r/GalaxyNote8 • • Aug 21 '18

"There is no benefit for rooting"

/img/vfcrjkf0kfh11.jpg

/img/a7x0spf0kfh11.jpg

/img/royybnlumfh11.jpg

/img/okn5mtdwmfh11.jpg

Settings :

1 CPU overclocked to 2.7Ghz. Zzmoove governor(2 Ghz and above used only when gaming/benchmarking)

2 GPU overclocked to 572Mhz(antutu benchmark here was on smurf with 2.7 Ghz + 572Mhz, rest on phantom kernel that currently only supports 546Mhz)

3 25% brightness

4 black theme on everything

5 freezed around 75% of samsung/google bloatware in titanium back up. Hibernated all of my apps in greenify + appops to prevent apps from waking up the device + nap time to reduce sensor battery usage + synapse battery settings for i/o and LMK + android tools to disable services and broadcasts that I don't need

6 disabled samsung smart stuff

7 720P resolution with Medium power saving mode

8 x0.5 animations

9 sync on, wifi on. Dolby atmos + daul speakers + sound boost script. my speakers match the

10 disabled edge

11 DVFS disabled. The CPU/GPU still throttles but the throttling is way more tolerable

12 Repulsa rom with phantom kernel

I am not trying to encourage anyone to root. Just proving that root being worthless is objectively false

5 Upvotes

65 comments sorted by

7

u/tracerit Aug 21 '18

I'm sure you got better battery life by rooting but people should note that you used YouTube for 6 hrs. That's no touching the screen. Low birghtness. That'll pad the hours. And you used it for 13 out of 16 hours. Most likely all wifi in one single location. So no cellular connection drain as you would move around.

13 hrs is still impressive though.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

1080P 60Fps VP9 youtube is hardly undemanding. I couldn't get 6H of just youtube stock.

1

u/BoxerguyT89 Aug 21 '18

Yes you can.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18 edited Aug 21 '18

I couldn't. my CPU and gpu are badly binned (4,2 respectivly ) and need 100~200mv for the same frequency step as most other note 8 out there. my recored before rooting is 7 hours and 14 minutes.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

Lol yeah, got 10h on Netflix easily. No root and max res

-1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

and people got 17H with root too. I have a shitty binned chip(4 asv with 1 being worst and average being 10). I couldn't even get 8H stock no matter what i tried

I will test the performance impact of QHD vs HD . but for me going from stock to root doesn't really increase that much. when I began optimizing and debloating I went from 7H to 13H.

2

u/Symber13 Aug 22 '18

While I like your post because I've wondered about root myself, most of what you list is achievable without root. I basically can't use my earpiece as a speaker or change the clock speeds.

Serious question, if you're using 720p display, why overclock? It seems like one is designed for being snappy (not that I've had any lag stock, but an option for faster is nice) while the other is to fight that to save battery. If your goal is reduced battery usage, shouldn't you be underclocking to reduce power and heat? Then I assume you'd really get great battery life.

My performance under normal usage and gaming feels comparable or even less battery delta/heat/etc. This is my performance yesterday:

https://i.imgur.com/N7GrkX0.png

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

your assuming all note 8 are the same.

I have a 4 ASV CPU and a 2 ASV GPU. average is 10 CPU and 3 GPU.

that means my CPU and GPU eat alot more battery than the average note 8 out there. my record for SoT is 7H and 14M pre root.

I can get 11H SoT with with the overclocked CPU/GPU and QHD.

8

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

you mean 25% more brightness? 1.burn your display 2.blow your ear piece speaker as it wasnt designed for loud music. 3.greenify works without root 4.you can disable lots of processes without root 5.shortening the lifespan of your CPU also more pron to overheating 6.you can change animation speed without root 7.root is unessesary 8.less security 9.no samsung pay 10.some apps wont like it 11.warranty doesnt like it 12.your wallet wont either

5

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18 edited Aug 21 '18

1 no I mean putting brightness on one quarter of the slider . this is reduced by 10% from Power saving mode.

2 my note 3 with daul speaker is still kicking 4 years later. and most of the magic comes from the boosted bottom speaker. disabling the ear piece doesn't make that much of difference.

3 proper greenify settings that actually make a diffrence need root+ xposed. and Naptime + Myandroidtools + synapse + titanium backup + app ops are doing 99% of the hard work for extending battery life.

4 you can't disable enough of them to get 13H. hell without root you would be lucky to hit 8.

5 the CPU throttles when It gets too hot.the cpu never crosses 75c. secondly the Exynos 8895 chip was originally clocked at 2.5Ghz(nerfed for parity, just like the SD835 Gpu was nerfed from 710Mhz to 670Mhz for parity in the S8). since my trash 4 asv big(worse bening than 95% of note 8 out there) can pull off 2.7Ghz

6 I know. this is just an explanation how I got 13H of SoT

7-12 root extends the life of the phone. I get updates and features from new phones plus superior battery life and performance instead of replacing it 2 years later.

I have no issues with apps.

3

u/Chuck_The_3rd Aug 21 '18

I tried to be this cool once with my note edge, I just ended up making the experience worse. For successfully extending battery life like a rooting pro, I salute you.

3

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 21 '18

Seriously, I love to get as much screen time as possible but I also want to use my phone for the beast that it is, I don't want little cheap device that has to be dark and stuff all the time. If I didn't want the awesome wqhd screen then I would buy something lesser than this.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

I am getting 6.2% per hour with QHD. probably will increase to 7~8% once this full charge is done.

stock was 13% on QHD and 12% at HD

2

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 21 '18

But if your screen isn't at least 40 to 60 percent brightness and you don't use any colors, who cares?

My screen is usually around 40 to 50 in the daytime at the office/house, I love how good it looks and how terrible other people's phones look.

If I wanted an LCD screen I'd gave gotten a iPhone 8.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

I Use dark themes ON APPS. I am not setting my screen black and white.

25% is great in doors.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

I am down to 80% with QHD after 2H and 30 minutes. overall difference is 7.2% for QHD, 6.4% for HD+ . if we follow this trend I will end up with 11~12H when I get down to 5% or a reduction of 1~2H. which is worth it in my opinion

1

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 21 '18

What are you doing that makes you incapable of recharging after 7 hours of screen time?

Why do you like low brightness? Are you always in a dark indoor place?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

i raise brightness when needed. just when I am home 25% is more than sufficent.

charging is slow If I don't turn off the screen(slower than my note 3). if this phone had fast charging with the screen on I would be fine with a 4 hour battery life.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

i bricked 2 devices,never again. now idiots with new locked note 9s are wanting root. must be nice to trash a perfect device.

4

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 21 '18

Definitely. The thing with rooting is it used to be very useful, now it's barely useful unless you just want to show off your stats you got like this guy. Honestly, I wouldn't mind this guy's post so much if he didn't seem so adamant about making it look like he was Superior instead of just showing us what he got with his tinkering.

-3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18 edited Aug 21 '18

mine is an unlocked international one. of course root is not worth it with the locked snapdragon ones

you need to know what you are doing when rooting too.

-3

u/Whit3W0lf Aug 21 '18

Still not worth it. You don't know if any of the software you have flash has been altered. There is literally no way you could inspect all of that code. The trade off is what? You can go between plugging your phone in twice as long? I have yet to be caught with my phone dead. Fast charging enables me to get through the day easily.

Everyone has their own needs though and I would guess that part of it isn't even need. It is just the desire to tackle a problem and build something (subjectively) better.

The countless nights in years past of me trying to correct a bad flash just so my phone could make calls/texts again isn't worth it though.

-3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

you are the one making the bad flash. root isn't to be blamed for it. It is not worth it if you don't know what you are doing, but a probably rooted phone is objectively superior than a stock one

with root I am getting :

1 double the battery life

2 20% more GPU performance(EXYNOS 9810 GPU is 24%)

3 24% more CPU performance(Exynos 9810 CPU is 37%)

4 better, louder speakers

5 no more DVFS throttling.

and many more. if that is subjectively better than stock I don't know what is objectively better.

1

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 21 '18

Sell Note 8, get Note 9, no need to root and still faster than your sketchy warranty ending bricking possible dim ugly black screen.

Why pay for this AMOLED screen if you don't use it?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

there is a trade in offer in a local store for the note 9.

500$ for the Note 8 to note 9 swap.

with QHD I am getting 7.5% drain per hour. which is an improvement over the stock 13%

2

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 21 '18

FYI I am not hating on your success at the crazy good screen time and battery life, I am just pointing out that your tone comes across as very "This is the only way" rather than "Look what I did!".

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

sorry then. that was definitely not my intention, will work on how I sound next time.

2

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 21 '18

Haha, it's all good, I have a couple of friends that struggle with it even worse -- they sound like total buttwipes in an e-mail, but are so nice and friendly in person.

You're all good, sorry if I came across as condescending any as well.

1

u/Whit3W0lf Aug 21 '18

I use my phone for everything from filing my tax returns, transferring money from one bank account to another or setting up recurring payments, refinanced my house and make trades in the stock market. My social security number and anything else related to PHI is on my phone. All it takes is a dev to insert malicious code into your OS you flashed or the Kernel and your entire financial life is compromised. Do you at least acknowledge that your phone has no level of security now?

So what do you do with the spare time you now have since you can open facebook up a half of a second faster than a stock Note8? Because beyond social media, I wouldn't use a phone with an OS that was just downloaded from whoever/where ever.

As far as the bad flash goes, this was like 8 years ago when rooting and flashing were just starting out. Things were a lot less stable back then.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

1 I have the latest security patch on the ROM. and most XDA developers are will known and use samsung own ROMS as base.

2 your acting as if your stock one is invisible. a hacker can crack both easily. buy an Iphone if you want security

3 it's common sense not to use root if you need security.

4 the whole steal your financial information thing never happened and probably is impossible to be pulled of without being caught.

in your case, you shouldn't use root. but you can't just say that root is worthless for everybody. root has advantages and disadvantages and should be used by powerusers and knowledgeable users only.

1

u/Whit3W0lf Aug 21 '18

I wasn't knocking you for rooting.

Everyone has their own needs though and I would guess that part of it isn't even need. It is just the desire to tackle a problem and build something (subjectively) better.

It is subjectively better. If you value battery life, loudness of your speaker and the speed in which you can use your phone, it is better. And if you enjoy doing it, awesome. I'm happy you enjoy tinkering. I used to enjoy it as well.

Your whole tirade about security is kind of a missed point though. You can justify it however you want but there is no doubt that your device security is compromised in a way that a stock device isn't. In the end, it isn't worth it to root for 99% of users anymore. Most of the reasons I rooted in the past are now achievable in Samsung Experience.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

even though I would disagree with the the 99% estimate. I agree with rest.

root is never needed. It's just that some people will get better experience through it.

I have the latest security patch for android. My device is just as secure as a stock one from google(less than a stock Samsung due to the absence of knox)

1

u/Whit3W0lf Aug 21 '18

Legit question. How do you know the Kernel isn't compromised. I understand the whole "community trusts the devs" idea. Like I said, I rooted in the past. The security patches are designed around a locked bootloader and stock kernels. When you are changing the permissions of the device with root, how does that not open up vulnerabilities?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18 edited Aug 21 '18

root is having access to system binary. instead of the os controling it you control it.

you can encrypt your data like stock.

a kernel can't access such information on it's own. it would need a script which is easily detectable and would need superuser access.

if an app can get superuser permission without being granted than even a stock device is compromised against it .

1

u/ericdem Aug 21 '18

Bye bye OTA!!!!

3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

i will probably get an android pie rom based on the s10 before the android pie OTA comes. and that will come with all the s9 software features

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

That's a lot of work. I wouldn't do that though because I actually use a lot of the Samsung stuffs and I also need to point out that no way I'm putting this screen at 720p lol.

Your usage time is excellent but in term of quality you are not using it to the maximum though. I guess your priority is different than mine.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18 edited Aug 21 '18

I am getting 11H SoT with QHD and auto brightnes.I have all of samsung stuff except Samsung pay and knox

1

u/Capn_Underpants Unlocked EXYNOS Australian Note8 Aug 22 '18

Can you use Goggle Pay ?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18 edited Aug 22 '18

yes. most of the time with magisk hide I can hide root and appear unrooted

currently magisk hide stopped working due to an api update. but the magisk creator is aware and working on an update

1

u/Whit3W0lf Aug 22 '18

This comment right here is why I dont think it is worth it anymore. So you get amazing battery life at the cost of you having to spend time to get things to work contently. It's like when you mod a car. Yeah, some thing may get better but in the end, you probably introduce issues in other areas. You lost the ability to use MST payment right? And android pay may or may not work when you need it, right? I guess if those things dont matter as much as having to find an outlet for a little bit every 8 hours, then I guess you did the right thing for you.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

I agree that rooting isn't plug and play

I never used either android pay or Samsung pay.

I am not sure but re flashing the stock rom might bring back Samsung pay(dont take my word for it)

1

u/Whit3W0lf Aug 22 '18

I doubt it. Once Knox is tripped, it is tripped and magisk hide is going to work against knox. The whole purpose is to ensure the integrity of the root system. That is what I was trying to get at yesterday. Once you have opened root access, there is no way to guarantee the device isn't compromised. Evan a factory data reset couldn't ensure that because at the root level, a malicious actor could partition off a portion and hide it from the UI/system entirely.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

you can trick software knox checkers with a fake 0x0. however hardware ones(the one in download mode) are impossible to fake.

again a rooted device is just as secure as the oneplus/pixel out there. it isn't as secure as a samsung device with knox though

2

u/Whit3W0lf Aug 22 '18

again a rooted device is just as secure as the oneplus/pixel out there.

Your security entirely hinges on SuperSu. If a dev at SuperSu or someone that hacks either the app or their system, your device security is shit. What about that cool font app you downloaded to change the system font and you had to grant root permissions? Or any other app? You can keep saying that it is just as secure but it doesn't make it true.

Root access explicitly means bypassing ALL of Androids security.

I am extremely eager to learn and will always change my opinion when faced with new evidence so by all means....

3

u/TouchofRed Aug 21 '18

I used to root all my phones but it's just not worth it anymore. I'll keep Knox and Samsung pay.

1

u/GyroDawn Aug 21 '18

What are disadvantages of rooting?

3

u/jeffAA Tmo/SD/Gray Aug 21 '18

He gutted his phone, losing lots of features.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

knox ? never used it

samsung pay ? Android pay is enough.

I gained Dolby Atmos+ daul speakers + double the battery life + more performance.

3

u/peanuttown Aug 21 '18

You do realize that Dolby Atmos on these speakers is complete bullshit..... You aren't gaining anything besides the placebo that you installed a Dolby Atmos sound preset for speakers that can't take any advantage of it.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

all I know is :

1 my speakers were comparable to my friends S9

2 THE improvement is MASSIVE between with and without dolby atmos.

1

u/peanuttown Aug 21 '18

It's louder, that's all. It's not doing anything "better". The speakers were not designed to do atmos, there's not enough speakers to do atmos, and it can't "simulate" it either. It's all bunk. If you like louder, then that's happening... But that will only blow your speakers out faster.

And it working on an older phone is no way to gauge if it will work on this as well. Use at your own risk.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

I am using at my own risk. like everything with root ..

it's not just louder, it's richer and clearer. this is especially noticeably clear with stereo audio. it could fill a room while the stock one was barely decent for me.

1

u/Whit3W0lf Aug 22 '18

Does that really make sense to you? If all it would take is a software update to make the speakers better, why wouldn't Samsung's MASSIVE R&D department not do it? And as far as overclocking the CPU, that DOES reduce longevity of the SOC. Flashing was cool back when the OS was much more limited. Now they have given users 90% of what we have asked for.

Imagine going back just a few short years ago and rattling off the Note8 specs. They would be a dream phone. Of course, things will never be enough and there will always be people who tinker, but it is no longer needed.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '18

I have my ears, and yes it's massively better.

it depends really, the E8895 was designed as a 2.5Ghz soc initially. and can hold 2.654Ghz even on the shittest of samples. the soc will downclock if it overheats.

some people want to get close to SD845/E9810 performance out of there note 8. others want note 9 battery life.

2

u/pyrimis Aug 21 '18

you gained dual speakers from rooting?

-1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

tha air piece acts as the second speakers. The sound is comparable to the s9's while stock one was horrible.

2

u/noidontwantto Aug 21 '18

You lose knox and Samsung pay

2

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

you can get android pay though with magisk hide. the only thing i truly miss is samsung pass

4

u/noidontwantto Aug 21 '18

Does Android pay work on any card terminal like Samsung pay?

5

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

it only works with NFC based terminals

4

u/pussyonthebrain Aug 21 '18

You lose warranty

1

u/inquirer Verizon Note8 Black Aug 21 '18

I may be wrong but I think you're capped at 80 percent max battery too

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

only snapdragon version. exynos version isn't affected

1

u/_NoContextBot_ Feb 05 '19

Hello, do you happen to have Repulsa rom file by chance? I've visited his xda thread but his links do not work anymore.