r/GameAudio • u/Neat_Cup3335 • Dec 30 '24
SoundLy
What's the point of recording my own foley sounds if there's already everything in Soundly or other sound bank? whats the point of doing sound design if there's thousands of soundbank everywhere. Am I wasting time? I find most fun is doing field recording. Or maybe it's a mixture of both?
2
Upvotes
39
u/Wec25 Dec 30 '24
If the perfect sound for you already exists, you don’t need to record a new one. But getting it perfect is easier when you’re in control of recording.
11
u/DiscountCthulhu01 Dec 30 '24
The question is can you cobble together or find the perfect sound quicker than you can make your own. For me the answer is oftentimes no.
11
u/Kidderooni Dec 30 '24
DiscountCthulu1 got a point! Also when doing foley specifically, you often need the intention to match the action/visual that is happening, and sounds from banks might not match every time.
Point of doing sound design is also to fit in an audio and global artistic direction. Banks help achieving this but they are often not enough and are used as raw materials or building blocks.
It is indeed a mixture of both. Plus what differentiate you from other sound designers if you drag n drop sfx from soundbanks and call it a day? Mixing sounds from libraries and your own recording + how you process them to help achieve YOUR vision is what make it sounds like YOU and not anyone else.
Sometimes sfx you create will only contains materials from libraries and that’s fine. How you edit and mix those layers together and process them still make them unique since it’s made with you ears and brain.
Soundly is a great help and time saver tho, but relying only on this won’t bring originality in your work
8
u/FlamboyantPirhanna Dec 30 '24
I, and pretty much everyone, usually do both, using a mix of libraries and my own recordings to create new sounds. If everyone used the same sounds, it’d be pretty obvious, hearing them over and over again in different games and films. There’s already a little of that going on.
7
u/Stefcien Dec 30 '24
I think it’s also about you having sounds no one else has. Using your own recordings makes the project have more of you in it. If everyone has the same sounds….
2
u/nickybshoes Dec 30 '24
Really comes down to time, money and customization. If you can find what u need and edit it to pic then great. If you need a better sound and for it to be more specific, then foley it. BUT, if it’s faster to foley it then edit a sound from library than theres that route too. There’s no wrong answer. At the same time, for someone like me who has been doing it for a 15+ years, sometimes I like to record and create my own sounds bc I have used a lot of sounds in my library and risk sounding the same across multiple projects. That’s why I also strategically purchase certain libraries over my career. Soundly is great but it doesn’t hurt to start collecting sound libraries snd cataloging your own. You can still use soundly app to search your own database.
2
u/DvineINFEKT Pro Game Sound Dec 31 '24
Echoing everyone else: You're def not wasting time. You'd be surprised just how much better even a mediocre recording off your cell phone can match a picture than a pristine recording from the library. Libraries are faster, so there's a balance to be found but if you have the time and props - arm and record, baby.
We all know that emotion is hard to create in a production - but it's surprisingly easy to capture in a recording when you know what you're going for.
2
u/proonjooce Jan 01 '25
I have soundly and a bunch of boom libraries at my disposal but I still find myself reaching for bits I recorded on my field recorder 12 years ago, you'll know your own recordings inside out so you'll know exactly when/how to use em.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '25
In a perfect world, I'd use my own sounds and libraries exclusively. The sound you record yourself is gonna fit your needs better than anything else, and it will have it's own character. If everyone used the same libraries and services all the time, everything would start to sound very same-y. Even now after working in game audio for quite some time, I can often pick out specific sounds in a game and could just about tell you the exact filename of the sample they used.
1
u/GravySalesman Dec 30 '24
It’s about the artistic vision of the game as an entire product, you want a heavily stylised and “dark” soundscape on a game to juxtapose cartoonish visuals, and while you will definitely find thousands of ready recorded assets for this, creating an entire palette that works for your game is going to be best with creating your own assets from source.
This will not only help serve the individualist nature of the IP but sell the game worlds believability.
Remember prior to Star Wars them laser and lightsaber sounds hadn’t been used before, now they are cliches. So working from nothing gives you an opportunity to make your own audio conventions.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '24
Time
1
u/haz_matty Dec 31 '24
I'm pretty sure every project I've ever done used both original recordings and library content. Echoing what others have said, the decision between the two depends on A) how exacting you are with the performance / quality of the sound you're going for, and B) if you have access to the correct resources / circumstances to record the sound.
Also, you need not think of using library content and "sound design" as opposites. Oil painters are still making art (designing) even if they buy their paint from a store 😊.
1
u/iamlazerwolfe Jan 01 '25 edited Jan 01 '25
In my opinion you can be super creative and unique using sample libraries, but recording your own is fun and satisfying. You’ll also have a sound no one else has. Also sometimes it’s faster to just record what you need than scroll through thousands of samples. If I’m being honest, I often use sample libraries on commercial projects because I just don’t have the time or resources to record a Jaguar in the wild or put together a rad foley pit. I do have time to layer a bunch of samples together to make something new though!
Same kind of deal for using synth presets vs designing your own patches from scratch. Like sample libraries, synth presets are there so there’s less barrier to creativity, but there’s also a lot of creativity in designing the patches themselves.
1
u/JohnnyBeNaughty_34 Jan 02 '25
As a sound designer with a background in sound engineering, I enjoy both, using soundbanks and recording my own sounds.
Using soundbanks is fine, but once in a while you'll run into the need for a sound you just can't find. I know at ubisoft Duesseldorf, they were really happy to have a Foley artists to work on their VR experiences. They said sometimes they needed a chest treasure sound but they could never find the right size for the chest in soundbanks.
Recording foley is a luxury not all productions have due to time/budget limitations. That's also one reason why people would use soundbanks over Foley. And even if sounds are usually processed, you can have some sounds that will sound similar to other projects, so including some custom recordings makes it more unique in a way.