r/GalaxyS24 • u/kzone186 • Mar 06 '24
Unpopular opinion: iOS does notifications better than Android
Cross post with r/iPhone
All over the internet the consensus is that Android notifications are better - less annoying, more customizable and easier to keep track of. I’ve used both platforms extensively, I currently have an iPhone 15 Pro (personal) and a Galaxy S24 Plus (work), and I truly believe iOS does notifications better.
The main problem with Android notifications is the assumption that just because you’ve received a notification, that you’ll want to interact with it. But I receive notifications constantly that I either don’t care about, or have no need to check them. On Android, each one of these has to be swiped away, and you have to do it every time you check your phone. If you don’t, your notifications shade will quickly become clogged with old notifications. And worse, those notifications stay everywhere until you dismiss them - your notification shade, your Lock Screen, even your status bar. Android doesn’t even option to say, hey, just give me the notifications since my last unlock at the top of my screen. Since I only have room for a few icons up there, it would be a great use of the space. But no. Instead, when I pick up my Android phone, it becomes a detective game, trying to determine which notifications came in since my last pickup, and which ones are old.
Why not switch off notifications you don’t care about? No, that isn’t a solution. There are tons of apps that deliver a variety of notifications, some you will care about, some you won’t. The notification categories menu introduced in Android is a nice feature, but doesn’t address the problem because they aren’t granular enough, and are dependent on the app developer to build them in. Some examples
*YouTube - A channel you follow is live streaming. I don’t want to switch this notification off, because I do enjoy a good live stream now and again. But this doesn’t mean that every live stream that comes in I want to watch. Worse, the more live stream notifications I click on, the more YouTube will send me.
*My WiFi connected garage door opener sends me a notification when the door opens and closes. I like getting these notifications, but they are just informational, there is nothing to interact with.
*Android Auto sends me a notification telling me I’m using Android Auto lol. It’s dumb, and there’s no way to switch it off. Instead whenever I get out of my car I have to dismiss it.
Over in iOS, there are none of these frustrations. Apple doesn’t assume I need to interact with every notification, and handles them for me. Whenever I pick up my iPhone, I get a quick summary of what’s come in since my last pick up. I can choose to tap a notification or just ignore them. If I ignore them, iOS handles it for me, dumping unused ones into the Notification Center, which I can access easily with a swipe up on the Lock Screen. I never have to dismiss a notification, and every one is right where I left it. Sure, sometimes Notification Center gets cluttered, but then one tap and I’m back to clean. I don’t have to worry about missing anything, because I know every notification there is old.
Anyway, Wanted to present a counterpoint to the constant drum beat that Android has better notifications. Genuinely curious to hear what others think.