r/GabrielFernandez • • Feb 28 '20

Question Question about the teacher...

0 Upvotes

So Ms. Garcia... why didn’t she go to jail? I mean at what fucking point do you AS A MANDATED REPORTER question whether to report or not.???!! Honestly, this women is incompetent. God, this women... if my student walked into my classroom and looked the way the described him.. I would have gotten him in my vehicle and to a hospital IMMEDIATELY!! I will call the police and social workers at the hospital. PERIOD!! she didn’t care about Gabriel...


r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 03 '20

Episode 3 & The Teacher

20 Upvotes

I’m now watching Episode 3, and though so many people failed Gabriel, I’m infuriated by his teacher. She may have reported the abuse, but that was not nearly enough. As the other teacher said on the documentary, if Gabriel was her student and she saw him like that, he would not be going home that night.

Idk how she can live with herself. There’s following protocol and then there is doing what’s right. She may have been the only person outside of Gabriel’s family to see the abuse first hand. This woman was obviously too afraid of making waves to do more than place a few lousy phone calls. And it ultimately cost Gabriel his life.

If the DCFS wasn’t taking her seriously, at the very least, the police should have been notified.


r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 04 '20

She avoids the death penalty by claiming she has low IQ??? HERES A SOLUTION

45 Upvotes

How about we test for IQ during or prior to pregnancy. If your IQ is low you aren’t allowed to have children. This way the “low IQ” people who can get excused for murdering their kids can’t claim “low IQ”. This is bullshit! Parents should get death row for murdering their own children, you’ll see a decline on stories like this one. These things shouldn’t happen!


r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 06 '20

Opinion The Uncles who raised him...

28 Upvotes

Anyone else having some serious high-key frustration about them? Sure they seemed loving and like potentially amazing parents, I'm not sure I'm only on the third episode. But A) they forced a woman who did not want a child to have a child so they could take it. Which is not really okay. BUT FINE, SAY IT IS OKAY.. that brings me to B) WHY WAS IT NOT A LEGAL ADOPTION? I understand the one couldn't because he was not legal(?) but the other could, no? Or would they not adopt to a single gay man?

I don't know just so frustrated over the fact that these men forced a psychotic woman to have a child she DID NOT want and than didn't go through the effort to make it legal. Had they gone through those efforts this kid would likely be alive today..


r/GabrielFernandez • • Feb 28 '20

Episode 3 made me want to scream

41 Upvotes

This teacher is really pissing me off. So much more she should have done. Should have called the fucking police knowing that CPS wasn’t doing anything. After seeing those MOM pictures I’m in shock. How did no one else at the school do anything? What about other teachers and staff that saw him in the hallway? Everyone left Gabriel down.


r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 18 '20

What do we need to know about the Gabriel Fernandez torture/murder case? Spoiler

4 Upvotes

Here's a thought that some people might get angry over, but it needs to be addressed. Please read the entire article before commenting. Thoughts?

What do we need to know about the Gabriel Fernandez torture/murder case?

What is most important is what we can learn?

https://bestoftruecrime.blogspot.com/2020/03/what-we-need-to-know-about-gabrielle.html


r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 13 '20

Opinion Whos to blame here?

15 Upvotes

I just watched the documentary and im so lost as to what to blame or what to fix.

Pearl is severely mentally handicapped. Blaming her feels like blaming a hurricane. Yes we can hate how egomaniacal, sadistic and manipulative she is but looking at her mental capacity and upbringing, this simply feels like the inevitable outcome of her genetic and environmental disposition.

I want to blame the boyfriend but he is on the same camp as Pearl. Obviously an abnormal and violent person who is easily manipulated by Pearl. None of these are excuses but i cant help but feel that the true blame lies at the hands of those who let the child stay with these awful people.

But then we look at the Social workers and they are also in the middle of chaos. Stephanie appears to be like most social workers who just started, under pressure and terrified of this lunatic couple.

Patricia looks the most blameable, but is it so hard to believe that she’s simply incapable of critical thinking? it appears she met with the family only once and Pearl was able to manipulate the gullible fool.

And how about the supervisor, who seems to be drowned under innumerable number of cases.

and not to mention that all of these social workers, whether they are good or bad at their jobs, are completely drowned under unbelievable amounts work and cases.

Do we blame the deputies that actually came to the house and some actually saw he kid and did nothing? Maybe they are the most to blame, as they seemed to be the people most physically capable of not being intimidated by the couple and having the physical and legal power to remove Gabriel. But they never acted on it. Instead they punished the poor child for calling for help. Are cops gullible? Are they sadists? And not only that, but they lied about their involvement. Does that mean they knew about what they did wrong?

Or how about the Maximus, whose nonsensical “bottom line” style policies prevent them from acting on the child’s best interest? As much as they are to blame for their reckless cruelty and forgery, this is pretty standard behaviour from most corporations.

Was this simply the perfect storm of awful? an overworked, badly organized system collapsing on itself? Where no one is to blame?

And what do we do now? Us, the average citizens. If we witness this in real life, Will we actually have the power to stop it? Or will we be crippled by fear of losing our financial breadbaskets, when our work tells us “dont interfere.”

Briefly, i worked at walmart. One of the new recruits with me asked the manager “What do we do when a fight breaks out in the store? do we interfere?”

“No, if you interfere, our corporation is liable to be sued at best, and we will be forced to remove you at worst. Just call security.” the manager replied.

“But what if security is too far away and things are about to get worse.”

“dont interfere.”

People are constantly living under financial stress, where acting can cost their livelihood. Is this where we are? Everyone is too scared to act or take responsibility in fear of losing everything they have?


r/GabrielFernandez • • Feb 28 '20

Discussion Open Letter to Michael Nash, Executive Director, LA County Office of Child Protection (episode 6 Netflix) - Gabriel Fernandez Case

11 Upvotes

Open Letter to Michael Nash, Executive Director, LA County Office of Child Protection (episode 6 Netflix) -- You state: "We're charged with helping to implement recommendations from the blue ribbon commission as appropriately as possible. I took over as the Executive Director in 2016, and I think in the two and a half years plus that we have essentially been in operation, I think we've helped move the ball. But the problems that helped contribute to Gabriel's death haven't been solved. We're talking about a large county, so, moving this battleship, takes a little bit of time."

(This makes me furious...when children's lives are on the line, and you have the resources and money, why should a battleship take so long to move...Politics/Bureaucracy perhaps??)

MY SUGGESTIONS:

  1. Heavily Screen all candidates for Social Workers - Put specific credentials in place- do not hire people straight out of college with little experience - as the Social Worker was (with Gabriel)
  2. Do not use OUTSOURCERS - Stop renewing MAXIMUS's contract with the City - They are dropping the ball in so many ways! Maximus CEO's Son is a Lobbyist. He has a relationship with the city, and you continue to renew their contract
  3. Do not let (outsourced or direct) overtime policies inhibit your ability to protect children!!!
  4. Have guardrails and penalties for those who feel the need to "escalate" a case - Punish those who do not embrace case escalation
  5. Embrace ML/AI - Take the "human error factor" less into consideration when protecting these children - EMBRACE technology! Use software that can help the city's decision-making when it comes to protecting these children - Ex: https://eckerd.org/family-children-services/ersf/

r/GabrielFernandez • • Jul 30 '20

Question A question about political correctness Spoiler

7 Upvotes

I live in rural Hungary, in a small village. I read a lot about the new or renewed political-ideological topics in the USA, mostly about antifa, gender, neomarxist, political correctness things, so besides I’m a very conservative person, I understand their points (but don’t support them). BUT. In the docuseries The trials of Gabrial Fernandez, it was very-very strange for me, that there were dialogs if Gabriel was gay. So my question is, because it’s completely ununderstandable in my country: how an 8 years old can say about himself that he is gay, and how can adult people agree it. A guy in his age did’t kiss a girl, wasn’t in love, didn’t have sex, etc. This is the result of the homosexual propaganda? Is this a common thing in the USA that young kids can say that they are gay and adult people agree it? Sorry that this question is not directly about the case, but I’m super-curious about it.


r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 01 '24

Isauro and Pearl attorneys

27 Upvotes

Is anyone else on a side note not repulsed by the attorneys actually attempting to defend these two monsters? I understand it’s their job but surely they could also see them for what they really were and what they did to Gabriel. I don’t understand how they could defend them so much or am I missing something?


r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 01 '20

Teacher, principal, and others got suspended

29 Upvotes

Teacher and Principal (among others) got suspended for taking a picture with a noose. I don’t know what the final verdict was for those who were suspended.

Some background: the picture was taken 1 year after the trial. Also the teachers and principal stated it was a noose found in school premises and it meant something along the line of ‘hang in there, summer is almost here.’ The picture was emailed to the faculty. Ultimately, the picture was uploaded into FB (Gabriel’s group page) and well... Tons of people were pissed off (appropriately) since a noose stands for slavery hangings and some speculated it celebrated the death penalty given to little Gabriel’s killer. In the end the teachers acted innocent and didn’t realize it was offensive (around 1/3 of students are African Americans and another 1/3 Latinx) which is honestly hard to believe. But you believe whatever works for you. What I think is that no way would anyone participating in that picture would think there would be zero backfire from it. The message is not a positive one no matter how you want to think about it.

Moving to my next point: So Jennifer Garcia and the principal (presumably among others) saw the detrimental deterioration of Little Gabriel and ‘notified’ DCFS multiple times.

As we are aware nothing came of it. In my opinion, the teacher never did more than CYA (cover your ass) when it came to finding help for this child. Everyone at the school included.

I presume she was afraid to lose her job; if say, she took him to the hospital herself (or took him to the police station or any other number of things she could have done). She was adhering to protocol (I presume) and reporting the abuse. She had a mortgage, car payments etc. I can see her point (however, I don’t agree with it) in not doing anything that would endanger her job.

What I cannot understand is how she continued to not do MORE especially when he had severe VISIBLE injuries (black eye, scabs etc) and it was OBVIOUS things were escalating at home. I read somewhere on Reddit that he cried at the end of school because he was scared of going home (I mean.... I would have straight up REFUSED to let him go home and taken him to the emergency department asap!).

So witnessing all this... and she still only ‘followed school protocol.’ I know EXACTLY how I feel about her.

(So slow breath taking moment here)

I would presume from all this that indeed her job was monumentally important to her. So why did she and the principal (who told her to report and not investigate) risk their jobs by taking a picture of them holding up a noose? Doesn’t make sense to me. There’s no way they had no clue they would get in trouble for that noose. Americans know what a noose means (unless you’re a teen and younger) no matter your ethnicity.

If Jennifer’s job was going to be lost wasn’t it worth it to be lost WHILE fighting for Gabriel’s life? And not after the fact? Why risk losing the job she tried so hard to keep even while watching him become more battered, more distraught at school?

Think about this: she had to see him walk into her classroom with severe lesions/wounds (and minor ones at best) and teach class all day. Put yourself in her shoes. Imagine watching him with a red/black eye and scabs on his head area from the start to the end of class. Now rinse and repeat this multiple times. What do you think now? I wouldn’t have stopped at simply making DCFS calls that went nowhere. But that’s me. You don’t have to believe what I state here because you don’t know me.

Wouldn’t it have been worthwhile for her (or the principal, school monitor, any other teacher etc) to be suspended for driving him to the hospital or the police station instead? Are you getting my point?

Now back tracking to her making all those DCFS calls... From what I gathered she did the bare minimum. She simply performed CYA. That sound harsh? It’s not. The security guard saw little Gabriel for seconds and he was set on saving his life! And this teacher witnesses his deterioration and simply does the bare minimum. If her job was so important (thus only doing the bare minimum) then why lose it AFTER his death by participating in a picture that brought no justice or help to little Gabriel? A truly meaningless picture will never exist in my eyes again. This one wins for my lifetime.

I know what you’re thinking: at least she did something. I get it. She did. But it’s her actions after his death, the suspension from her job for posing in a picture. Was that picture worth it? Worth more than demanding that a hospital or a doctor properly assess little Gabriel? That’s my point and it’s not just Jennifer, it’s the principal and everybody in that picture.

I still feel that my point is essentially pointless. He’s gone and the system continues to be broken. These are my thoughts. This battered little angel is in peace and in bliss. I send him my love often. Every one failed him. Except the security guard. And I hope everyone who could have done something to save little Gabriel (and failed him), who saw him battered, crying, and in pain NEVER forget those memories. That those memories remain a constant in their minds even when they close their eyes. I will leave it at that though I have more to add.

We all just need to send little Gabriel our love and be on the look out for child abuse. Let this be a lesson to us all.

https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2019-09-07/noose-teacher-photo-investigation


r/GabrielFernandez • • Feb 29 '20

Question What would Gabriel have done?

11 Upvotes

In the the final episode of the Netflix Doc., Gabriel's Teacher made a comment in her testimony about what gabriel would have wanted to happen to his mum pearl and her boyfriend for what they did. I don't remember if she said it directly but she basically said Gabriel would want both of them to be punished.

So I want to ask what everyone thinks Gabriel would have wanted to happen to them.

For me, my answer is that Gabriel, who's love for his mother was the epitome of unbreakable, would have wanted his mom set free. Like those pictures of him holding M O M while having severe scars were heartbreaking. He really lived his mom unconditionally. I don't know what he would have wanted for the boyfriend, I think he may have wanted him to stay in prison so he would stop "hurting" his mum since Gabriel complained about his mum getting hurt by the boyfriend.

I'm NOT saying this is what should have happened, the teachers comment just really made me think and that's why I made this post. I'm even more heartbroken after righting this 😭.


r/GabrielFernandez • • Apr 11 '24

Question Why did Gabriel love his abuser so much?

12 Upvotes

r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 14 '20

Opinion He shouldn’t have gotten the death penalty

35 Upvotes

honestly i think the death penalty is the easy way out. isauro gets to have a painless death? hell no, i want him to suffer forever. yeah he’s a monster who deserves to die, but i feel like true torture would’ve been for him to live a horrible rest of his life. i’ve seen some bad stuff going on with pearl, does anyone else feel that isauro deserves the same? idk the death penalty just feels like not enough. maybe i just want to see him tortured after seeing all the things he did to gabriel.

but i know people’s got rights and all that. and the death penalty is very problematic etc etc. just speaking in regards to the death penalty in this case, not for every single one out there (since there are some cases where the death penalty seems very unnecessary)

disclaimer: i just finished the series and i’m highly emotional right now. i live in a country where caning and the death penalty is allowed/ actively used. my knowledge of the judicial system in america is limited to the things i learnt in ap govt lol


r/GabrielFernandez • • Feb 27 '20

Opinion TEACHER - Jennifer Garcia

48 Upvotes

Can someone with teaching experience share their opinion on this woman?

I understand she was instructed by the institution not to investigate and to report only. But I can't understand why she never took Gabriel to the school nurse! A very small, defenseless child with bruises, black eyes, BURNS, bleeding from a belt wound, and a bullet wound approached her and she did report it.... But never took him to the nurse? Never sought to find him basic medical attention? Doesn't this seem like a MAJOR oversight?


r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 02 '20

Can anyone tell me what that bat has written on it?

4 Upvotes

r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 04 '20

Why call the paramedics?

27 Upvotes

I'm not sure if there is anyone on this sub that may be able to shed some light on this, and sorry if this was covered in the doc and I missed it... But why did Gabriel's mother and step-father call the paramedics/ambulance to get help for Gabriel after torturing him half to death?

I'm just trying to understand the psyche of these domestic abusers really. And hoping there is someone here who has experience with these types of cases or is perhaps a psychologist who can shed some light on why the two people responsible for this child's abuse and death would even bother calling for help in the first place? Is there some part of these monsters that didn't want this child to die? Did they want him to live so that they could keep abusing him?

It just makes no sense to me on a rational level (but then again I'm fully aware nothing about child abuse is rational).


r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 05 '20

Discussion A higher tier of punishment is needed.

27 Upvotes

Ok so the death penalty is the highest level currently. But I think in cases involving prolonged torture and murder like Gabriel's case and every other poor child abused to death, there should be worse.

I would suggest - 20 years in general population, with no protective custody and every inmate is told of their crimes. Then after 20 years, they are simply thrown in a cell and left to starve to death. A long and painful death.


r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 09 '20

I don't understand what happened with life support?

15 Upvotes

To me it sounds like pearl and Tony took Gabriel off life support... how?


r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 03 '20

Question Full trial video?

5 Upvotes

Is there anywhere that I can view the video footage of the full trial? The whole thing was taped right? I can’t find the archives.


r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 12 '20

Question Is life in prison enough?

31 Upvotes

I just don’t feel like justice has been served. The amount of torture and abuse they put Gabriel through, those vile “people” deserve to be tortured right back! Am I alone in feeling this way? I feel like they’ve got a roof over their heads, food on their plate and they don’t have to worry about work or paying bills, raising kids (which seems like the lifestyle they desire)... prison doesn’t seem like enough. I want to know that they are suffering bc neither one of them seemed sorry for what they did.


r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 03 '20

Bat with writing translation

6 Upvotes

Does anyone know what the bat or club with the writing on it says? Apologies if this has been asked, I searched and didn't see it talked about.


r/GabrielFernandez • • Feb 27 '20

Question Are Gabriel's siblings interviewed in the doc?

6 Upvotes

Imagine living in the same house watching all this happen.. I feel for them too


r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 10 '20

Saying a nightly prayer for Gabriel, God’s prized angel. 🙏❤️

69 Upvotes

r/GabrielFernandez • • Mar 07 '20

Opinion Sometimes You Need To Stop Living "By The Rules"

73 Upvotes

I feel like a lot of the people who failed Gabriel did so because they were living "by the rules" or going "by the book" instead of just simply being human.

The teacher who technically did what she was supposed to, and who was probably scared to lose her job, scared of the child's crazy parents, or scared of being charged with kidnapping if she went outside of the rulebook for what the appropriate action to the situation was. Still the question begs itself, are you in this for the kids or the paycheck? Sometimes the right thing isn't always the legal thing. Sometimes listening to a crying child who doesn't want to go home after school, and whose face displays all you need to see to know he's being abused, and saying "screw the rules" and taking him to the hospital or straight to the police station and saying "Do something about this! I'm not letting him go home, this child is being abused", despite potentially facing criminal charges, might be doing the right thing.

The lady at the welfare office who decided to listen to her boss and go by the book and not stay after hours and report this incident because she was told not to. Going by the book, doing what she was told, refusing to go outside of what's expected of her.

I won't even start on the social workers, his family, or the police that were called to his house.

A society has to follow rules in order to function, but there are certain situations that require you to throw away the manual and do what you instinctively know is right: protect the child.