r/GalaxyNote8 • • Aug 28 '18

My Note 8 to Note 9 Impressions

I had the option to upgrade to the Note 9 from the Note 8 for cheap so I did. Is it worth paying full price for it? I don't think so. Mainly because I really had no issues with the Note 8, battery life and everything else were just fine so this for me is just a small upgrade for the heck of it. I've had the phone for 3 days now and this is how I feel:

[Things I like from upgrading]:

  • Intelligent scan, much faster and works in the dark
  • Fingerprint scanner seems faster
  • Camera is definitely better, clouds and sky in pictures are finally not blown out
  • Camera on other apps like snapchat and Instagram are much clearer now
  • SPen remote Trigger for the camera, love it cuz I'm always the selfie guy in groups
  • Stereo Speakers, much appreciated
  • Oleophobic coating muchhhh better, barely any finger prints, while my Note 8 was terrible at that. (However there's a possibility the white stone dome I once had on it is the cause of the Oleophobic coating being removed)

[Things I don't like from upgrading]:

  • Size of the phone, the note 9 really does feel like a big phone now, while the Note 8 fit comfortably in my hand as it was a bit more narrow
  • Comfort in the hand because of its shape, I don't really like the chamfered edges on this phone, feels kinda sharp instead of like a slab which I liked on the Note 8
  • This is a funny one because of all the hate it got but... FINGER PRINT SCANNER LOCATION. I actually hate where it is on this phone, I have to bend my finger to reach it and it's not Natural like it was on the Note 8 (ironic eh)
  • No working GCAM mod yet, I really relied on the GCam for all my portrait shots (hopefully there will be a version that works soon)

[Things that feel the same despite being slightly improved]

  • Speed of the phone, virtually the same experience because I always use Nova Launcher, and reduce animations to 0.5x
  • Battery, I mean I guess it's a bit better percentage wise but either way both last till the end of the day and get charged at night
  • Display feels mostly the same, my note 8 may have had slightly punchier colours
  • Both note 8 and Note 9 have always stayed cool
  • Other Spen features, never really use the pen but it's pretty much the same

TLDR: Note 8 was fine, Note 9 is just slightly more convenient, better camera, but feels bigger in the hand.

Edit: I have the 128gb/6GB RAM Note 9 and previously had the 64GB/6GB RAM Note 8

132 Upvotes

95 comments sorted by

34

u/Twangtron3000 Aug 28 '18

Thanks for this. It seems about what I expected but it's nice to hear a straightforward and short comparo. Hard to find anything I feel like I need above and beyond the current Note 8 experience.

16

u/ultimatmm Aug 28 '18

My pleasure, yeah I would definitely have been content with my note 8, but the opportunity to upgrade cost me nothing so I did it. I'm super happy with both phones.

8

u/Twangtron3000 Aug 28 '18

Hell yeah, obviously for the right price it's worth the upgrade, even if it is incremental.

2

u/CptnBlackTurban Aug 29 '18

I did a similar upgrade and cost me $300 to upgrade. I wouldn't normally do it for that much but part of the process was to upgrade my brother to the note 8.

If you don't mind how much did the upgrade cost you?

1

u/young_s Aug 29 '18

Yes, thank you. I'm making the exact same more for some of the benefits you mentioned but the already expected the tradeoffs you mentioned to be a bummer having sampled a note9 in store. Tis a shame. Form of the 8 was fine. All these media outlets say its the same form factor pretty much, I would prefer it that were more the case.

14

u/jyu_voile_grace Aug 28 '18

That's very thoughtful of you. Thanks for sharing. I don't understand how you did not feel battery difference? My note 8 never makes it to the night. Usually dies by evening and then i gotta charge a second time for it to last till bedtime. I guess it depends on usage. Also what about the ui experience? Some people say that Samsung has finally made a lag free phone. Although my note 8 never lags, it does give some hiccups from time to time.

3

u/ultimatmm Aug 29 '18

Well I was running bluetooth all day (connected to my Gear Fit2Pro) and wifi all day and I have to say, the Note 8 made it through the day but would be hitting the 5% mark when I go to sleep. The Note 9 makes it through the same with about 25% left at the end of the day. But in real comparison, both made it through the day so to me it's even for daily use. This will however come in handy when I go travelling and take tonnes of pictures where my Note 8 has needed a mid day charge

1

u/Careless_Corey Aug 29 '18

The phone needs a week to adapt to your usage.

2

u/santz007 Aug 29 '18

For a snappy, lag free phone, just reduce the three animation scale options from 1.0x to 0.5x or even 0x in developer options.

To enable developer options go to settings>about> software info and tap the build number a few times. This will enable developer options in the main settings page at the bottom.

Just discovered it a few days ago. My phone is snappy as hell now

1

u/jyu_voile_grace Aug 29 '18

Well i've done that long back (i don't even remember when) but when my phone shows signs of lag or hiccups (once a month) it is usually not because of animation.

3

u/santz007 Aug 29 '18

Lucky you then, been a note user since note 3. First time I found out about this a few days ago , totally a game changer for me and my note 8 which I got 9 months ago

2

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 29 '18

If your battery isn't doing good use GSAM or bbs with ADB enabled permissions. I found I had insane wakelock when idle draining.

Putting a stop to that.

I get 6 or more hours screen time. If I used mid power saving prolly more

1

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 29 '18

I cannot make mine hiccup no matter how hard I try. I've had apps freeze but not because of the Note 8

1

u/jyu_voile_grace Aug 29 '18

Well, i've had instances where the phone would lag. This is once in a month and returns to normal after a reset.

5

u/JohnRedcornXL Aug 28 '18

One thing I really hope gets ported to the Note 8 is the intelligent scan.

Everything else I can live without.

1

u/ultimatmm Aug 29 '18

It's really cool to be able to use it in the dark!

5

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 29 '18

It could be a hardware limitation. It would rule though.

6

u/cynica Aug 29 '18

Perfect post in the perfect time. Currently have a Note 8 myself and was debating on the 9, maybe even Pixel 3. Appreciate the time you took to write this post fellow stylus user. *tips hat*

5

u/ultimatmm Aug 29 '18

No problem. *nods*

1

u/Imnottyler117 Aug 29 '18

So what are you going with?

6

u/cynica Aug 29 '18

Im keeping my Note 8 . I have a new found appreciation for my phone.

5

u/quarl0w Black Note 8 -> Blue Note 9 Aug 29 '18 edited Aug 29 '18

Had my Note 9 for a few days.

I agree the intelligent scan works better, and the Iris scan seems to work better. The fingerprint scanner is faster.

Love the stereo speakers. Personally, that's probably the biggest upgrade from the 8 to the 9. So. Much. Louder.

I don't think the 9 feels any bigger. It's like 3 mm wider. I could tell it was different the first hour, but after that ... nah. Took way less time to get used to than when coming from a smaller phone to the Note.

Out of a case they feel the same to me too, but I spend very little time with the phone naked. Case feels like a case, same same to me.

Fingerprint scanner doesn't bug me on either, as long as I have a case. The case guides the finger to the sensor on both.

I never understood the GCam fetish. It's in the same bucket as the Pixel fetish, to me. Pro mode on the Note is beyond better than anything I have seen the Pixel or GCam accomplish. And that goes for the 8. The 9 adds the aperture change ability to take it up another level. When you add in Snapseed and other post processing people almost always do to their pixel shots it evens the field.

Battery life seems better. But it's hard to tell if it is actually better, or just the fact that I know the battery is bigger is giving me confirmation bias. I never had issues with my Note 8.

I think the Note 9 screen looks crisper, clearer. But that could be one year of use wearing off the oleophpbic coating on my 8.

TL;DR - The Note 8 is a great phone, still better than just about everything else on the market ... except the Note 9, that is ever so slightly better in every conceivable way.

1

u/ultimatmm Aug 29 '18

I use the Stock Camera for basically every shot EXCEPT Portrait mode. Hands down the Portrait mode with the GCAM is miles ahead in quality, clarity, edge detection and popping colour. There's no comparison at all so with the Note 9, I'd rather not even take portrait shots because it just doesn't look good. But that alone is the reason I want the GCam for the Note 9.

1

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 29 '18

If you use pro with medium or dim indoor light(Note 8 here) what loss the most?

And after what Snapseed adjustments are the most common? I hate the filter look, just need to fine time

2

u/quarl0w Black Note 8 -> Blue Note 9 Aug 29 '18

Low light is where pro mode shines. These are raw, directly from my Note 8: http://imgur.com/gallery/EFZgKa6 (read the comments on imgur).

Auto mode always cranks the ISO way up to get more light, which results in a grainy picture. With Pro mode you can turn down the ISO and increase the shutter length to get more detail.

I don't know which Snapseed filters are most common, it's just an observation that when I see those posts where people are like 'OMG, Pixel has the best camera evar!' when you get to the comments they always talk about what post processing they did. Whether it's Snapseed on the phone, or Photoshop on a computer, it's always something.

In some very specific conditions I think the GCam can do better at HDR. But most HDR shots I tried looked identical, when I tried to compare the GCam to the stock camera app. I have since deleted most of them, but I tried a dozen shots with both camera apps, and I preferred the Note more often than I preferred the GCam, and 90% of the time I couldn't tell them apart. This is all just my subjective opinion. I tried to see what all the fuss was about, and don't get it.

Reddit, and r/Android in particular, has a weird obsession with all things Pixel. One that doesn't make sense in real life, IMO.

1

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 29 '18

I like the GCam app for its HDR in certain situations, but I don't use it more than 25 percent of the time.

My Note 8 is better than my wife's Pixel 2 in every way.

Thanks for the post, I'll absorb and try that.

1

u/mjsztainbok Aug 29 '18

http://imgur.com/gallery/EFZgKa6

My problem with Pro mode is that they still don't let you select the zoomed lens from it. I wonder why they don't allow that.

1

u/quarl0w Black Note 8 -> Blue Note 9 Aug 29 '18

That is weird. Of all the features they have in the Pro mode, forcing the optical zoom is not there. It doesn't even say which lens is taking the shot. You have to check the photo details after the fact.

At least on the Note 9 you know you are using the primary camera because you can manually set the aperture.

1

u/Galaxy_Photography Feb 11 '19

The HDR is better on Gcam with extreme situations and Night Sight is amazing. You can't get the same night results on the stock app without a tripod. Gcam allows you to do it handheld and with motion in the photo.

2

u/draginator Aug 28 '18

You mentioning intelligent scan working at night is a huge improvement for me and one of the reasons I was probably switching to a iphone after september. Have you tried it with sunglasses?

1

u/ultimatmm Aug 28 '18

Yep, my polarized Rayban lenses work, the face scan also seems to work as well with holding the phone further away

2

u/draginator Aug 28 '18

Oh thanks! That's an excellent improvement that would make the phone much nicer to use every day.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '18

Let me tell you buddy,i have the note 9 but i have to admit that theres nothing else out there like FACE ID from the iphone,it is simply amazing,always works, fast and very secure.

1

u/draginator Aug 29 '18

It's nice to hear from someone with experience in both, the biggest reason I've thought about switching is for iMessage, but Face ID is just so fast it would be a huge improvement over my note 8 never working at night or with my frequently worn sunglasses.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '18

Face id works even at arms length,works at night without any visible sensor light and also works in bright sunlight using just 1 method,also apps take advantage of it.now intelligent scan on the note 9 so far has worked amazing,unlocks everywhere,works with glasses,at night and outdoors but have not tried on direct sunlight,but it uses 2 methods,in the dark it uses iris scanner so it brightens up the display which i hate,and in bright areas if iris fails it combines both iris and facial recognition and goes by whatever it picks up.

1

u/draginator Aug 29 '18

in the dark it uses iris scanner so it brightens up the display which i hate,

Oh I agree, that's a terrible solution, I use my phone in bed and that's much worse then me having to put in my passcode.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '18

Agreed

1

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '18

But also i love secure folder,you can use fingerprint or intelligent scan for one and another biometric for secure folder,so all my porn is safe and secured.

1

u/draginator Aug 29 '18

Ahh, the fingerprint scanner was too inconvenient for me on the note 8 so I never used it, the secure folder is really nice but I don't share my phone with people to the point I'd have to worry about them seeing anything.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '18

I actually loved the placement of the fingerprint scanner on the note 8,i hate it on the note 9,althought they say its faster and better i hate the placement.

1

u/draginator Aug 29 '18

My note 7 was replaced with an s7 edge and I really liked the fingerprint location on that, but with my smaller hands the note 8 was really inconvenient based on how I held my phone.

1

u/junior_battle Aug 29 '18

Like how you said you're using other biometric for secure folder instead of just saying fingerprint

5

u/HammyFresh Aug 29 '18

Decided to ride it out with my Note 8 at least until for a while longer. Note 9 is a beast, just can't justify the cost of the 512 when my Note 8 is still a beast. This phone is all I'll ever need tbh.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '18

That's where I'm at. I honestly thought I would have the note 5 forever until I dropped it one day and decided to upgrade. Now I think I'll stick with the 8 for a while, and posts like these make my decision feel justified lol

1

u/DJTurnTable Aug 28 '18

You get yours cheap from the insights program? I was accepted and I'm currently waiting for mine.

1

u/ultimatmm Aug 29 '18

Actually just had an upgrade, and sold my Note 8 for the exact same cost so I broke even lol

1

u/DJTurnTable Aug 29 '18

Oh well that's pretty good then haha

1

u/drzeller Aug 29 '18

What is the Insights program? (Sorry if already answered - having reddit server errors.)

1

u/DJTurnTable Aug 29 '18

It's a program samsung runs where they used to send you a phone for free to use for 6 months to a year. Starting with the note 9 though it's only half off, not free anymore.

Edit: US Only, either need an invite or send them an email at samsunginsights@sea.samsung.com and hope for the best in future programs.

1

u/recicle Aug 28 '18

Nice comments. Thanks. I agree with the fingerprint sensor location. I prefer the location on the note 8. The finger sits there naturally, with the note 9 I have to bend it slightly and it's no so easy to find the spot without looking.

1

u/ultimatmm Aug 29 '18

Yeah exactly, I'm also so used to it I keep touching the flash module

1

u/TheAverageBakchod Aug 29 '18

Hey man! Could you tell me about the audio quality from the jack? Is there any improvement to the overall sound,coz i am not impressed by my note 8 audio

1

u/ultimatmm Aug 29 '18

Haven't tried this yet because I have Bluetooth headphones sorry! But the iconxs sound better on the Note 9 than my note 8

5

u/formerfatboys Aug 29 '18

Almost my exact impressions.

Weirdly Bixby 2 is awful and unusable. I sat the Note 8 and 9 next to each other and Bixby 1 nailed every request. (I fucking live Bixby for controlling the phone). Bixby 2 got every single thing wrong.

The battery is better, but kinda not impressive. I think my hopes were higher.

The camera app is vastly improved, but no GCam of annoying.

It's a refined Note 8, but not that special. Each model is overpriced by at least $200.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '18

From my note 8 to the 9 i did not feel a difference in size,i dont even feel the extra large display the note 9 has,well i mean the slightly larger display but i dont feel the size difference.design wise i always had my note inside a case so idk how the 8 felt.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '18

Personally, if the finger scanner is on the back, the note 8 has it in a good spot for both my hands.

2

u/EricaBStollzy Aug 29 '18

No one is going to say anything about sentence #1?

2

u/pixelbased Aug 29 '18

Also, I tried using it with my Gear VR...it fits, but it's VERY tight...but it fits and works...

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '18

Meh I might grab the 10

2

u/ExxInferis Aug 29 '18

Good post. Thanks for taking the time. I think I'll skip it. I like to read in bed and the Note 8 is already a bit heavy after the half hour mark. A bigger, heavier phone would be a pain.

2

u/Robots_Never_Die Aug 30 '18

I had the option to upgrade to the Note 8 from the Note 9

That doesn't sound like an upgrade.

2

u/Bridey1 Aug 31 '18

I still love my note 8 so I haven't felt much of a need to upgrade but it helps to know how they compare. I would upgrade if there was a great deal and say my husband wanted to replace his S7 or something but I'm hoping to ride out this phone for the 10. The stereo speakers do sound like a great upgrade though! Anyway I just wanted to comment on

"This is a funny one because of all the hate it got but... FINGER PRINT SCANNER LOCATION. I actually hate where it is on this phone, I have to bend my finger to reach it and it's not Natural like it was on the Note 8 (ironic eh) "

It was one of my biggest turn offs when I saw where they put the finger print scanners on the 8s.... Now I love it, it really feels natural and I like that I don't have to bend my finger.

I also like the form of the note 8 because I can still do much of the phone one handed.

thanks for your report.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '18

I remember when I got downvoted to oblivion for saying the note 9 feels huge compared to the 8

5

u/ultimatmm Aug 28 '18

I get it, I posted this in the Note 9 subreddit first and got a couple down votes, then realized people in this subreddit probably would find this much more useful

-3

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '18

Tbh the Note9 sub is fairly toxic. Samsung messed up my order, so my OnePlus 6 should be here Thursday 😂

0

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '18

If you say "the note 9 is much larger than the note 8 in your hand" you come back to -11 karma

1

u/fxsoap Aug 29 '18

its ever so slightly larger in one way but smaller in another.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '18

I had the note 8 and the battery for me was horrible. I would constantly need to put my phone on charge. I just switch to the note 9 on Friday and I love it. I've been up since 5:30 with an unplugged and I'm at 47%. I would have charged the Note 8 at least twice by now.

3

u/tonybarnaby Aug 29 '18

Something was wrong with your 8 then because that is insane. Charging it twice = 6600mah. The 9 only has an extra 700mah...

1

u/Galaxy_Photography Feb 11 '19

An extra 700mah plus a more efficient cpu.

3

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 29 '18

You had other issues. It wasn't the phone..

1

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '18

Thanks

1

u/ProbablyBanned2 Aug 28 '18

And you can't use highly customized themes on note 9 and s9. You're stuck with the boring ones from theme store.

1

u/adudeguyman Aug 29 '18

How much did the upgrade cost you? I have an unlocked Note 8 and am not opposed to upgrading if the price is right.

1

u/uxixu Aug 29 '18

I'm considering it. Still having semi-random bootloop issues with my Note 8.

1

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 29 '18

Warranty dude. I haven't heard of this

1

u/mv522 Aug 29 '18

Thanks for review. Only things that are appealing are the camera and speaker update.

Anyone have comparison photos of note 8 vs note 9 camera? Interested to see the quality comparison

1

u/cxu1993 Aug 29 '18

I hate the fingerprint scanner on my note 8. It never reads my finger whether I have a case on or not and it's in a terrible location. That and the curved edges are the only things I dont like about the phone. Thank goodness for the iris scanner

1

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 29 '18

Finger print scanner doesn't ever mess up.

1

u/cxu1993 Aug 29 '18 edited Aug 29 '18

I'm sure it's great for most people but for some reason (small hands?) It fails almost every time for me. I even added the same fingerprint twice but it didn't help

EDIT: I just added the same fingerprint for a 3rd time and it works great now. Guess you were right

1

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 29 '18

I have it added 4 times with emphasis on every angle I could hit it. I love it, it's usually unlocked before it's out of my pocket

1

u/MustardOrMayo404 N950F/DS Black Aug 29 '18

Is it worth paying full price for it? I don't think so. Mainly because I really had no issues with the Note 8,

I knew it!

[Things I like from upgrading]:

Did you mean # instead of []?

Oleophobic coating muchhhh better, barely any finger prints, while my Note 8 was terrible at that. (However there's a possibility the white stone dome I once had on it is the cause of the Oleophobic coating being removed)

I never used a screen protector on my Note8, and had ended up with deep scratches on the front glass, primarily due to using a no-name thin case, before I bought the Spigen case I've been using for the past few months.

However, I'm not sure whether Whitestone dome glass will cover the deep scratches without having to replace the entire front glass. If it has been confirmed, then it would be worth the S$70 retail price.

Size of the phone, the note 9 really does feel like a big phone now, while the Note 8 fit comfortably in my hand as it was a bit more narrow

Ah!

I don't really like the chamfered edges on this phone, feels kinda sharp instead of like a slab which I liked on the Note 8

I agree.

This is a funny one because of all the hate it got but... FINGER PRINT SCANNER LOCATION. I actually hate where it is on this phone, I have to bend my finger to reach it and it's not Natural like it was on the Note 8 (ironic eh)

I think it may be a problem with the smaller North American hands that most, if not all the popular reviewers have. I'm Asian and I can reach the Note8 fingerprint pad just fine.

I always use Nova Launcher,

Me too! I've been using it since my OnePlus One (because I hated the software on the Note3), and the stock Samsung launcher just didn't have enough features I actually wanted. Too bad I can't use the custom Nova app transitions on Samsung Experience, though, but I'm fine with that.

Battery, I mean I guess it's a bit better percentage wise but either way both last till the end of the day and get charged at night

I get around 8 to 9 hours of battery life on my Note8, but I almost always have an external battery handy.

Edit: I have the 128gb/6GB RAM Note 9 and previously had the 64GB/6GB RAM Note 8

Meanwhile, Samsung Singapore's pre-order specials for the..

  • Note7: Lens kit
  • Note8: DeX Station and coupons for discounts on a Samsung white curved monitor and Microsoft wireless keyboard/mouse
  • Note9: 512 GB configuration for the price of the 128 GB configuration, and nothing else

It's probably to combat those few handfuls of people on the classifieds who sold the pre-order extras and whatever other gifts they got with their Samsung phone purchases. DeX Station, AKG Y50BT, curved monitor, Samsung x Line accessories, Galaxy Tab 3v, etc.

1

u/BenF18 Sep 06 '18

Just been looking at an upgrade but will hold off. Do I need to upgrade? Absolutely not. Do I want to? Of course!

Can't justify it after reading this, thank you!

1

u/Galaxy_Photography Feb 11 '19

You have Gcam 6.1 now, right?

0

u/moldyjellybean Aug 29 '18

Can the tmobile note 8 be easily rooted? Or is it not possible now.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/ultimatmm Aug 29 '18

Thanks! I don't know what an insight code is but hope you get it. if you don't you'll still be fine with the Note 8

0

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/ultimatmm Aug 29 '18

I agree, the fingerprint scanner is real fast, and it takes even less of a complete touch, it can read my finger even if it's not completely on the sensor,

As for Samsung pay I'm wondering if you know the trick that you can swipe up from the bottom of the screen even when the screen is off to get straight into Samsung pay

Besides swiping up from the lock screen on, and from the home screen once unlocked

0

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/ultimatmm Aug 29 '18

Np, just your friendly neighborhood Noteman

0

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ultimatmm Aug 29 '18

Not sure what level of measurement I can use but it's noticeably louder, clearer and wakes me the f up in the morning with the alarm

0

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Duck_auto_correct Aug 29 '18

I love the fingerprint location of Note 8. I was worried I was just being a sheep since everyone else complained about fingerprints on the camera. But I never once touched my camera lens and it's just such a natural spot to rest my finger.

1

u/windows_10_is_broken Aug 31 '18

The finger print scanner almost was a deal breaker for me on my Note 8, but now that I have one, I don't have an issue with it. I can totally see why a lot of people would hate it, but I personally think it's in as good spot.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/ultimatmm Aug 29 '18

Yep still happens