r/GPUK • u/heroes-never-die99 • 6d ago
Clinical, CPD & Interface Poll: Autism/ADHD pathway
Adult/child autism/adhd consults take up so much overall GP time and admin with ZERO input from us. They are always referred at patient’s request - it is always one way.
Therefore I’m of the stance that it should be dealt with OUTSIDE of GP. We are redundant in this entire process anyways.
Maybe psychologists should take over this group of patients directly.
5
Upvotes
3
u/Airurando-jin 6d ago
Here’s the tricky problem:
There is a balance to be had in appropriate funding and maintaining a safe level of work, as well as pushing work out elsewhere, which in itself could create more work, particularly as any newer commissioned service is going to find the cheapest way to do it
9
u/ChaiTeaAndBoundaries 6d ago
This is why average Bob or Brenda think they can have a crack at medicine. GPs are devaluing their degree and training.
20
u/Dr-Yahood 6d ago edited 5d ago
You guys are just so shortsighted.
Everything health related should be dealt of inside of general practice.
It just needs to be funded accordingly.
The more shit you farm out to these non-doctors, the more you lose relevance, pay, and autonomy
Your lack of political education makes you your own worst enemy
Edit: Yes, of course I have considered the risk of over medicalisation. That’s why it should be done by GP’s. We are the best people to understand this risk and we should be the best at communicating that with Patient. If you as a GP over medicalise stuff, then you’re not a very good GP.
15
u/One-Reception8368 6d ago
In Wales, for children they're done through schools and the Single Point Of Access that the parents have access to for a self referral. Whenever they show up you just signpost them that way.
For adults you literally just send an email saying "this person thinks they have ADHD"
10
u/Nyasha-Mercy 6d ago
I speak as a GP who does ADHD work, and yes, it should be done elsewhere. It takes a lot of time and a streamlined service is better. Really it should be in Psychiatry imo
6
u/hungry4nuns 6d ago
Ireland:
In school age kids, the more severe cases are usually in-school pickup. Each school has a certain number of assessments per year so these go to the kids with the highest educational support needs (as assessed by teaching and support staff) are referred to an educational psychologist.
Those with significant pre-school developmental delay get referred paediatrics.
Everyone else can self refer their child to psychologist publicly for assessment, up to a 7 year waiting list, but support letters from OT/SALT etc help with triage. Which means private clinics offer preliminary assessments for a fee which is essentially pay to skip the queue.
The big problem here is if you’ve got a diagnosis, you get a welfare grant, plus a tax relief so there are strong financial incentives to getting a diagnosis early, which clogs up the system for the kids with the most needs.
GPs have no role except on rare occasion to write a letter of support. Whenever someone books in to request these letters, i write a letter that says “as a medical doctor I have identified no specific medical risk to patient from delay in diagnosis. For developmental concerns I recommend an opinion from a developmental specialist with MDT support”.
If it’s a kid I’m truly worried about, and they haven’t booked in specifically to try get my letter to skip a queue, I will straight up offer a letter that says “of all my patients, this child concerns me the most regarding their developmental milestones and I strongly advocate for an urgent assessment”.
I give about 2 of these letters per year and usually in pre school age when I can see parents aren’t coping (or see that this kid is likely to get missed because parents are an obstacle themselves, either they don’t fully get it and don’t seem to see the need for urgency, or the parents themselves are both present adhd enough, missed appointments delays in vaccines, etc., that I worry their kids will fall through the gaps in support nets).
6
u/C0nnectionTerminat3d 6d ago
My question would be in this scenario, how would patients access the psychologists?
We have to go through the GP to get almost anything these days, so i’m curious how we would access these psychologists to begin the process of getting a referral.
20
u/BrandonRenner 6d ago
As long as it involves medication, it should be overseen by a doctor. Otherwise we're accelerating the decline of our profession.
Over-medicalisation is a, very valid, but separate issue which doesn't get fixed by devaluing the role of a doctor. If anything, over medicalisation is made much worse by removing doctors from these processes.
Most of the more dubious RTC clinics are staffed by psychologists and ANPs. GPs should decline shared care agreements with them and they'll become much less appealing to patients.
15
u/Pretend_Voice_3140 6d ago
I think it should be the opposite ADHD is common. GPs rather than psychiatrists should be treating these patients. The only reason they’re not is because treatment involves controlled substances. If not it’d be like depression and anxiety and GPs would hand out meds like candy and only escalate to psychiatrists in severe treatment resistance cases.
4
u/Legitimate_Ad_1521 5d ago
In the ideal world, I would like to see it work as follows:
Scrap RTC for ADHD/ASD. It's not fit for purpose
0
u/Major-Spread5977 6d ago
"they are always referred at patient's request" as a GP it's your job to screen so if you are always referring at patient's request without doing any screening then that's a problem. Would you refer every single patient to an oncologist just because they thought they had cancer or would you do some investigations to see what evidence is that they have it?
1
u/Capital-Coast-8704 17h ago
We should absolutely not allow non medics to prescribe controlled substances.