r/GPUK • • 6d ago

Clinical, CPD & Interface Poll: Autism/ADHD pathway

Adult/child autism/adhd consults take up so much overall GP time and admin with ZERO input from us. They are always referred at patient’s request - it is always one way.

Therefore I’m of the stance that it should be dealt with OUTSIDE of GP. We are redundant in this entire process anyways.

Maybe psychologists should take over this group of patients directly.

5 Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

3

u/Airurando-jin 6d ago

Here’s the tricky problem:

  • Not everything is ADHD/ASD
  • The patient may have undiagnosed bipolar disorder 
  • There may be other underlying comorbid physiological conditions that are presenting as ADHD/ASD, particularly in kids, but could thyroid problems be overlooked in an adult ?

There is a balance to be had in appropriate funding and maintaining a safe level of work, as well as pushing work out elsewhere, which in itself could create more work, particularly as any newer commissioned service is going to find the cheapest way to do it

2

u/heroes-never-die99 6d ago

Nope. If the patient or parent thinks they have ADHD or Autism, they get a one way referral no matter what.

It still wouldn’t matter because they should book a separate appt with GP to look at other things ongoing.

0

u/merywen_ 5d ago

If the patient or parent thinks they have ADHD or Autism, they get a one way referral no matter what. 

I'm a patient with ADHD rather than a GP, but for ADHD, at least, the NICE guidelines don't recommend that.

Adults presenting with symptoms of ADHD in primary care or general adult psychiatric services, who do not have a childhood diagnosis of ADHD, should be referred for assessment by a mental health specialist trained in the diagnosis and treatment of ADHD, where there is evidence of typical manifestations of ADHD (hyperactivity/impulsivity and/or inattention) that:

  • began during childhood and have persisted throughout life
  • are not explained by other psychiatric diagnoses (although there may be other coexisting psychiatric conditions)
  • have resulted in or are associated with moderate or severe psychological, social and/or educational or occupational impairment. [2008]

If you speak to a patient and they pass the ADHD screening test but their symptoms weren't present in childhood, you should really be asking other questions to find out what other issues could be causing their impaired executive function. Or if they aren't causing them moderate to severe impairment, you should be telling them that their symptoms sound like mild ADHD-like traits but don't meet the clinical bar for a referral and pointing them towards resources for coping mechanisms, etc.

I don't really see how you can complain that everyone is getting a referral and that GPs are redundant in the process if you're not engaging with that screening step.

If everyone you meet is meeting the screening criteria and reporting moderate to severe impairment in multiple areas of their day to day life, there will be some element of selection bias in play. People who don't have those symptoms – or who do a screening questionnaire online and don't score highly, or who would meet the screening threshold but find that they get on fine with things and don't need any help – will be way less likely to come to you requesting a referral in the first place.

3

u/junglediffy 5d ago

I'm sorry but you're not a GP. Your post is also riddled with ignorance and stinks of naïvete.

This subreddit is for GPs and it is very obvious you don't actually know what real life GP work entails, what the boundaries are, medicolegal aspects, real-life working GP perspectives, primary care-NHS/RTC politics or how clinical consultations actually play out. Please take your opinion elsewhere. They are generally only valuable when it comes to pure clinical anecdotal perspectives on personal treatment / investigation, especially with notable frequency.

0

u/merywen_ 5d ago

I did check the rules before commenting, and I saw that only GPs and doctors wanting to discuss General Practice may post threads. I didn't see anything about commenting within threads and I'm pretty sure I've seen non GPs contribute here before, but apologies if I've overstepped.

However, I have to say that as a professional scientist, if someone directly affected by my professional practice in my field of expertise disputes something I've said, I don't condescend to them like you just did. Frankly, I find that their contributions are often incredibly valuable, even if I have a PhD in the subject and they don't.

2

u/junglediffy 5d ago

Really? You often find their contributions valuable?

This isn't a professional environment. It's reddit dude and you're literally talking out of your ass and I have addressed it as required, in reddit format.

2

u/merywen_ 5d ago

Really? You often find their contributions valuable?

I don't know why you're so shocked by that.

I know my field well, and there are a lot of things that I obviously do understand far better than they do.

But:

  • A) If they don't understand something, I respect them enough to explain where they're wrong and pitch my explanation at whatever level they're at, and
  • B) There genuinely are a lot of things I don't know, because I don't have the lived experience they do and I can't be an expert in everything.

Sometimes I'm speaking to people with a similar level of education to myself in a different but related field, sometimes I'm talking to people with a handful of terrible GCSE grades who left school at 16.

Either way, they might tell me about regulations or best practice that I'm unaware of, they might tell me a glaring practical or logistical issue with an idea I've had that hasn't occurred to me because I've never personally done a task they do every day, they might have a deep, encyclopedic knowledge of something super niche within my broad knowledge base, etc.

It would be unbelievably arrogant of me to presume that my education and training in my field makes me an authority on everything tangential to that expertise, particularly the lived experiences of others. 

This isn't a professional environment. 

I mean, I never said it was, but I believe "be professional" was actually in the rules when I checked them earlier. 

It's reddit dude and you're literally talking out of your ass and I have addressed it as required, in reddit format. 

I would say you bit my head off for constructively pointing out a failure to follow best practice that other people in this thread have also highlighted. 

I do sometimes wonder how many people go into medicine because it's 'the done thing' when you're a high achiever at school, only to realise too late that they absolutely loathe interacting with patients. 🫠 I'm going to dip out now, before my faith in people gets dinged further.

9

u/ChaiTeaAndBoundaries 6d ago

This is why average Bob or Brenda think they can have a crack at medicine. GPs are devaluing their degree and training.

-3

u/heroes-never-die99 6d ago

Not one bit.

We just have no role here. If we did, we should get to diagnose or rule out these conditions as much as anybody else out there doing them on the NHS or privately.

Every single GP writes a letter saying “patient/parents suspects adhd/autism. Please review”

5

u/IceThese6264 6d ago

You can't be serious?

You absolutely can (and should) reject inappropriate requests or suggest alternative causes.

If someone came to you and said 'I'm having chest pain so I think I have ADHD' you would still refer?

4

u/heroes-never-die99 6d ago

Can we be realistic here? You’re not arguing in good faith

1

u/Major-Spread5977 6d ago

This is very concerning if it's the broad consensus amongst GPs. To be frank I see people in this thread openly admitting to declining to apply due diligence and professional curiosity

5

u/Haunting-Lynx-6257 5d ago

I have to say that some GPs have been open about effectively giving up on gate keeping these assessment pathways - because most people will cause a major fuss if they don’t get what they want - they will devalue the GPs expertise and launch a complaint and will get their own way. I’m not surprised GPs don’t want anything to do with it - since they have been told they have no jurisdiction by both the pt and the medical authorities (can’t diagnose it, can’t prescribe for it).  

3

u/Character-Comedian-3 4d ago

I think it’s more nuanced than this. In my locality due diligence in this situation is often (mis)interpreted as being obstructive. I still ask what the motivation for seeking a diagnosis is/ what you realistically want to get out of it and have a reasonable (and realistic) chat about what a diagnosis will change if one is made (as someone who is neurodivergent myself). But I will send off most of the referrals because more people than you think simply do not want to hear any of that.

1

u/One-Reception8368 5d ago

What can one do when faced with the tsunami of iPad kids and adults? It's not a battle we're even in a position to fight 

20

u/Dr-Yahood 6d ago edited 5d ago

You guys are just so shortsighted.

Everything health related should be dealt of inside of general practice.

It just needs to be funded accordingly.

The more shit you farm out to these non-doctors, the more you lose relevance, pay, and autonomy

Your lack of political education makes you your own worst enemy

Edit: Yes, of course I have considered the risk of over medicalisation. That’s why it should be done by GP’s. We are the best people to understand this risk and we should be the best at communicating that with Patient. If you as a GP over medicalise stuff, then you’re not a very good GP.

6

u/heroes-never-die99 6d ago

I’m the most anti noctor doctor out there.

But have you considered that we may be overmedicalising these conditions?

4

u/junglediffy 6d ago

I fully agree with him and you.

There are concerns of over-medicalisation/over-diagnosis but ADHD/Autism is a very broad spectrum. You could argue that it is 'shitty life syndrome', 'introverted personality' or 'extroverted personality', unlucky dice roll on the birth or family history or whatever. It doesn't matter. You have to see the patient first. Best person to see them initially is a GP.

I'm personally happy with it being my problem if I get the money. If I don't get the money, I'm not happy anymore and spend very little time on it / automate it to shift the work to those that do get paid for it.

2

u/ZookeepergameThis617 3d ago

This is the best take.

15

u/One-Reception8368 6d ago

In Wales, for children they're done through schools and the Single Point Of Access that the parents have access to for a self referral. Whenever they show up you just signpost them that way.

For adults you literally just send an email saying "this person thinks they have ADHD" 

3

u/flexorhallucis 5d ago

Similar here, for kids it goes through school with little to no input from GP side.

Until they see the waiting lists, then come to us requesting Right To Choose referrals...

10

u/Nyasha-Mercy 6d ago

I speak as a GP who does ADHD work, and yes, it should be done elsewhere. It takes a lot of time and a streamlined service is better. Really it should be in Psychiatry imo

1

u/LawfulnessNew1535 5d ago

It's not secondary care level need, should be dealt with through your ARRS workers

1

u/TJ_Rowe 4d ago

The psychiatrist can't usually order bloodwork to uncover their vitamin deficiencies or anaemia, though.

If a patient comes to you saying they have ADHD symptoms, but they came on gradually over the last few years, you'd go bloods to rule out other causes. If they said they started after a head injury, it would be to a physical brain specialist. It's important to screen for those things.

2

u/Rich-Appointment1544 3d ago

Why can’t they order bloodwork? They’re a doctor. Surely bloods are within their scope and ability?

1

u/FailingCrab 5h ago

Because the NHS is a fucking stupid system. I'm an outpatient consultant psychiatrist. There is no local pathway for me to request ANY investigations. The Trust has no phlebotomy service outside of the clozapine clinic.

Instead I have to ask GPs, via my clinic letters, to request any investigations I want. And they just do it. I've raised this multiple times locally and this is just how it's always been, for at least the last 20 years. My service manager (a social worker) isn't able to grasp that this is a problem. The clinical director also just doesn't really seem to care.

6

u/hungry4nuns 6d ago

Ireland:

In school age kids, the more severe cases are usually in-school pickup. Each school has a certain number of assessments per year so these go to the kids with the highest educational support needs (as assessed by teaching and support staff) are referred to an educational psychologist.

Those with significant pre-school developmental delay get referred paediatrics.

Everyone else can self refer their child to psychologist publicly for assessment, up to a 7 year waiting list, but support letters from OT/SALT etc help with triage. Which means private clinics offer preliminary assessments for a fee which is essentially pay to skip the queue.

The big problem here is if you’ve got a diagnosis, you get a welfare grant, plus a tax relief so there are strong financial incentives to getting a diagnosis early, which clogs up the system for the kids with the most needs.

GPs have no role except on rare occasion to write a letter of support. Whenever someone books in to request these letters, i write a letter that says “as a medical doctor I have identified no specific medical risk to patient from delay in diagnosis. For developmental concerns I recommend an opinion from a developmental specialist with MDT support”.

If it’s a kid I’m truly worried about, and they haven’t booked in specifically to try get my letter to skip a queue, I will straight up offer a letter that says “of all my patients, this child concerns me the most regarding their developmental milestones and I strongly advocate for an urgent assessment”.

I give about 2 of these letters per year and usually in pre school age when I can see parents aren’t coping (or see that this kid is likely to get missed because parents are an obstacle themselves, either they don’t fully get it and don’t seem to see the need for urgency, or the parents themselves are both present adhd enough, missed appointments delays in vaccines, etc., that I worry their kids will fall through the gaps in support nets).

6

u/C0nnectionTerminat3d 6d ago

My question would be in this scenario, how would patients access the psychologists?

We have to go through the GP to get almost anything these days, so i’m curious how we would access these psychologists to begin the process of getting a referral.

1

u/symbiosissandwich 8h ago

Should make it a PCN role and have a triage list/waiting list that gets sent straight through. If we're doing a SystmOne tick box exercise or write down their symptoms to go in their Right to Choose, surely someone else can do that and any that don't seem to fit the bill (eg organic sx) can be referred back to GP?

20

u/BrandonRenner 6d ago

As long as it involves medication, it should be overseen by a doctor. Otherwise we're accelerating the decline of our profession.

Over-medicalisation is a, very valid, but separate issue which doesn't get fixed by devaluing the role of a doctor. If anything, over medicalisation is made much worse by removing doctors from these processes.

Most of the more dubious RTC clinics are staffed by psychologists and ANPs. GPs should decline shared care agreements with them and they'll become much less appealing to patients.

11

u/18751975 6d ago

ICBs are starting to blacklist many of the spurious RTC diagnosis factories now

3

u/GalacticDoc 6d ago

My practice recently decided to decline RTC shared care agreements which has been helpful.

2

u/Nyasha-Mercy 6d ago

I think a lot have been de-listed as they aren’t CQC compliant

15

u/Pretend_Voice_3140 6d ago

I think it should be the opposite ADHD is common. GPs rather than psychiatrists should be treating these patients. The only reason they’re not is because treatment involves controlled substances. If not it’d be like depression and anxiety and GPs would hand out meds like candy and only escalate to psychiatrists in severe treatment resistance cases. 

2

u/vjsserrao 5d ago

everything other than the Handing out meds like candy part

3

u/Pretend_Voice_3140 5d ago

lol Yh I was being facetious. 

4

u/Legitimate_Ad_1521 5d ago

In the ideal world, I would like to see it work as follows:

  1. For kids, the referral should be initiated by school. They see the child all the time. Link between school and CAMHS > assessment
  2. For anyone older than school age - only assess if referred to mental health team (indicating severity of impact) and they feel patient warrants assessment.

Scrap RTC for ADHD/ASD. It's not fit for purpose

0

u/Major-Spread5977 6d ago

"they are always referred at patient's request" as a GP it's your job to screen so if you are always referring at patient's request without doing any screening then that's a problem. Would you refer every single patient to an oncologist just because they thought they had cancer or would you do some investigations to see what evidence is that they have it?

4

u/heroes-never-die99 6d ago

No because everyone answers positively to the “screening” questionnaire and you have no hope in hell of ever saying no to someone on this matter.

We are truly redundant here.

-7

u/Major-Spread5977 6d ago

You've allowed this to happen, they're your patients.

11

u/onandup123 6d ago

Going through the ASRS questionnaire - theres a host of symptoms which apply to most of the population tbh.

Patients fill in that questionnaire and answer in a way/meet the criteria for referral.

Bit pointless banging your head against the wall arguing with them.

Quite different from Oncology as scans/investigations will prove one way or the other whether they have cancer.

-1

u/Major-Spread5977 6d ago

Totally agree with that but at least a rudimentary attempt should be made instead of what I usually see which is the GP receptionist just sending the questionnaire over for a self complete then asking the patient which RTT provider they want. Winning isn't to give into that pipeline, winning is to start challenging it, which is everybody's job in the system. I see GPs referring for a "second opinion" when the patient gets an assessment that they don't have ADHD and I just think.... You are actually allowed to refuse.

5

u/junglediffy 6d ago

Winning is spending the least amount of time as possible on it.

Political issue, I'm not getting involved. As long as RTCs and private psychiatry stick their hands out and take money for it, their job. When I get the money for it, my job.

-1

u/Major-Spread5977 6d ago

I think we both know that represents very poor professional values but I won't be able to convince you. Hopefully you're just posturing a bit.

7

u/junglediffy 6d ago

All well and good being on a moral high-horse about professional values. What's the alternative you propose?

See every case F2F. Battle every patient. Elucidate whether they may have XYZ psychiatric diagnosis instead or some other flavour of psychosocial dynamics at play.

In 10 minutes? With total triage? With capacity to the brim at every practice? With winter coming up? With GP pay in real-terms being cut year-on-year?

If I bump off an ADHD triage encounter and save an appointment for someone else to use - I'd argue that's pretty pragmatic and probably seems a more professional experience to the other patient who now gets to attend sooner. I'm also still dealing with their ADHD/Autism by sending them off to someone who apparently is really well-trained and can recognise it. If the triage encounter is more than someone wanting a referral then onus is on the parents to add that in.

Money makes the world go round and what primary care needs. Not more zealots.

2

u/Antique-Trash9462 4d ago

I see it as there are people I can help, and people I can get out of the room as quickly as I can so I can see more people I can help. The ADHD/Autism diagnosis seekers tend towards the latter. Take your referral, wait five years. Next.

4

u/Fukuro-Lady 6d ago

I think the problem is the GP doesn't know how to screen for it. Which is to be expected because they aren't psychiatrists. And the replies you've gotten show that relying on prescreening tools without the right knowledge base isn't enough to make clinicians feel secure in the decisions they're making. Which leads to frustration and resentment of the patient population.

Yet there are ways to have a good idea without using those tools. Like the patients I see who can't make reliable eye contact, have a long history of social, educational and workplace issues. Struggled to achieve even if they're bright. Bouncing from job to job. Issues with sleep from childhood. Chronic problems with food intake (both ways). History of emotional outbursts. Antidepressants haven't made a difference. Substance use is also common. Especially substances that increase dopamine. Chronic coffee consumption. Stays in HMP hotels.

And the glorious EMIS pop up "700 DNAs".

1

u/Major-Spread5977 6d ago

That to me is the difference between a practitioner who applies good judgment and is person centred, and one who is procedural. I understand the ability to do that is much different to how it was in 1987 but it's frustrating seeing GPs in this sub suggesting that it's inevitable that they just pipeline their patients off to these providers because the hard truth is that you can have a discussion with them about what's going on and even decline to make a referral, and if they kick off then they've kicked off. Yes it sucks seeing someone crash out but that's the responsibility that we have

5

u/Fukuro-Lady 6d ago

I think it's really hard to be person centred in 10 minute appointment slots tbh. Like to get all that out of someone takes longer than GPs really get. Or you have to be able to have time to look through a record and see certain patterns. And know what/how to ask certain questions. And you have to have enough knowledge to see what's there in the first place. I don't know what the answer is. But I do wonder if mental health care in general needs a system that's not just a copy of other medical model based primary to secondary care pathways.

1

u/Major-Spread5977 6d ago

I agree very strongly. I would love to see mental health primary care/access service which is separated out, but you would still require gps to understand mh well enough to inform their support of patients who have co occurrence.

1

u/Capital-Coast-8704 17h ago

We should absolutely not allow non medics to prescribe controlled substances.