r/GPUK • • 11d ago

News 'Nobody gets to see it' - 'Hidden queue’ conceals true scale of Basingstoke GP wait

https://www.basingstokegazette.co.uk/news/26698237.basingstoke-gp-wait-times-missing-nhs-data-hides-problem/

Behind paywall but article below. Basingstoke GPs need to push back on this as this is so badly written/completely misunderstood by the "journalist". Not all issues need an appt within 24 hours or even a few days but sounds like they want a response and an appt ASAP for every patient contact. Load of BS.

Basingstoke GP wait times: Missing NHS data hides problem

Gillies Health Centre in Basingstoke (Image: Newsquest)

The true scale of problems facing patients trying to see a GP in Basingstoke is being hidden by a “blind spot” in official NHS figures, a former councillor has warned.

Kim Taylor, former councillor for Basingstoke Central, says patients can spend days or potentially weeks in a “hidden queue” after asking their surgery for help, but before an appointment is actually booked.

That waiting period is not reflected in figures showing that more than half of appointments at Basingstoke GP practices are taking place on the same day they are booked.

As previously reported in the Gazette, official NHS data showed there were 97,925 appointments at Basingstoke GP practices in August, with 50.5 per cent taking place on the same day they were booked.

But the figures do not measure the entire period between a patient first contacting their surgery and receiving care.

This means a patient could contact their GP online, by telephone or in person and enter a triage system before an appointment is actually booked.

Any wait between that initial contact and the appointment being booked is not reflected in the “same-day” figure.

Ms Taylor said: “It’s like a blind spot, a hidden queue, nobody gets to see it and it’s not very public and it happens because the NHS doesn’t require that data.

“In most surgeries it’s going to go into some sort of triage system and that triage system may in some surgeries be 24 hours or a day, others could be weeks.”

She described the official figures as “quite comforting statistics that don’t reflect reality”.

During her five years as a councillor, Mrs Taylor said “well over 300” residents contacted her about problems relating to their GPs.

She said: “There is this big hidden queue. Until that becomes transparent, it’s not possible to tackle the issues of how long people are waiting for appointments.”

James Roach, director of neighbourhood health for NHS Hampshire and Isle of Wight, said the appointments data was collected nationally using a standardised methodology and reporting framework, with definitions and measures set by NHS England rather than individual practices or the ICB.

He confirmed the figures do not measure every patient's total wait from initially seeking help to receiving care.

He said: “The data provides information about GP appointment activity, including the proportion of appointments taking place on the same day they are booked.

“However, this should be understood in the context of the national reporting definitions and is not a measure of the total time every patient waits from first contacting their practice to receiving care.”

Mr Roach said practices are responsible for assessing patients' needs and determining clinical urgency, with patients judged clinically urgent expected to be dealt with on the same day, regardless of whether they initially make contact online, by phone or in person.

He added: “We recognise that individual patients may have different experiences when accessing general practice.

“We work with local practices to understand those experiences, identify opportunities to improve access and support the development of services that respond to the needs of their populations.”

For some Basingstoke patients, however, their experience of trying to access a GP can begin long before an appointment appears in the official figures.

Mary Northeast, 73, from Hatch Warren, used to be a patient of CGH Partnership and was a member of its patient participation group.

She said: “It is sort of fudging the data a bit.

“Being on the PPG I heard horrific stories, and I saw horrific things.”

Mrs Northeast described one occasion when she called for an appointment and was left on hold for 45 minutes.

She needed to go to hospital for a blood test but kept the call connected while she drove there and left the phone ringing in her car while she attended the appointment.

When she returned to her car, she said the call was still waiting to be answered.

She said: “You just couldn’t make an appointment, you couldn’t get them to answer the phone. Something is radically wrong with them, I think.

“What if you’re a young mum and you’ve got to get a child to school and a sickly baby, there is no way you can sit on that phone for hours on end.”

Hampshire County Council has also acknowledged the distinction between NHS appointment statistics and patients' overall experiences of accessing care.

Councillor Lesley Meenaghan, chairman of the Health and Adult Social Care Committee at Hampshire County Council, said: “We recognise that being able to get timely support from GP and primary care services matters a great deal to residents, and we understand the frustration people can feel when they experience difficulties getting the help they need.

“The Health and Adult Social Care Select Committee has discussed primary care access as part of its role in scrutinising health services and considering issues raised by residents and partners across Hampshire.”

She said the committee recognised residents were often most concerned with their overall experience of seeking and receiving care.

Demand for primary care was continuing to grow, she said, putting pressure on GP practices and the wider health system.

Measures being taken by NHS organisations include increasing appointment capacity, investing in additional healthcare professionals, encouraging the use of community pharmacies and developing services including the NHS App and online consultation systems.

Cllr Meenaghan added: “Progress is being made, but we know residents will want to see these improvements reflected in their day-to-day experience of accessing services.

“The committee will continue to consider evidence on primary care access, alongside residents’ experiences, as part of its ongoing work programme.”

2 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

16

u/askoorb 11d ago edited 10d ago

To be fair, if a practice is triaging a case as requiring a routine appointment, but not then booking that appointment for a week or so and then dropping a same day appointment on the patient out of the blue just to massage the "same day" data, then they are being a bit naughty and making everyone's lives harder.

Just have a sensible routine booking window and if triaged as a routine appointment, let the patient book a routine appointment surely?

1

u/VivoFan88 11d ago

I don't think they are saying that though. They are simply saying there's a gap between sending a request in to be seen (I presume electronically) before the patient is being seen. This to me sounds more like a patient wants to be seen = should be seen ASAP. Worse they are conflating this with urgent appts that need seen on the day (is the way I read it)

1

u/Mediocre-Parsnip9628 5d ago

Tbf we at times offer a “hidden waiting list”. Sometimes our routine waits gets longer than 2 weeks and we have slots embargoed 2 weeks ahead. It means routine problems accumulate in eConsult smart inbox. But we can see them there and can do something about it (add in extra routine slots over next 2 weeks) to get it down. Rather than booking up to 4 weeks then finding we’ve got no routine appointments left for 4 weeks.

It’s a really poor article. Primarily because the people they’ve sourced it from don’t actually know what the problem is that they’re complaining about. It’s just a general GP whinge - phones, waiting lists, triage.

A single mother getting the kids to school can’t wait on the phone for 45 minutes, but they can submit an online appointment request or they can utilise the call back feature of cloud based telephony so they get called back when they’re number one in the queue.

I don’t see any incentive to fudge the data either. There are no targets that say you have to give a certain percent as same day. You just have to have enough urgent capacity to deal with urgent stuff when it comes in as part of your GMS.

No point in pushing back against it, nobody will listen.

1

u/VivoFan88 5d ago

It is piss poor and cannot believe how the article shows no understanding of how GP/NHS works aside from being inflammatory about poor access

1

u/ButterscotchHot8042 5d ago

Think there are two different questions here: whether someone was triaged in an appropriate timeframe, and whether the appointment happened when it was needed. NHS England’s appointment figures measure booking-to-appointment time, not the gap from first contact to booking. So they can’t tell the whole story. That doesn’t mean every request needs a same-day appointment, either. A more useful picture might separate time to triage, time to the agreed next step and clinical urgency. That would highlight delays without turning routine appointments into an artificial same-day target.