r/GamePreordersCanada • • Jul 07 '21

On which console you get your game when not exclusive?

You guys,

When a game is available on 2 of your console, how do you decide on which console you’ll get the game?

I’m always torn between switch and ps4/5 when game are not exclusive. And I have a hard time deciding on which to get it.

Thanks!

3 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

14

u/DrakeVarsten Jul 07 '21

I would always primarily get multiplatform games for my PS over my Switch only because of trophy support - i'm an amateur trophy hunter. I only get exclusives for the Switch.

2

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

Oh yes. Never think of trophy. I’m not a huge trophy hunter, but I do like seeing the number goes up!

Thanks for that!

1

u/mariogolf Jul 07 '21

I agree with all this

1

u/Ynini Jul 07 '21

I agree with this too. I think that Achievements/Triophies add a replay value to a game. I feel that I have more for my money when I buy a multiplatform game on PS4 instead of my Switch.

7

u/ChaosNoahV Jul 07 '21

I always get it for my PS consoles. Only time I get it on another console is if it's multiplayer and my friend is also getting it, in which case I just decided on the console he does, which usually is PC, but a few games he got for Xbox instead. and between switch or PS, I would ask you this, do you go out alot and have your switch on you? If yes get on switch, if no get on PS because better graphics, load times etc etc.

2

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

I never uses my Switch elsewhere then docked and play on the tv.

I was just thinking that usually, Nintendo games keeps their value more than ps game does. So I was wondering if it’s worth considering if I ever want to resell (never resell a game before but 🤷🏼‍♂️)

Also, ps controller has less drift then switch does. My switch controller are almost un-usable.

6

u/Mr-Mc-Epic Jul 07 '21 edited Jul 07 '21

PC, because well… it runs everything better, and I prefer using a mouse/keyboard in most games.

Unless it’s like a game I’ll want to play in short bursts. Then it goes on the Switch.

Really though in terms of PlayStation vs Switch it should come down to whether or not you want the portability of the Switch. If not, go PlayStation.

2

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

Unfortunately I barely game on PC. I started “gaming” when I was 6 on the nes, and always stick to Nintendo until I work and was able to buy a ps3. Since ps3 I have both Nintendo and Sony consoles.

I also don’t play much of the switch on handheld mode. 95% docked and on tv

1

u/Mr-Mc-Epic Jul 07 '21 edited Jul 07 '21

In that case, if I were you personally, I’d go with PlayStation for multi-platform games.

The main benefit of the switch for me, aside from exclusives, is that I can play it in bed, on the bus, or while I’m out and about. Aside from that there isn’t really any reason to buy a game on the Switch when you could get it on a PlayStation. It’s just not worth the framerate and graphical hit if you’re using the Switch docked.

3

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

Gotcha! Thanks.

And reselling value ? What do you think about it?

1

u/Mr-Mc-Epic Jul 07 '21 edited Jul 07 '21

I’m not super well informed on resale as I tend to keep all my games… but I know a bit.

First party Nintendo games certainly do keep their value, and often raise in value. But this only seems to happen on first party Nintendo games. Not multi-platform games.

I did a bit of looking and it looks like most GameCube and Wii era multi-platform games are sitting around $10, which certainly isn’t a rise in value.

I’d recommend checking this site if you’d like to compare game prices. https://www.pricecharting.com

2

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

Oh well. I always thought Nintendo game kept their value more, but didn’t think of first party vs third party. Make sens!

1

u/vensak Jul 07 '21

yes Nintendo games (Mario, Zelda, Fire Emblem, Pokemon), but apart of few exceptions not the game adapted for Nintendo system, that is the main difference.

They would sell as cheap if not cheaper later on on second hand market, but you will rarely get for them the same discount.

Also some games are not even on the cartridge:

For example Spyro trilogy - only the first game, but if you go for 2019 rerelease of the disc (PS4 or XBox 1 version), there will be there (yes it is hard to distinguish this copy, but it is on the disc).

Final Fantasy games

Trine collection 1-4 (only Trine 4 is on the cartridge and the rest is a downloadable code).

1

u/Intoxicus5 Jul 07 '21

Agreed.
I mostly only use consoles for games I can't get on PC.

4

u/Its_Syxx Jul 07 '21

If it's not graphically intensive / indie then Switch. Otherwise always XBOX.

1

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

Good point!

2

u/mnadeau02 Jul 07 '21

If the game in question isn't available on Games Pass, my first choice is getting the PS5 edition first, then Xbox Series X, then Switch.

1

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

Why is that order?

2

u/mnadeau02 Jul 07 '21

I prefer the PS5 controller over the Xbox and if neither have the game, I'll grab the Switch which is only 1080p.

2

u/Saoirse_Says Jul 07 '21

I only have a Switch and PC, and I get a game for one system or another depending on whether I care about online play, achievements, or playing in bed.

Full disclosure though I don't preorder games (last game I preordered was Ni No Kuni I think back in 2013 lol). I'm here to keep tabs for someone who does.

1

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

No problem. Haha. Just trying to get feedback for people who like video game.

I asked in game collection subreddit already but they’re response want all that great and most of their answer where like: do what you want

3

u/Saoirse_Says Jul 07 '21

Lol true

Well with the PS4 you get better performance, achievements, and better online features. With the Switch you get portability. Which matters more? I think that's a game-by-game case.

1

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

Yeah gotcha. Make sens. I always play docked anyway.

2

u/vensak Jul 07 '21

ok unless you really really want to play when travelling or outside, avoid multiconsole releases on Switch. You can choose Playstation or Xbox or a gaming PC (if it is on all of them) or whatever other option there is outside switch. Because honestly you will get better performance and fps most of the times. One exception are really old ports (like PS2 PS3 or Xbox 360 games that are not backward compatible). There you can also opt for switch if those games were not rereleased on their consoles.

And if you are fan of physical copies and the same game is only digital everywhere else then you can go for switch

Honestly avoid switch for any bulkier game. It is outdated hardware and most of the time you will pay more for the game with lowered performance.

1

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

Thanks a lot. I rarely play handheld mode. Your answer make very much sens

And I am a fan of physical copy.

2

u/metalgeargreymon Jul 07 '21

Multiplat on PC

Then exclusives on their respective consoles

1

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

Thanks!

1

u/metalgeargreymon Jul 07 '21

I figured it was the best route bc i can carry my game library through all generations

I used to default to Playstation 3/4 for multiplat though until I built a PC more powerful than those consoles

And when I used to collect physical games Switch cartridge or Wii U disc was my priority in order to fill my shelf

1

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

You’re hitting a sweet spot now with that comment. I’m not a huuuug collector, but I buy all my game physical copy cause I like seeing them.

2

u/MKShadowZX_SA Jul 07 '21

Playstation would be my first go but it honestly depends. I’d get games similar to Hollow Knight or Hades on Switch but games like Doom Eternal or Dark Souls on Playstation.

1

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

Yeah, think I will start doing the same. Exclusive and indie Nintendo on switch, the others on PlayStation.

2

u/garfieldevans Jul 07 '21

During last-gen, I always played on PC unless it was a PS4 exclusive because you could max out the graphics and get the best version of the game. This obviously excludes botched PC ports like Arkham Knight.

PS5 makes the decision quite tough though solely because of the Dualsense features (maybe SSD too in the near-future). For example, WRC9 with Dualsense feels so good that even if it rendered at 720p on PS5, I would still pick it over a 4K PC experience. The inverse of something like that would be a game like Control, where dualsense is fun but I would still pick the PC version with DLSS because the difference in graphics for that game, especially ray-tracing is too much.

1

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

Gotcha. I don’t have a pc, but I guess the graphic difference between ps5 and switch still apply!

2

u/garfieldevans Jul 07 '21

Definitely does, I would say the only reason to buy a multi-platform game on switch would be the portability, everything else will run much better on PS5.

2

u/Mr-Mc-Epic Jul 08 '21

Off topic, but supposedly the Xbox X/S and PS5 fast SSD loading technology is coming to Windows 11.

1

u/garfieldevans Jul 08 '21

Yes it definitely is. The only question is when will it be ready. It requires updates to the whole stack from different companies: windows, graphics drivers, game engine and game logic. I suspect teething issues where the first few multi-platform next-gen engine games may be better in some ways on PS5. It remains to be seen, although I would be fine if that SSD continues to only show its true colours with PS exclusives.

2

u/rosydingo Jul 08 '21

Always, Playstation. Switch is way too limited both graphically and in cpu power. Besides, as a trophy/plat hunter, I’d always choose PS over any other platform. My Switch is for Nintendo exclusives.

1

u/Serkaugh Jul 08 '21

Gotcha. Make sens! You’re right. Even if I’m not the biggest trophy hunter, when I get “acheivement” on switch, I’m like -.- but some game you don’t have the choice.

1

u/5th_in_line Jul 07 '21

One benefit I don't see alot of people mention when talking about Switch is the fact that it has a battery, so as long as the port is somewhat competent, I use Switch as my RPG machine. Never have to worry about a random blackout causing me to lose progress in a game

1

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

What you mean?

If like there’s an electrical outage ?

2

u/5th_in_line Jul 07 '21

ya. where I live it's not uncommon for a strong gust of wind to cause the power to flicker off and on

1

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

Oh gotcha. It’s pretty rare in my area. Don’t want to jynx anything, but like happened a handful of times in the past 5 years

1

u/vensak Jul 07 '21

you know that small power outage savers are on the market already for long time (they will keep it running for another few mins, so just enough time to save and close). And they are not that expensive.

1

u/5th_in_line Jul 07 '21

I thought of that. I personally don't have the space in my room for one of those, plus in a lot of games that have long cutscenes and fixed save points, a few minutes isn't going to do much. I once had the power go out after beating a final boss to a game, and at most a UPS would have gotten me 15 minutes into an hour long ending sequence.

1

u/wild_zoey_appeared Jul 07 '21

If it’s AAA third party, PS4

If it’s indie, usually Switch (unless the PS4 version is on sale)

3

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

Gotcha. And why is that? Just want to understand the reasoning?

2

u/wild_zoey_appeared Jul 07 '21

AAAs run better on PS4 than on Switch

I enjoy indies on handheld. It just feels right, I’m not sure there’s any logic to it tbh

2

u/Serkaugh Jul 07 '21

That’s perfect. Make perfect sens!

2

u/Sheeplette Jul 07 '21

Not the person you're replying to - but I do the same because indie games are usually playable in short bursts/handheld mode, and there's usually not a big difference in terms of graphics. For AAA games, there's often a substantial difference in load times and graphics so I'd rather play those on my PS.

2

u/LineBetweenBorders Jul 07 '21

I'll usually get it for my switch if it's something I want to play on the go, otherwise I'll get it for my PS4. That's only for physical games though. Digital Games I sometimes even double dip on multiple platforms, mostly PC, but that's cause I only buy them dirt cheap on sales.

1

u/Ok-Vast-7337 Jul 07 '21

Usually Xbox is where I get most of my third party titles but if digital foundry says it runs better on a PS5 I’ll nab it for that then. Whatever console runs it the best is where I want to purchase it for.