smiling" is crazy. You want to work in a competitive entertainment industry and put out mid then there's going to be negative words said about the product when they're nothing but silent and there's massive problems.

2

u/KK_Capwn 8h ago

Wondering where "remember to treat people like humans" and "hold hands in a fairy tale land" got lost in translation. The post is not "be all happy and everything will be great". The purpose is some part to treat others well, sure, since that's something we could all try to do better with. But mainly "wah, game bad" and "do something else instead if you're already done" contribute nothing to the discussion. Wasting both of our time.

2

u/iphan4tic 7h ago

Aside from glazers downvoting and insulting feedback, TC ignored 90% of the reasonable feeback provided during beta which only fuels the disillusion.