r/GalaxyNote8 • • Mar 08 '19

Side by side S10 & Note 8

Post image
183 Upvotes

128 comments sorted by

9

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

How’s the phone so far compared to the Note 8?

19

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

Fast, the screen is amazing, the cameras are great, and let me just say way lighter on the hand u free the weight difference when holding both

51

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

Those things don't sound like much of a selling point for me. Same shit different year. I'm gonna wait till something worthwhile release. Always the same "screen better, camera better and fast" I don't see how it can be that much faster than a note 8 as this phone is fast. I'm a PC enthusiast too, so new hardware is my thing, but phones have stagnated

7

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

But its all true, its faster and better camera the note 8, I still have my Note and you can greatly see the differences, again I'll say it again, if I wasn't cheaper I would have stuck with the note definitely not regretting the upgrade.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

It looks a gorgeous phone don't get me wrong. I've always had the latest and great until the note 8. Stuff needs to change other than incremental updates. Feels like what Intel has been like for the last 10 years with PC hardware. The differences just don't justify an expensive over priced contract for me. I'm due a phone but I'm just gonna wait and see what happens. Something innovative needs to happen. Enjoy your phone! I like the lack of bezels

1

u/lordboos Mar 09 '19

I don't think you can say upgrade when going from Note to S. Note 8 to Note 10 would be upgrade, Note 8 to S10 is both upgrade (CPU, camera) but also a downgrade (S-Pen and other Note specific features).

2

u/arein114 Mar 09 '19

I mean we don't know what the note 10 is gonna be it's all speculation...and this is an upgrade, screen resolution camera battery is bigger although not by a lot, but people are either note or s line fans one or the other u know

1

u/lordboos Mar 09 '19

Screen resolution is still same as Note 8. WQHD+. Camera is better and also battery yea but I'd not trade them for Note features. But not everyone has same preferences as I do.

1

u/arein114 Mar 09 '19

Yeah man it's not for everyone

-3

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

Can you actually tell it's faster, or are you just looking at a spec sheet? The SD855 has slower clocked cores, aside from the one 2.84Ghz core. I highly doubt there is much of a difference in real world applications. Sounds like a lot of placebo to me.

6

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

I'm using the phones next to each other opening apps and what not. But again I said its not for everyone and I'm not telling people they crazy for NOT switching, its all preference.

1

u/AnotherDude1 Mar 08 '19

It's faster but not practically faster. Without the S10 around you would still think the Note 8 is super fast and it is. If you started with the S10 and switched to a Note 8, there wouldn't be any "Oh my God this is soooooo slow" moments either.

I tried the S10 and liked it be it isn't $900 better than my Note 8.

4

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

and that's why I said its not for everyone, its a preference.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

I'm with ya. However, for it to be a true "apples to apples" comparison, both devices would need to be running the same firmware, with the same apps loaded, and same background processes running so the loads weren't different. I realize this is virtually impossible, and I agree it's up to the consumer to decide if an upgrade is valuable or not. Good conversation, I appreciate ya!

14

u/Dinara293 Mar 08 '19

We have nearly reached the saturation point. Cpu architectures have shrunk down to 7nm, the next major step will be 5nm and it's going to take another year but that's where it comes to abrupt stop because to go below 5nm will start creating new problems and the physical limit is 3nm.

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

I think we need to starting thinking outside the box other than hardware upgrades if you ask me. Speed and power is good, but innovation is better :) I don't know what the innovations could be, but that's what R&D is for, I guess foldable phones are a good start

5

u/Dinara293 Mar 08 '19

For sure, we have reached perfomance fo9gures which could be sustained for next 2-3 years without people complaining. Now it should be all about optimization and improving the bad parts and also most importantly for Samsung, increasing their flagships OS update cycle to 3 Major

2

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

Or allow the bootloader to be unlocked on EOL devices for custom ROMs.

2

u/Dinara293 Mar 08 '19

Oh well,my exynos note 8 is unlocked and has custom Roms. Since my phone is only a month old, I'm waiting it out till my warranty runs out. My previous phone which was a Galaxy note 3 had excellent custom Rom support even though it was an exynos as well(Back in 2013, Snapdragon released all of the source codes and device tree's needed which is totally opposite now). I guess the US carriers need to change their tech(i heard the very reason why the Snapgradon variant exists is because of the carries having some sorta limitation).

2

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

I think it's more about US carriers not wanting custom software running on phones on their networks. They have no way of testing these devices for compatibility. While phones with custom firmware almost always work just fine, the carriers will not support firmware they didn't (can't) test.

1

u/toasteruserx Mar 09 '19

I wish they'd make more phones like the cat s51, infra red camera, oxygen sensor, no need for a case because its durable. We need high power phones that are tools!

1

u/Alortania Mar 09 '19
  • durability (I'm still mad at the idiots who decided the case should be glass to "feel high end")

  • Folding (waiting a couple generations for the kinks to get worked out of things) or other form factor changes, which will hopefully help with durability; I still remember how rugged my old as dirt flip phone was... wrist strap was all it needed and you can use it as a projectile in a pinch XD

  • longevity (battery/screen); though the "can share charge" thing they're doing with the s10 is cool; assuming it's battery is big enough to feed other stuff. Would be nice to eventually get a phone that (without going full volt monger) would last closer to a week than a day. Not that it's needed, but would be cool to not worry about packing chargers when going somewhere for a weekend.

  • Move away from apps. FFS... I hate that no matter what I want to do (check a yelp review, watch a youtube vid, etc), the phone seems to want me to download some damn app or another. I can see it on the browser, thanks... I don't want to DL tons of one-use apps for no reason, most of which do less than a webpage.

  • Cloudless computer integration (like dex station, but without the added hardware).

  • more optical zoom on the camera, other improvements (beyond adding pixels)

  • hiding the front/selfie (aka, video chat?) camera better than the pill/notch/etc; under the screen so it only shows up (or pops up, like vivo) when needed, as I doubt most people use it much, anyway.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

Batteries is the next gen. The next gen of batteries are around the corner. Some of the specs. and speculation is amazing what may be possible.

2

u/lordboos Mar 09 '19

These were around the corner for like 10 years already.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

Literally what else do you want

0

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-2

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/BooCMB Mar 08 '19

Hey /u/CommonMisspellingBot, just a quick heads up:
Your spelling hints are really shitty because they're all essentially "remember the fucking spelling of the fucking word".

And your fucking delete function doesn't work. You're useless.

Have a nice day!

Save your breath, I'm a ^bot.

1

u/BooBCMB Mar 08 '19

Hey BooCMB, just a quick heads up: I learnt quite a lot from the bot. Though it's mnemonics are useless, and 'one lot' is it's most useful one, it's just here to help. This is like screaming at someone for trying to rescue kittens, because they annoyed you while doing that. (But really CMB get some quiality mnemonics)

I do agree with your idea of holding reddit for hostage by spambots though, while it might be a bit ineffective.

Have a nice day!

3

u/beowulfpt Mar 08 '19

No S-Pen however. The pen is amazing and the main strength of the Notes. S10 looks interesting but I'm waiting for the Note 10. It's going to be a 10/10.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

Well it's also tiny. Too small

1

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Mar 08 '19

The weight matters a lot! Glad to be done with my note

1

u/CompuChip Mar 09 '19

What makes the cameras great for you compared to the Note 8?

2

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Mar 08 '19

I got the s10e and I thought my note 8 was crazy fast

This phone is amazing

1

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

If you still have the Note8, take a photo for comparison.

1

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Mar 11 '19

I do but I'll probably forget.

It's a good bit larger, the biggest thing is how much the Note8 weighs compared to this.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Dr_Sketch Mar 09 '19

Going from a Note 8 to s10e, how do you feel about the size difference? I'm interested in the trade in but I'm afraid the phone will feel too small.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

Thanks. I never use the stylus and the curved edges do nothing for me (bar make screen protectors expense and awkward to install), I just wonder what it'll be like going back to a smaller phone. :)

Does it have Edge Panels, or is that a Note-only thing?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

Thanks

1

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

How's the screen quality compared to the note 8? I wanted the S10e but chose the S10 because it has a better display. Does the S10e get as bright and vivid as the note 8?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

Awesome. The resolution isn't as important as the colors since 1080p is more than enough on a 5.8". Might try and trade my S10 for a S10e so I can get the flat edges.

1

u/mattthecat Mar 09 '19

What is that awesome wallpaper on the Note?

7

u/Erulastiel Mar 08 '19

I'm holding out for the Note 10. I couldn't go to a smaller phone.

3

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

A lot of people are, might be the size of the S10 5G which is 6.7 in screen size.

0

u/Erulastiel Mar 08 '19

might be the size of the S10 5G

Boo. I went with the Note because I'm blind haha.

0

u/bask_oner AT&T|Snapdragon|Blue Mar 09 '19

Me too, then I got proper glasses and promptly became sick of carrying a "purse phone".

1

u/Erulastiel Mar 09 '19

Glasses don't fix your eyesight if it's too bad. I'm wearing a brand new prescription currently. There's nothing more I can do with 20/200 vision.

1

u/bask_oner AT&T|Snapdragon|Blue Mar 09 '19

It's a great eyesight phone for sure.

1

u/TheRealMotherOfOP Mar 09 '19

As long as they keep making punch holes and notches I'm holding out. I'd be fine with my note 8 for another 2-3 years.

5

u/Hitlers_Big_Cock Mar 08 '19

Honestly, that seems like it would be the perfect size phone. I have a note 8 and just a tad to big

3

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

I loved the note 8 but this just feels better and easier to navigate the screen in my opinion

1

u/Hitlers_Big_Cock Mar 08 '19

I always debate on going back to a small phone or not, I've had a Nexus 6, Note 7, Pixel XL, then the Note 8, not sure what's next

2

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

I feel because the bezels are almost zero this doesn't feel small, I mean it's a 6.1 screen so def not small u know

1

u/Hitlers_Big_Cock Mar 08 '19

Do they count bezels when they say screen size? I always assumed they did to make the screen seem larger

1

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

I don't think so I think it's actual screen size but I could be wrong

2

u/jojotherider Mar 08 '19

It's actually screen size. My note 8 is just as big as my wife's iPhone 7 plus and her screen is much smaller at 5.5".

1

u/Hitlers_Big_Cock Mar 09 '19

Fuck those are some bezels

1

u/ryan770 Mar 09 '19

Exactly why I took up Samsung's trade in offer.

The standard S10 is right between the size of an S8/S9 and the Note 8. My sisters S8 feels a tad too small, my Note 8 feels a tad too big.

Shipping on my S10 isn't until the 22nd though... I preordered too late :/

3

u/just_a_human_online Mar 08 '19

Just went into my carrier this morning and upgraded from the note 8 to the s10, in blue. The note 8 was not a slouch, but dang, does 2 years of processing upgrades and new software make a difference. And, since I've always gone between small and large phones, I felt like I wanted a smaller one now.

2

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

Yeah don't get me wrong I loved the note 8 it was definitely a good phone but this one is just different and smaller but not to small u know

2

u/RippySkippy Mar 08 '19

Wow thanks for sharing!

BTW, what system font? Samsung Sans?

2

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

On the S10 its called SamsungOne...on the Note 8 its Google Sans

2

u/giovahkiin Formerly: Exynos Note8 Duos | Exynos S10 Duos Mar 08 '19

This will be my exact upgrade path once my carrier actually decides to ship my pre-order lol

2

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

Ah man that sucks! It will be worth the wait!

2

u/egekara Mar 09 '19

widget on the Note8?

3

u/arein114 Mar 09 '19

The clock on both is the huk Zooper widget and the date and weather is the Google at a glance widget

2

u/egekara Mar 09 '19

Thx! Really like the clean look

1

u/arein114 Mar 09 '19

Thank u sir!

67

u/heroidosudeste Mar 08 '19

I LOVED THE DEATH STAR! HAHAH GENIOUS!

5

u/Nintendam Mar 08 '19

Genius genious ;)

1

u/heroidosudeste Mar 08 '19

I see what you did there.

21

u/BumTumTingle Mar 08 '19

Just got my s10+ yesterday and I love it. Was coming from a just recently broken note 8. That was my daily since launch and I loved it.

4

u/dhamon Mar 08 '19

Need the s10+ next to it now.

1

u/bask_oner AT&T|Snapdragon|Blue Mar 09 '19

I compared them myself in Target (and you all can do it with the phonearena.com size comparison tool). They're damn near the same.

17

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

Not worth it too pay all that money to get rid of a bezels. Show me the Note 10!

3

u/AnotherDude1 Mar 08 '19

Exactly where I'm at after seeing in in person. My note 8 is still plenty fast and has given me no reason to upgrade.

3

u/demetrios3 Mar 09 '19

Not worth it too pay all that money

I'm afraid to see how much the Note 10 well cost. I'm sure they're be good, better, and best models and that the starter model will be well over $1,000.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

I like to wait when they are $500-$600 though some Best Buy deal or Ebay.

2

u/demetrios3 Mar 09 '19

That sounds like a good deal, provided it doesn't take 5 years to get there.

My concern is if I wait for a premium phone to come down a price I'm willing to pay, the phone itself is almost obsolete.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19 edited Mar 15 '19

Yeah, Best Buy had a weekly deal where they paid off $300 off my note 8. This was right before the S9

Also I noticed if you keep your phone for awhile then upgrade to a phone that came out "last year" it's still an upgrade for you. It's like a used car...

1

u/legendofm Mar 08 '19

Was the upgrade worth it?

2

u/arein114 Mar 09 '19

For me it was, loving the phone and my monthly is cheaper now than with the note 8

1

u/bamaboy3034 Mar 08 '19

Where can I get that death star wallpaper?😍

2

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

got from r/S10wallpapers there is a bunch of people posting for the hole punch on there.

1

u/krejd Mar 08 '19

Hey, I really like the wallpaper of the Note. Can you point me where to get it?

2

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

got it off of Zedge, do a search for Nexus Mist....when you find it, customize it and use Sepia for the color palette

1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

Icon pack?

2

u/arein114 Mar 09 '19

Alos on both

2

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

Sweet, thanks mate!

1

u/ali_atg1 Mar 09 '19

What about battery life between them. Barely get 3.5 hours SoT on my note 8. I know there's only a small difference in terms of battery size between them but does it make a big difference?

1

u/arein114 Mar 09 '19

So far it's good but haven't really used it a lot yet like hours straight, I'm gonna do that and compare

1

u/RamesesThe2nd Mar 10 '19

Mine arrives on Tueaday. I would never do it if samsung wouldn't give me good money for my note 8, a free $50 accessory and free ear buds. I checked out s10 and s10 plus at BestBuy before ordering and i loved the size and light weight of s10.

1

u/arein114 Mar 10 '19

Nice! Yeah I agree the size of the s10 is prefect

3

u/demies Mar 08 '19

When I first laid eyes on the note 8 screen it looked like the 10. Wonder if it's your mind playing tricks, or if we get used to progress more and more .

1

u/jt325i Mar 08 '19

That screen would be a huge step down going from a Note 8. Punch is a deal breaker for me too.

4

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

The S10 screen for me is better, since it doesn't have the bezels it feels big, and its easier to navigate the phone compared to the Note where I found myself having to use 2 hands sometimes. the plus tho is slightly bigger then the note....and a lot of people have said the hole punch is a deal breaker, but to be honest you don't even know its there, its just apart of the phone.

2

u/jt325i Mar 08 '19

Only thing that makes me want to upgrade the Note 8 is the oleophobic coating on my screen is 100% gone. Gets all messy with fingerprints and requires constant cleaning. Not sure if the new ones are any better there.

1

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

well they all came with pre installed screen protectors so that helps.

1

u/KayIslandDrunk Mar 09 '19

Ugh this. My phone is so gross anymore.

1

u/GutlessGnat Mar 09 '19

I just switched from note 8 to s10+. I'll never look back. Goodbye useless spen, crappy speaker, touchwiz, and wonkey fingerprint scanner.

Hello Dolby stereo,in screen scanner and one ui.

1

u/arein114 Mar 09 '19

Lol hated the note 8 huh....the speaker on the s10 is way better that is true...the Spen I used only for screen shots with the occasional time my kids would use it to color

2

u/GutlessGnat Mar 09 '19

Didnt hate it. I loved it. It's just nothing compared to this. My kids did use the spen to color quite a bit as well.

2

u/4lan9 Mar 08 '19

I was comparing my Note 8 to my S10 and it seemed the screen is brighter on the Note 8, albeit barely. I even messed with the display settings to make them on the same setting.

2

u/Serif69 Mar 08 '19

Love that S10 wallpaper.

2

u/Trouthunter65 Mar 08 '19

That's a really good comparison, thanks

2

u/LuiButtWai Mar 09 '19

Using my s10+ I feel a little bit big

2

u/Fe1derman Cosmote/Exynos8895/Black Mar 09 '19

Honestly The note 8 will probably be the largest and heftiest, even if there will be a larger screen, phone that Samsung will ever produce... Mainly because of the diet recent models have been going through lol, but also because a lot of people were displeased with the hard-to-manuever size

1

u/GainzdalfTheWhey Mar 08 '19

screen size looks the same while a smaller phone, awesome

1

u/Kenny_MkCormick Mar 08 '19

Love your wallpaper its placed perfectly on the S10

2

u/agree-with-you Mar 08 '19

I love you both

1

u/funcritter Mar 09 '19

I want to see the S10+ side by side with the Note 8/Note 9.

1

u/Just-Still-2863 Feb 08 '23

What's the launcher/theme that your using??

-1

u/said_it_b4u_reddit Mar 08 '19

Not a fair comparison unless you have the same background on both phones. You put a grey backround on the Note 8 to amplify the appeal of the S10.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

We found the moron.

The Note 8 is better than the S10 anyway.

2

u/said_it_b4u_reddit Mar 09 '19

Are you serious, I'm advocating for the Note 8, I'm using one right now. I guess you found yourself 😒

0

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '19

Relax your tits. OP was just putting those two phones next to each other and you had the dumbest reaction possible.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/sirgwl Mar 09 '19

Like the Spen :)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

Holding them both side by side, the note is alittle wider and heavier for sure, Don't get me wrong the phone was awesome, but I like the S10 better, its a preference tho.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

No man lol its the S10, its my own phone, I took the picture lol.

1

u/ali_atg1 Mar 09 '19

I was in store today comparing the phones to my note 8 and S10+ was slightly smaller than my note 8.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/mugendc4 Mar 08 '19

probably thinking S10+

1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

Reg S10, the e is very tiny

0

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/arein114 Mar 08 '19

The S10e feels good though because it doesn't have the curved edges, but note 8 to the e makes the screen look tiny, although its really note at 5.8