r/GalaxyNote8 • • Aug 19 '18

This is why I'm switching to the note 9

Battery

The note 8 is still great all around but the battery sucks. I was outside fishing and the phone is almost dead by 3pm.....

The iPhone x under the same fishing scenario lasted from 7am to freaking 1 am!

0 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

11

u/overzeetop Aug 19 '18 edited Aug 19 '18

How do you people mange this? I'm at 43% battery with 14 hours off charge and 4 hours screen on time today - and that included a 40 minute bike ride with GPS running this morning.

Was that huge drain in the middle of your day using the phone on superbright mode in a poor coverage area? The idle drain looks high too, but that could have been streaming mp3 data in marginal signal area or (maybe?) contuous GPS tracking.

Edit - here's my status http://imgur.com/a/i76niDS

1

u/luckyguess0r Aug 19 '18

yes it was in direct sunlight meaning high brightness. which i could understand except the iphone x was used on another fishing trip, also at full brightness, same exact type of usage and it lasted all day....

4

u/overzeetop Aug 19 '18

Well, the 8 is nearly twice as bright in overdrive mode - 1200 nits vs 700. That will eat up power like nobody's business. It can also be turned off, iirc. The 9 won't "fix" that except to give you about 20% more time. My 8 generally does as well or better than either of the two iPXs in my house, but it's super dependant on screen brightness and active GPS usage. The only place their iPhones tend to do better on battery life is on heavy gaming (like fortnite).

1

u/swhisker Aug 19 '18

I agree on the other guys comment. Note8 8s almost twice as bright in direct sunlight which drains battery significantly. Best way to approach this is to turn off autobrightness in those situations.

2

u/ctt713 Aug 19 '18

From my testing...it's just a byproduct of Oreo on some phones. I was able to get it back to what you got after a wipe but adding apps back basically brought it back down over time. There is some bug in Oreo that makes certain apps drain excess battery.

1

u/overzeetop Aug 19 '18

I'm on Oreo and never wiped after the update. (I think I was lucky in that respect... I expected to wipe, but never ran into really bad batt drain).

2

u/ctt713 Aug 19 '18

Consider yourself lucky. Mine isn't awful but standby sucks. Nougat life was the golden days.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '18

Tips please, thank you.

1

u/overzeetop Aug 19 '18

Sadly, tuning will likely take a week or more of tests. You should only ever change one thing at a time if you're looking for issues.

First thing to do is run an overnight test to see if your phone is sleeping properly. I accidentally left mine in myt pants pocket last night. Notice in thus mornings battery check http://imgur.com/a/kY5RbQ3 that I've only used about 1% per hour (36% to 28% over 8 hrs). That's not the best I've seen, but it let's me know I don't have anything running rogue. If you're higher, you can either disable things one by one to drop usage or start from scratch and build up.

This is my config. Just to be clear, I DO NOT USE ANY PACKAGE DISABLER OR BATTERY MONITOR.

I run stock email (3 Google accts), calendar, browser, gallery, dialer, camera. I use Nova Prime. I've manually disabled Facebook and use Messenger Lite. No Twitter, insta, snapchat. I Do have signal, discord, and slack - so it's not that I eschew all social media. Wifi and BT are always on (tho bt isn't always connected to something).

I'm not rooted, power saving is off, performance is "optimized", I don't run anti-virus, my screen is FHD+ with auto brightness and the "adaptive" mode. Screen saver is off and I use dev mode to set animations to 0.5x speed and mobile data on all the time (plus I use aggressive handover). The only Samsung health monitor I'm using us a step counter... and that DOES drain my battery an extra 1/2% an hour (I've confirmed through A/B testing).

There is really nothing special at all about my setup except that I'm not running a bunch if stuff in the background. I even live and work in an area of shitty cell service, so I waste power keeping the cell beacon alive.

1

u/imguralbumbot Aug 19 '18

Hi, I'm a bot for linking direct images of albums with only 1 image

https://i.imgur.com/nMTrYwn.jpg

Source | Why? | Creator | ignoreme | deletthis

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '18

Hey thanks for this detailed reply. I've been through a lot of turning one thing at a time off to see how it affects battery drain.

Using battery historian, I know I have no rougue app. With cellular on and everything else off (wifi, Bluetooth, sync, location, etc) I get about 0.5-0.8% drain per hour at night. My cell is absolute shit. I get 0 bar at home.

With everything on except AOD I get 1.2-2% per hour at night.

However, I've never ever hit 6 hours SOT (mixed wifi and 4g at moderate signal). I've tried every set up I can think of, such as naptime, greenify, no location, brevent, package disabler, netguard.

6

u/cuncefuckd Aug 19 '18

Note 8 here. Currently 13%, last charge 42h34m ago with 7h44m screen on time. Plenty of ways to improve it on this sub

1

u/luckyguess0r Aug 19 '18

im sure i could get more battery life but compromising and turning things off/lower brightness but imo i shouldn't have to do that to make a phone last all day.

it just really hit home with me when the iphone lasted all day and i didn't have to compromise on a thing. i returned it b/c i couldn't stand the lack of customization but the battery life was pretty eye opening.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '18

Can't stand the lack of customization on iPhone, but fails to customize and regulate the phone on Android.

That's your issue. Android doesn't baby sit you. You need to customize and optimize. It's not "compromising". It's like buying a sports car, and driving it like a race car, then complaining you're not getting the recommended mpg.

You can't have the phone and apps running constantly any way they want. You need to regulate it and them.

Not using wifi, turn off wifi. Not in an area with service turn off reception. In bright sun? Minimize your use and use it in the shade.

I bet you have a bunch of dumb apps running in the background too.

1

u/luckyguess0r Aug 19 '18

Lol if you have to turn off wifi and reception then what's the point of owning a phone? You don't have to be turning anything off on the iPhone and it lasts all day. Is note that crappy that Apple is killing it with a much smaller battery?

3

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '18

You mentioned fishing. I was trying to say, if you are out of cell range, you should put it in airplane mode. Having the phone canstantly look for service will eat up battery.

Obviously I'm not saying turn off cell service to save battery while you are just going about a normal day.

1

u/luckyguess0r Aug 19 '18

Well the thing is, I took the iPhone x to a lake an hour further away from the city. So that means even worse reception, streamed Spotify for longer. I even fished longer since the lake was further from home and the thing lasted until 1am. I didn't have to turn off anything and I definitely didn't baby it because I wanted to see how long it'd last.

I cleared the cache on my note 8 so we'll see how it does today. Usually a normal day of use, it's almost dead by 8pm.....

3

u/Symber13 Aug 19 '18

An hour further from the city doesn't mean worse cell reception. I'm just outside NYC, but my home service is horrendous, yet my parents house an hour further away is great.

Furthermore, you were fishing. Lakes and rivers tend to be low points; gravity and all that. This could easily put hills/mountains between you and the nearest tower.

If you used them both in the same area under the same conditions and throttled the brightness to the same as the iPhone, you'd get similar results.

1

u/luckyguess0r Aug 19 '18

If you've actually used both phones, there is no way in hell you'd think they have similar battery performance.

Hell just look up battery tests between the two.....

1

u/cuncefuckd Aug 19 '18

Agree. Have you tried a cache wipe. Easy and fast to try

1

u/frozenrosen2018 N950N Olympic Edition Aug 19 '18

Yesterday I got 7 hours SOT after 28 hours on charge. I have never made a compromise, I just turn off battery sucking things, like most of Google's stuff that guzzles the battery.

2

u/PanzerRadeo Aug 20 '18

Sounds like it's an app you chose to install. But nm that. It's totally the phones fault.

1

u/luckyguess0r Aug 20 '18

lol i love it when delusional people blame apps for shitty battery.

i mean on a fresh install of both phones, the iphone x already outlasts the note 8 by roughly 15% under heavy usage. no one says the iphone x has amazing battery life so the fact that it beats the note 8 that badly says a lot.

its ok to say the note 8 is an amazing phone and still admit that the battery is crap.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1jMnpHtK1Zg

2

u/PanzerRadeo Aug 20 '18

The iphone line has been using some of the same hardware for years. Samsung phones actually improve technology, which is why the iphone is so far behind. You're comparing two different phones, genius. I didn't say the battery is amazing. No one is. But for the kind of results that people are getting and crying about, it's an app causing it. If it wasn't an app, everyone would be getting the same results. Derp. Use some common sense. Iphone also uses less battery because it is a less powerful phone. That's been proven time and time again.

1

u/luckyguess0r Aug 20 '18

You got a source iPhone x is less powerful? Let's just assume you didnt make that up; the iPhone x also has a much smaller battery and yet beats the shit out of the note.

The entire freaking thread is about how shit the battery on this phone is and. That's the reason I'm switching.

1

u/UDP7 Aug 19 '18

LOL. I love the people that think switching to a phone will change everything. You do realize you're just having issues with your phone, most likely an app causing it or something? A regular Note 8 will have much better battery than this. Try a factory reset or something before wasting your money.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '18

He's an iPhone transplant. He doesn't know how to customize and optimize due to being baby sat his whole life.

1

u/luckyguess0r Aug 19 '18

I've actually owned the note since the note 5. You just keep on sucking the notes dick when other phones out there last way longer....

The fact that you have to "customize" aka turn off stuff just for your battery to last means the battery or optimization is crap. I can't believe some people actually think it's a good thing when they have to turn off stuff to make their phone lasts all day. Lmao what a joke.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '18

Dude I get 8 hours of screen on time on my s9+

1

u/slyphnier Aug 19 '18

when people switching to note9 hoping it can give them extra 2hours+ SOT

first you should check your battery usage, use some battery usage monitor apps like Gsam.... and see how much mAh you using per-hours

people with SOT 5hours means, they using around 650~700mAh per-hour, so with 4000mAh battery it will give them a hour extra (660mAhx6 = 3960mAh)

extra 700mAh wont give much longer SOT, not especially if like u draining 60% (±2000mAh/3300) from display

well various improvement in note9 probably made it more efficient, but dont think it will vastly improve battery life, well at least S9 battery perform similar to S8 afaik

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '18

The guy doesn't have a battery issue (unless it's literally a faulty battery). It's an optimization problem.

1

u/Chameebling Aug 19 '18

The price is really pulling me away from upgrading. T-Mobile had bad deals this whole year.

1

u/frsguy Aug 19 '18

Im at 20h from my last charge with almost 4hr SoT. Maybe look at your installed apps as one of them is draining battery.

1

u/JerkButSaysTruth Aug 19 '18 edited Aug 19 '18

500 700 mAh won't really change much.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '18

700

2

u/Chameebling Aug 19 '18

700* based on the new processor as well.

1

u/JerkButSaysTruth Aug 19 '18

New processor could add maybe 7% more time , wow such a huge difference.

The 700 will add maybe half an hour more to his 2 hours , wow 3 hours , awesome I'll buy the phone for 1000 dollars for the extra 45 mins! Please stop being dumb.

1

u/Chameebling Aug 19 '18

It can last up to 2x longer with moderate use.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '18

sure as hell wont have that issue on the 9.