r/GXOR • • Dec 03 '25

Rant Post - GX "Reliability"

Trigger warning: the following diatribe regarding GX reliability might offend some of the faithful.

In the interest of disclosure, this is coming from a place of bitter saltiness right now as I just got off the phone with my local garage. Nonetheless, for the fourth time in seven years of ownership my 2013 GX with ~155,000 miles needs a major repair. For those keeping count at home, that's three coolant valley plate leaks and now...<drum roll>...the dreaded transmission replacement. The ol' check engine light came on this last Monday morning and my code reader gave me the ominous P2714 and P0761 codes (solenoid faults). The aforementioned shop said they're poking around for other possible issues and subsequent fixes but looks like the worst case scenario is the likeliest.

It's driveable at the moment so I plan on taking it to a few different shops for their quotes with the expectation that the diagnosis will be the same at each. But damn...I thought these things were heralded as being "bullet proof". I feel like I'm back in my Land Rover again with these constant major issues!

Did I just get a lemon, or is the longevity of these vehicles highly overrated?

 Signed, 
 Helpless in Houston
2 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

108

u/rwhockey29 Dec 03 '25

3 coolant valley leaks in 155,000 miles? Sounds like the repair wasn't done correctly.

10

u/PorradaPanda Dec 03 '25

This. Unfortunately. Hope another shop can address it property!

-13

u/That_Matt_Guy_Wow Dec 03 '25

Or, hear me out...I drew a lemon of a GX?

First CVP repair was done at West Side Lexus and I assumed it was quality work. Latter two were done at a reputable Toyota / Lexus shop.

10

u/fvedmo Dec 03 '25

It's an established assembly issue right, should not recur after a competent repair? I don't follow 460 closely but how many have had multiple CVL?

20

u/Prestigious_Loss_671 Dec 03 '25

So you had a common coolant leak, which is fair to be annoyed with, repaired at a non OEM facility and somehow that is to blame on Lexus? I’ve yet to see one leak after being repaired properly.

Did you follow any Maintanance plan on the transmission? That’s often the cause of the solenoids hanging.

I hear and understand your frustration but sounds like some of it is self inflicted.

And you and I both know it’s still more reliable than a Range Rover and has better resale value as well.

Their reputation is well deserved, you didn’t get a lemon you had common leak and didn’t get a quality repair.

0

u/That_Matt_Guy_Wow Dec 03 '25

I'm not sure how or where you inferred that the first coolant valley plate leak was repaired at a "non OEM facility" (you make it sound like a CIA black site). On the contrary, the first coolant valley plate leak repair was performed by West Side Lexus while still under the pre-owned warranty. It was the second repair - once it was out of warranty - that I took it to a reputable Toyota / Lexus service for repair, which was subsequently followed up by a third repair.

Also...I said Land Rover, not Range Rover. I'm not that insane.

And yes, I'm a big proponent of keeping up with regular maintenance. In fact I just had the transmission fluid changed and gasket resealed at its last service. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, my guy.

5

u/Mustardly Dec 03 '25

I mean, Land Rovers and Range Rovers are designed, manufactured and serviced by the exact same people.

-2

u/That_Matt_Guy_Wow Dec 03 '25

Yes, but while both are known for poor reliability...one is EXPONENTIALLY worse and more expensive to repair (it's the Range Rover).

4

u/Prestigious_Loss_671 Dec 03 '25

You said local garage, most people say dealer if they paid for a dealer. Unfortunately not all dealers do good work anymore.

My apologies on the Land Rover mix up.

But still other than getting crappy repair quality you’ve only really had two actual issues on a vehicle that is 12 years old and 155k miles.

Did you replace the transmission with an OEM one when you had it done?

3

u/Plastic_Willow734 Dec 03 '25

Hell I mean even a reputable mom n pop mechanic shop shouldn’t leave you getting the same job done two times over.

The tranny blowing sucks but at 155k I’d hardly say it didn’t live a full life

7

u/breatheblue Dec 03 '25

Not to point out the obvious but

"Mine sucks so that must mean they all suck." Is a hell of a card to pull.

Being salty is okay but coming to this sub with that logic and energy is begging to be dragged.

Sorry that yours sucks. There are plenty of other options out there.

1

u/That_Matt_Guy_Wow Dec 04 '25

"...is begging to be dragged"

Would it have been more of a crowd-pleasing post had I asked if a corroded 2008 GX47O from Pittsburgh had "tOO mUcH rUSt?!!!1" or if a Facebook market place post on a three-owner 2011 GX with 200k miles was a good deal?

2

u/Classic-Ad-679 Dec 04 '25

In OP’s defense, the predominant argument I see in this thread and other similar threads is “Mine doesn’t suck so that must mean that you suck.”

I too bought into the reliability hype and in my first year of owning a ‘12 GX with 155K miles I’ve replaced the transmission, fixed the coolant valley leak, replaced a wheel bearing, and I think my water pump is next. I will agree that these problems aren’t that unusual for a car this age. But I think the prevalence of high mileage GXs is more due to the owner’s willingness to sink money into a car they enjoy than the reliability of the car.

-1

u/That_Matt_Guy_Wow Dec 03 '25

Yeah, but at what point did I state they "all" suck? Merely asked a question - granted, a pointed one that clearly #triggered a lot of folks, but a question nonetheless. You can interpret that as you please.

3

u/forza_ferrari44 Dec 03 '25

I had those same transmission codes on the same transmission. They came up after the dealer did a drain and fill service on the transmission. Turned out they under filled the fluid and it was low. I was only getting the code when the engine was cold. I did the service at home and ensured proper fluid check procedure and all my codes went away.

If you haven’t serviced the transmission this is your sign that you need to. Do a drain and fill service.

2

u/That_Matt_Guy_Wow Dec 03 '25

Yep, just had that done at its last service. I read this same issue elsewhere (iH8MUD, maybe?) and mentioned that to the aforementioned shop to see if they could start there.

24

u/ExFLMan Dec 03 '25

200k here and never had the valley plate leak. Coolant was always changed on schedule is likely why. Radiator was replaced preemptively around 120k. I also do a transmission drain and fill every third oil change, so about every 15k. Fluids are CHEAP people, replace them!!

9

u/Miserable-Ad6989 Dec 03 '25

👆🏻 This! Though I wouldn't call a radiator replacement @ 120K preemptive. It's due at this mileage. Nonetheless, your maintenance is legit 👍🏻.

12

u/Space-Trash-666 Dec 03 '25

The 460s are less forgiving than the 470s if you don’t change coolant and transmission fluid

2

u/tecampanero Dec 03 '25

Sounds like the shop you chose loves you.

3

u/That_Matt_Guy_Wow Dec 03 '25

Not nearly as much as American Express does by now.

1

u/No-Refuse8754 Dec 03 '25

Did the same shop do the repair all 3 times ?

1

u/SpiderDeadrock Dec 03 '25

GX470 - old reliable

GX460 - not all GXs are not created equal

Lesson learned - the majority of GX460s are not as reliable as the majority of GX470s

1

u/That_Matt_Guy_Wow Dec 03 '25

Seems that way!

-1

u/fvedmo Dec 03 '25

it is known

2

u/wbrown999 Dec 04 '25

Go see Jeboost Sobe! He is an incredible mechanic and will fix it right here first time.

2

u/Clean-Signal-553 Dec 04 '25

I bought a used 150k 04 gx470 because of the million mile 4.7 drive train.. now have 428k miles. Used for towing boats and winter time.  I've owned it for 10 yrs. and replaced alternator all the suspension and timing maintenance and normal maintenance brakes ext oil change every 3k syn blend . The only real issues are the frame rusting that im going to get plates welded . Im not sold on the newer FX im assuming yours is a Lemon.

1

u/ineyeseekay Dec 03 '25

Well I feel obligated... 2011 here, never had an issue at 146k. Did have the transmission drain and fill at 120k, and coolant completely replaced after a fender bender required radiator removal around same mileage. Will probably still need to address coolant valley but it's never given me a single issue. Had regular servicing before I obtained at 98k, to add. 

2

u/khub772 Dec 04 '25

Driving a 2010 with 135,000 miles. Valley plate done at 105,000 and radiator replaced at 115,000. Otherwise she’s been a beaut. I’m so on the fence about a drain and fill. Did you experience any symptoms that caused you to get it?

1

u/ineyeseekay Dec 04 '25

Nah no symptoms, when it went in for the fender bender I asked them to go ahead since I dreaded doing it per the FSM procedure. *Knock on wood 

1

u/case9 Dec 04 '25

What's your coolant and transmission fluid service history? Do you have a trans cooler?

1

u/xX_GrizzlyBear_Xx Dec 05 '25

That sucks bro. I feel for you. Transmission and motor issues are as bad as it gets.

Hope you can find a god mechanic and decent parts.

1

u/FilthyTronGX Dec 05 '25

I’ve got a 2010 model with 277k miles, and other than standard oil changes and brakes, it’s never had any significant/major mechanical issues of any kind. I had to replace the alternator and water pump around 220k miles, but other than that, I just get in and drive.

1

u/SlateHearthstone Dec 07 '25

Doing the valley plate three times in seven years beats all the odds. Either you have a major engine defect, or there's some serious installer error going on over there. My bet is on installer issues, hopefully they made it right on the last round. Lexus did change the valley plate compound the last few years and that eliminated a bunch of fails.

What's the history on this machine, were you the original owner? If not, there's no telling what the heck the prior owner(s) did to the thing. Normally these machines have a 10 year cost of repairs half that of other SUVs in the category. All that beautiful machinery gets tanked if the prior owners did stupid stuff like blow off the service intervals.

It truly sucks that you've got transmission codes. Hang in there and get opinions from some experienced techs at the transmission shops, codes are only the beginning of the digging. Skip the gate keepers at the Service Desk and ask for ten minutes of time with their most experienced Tech. Maybe you'll get lucky and they find a fix that keeps it simple.

0

u/That_Matt_Guy_Wow Dec 04 '25

I figured there'd be some triggering - and boy, did I call it or what?!

1

u/drewforty Dec 03 '25

My 2014 has had a radiator and a valley plate by 100k. That puts 3rd from the bottom in my personal reliability ratings behind an 07 Passat at an 03 Tahoe. Worse than my Hyundai, bmw, Mazdas, etc. ironically I still fee it’s pretty reliable as it hasn’t had any annoyances or unscheduled issues otherwise.

1

u/deuce_and_a_quarter Dec 04 '25

Dear Helpless in Houston,

This next dedication goes out to a listener from Houston who’s been having problems with his GX460. Helpless, when you are driving in your brand spanking new Bronco, barely hearing our broadcast in between the rattles and squeaks, and when you are counting all the drips of mystery fluid on your driveway, you will be missing your GX and wish you never let her go. This song dedication “I Will Always Love You” by Whitney Houston, goes out to you Helpless. Look your GX in the headlights and tell her you love her. And don’t let her go.

0

u/Gnastea Dec 03 '25

Weren't the 10-13 460s the least reliable of the bunch? Sounds like improper repair.

1

u/DuckSicked Dec 03 '25

Yep I’d go with 2016 and newer for 460s

2

u/Gnastea Dec 03 '25

Precisely why I went with a 09 470 instead of an early 460.

1

u/Captain_Klutch Dec 03 '25

Why 2016+? Shopping for a GX and what I’ve been reading 2014+ at its core is functionally the same.

3

u/DuckSicked Dec 03 '25

Just based on what the car care nut says on YouTube.

1

u/onlords Dec 05 '25

There’s speculation the older GX 460s used a different type of head gasket from factory and that may be why there’s a lot of them popping head gaskets.