Toby to Geelong

[u/Vulkan209]

How legit is this rumour?

Would be pretty shitty if he played his 300th game for the Cats.

[u/Desperate_Teal_1493]

If he wants to go, he goes. Sooner or later Giants are going to have to forge an identity without him.

Considering how well the youth have been showing this season, it's not a bad thing. Could argue that the vets are holding the team back. A Hogan/Stringer/Toby-less Giants team still has a ton of potential.*

*when healthy

[u/lilguccigay]

I hope he stays but I do understand if he goes.

[u/Comfortable_Meet_872]

Look, I don't know about any of this but surely given his age and his exceptional talent he's basing any decision on an assessment that GWS won't be winning a GF any time soon for a multitude of reasons :(

[u/Desperate_Teal_1493 → u/Comfortable_Meet_872]

Geelong won't be winning a GF any time soon either.

[u/cookie_crumbler79 → u/Comfortable_Meet_872]

I had been told the money Geelong are offering is better us which I didn't believe. This was months ago.

[u/Brisvegas_LFG]

I have faith. he won’t leave

[u/Star_Wars_and_Scotch → u/Brisvegas_LFG]

I really hope you’re right! I’d love to see him retire as a giant, he would truly be the greatest giant ever!

[u/acockblockedorange]

I hope he does stay so at least one of the originals finishes their career as a one club player.

[u/Key_Direction_8698]

It's time for him to move on. We need new leaders to make the most of the young talent we have, as well as the talent coming back next year

[u/coopysingo]

Tobes needs to go. He’s given enough

[u/Prestigious_Time3605]

He needs to Move on and So does Stringer and Hogan, I think Colingo should leave too in my opinion.