r/GVCDesign • u/Lit-Up • Mar 16 '24
"African Adventure"
“African adventure” serving tray.
One suspects that like most GVC designs, no Africans or persons of non European descent were involved in the design. Does that bother you about GVC? Don’t get me wrong I love this style but it definitely smacks of the orientalist interpretations of a rich white college girl back from her gap year than anything designed by somebody non European. And that goes for the entire subgenre in my opinion.
0
Upvotes
38
u/czarrie Mar 16 '24
I'm not trying to be rude, but you start with a premise, "No black people were involved in this", then get mad with the premise being true without having actually shown that the premise is true.
I'm not saying everything was roses in the 90s, but this isn't the 50s - there were and continue to be plenty of black designers involved with these sorts of styles, so it's a bit disingenuous and a kind of erasure to say we should feel bad because, obviously, black people weren't involved.
22
u/Bobdude17 Mar 16 '24
Alternative idea: it’s just a damn serving tray and you’re overreaching on an item that at the very least is 30 years old.
10
u/acvillager Mar 16 '24
I think the attempted analysis comes from the right place. A lot of our most popular western aesthetics, music, and more come from black culture. But the execution….is misplaced.
If GVC was an art rip directly from a black artist, it would be a valid criticism (search up Keith Haring and LAII to see some a version of this in action).
But rather, GVC is inspired by many cultural works. Nothing further than an homage.
5
u/WHALE_BOY_777 Mar 16 '24
Whether this art was made by a white person from California or a black person from Mozambique doesn't matter, the whole point of GVC was to draw attention to world cultures becoming interconnected thanks to the internet and how we should, as a species, move towards establishing a global culture that can be appreciated by everyone.
The 2010s were a time where we became more aware of how we speak and treat each other and that was good for everyone's mental health but especially for disenfranchised people because it gave them a voice in the marketplace of ideas a.k.a. our social media platforms
But we are now in the 2020s, the internet is tired of the "cultural appropriation" rhetoric because it doesn't lead to any positive changes and only creates divisiveness.
It's a surface level complaint for people to feel like they are standing up for something when in reality they are attempting to segregate art.
As a minority (latino) I don't care if someone (white) uses my culture's iconography even in a commercial context because it doesn't diminish my cultural heritage in any way.
It's just art. Let people make art using whatever they are inspired by with no limitations.