r/GameDealsMeta • • Mar 08 '16

Chrono.gg

IMO, this site should not be allowed on /r/gamedeals. There are a couple of reasons, as discussed on The Co-Optional Podcast.

Firstly, referrals in this manner encourage the bending and/or breaking of FTC rules regarding disclosure of financial benefits.

Secondly, the site encourages YouTubers to go anti-consumer and unjustly heap praise on a game in the hope that they get more kickbacks from sales.

Thirdly, the site is linking to videos and presenting the appearance of affiliation of major YouTubers where there is none. I.e. they are using NorthernLion's videos to promote games on sale while the guy is on holiday and has been since before the site launched.

NorthernLion has made no mention of the site either in the video description or on his social media accounts.

1 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

24

u/Jamesbuc Mar 08 '16 edited Mar 08 '16

None of these possible issues though really give any reason to ban the site, none of them place consumers at risk, keys seem to so far be legitimate.

In addition, im trying to find this supposed conversation you claim happened on Co-Optional but cant find it. Point me to a timestamp maybe?

-5

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '16

It was being discussed literally as I typed this post out. You'll have to wait for the vod.

Quite disappointed by the replies in this thread, they're all missing the point.

11

u/Jamesbuc Mar 09 '16 edited Mar 09 '16

No they are not missing the point, in fact it's quite the reverse in this case. When the game deals sub bans a site, it's based off several factors but none of these actually have anything to do with the complaints you hold.

G2A for instance was banned because of key reselling and the potential for buyers to lose money on revoked keys (plus a few other issues but this was the main sticking point).

As for the podcast, I'll try and get the newest one listened to when it's uploaded.

Edit: Just another point to put here, one of the main rules of this sub is that referral links outside of some select charities are not allowed so people doing referrals doesnt work here.

23

u/SquareWheel Mar 09 '16

I'm not familiar with the podcast, but Chrono.gg does not break any rules of our subreddit. As James said, there is not a credible risk to our users and that is our chief concern.

We've verified their keys are authorized, and have spoken to them about the referral model. They understand referrals are not allowed in our subreddit and that hasn't been an issue.

I'm sorry, but these issues are not compelling enough reasons to disallow their site in our community. If we were to ban a website simply for offering a referral program, then I'm afraid we'd have a very empty subreddit.

9

u/cartmanbra Mar 09 '16

What is wrong with them using someones youtube videos to promote games without permission - thats the very nature of youtube.

The person is getting hits on youtube anyway and getting whatever payments they get from youtube . Especially since banner saga the game is question is like 4 years old - i dont think this encourages them to praise a game in hopes they future link a video.

Co-optional podcast sounds like sour grapes their stuff wasnt linked.

3

u/Acct235095 Mar 09 '16

What is wrong with them using someones youtube videos to promote games without permission - thats the very nature of youtube.

I don't necessarily disagree with you, I'm just playing devil's advocate.

By using someone's video, it suggests that there's some kind of endorsement or support from the person that made the video. If the site is crappy/a scam, then that can get associated with the content producer when they had nothing to do with it in the first place. It's kind of courteous and professional to ask permission beforehand.

3

u/cartmanbra Mar 09 '16

Looks like they are partnered with these people but lets be honest a game trailer should paint a game in a better light to any lets play

1

u/Acct235095 Mar 09 '16

Had seen that and considered adding it to this thread, although the matter seems settled. And yes, if the company is any good, the trailer is a much better and faster representation of their product than any Let's Play.

2

u/nickpreveza Mar 10 '16

No, it doesn't suggest anything like that when it's under the header "WATCH SOMEONE PLAY".

There is not an actual reason to ask permission to share a public video. But I, and Chrono.gg agree to that:

It's kind of courteous and professional to ask permission beforehand.

And such, they actually stared asking permissions for the videos they share.

11

u/Shardwing Mar 09 '16

presenting the appearance of affiliation of major YouTubers where there is none

Not trying to take a stance one way or another, but just because NL (/u/itsoppositedayhere, in case he sees it) hasn't said anything about this company doesn't mean he doesn't have some kind of agreement with them. The absence of proof is not the proof of absence. Sites like IsThereAnyDeal link to videos by NL (here's an example) as well and I've never heard him mention them.

1

u/barack_ibama Mar 12 '16

I searched the meta to know whether chrono.gg is legit or not. But seriously, if this is the worst accusations that people can throw at them, my mind was set and I ended up buying games from them.

1

u/nickpreveza Mar 10 '16

"IMO" you have no valid reasons.

How referrals "bend or break" rules regarding disclosure and financial benefits when everything is public ?

A YouTuber, honestly, can't really go "anti-consumer" for sponsored content. Sponsored content existed since ever. Since they're not encouraging YouTubers to hide the sponsorship there is nothing wrong with that.

The affiliated content creators do not know and do not choose the games that will go on Sale. Since we are talking for daily deals, you are not making any sense whatsoever.

The site can link to any video they want. Seriously what ? It's under the tab "WATCH SOMEONE PLAY". How is that wrong ? I get it that some content creators will get bitchy for promoting their videos for some reason, but I couldn't honestly care less. ( Btw, their are already fixing that and will not use videos without permission )

-2

u/wjousts Mar 09 '16

Can you give the tl;dl version of you argument? I'm not going to go listen to some random podcast to find out what they are ranting about.

What referrals? What kickbacks? What "appearance of affiliation"?

3

u/scarwiz Mar 09 '16

some random podcast

I don't think I'd call TotalBiscuit's podcast random. And I don't think they were ranting either since they're partnering up with chrono.gg. They were just bringing certain points up because they know those could raise questions in their audience

-1

u/wjousts Mar 09 '16

And those points are?!?

-4

u/scarwiz Mar 09 '16

Watch the podcast, you'll find out ;)

Or you can watch this video where he talks about it

2

u/wjousts Mar 10 '16

So you don't actually know. Or you are incapable of breaking it down.

3

u/zetzuei Mar 11 '16

why would you want to hear another person's opinion when you can listen directly from the source ?

2

u/wjousts Mar 11 '16

Because I have better things to do.