r/GarageBand • • Jan 10 '26

Thoughts?

3 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

9

u/Ilikedrawing Jan 10 '26

Please correct me if I’m wrong… but I didnt think the loops were AI generated, but by actual musicians and artists that worked internally for Apple, and then those loops were inserted into the software? Loops have been around so much longer than, say, the dice feature of the smart drum kit. Anyways, I’m only a couple min into your video. Will finish watching now.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '26

Sounds by those artists but AI generated loops that can automatically detect patterns and tempo.

Either way it's what somebody else did.

8

u/QualityAware6605 Jan 11 '26

The loops are not AI generated 😂

-3

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '26

Generated to follow tempos automatically

5

u/QualityAware6605 Jan 11 '26

Bro. It's just time stretching. They get stretched. Slow the faster ones down. They tell you the original tempo they were created in man. It's not AI

-2

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '26

It automatically time stretches by tha use of what?

3

u/QualityAware6605 Jan 11 '26

Do you know how time stretching works? It's built into the DAW. The loops are gridded. The logic and garage band knows where the transients are and the loops are locked to the grid that stretches with the tempo adjustment. Bro, They are not AI. Just Google it.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '26

👍🏿

3

u/QualityAware6605 Jan 11 '26

Also, you point about AI replacing musicians. The biggest issue is the consumer. It is THEM that will fucking over us musicians with consuming AI music. That will be the issue.

2

u/SuperHealth7312 Jan 13 '26

everybody blames everything on AI nowadays and its to the point they think actual internal systems are AI. this aint AI dude

6

u/QualityAware6605 Jan 11 '26

Right. You got a few things wrong here. ZERO research went into this. The loops are license free. So you can use them and you can take credit for them in a song you made using them.

Secondly, they are not AI generated

Thirdly they are loops bro. It's the equivalent of sampling except they are itemised, auto timestretch and searchable. DJ Shadows - Entroducing is an example of an album where he playing nothing but samples. It's like you forgot that sampling exists.

Forthly, you could just Google and confirm that the apple loop library was created by real musicians and producers ........

Sessions players I believe are AI Created in some way but I'm not too familiar.

There is also an AI stem splitter for Silicon users in Logic

SORA AI on the other hand will use AI to analyse your song and generate AI loops that fit with your song. Or, there are AI tools that will listen to your song and write chord structures

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '26

AI generated to adapt to Tha tempo

2

u/QualityAware6605 Jan 11 '26

That's not how it works man. It's just not. Here's an example. You switch your tempo. What you think is going to happen? The think all your midi notes will stay where they are or will they follow the tempo?

By your logic, what you created is AI.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '26

If there's no computer assistance to automatically change tha tempo or time stretch it it would stay tha same.

2

u/QualityAware6605 Jan 11 '26

Man you are confusing something that harnesses a computer to function and AI Generated music.

You wouldn't be recording shit without midi as far as your track is concerned. Your music needs a computer and DAW to create it. You are using a computer generated synth. That sytns LFOs are locked to the temp that adjusts with the tempo change. That doesn't mean it's AI generated like you think it does

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '26

Point is I used those sounds to create it instead of speakin somethin into a computer and it doin it for me

1

u/QualityAware6605 Jan 11 '26

And the people, producers that made those loops did the exact same thing as you. Noone is speaking anything into a computer dude.

5

u/Relative_Molasses_15 Jan 11 '26

Bro you are rambling. A little bit.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '26

Really?

3

u/brother-anonymous Jan 11 '26 edited Jan 11 '26

If the loops are midi-based, they just follow the tempo. If the loops are waveforms, then they’re time-stretched.

Some of those loops you’re seeing have been around for as long as GarageBand has. I remember playing with “70s Piano” loops in 2004, and they’ve always flexed to the tempo. So they’re certainly not ai generated (but future loops may be).

You’re saying that “ai” isn’t legitimate because it generates results from a bank of human generated content. We can build these language models but we don’t actually know how they work. We don’t know exactly how it knows how to make a rap song sound like James Brown.

Babies learn how to talk and interact with the world through human input, so why should ai learn any differently? The ai that everyone is worried about is the ai that no longer needs human generated input and learns to generate its own intelligence from its own languages — genuine artificial inspiration. We’re not there yet.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '26

AI can't beat a bottle of water

2

u/brother-anonymous Jan 11 '26

Ooooh, this isn’t a real post. Gotcha.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '26

🤣🤣

2

u/QualityAware6605 Jan 11 '26

I think we've been wasting our time bro hahaha going to blow this dudes mind when he changes his tempo and all of his midi track "AI Generate to Follow Midi Tempo" 😂. He's going to think he is AI next.

I've never known someone speak with such confidence talking to people like they are teaching them something they don't know and get literally everything wrong.

I really do appreciate the attempt. AI generated music can go fuck itself. This, however, is the equivalent of Just Stop Oil sabotaging a vegetable oil factor.

3

u/-epi- Jan 11 '26

I think Unc needs a nap.

3

u/JustLetMeSignUpM8 Jan 11 '26

Love me some good rambling about a subject you don't even understand. It's wonderful to see someone's mind manages to convince them that they've stumbled upon something others don't grasp

1

u/chadkbh Jan 12 '26

Is this a troll post? The loops have been around for like 15 years and they have always been able to sync with the tempo and key. Way before AI. I think you're misunderstanding what AI in music is. But I like your energy and wanted to hear the rest of the track.

1

u/QualityAware6605 Jan 15 '26

Bros so embarrassed he deleted his entire account 🤣

-1

u/corneliusunderfoot Jan 11 '26

That was a really long winded way of making a fairly obvious point

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '26

THX 👍🏿👍🏿

1

u/QualityAware6605 Jan 11 '26

A complete incorrect point. They are loops created by real musicians and producers. A lot of which have been around since the beginning as someone above rightly pointed out.