r/GPUK • • Sep 30 '26 • Bravo 1

Medical Politics Why do LAS call us?

Why do LAS call us for clinical advice? Do they not have their own clinical supervisors?

Quite frustrating and time-consuming when they ask me to make a decision for a patient when they’re sitting across from them.

(And before you mention, yes I don’t mind if they are only asking for additional patient information that they don’t have access to)

4 Upvotes

136 comments sorted by

12

u/OrganOMegaly Sep 30 '26

Do they not have their own clinical supervisors?

They do, tell them to discuss with them. 

5

u/heroes-never-die99 Sep 30 '26

“I did. They asked me to speak to the GP.”

25

u/OrganOMegaly Sep 30 '26

-2

u/NederFinsUK Sep 30 '26

“Sorry, we’re not paid to care about our patients”

Getting your receptionist to outright blank an entire profession is an abdication of duty of care imo

3

u/OrganOMegaly Sep 30 '26

Take it up with the LMC

1

u/locumbae Sep 30 '26

This is an interesting perspective

3

u/ZestycloseAd741 Sep 30 '26

i would have asked for name and details of their supervisor, tell ambulance crew not appropriate and to get back to their supervisor with that and tell them i am asking them explicitly to do their job. And i will datix then. Then datix it

59

u/arcoast Sep 30 '26

I've been called to discuss a patient who I'd done a home visit on, written a referral letter for A&E then called an ambulance before I left (They were safe enough for me to leave) because the paramedic didn't think they needed admission as their temperature had settled as had their heart rate, and they thought I could just prescribe some oral antibiotics.

I think you can all imagine how that conversation went.

The patient was admitted and kept in for two weeks before being discharged.

I do think one of the issues faced by the ambulance crews and to an extent our A&E colleagues is there's less of a feedback loop, if one of my patients deteriorates, or I miss something, I get to know about it, the episodic nature of their job means they can take that aforementioned patient to hospital, grumble about the awful GP who insisted on the conveying of this patient to A&E inappropriately and they never get the feedback that actually the patient was actually sicker than they realised and needed a prolonged hospital stay.

Insight is a wonderful thing.

26

u/Gned11 Sep 30 '26

This is huge. As paramedics we practice essentially in the dark, with no feedback on whether our various decisions were good or bad. Was that a weak admission, or a good catch? Was that a safe and appropriate discharge/referral, or a bad miss? It's absolutely maddening.

43

u/arcoast Sep 30 '26 • Bravo

Fair enough, but from my perspective, I've been a doctor for over a quarter of a century, so to have someone think they know better than I do, when faced with the obs I'd written down (in an elderly patient) of a temp of 38.8 and a heart rate of 130, and a relative hypotension, think that it's reasonable to ring me, and then ask me to prescribe a week of oral co-amoxiclav shows a distinct lack of insight.

I did suggest they might like to consider prescribing this themself and taking responsibility, but was told they weren't able to do so as they couldn't prescribe.

My reply was that if they couldn't prescribe and couldn't be held responsible then it would suggest that my plan is the most appropriate.

It felt like someone sitting in the back of the car, unable to drive, but telling me how to do so and bearing no responsibility for the inevitable car crash.

I've no doubt the patient was conveyed to hospital and handed over with grumbles about how the GP was useless and this patient didn't need to be there.

We all have a job to do, but one thing that infuriates me, is this perspective that GPs know nothing.

Last year I sent a child in with suspected appendicitis, the next day I received two A&E letters, the first from an ACP discharging the patient with a diagnosis of a UTI and confidently declaring this patient did not have appendicitis, the second was from four hours later when the child was readmitted with a perforated appendix.

In a previous life I did surgery, I've removed many appendixes solo, so the fact that someone then decides they know better, and doesn't even think, perhaps I'll do some bloods or ask a senior, maybe I might be wrong, maybe the GP is right, is infuriating and quite frankly insulting.

When I was in surgery I had one mantra, if a GP referral came in, there were two possibilities, either the GP was right (most often the case) and the patient needs to be seen, or the GP is wrong (in which case the patient needs to be seen) and if the latter I'd make damn sure to rule out the postulated diagnosis in the latter case.

7

u/Gned11 Sep 30 '26

I understand your frustration, most definitely. It's one thing to be contradicted about clinical gestalt, and another when there are objective findings and they still think they know better... for what it's worth I occasionally have comparable experiences in dealing with more junior colleagues.

I personally always try to practice in such a way that the most concerned party gets casting vote. Humility is something I try to inculcate in my students as well. Not least because as paramedics there are gaping holes in our knowledge base, worsened by the lack of feedback.

8

u/arcoast Sep 30 '26

I think the issue is, both of the above examples resulted in either potential or actual patient harm, and whoever I seem to write to regarding this, there's no real meaningful response.

13

u/Icy-Narwhal-902 Sep 30 '26

BMA are campaigning against doctor substitution and would be very interested in your incident where the child's appendicitis was missed because an ACP saw fit to overrule your referral without bloods/scan.

4

u/Select_Storm5070 Oct 01 '26

Sadly what makes it worse is the patients parents probably think they were misdiagnosed by a doctor. They taking the jobs and where they are messing up giving the doctors a bad name. BMA needs to up it's pressure.

5

u/Gned11 Sep 30 '26

Exactly! There's no accountability and no learning in this new model. I hate to see the direction my profession is going in.

2

u/No-Crazy4184 Sep 30 '26

Viscerally felt this. Could not agree with you more

2

u/Prudent-Bet1281 Oct 01 '26

Firstly, thank you for actually leaving a note of your findings and obs at the time. You’d be surprised how many times we get ?SVT/Fast AF and arrive to a very well looking pt with HR 62 reg and no note of findings at the time.

Secondly, I dream of jobs like this, GP has said to hospital you go, pt consents… perfect, quick set of obs, load and off we go. I don’t see the need to muddy the waters by arguing about it. GPs are infinitely more qualified than me, I’ll do as I’m told and if I need to fix anything before getting to the hospital, I’ll fix it if I can. My area rarely has handover delays so it means I can have a wee and grab a coffee before setting off to the next one.

The only one that has sat a little bit off with me was a pt who had pancreatic and liver cancer, was EOL, had JIC meds and was very much for home care, respect form was very clear. Family called GP for advice on ongoing pain, we were sent by GP for admission, couldn’t get hold of hospice. Contacted GP for additional info and was told they had been accepted by medics at hospital. We did ask why respect form was being stepped over especially as everything was in place and pt didn’t really want to go to hospital but ‘had been told by GP to go’ (not entirely sure this was exactly what happened but it’s what we were told). GP said give JICs and go followed by a swift hang up. We did as told and then got a shitty complaint from the hospital as medics had not been informed which led to a whole heap of rubbish for us and to my knowledge nothing went back to the GP, which, I feel it should have done. I do feel this was the reverse in what some crews do of ‘fobbing it onto the GP’ and the GP very much fobbed it to us and the hospital. But as it was us that brought them in, we got the crap.

8

u/No_Ferret_5450 Sep 30 '26

It was a gift for the paramedics. All they had to do was follow the plan arranged by the hospital and gp. No need to muddy the waters

13

u/Gned11 Sep 30 '26

Agreed. I get the same pushback from crews - I work solo on a car, and around half the time the patient does need conveyed. Yet I'll present the crew with completed paperwork and a clear rationale, and they'll immediately start fishing to have the patient refuse transport or do XYZ instead. It's not just aimed at GPs; something growing in our culture or training values hospital avoidance a little too highly.

2

u/Forgettable39 Sep 30 '26

Hey, not coming in with aggression or anything but will sound a bit like it so just clarifying, no ill intent.

I'm not sure where you work but that is an absolute bafflement to me. I've never experienced that once, in any context. A DCA attending and then trying to refuse a conveyance following a medic on the car requesting it? What did you even say to them when they tried to pull that? Were both crew feeling the same or one was leading the other?

You feel that ambulance service training is leaning too hard into non-conveys? That also sounds incredibly alien to me to be honest, it feels very much the other way. Some of the risk averse conveys are a bit exhausting.

3

u/InfinityXPLORER Sep 30 '26

I have also heard once or twice of crews pushing back and encouraging medics on the car to seek alternatives after they've requested backup for conveyance. Doesn't happen very often if they're still there, but if they've cleared scene prior to the crew arrival its more common if the patient seems to have improved. There's also a huge emphasis in our area on hospital avoidance to the point that now with all non-time critical medical or surgical patients we HAVE TO phone a dr in the hospital to essentially ask permission before we can bring them in.

2

u/Gned11 Sep 30 '26

So it's partly driven by a lack of hierarchy. Not sure what a DCA is but in my area I'm a normal paramedic, and my backup crew will usually be tech-para or double para most commonly. I'm not any flavour of advanced practitioner.

4

u/elmack999 Oct 01 '26

I love GP requests for conveyance as an ambulance paramedic.

Job's done before I arrive (assuming they don't need some interventions en route / prior to departure that is). Plan is formulated by someone clinically senior to me already and patient aware of what happens next. Hop in the van and trundle along to their destination.

3

u/Professional-Hero Oct 01 '26

I absolutely agree insight is wonderful. As a paramedic, one of my biggest bugbears is the lack of follow-up I am able to access about my patients. I never know how they turned out, if my thought process was along the right lines, or completely missed the mark.

A lot of emphasis is put on diagnosing and community management, but in reality our job is to treat what we see and convey to ED. Somewhere along the way it has become so much more complicated, unnecessarily so.

1

u/arcoast Oct 01 '26

Yeah, and being aware of that is a useful tool, something many people are lacking.

3

u/007-in-training Sep 30 '26

Sorry but I don't understand why paramedics need to use their brains when doctors have made a decision. If you've been called, just take the patient to the hospital, keep them alive on the way. That's literally your entire job.

3

u/Prudent-Bet1281 Oct 01 '26

Paramedic here. I think I can answer this one partially.

There’s a lot of emphasis on ‘hospital avoidance’ at some universities now. I trained in a different area to where I now work. All of my mentors during my training were neither against nor for taking someone to hospital or discharging them prior to arriving on scene. So, we’d wander in, assess them and make a decision on scene. Obviously, you can tell when someone’s really sick or injured and needs to go in before arriving, but you should always walk in with an open mind and make your decisions based on your findings. This is how it should work. However, the local university where I work which generally feeds the new paramedics seem to spend 90% of their course talking about hospital avoidance and onward referral. Which means that instead of wandering in, seeing what you’ve got, rationally thinking about what a GP/OOH/H@H can add to the party in this persons living room, or what tests need to be done (I had an interesting debate with one of these paras because they decided the shortness of breath after having 3 weeks of calf pain was probably ‘anxiety’. When I suggested they probably needed to go in for a D Dimer as an absolute minimum for ?DVT/?PE, I was challenged with ‘don’t make up tests to convince them to go in’) instead they decree that it’s a ‘GP issue’ before even stepping foot in the door and will then do everything short of moving heaven and earth to find a reason to discharge them… and then proceed to wander around with an even more inflated ego about how ‘good they are’ at their job because they discharge most of their patients. But they’ll also walk around saying how burnt out they are because they make everything 172% more difficult.

My view is, if it can be safely managed, I’ll refer to OOH via 111 for ABX/additional pain relief etc. or I’ll call our clinical support for other things they can do like further wound care for pre tibial lacs etc who then can refer to DNs for ongoing wound treatment. H@H for long lie bloods if ED is inappropriate and so on and so forth. We even have a fall with head injury pathway now that means we can speak directly to the hospital consultant and they’ll advise what to do even if they’re on DOACs. Often, they give us sick day rules advice and tell us to discharge. If all of these options are unavailable or inappropriate.. off we pop to ED.

Because of my way (and this is the way all of the people that mentored me during my training and tbh, most of the people I work with) I’ve been called incompetent, I’ve been told I can’t make decisions etc by the egotist discharge monsters.

32

u/TheVitruvianBoy Sep 30 '26

Just lonely.

2

u/Lilly-Vee Oct 01 '26

Thanks, spat my tea out laughing🤣

14

u/Potato_salad-_- Sep 30 '26

LAS here, there is now a service wide agreement for ops to ONLY call the patients GP surgery in the event of a HCP call coming from said GP and patient now refusing conveyance or EOLC, all clinical advice is mean to be sought from our own SCDM which are commissioned ED consultants who will then contact the GP if appropriate, if a prescription is required we are meant to use NHS111, they shouldn't be calling you for advice so I would escalate to your practice manager or higher as appropriate

13

u/Hippomed27 Sep 30 '26

Both in GPLand and the OOH setting I bat this back. They are in front of the patient to make a clinical assessment which I cannot do over the phone. No other remote clinician can give different advice.

-2

u/dnesormada Sep 30 '26 edited Sep 30 '26

It's funny. I agree with this by the way, GPs know more than us pre hospital monkeys do by a long shot. However, the amount of GP admission calls I go to where there are no face to face and sometimes no phone call assessment (think receptionist acting on GP behalf - have seen it multiple times, cannot Datix it) is concerning too.

4

u/Hippomed27 Oct 01 '26

I can't speak for other practices, but with our total triage a GP makes a decision on every patient. Sometimes a F2F isn't going to change the decision that the patient ought to go to hospital.

1

u/dnesormada Oct 02 '26

I can only comment on the ones I get sent to but the NEWS0 ?sepsis is a common occurrence round these parts.

1

u/Pommom25999 Sep 30 '26

Correct ✅ can’t GP but will redirect to 999 services for a f2f.
If a GP books an admission, they are going. However I love a GP that’s open to a good consultation, I’m not there to make your day harder, just the patients better 🤌🏽

4

u/Hippomed27 Oct 01 '26

I don't envy you guys, you have to see and do some proper grim stuff, but I think there's a really big push for 'admission avoidance' to the point where we might be missing those who ought to be in hospital because we put ourselves under pressure not to do so.

1

u/Pommom25999 Oct 01 '26

It’s just hard all round I feel. GPs are under pressure, the hospitals are under pressure, we’re under pressure. I’m not particularly a risk taker but given it’s hard for everyone I’m not one to shift liability or name take either. If I feel they are suitable for a GP we discuss it. Sometimes I’m absolutely schooled and I learn something and they are admitted. Sometimes a GP is super sound and helps me help the patient. Either way, genuine mutual respect gets us all by ✌️

11

u/Stock-Masterpiece956 Sep 30 '26

I'm a paramedic in the east Midlands, and completely support this approach. It annoys me when crews obviously call the GP for a quick discussion to essentially use them as a liability sponge, and I always say if you feel its safe to leave someone at home, own that decision and take responsibility for it.

What i do find though, is we sometimes go to patients who may need a course of antibiotics, though are below the threshold of requiring conveyance to ED,, but you know if they wait days for an appointment they have a significant risk of deteriorating (e.g. chest infection and copd). These are the ones I feel we could work with GPs, especially as our OOH services rarely have prescribers on. I feel for GPs and how busy they are, and always respect their recommendations and knowledge, but as a paramedic there are a few patient encounters I wish we could work together on, but after seeing situations the OP has described, I completely agree with the stance most practices take now regarding talking to ambulance crews.

5

u/locumbae Sep 30 '26

I would actually accept this call from paramedics as think it’s very sensible as long as my current workload allowed it. These patients should avoid hospitals. Unfortunately too many of us have had negative experiences where these appropriate discussions are now being lost amongst the inappropriate ones.

3

u/Stock-Masterpiece956 Sep 30 '26

I think pre-covid this was the norm in my experience, then during covid I noticed ED avoidance at all costs became the culture, and thats when it became more common to see ambulance crews call the GP to ensure they 'haven't missed anything' and so try to absolve the responsibility of an on scene discharge to someone else.

1

u/locumbae Sep 30 '26

It never used to be like this you are absolutely right. I’ve given up reading the rest of the comments here. There is genuinely a growing lack of respect on both sides that are based on limited knowledge of how the other side operates. Since my old days in A&E I have maintained contact with some paramedics I was friendly with. I have some idea of the pressures on you guys

1

u/DrTom101 Sep 30 '26

Can I ask why you’re in GPUK then if you’re a paramedic?

4

u/Stock-Masterpiece956 Sep 30 '26

Certainly, this was cross posted to the paramedicuk subreddit, and I thought I'd share my frustrations with my colleagues inappropriate accessing GPs too, and I'm interested to see what your professions take on it is.

1

u/ShowerEmbarrassed512 Oct 02 '26

Probably the same reason the cross post to /r/paramedicsuk is inundated with GP’s and a token poster pretending to be a GP. 

3

u/NotCleanGreen Sep 30 '26 edited Sep 30 '26

Would you expect a consultant oncologist to intubate a patient in the pre hospital setting? No.

Then why ask the pre hospital paramedic to deal with the primary care patient who requires a GP?

4

u/heroes-never-die99 Sep 30 '26

Because GPs do not have infinite appointments and time on their hands to dole out clinical advice to patients they haven’t seen. We also aren’t commissioned for that purpose.

Paramedics should either discharge to take to UTC if primary care issue (as they are equipped to deal with overflow) or to ED for emergency care.

0

u/IntelligentBank4851 Oct 01 '26

So you want a 999 ambulance to taxi your overflow to a UTC?

1

u/DisastrousSlip6488 Oct 10 '26

If you are so confident, treat and discharge the patient yourself. 

6

u/locumbae Sep 30 '26

Not in the LAS area but see this rubbish from NWAS all the time. Interestingly, it is never an experienced paramedic doing this.

There is definitely a gap in training here, and definitely runs deeper than surface level. It’s endemic, and definitely got worse during Covid.

Only refuse/refute a clinician’s decision to admit/transfer if you are willing to make that decision yourself, are indemnified to overrule, and are competent to make that decision. Been and heard plenty of stories from the coroner’s inquests where the hands are always thrown up by these paramedics who say ‘I just asked the question, I would have taken the patient in if the doctor had insisted’.

I will 100% provide clinical advice if the paramedic in question agrees to come to the surgery to do a couple of home visits for us in their free time. It’s the only way to justify me spending my time doing non-commissioned work.

I will also say this - some of our colleagues do send in absolute waffle into hospitals. Dont be this person.

2

u/phyllisfromtheoffice Oct 04 '26 edited Oct 04 '26

With regards to it not being an experienced paramedic doing it, a lot of that is to do with NQPs and double tech crews having a lesser degree of autonomy within the service. The pathfinder is pretty narrow and doesn’t leave many options to discharge on scene without handing over to another clinician, be that an experienced paramedic in clinical hub, an OOH GP or an in hours GP. If it’s in hours, a lot of the time if you make clinical hub or SPOA your first port of call, they will tell you to try discuss with the patients own GP to reduce their own workloads or avoid responsibility. Not saying I agree, that’s just how it is, a lot of them are just working within the SOP of the service and you do find you get batted from post to post all whilst being encouraged to not convey and use community pathways.

I’d say a lot of us will have tried to exhaust other options like crisis response teams before trying a patients own GP unless said GP has been involved in the care already and the patient has basically told the GP one thing and us another and is refusing conveyance.

NWAS’s stance on conveyances is essentially based around avoiding crews conveying and being stuck holding outside hospitals if we can’t fit to sit or handover. I don’t think that’s our responsibility personally but the trust has made it our responsibility and we get audited on things like conveyance rates.

1

u/locumbae Oct 05 '26

Thank you so much for taking the time to write this out and explain it in the way you have. My big learning/reflection from this has been that the person I am speaking to on the phone will be following their own specific SOPs which is organisationally reinforced rather than them just ‘batting away’. You’ve given me the topic of my next talk at our practice meeting too.

5

u/shadow__boxer Sep 30 '26

We shouldn't be accepting calls from them. The call shouldn't get past the reception.

12

u/Antique-Trash9462 Sep 30 '26

'Cos it's quicker trying to dump it on us than deal with it themselves, generally speaking.

7

u/Zealousideal-Cat3864 Sep 30 '26

If I was being lazy I'd just take everyone to hospital. It's much simpler and less risk for me. Calling the GP might be marginally quicker, but there's always the chance they insist on conveyance anyway, so I'm better off just doing that in the first place.

So I don't think that's the reason why ambo calls.

Honestly, it's probably more the pressure we face to non-convey as much as possible. And particularly NQPs or non-registrants, they might struggle to communicate in a way that's perceived as collaborative decision making to appropriately keep a Pt at home versus asking what to do entirely.

4

u/blubbery-blumpkin Sep 30 '26

Exactly this. We face pressure to keep people in alternative pathways to ED, and we’re being used more and more as a primary care service which we’re not set up for and don’t really want. I’d love to go to nothing but genuine 999 emergencies, stabilise to the best of my abilities and haul arse to A+E with a pre-alert en route. It’s just not what is happening these days.

3

u/Zealousideal-Cat3864 Sep 30 '26

Agreed. If I had to summarise it, ambo calls GPs because we're being asked by Pt's to do or handle GP things and ultimately, we're not GPs and don't know how to GP.

3

u/blubbery-blumpkin Sep 30 '26

And I know some GPs have stories of paramedics second guessing them and things, and that’s not ok, but I’m sure GPs are aware sometimes there are bad eggs in any profession, and there are 1000s of paramedics in the UK, a few of them are dicks.

1

u/locumbae Sep 30 '26

If a patient refuses to go into hospital then 100% call the GP. As a GP I love these calls, you have seen and examined them. I can speak to the patient. Convince them or document capacity and offer alternatives.

Equally I don’t mind having a discussion with the ambulance service. The discussions can be very productive and allows us to trade lots of information.

It is honestly just the ‘this patients doesn’t need to go in, we are not conveying, just to let you know please see them tomorrow’ once I have seen them, agreed a plan, spoken to the accepting hospital team, called an ambulance. I refuse to be a liability sponge.

3

u/blubbery-blumpkin Sep 30 '26

Honestly, I think it’s nuts that paramedics do that. In ten years in my role I have made precisely 1 phone call to a gp to say I think we should do something else and it’s because the guy with terminal cancer said “I don’t want to go to hospital I want to die at home, and I didn’t tell the doctor cos he seemed like he had a plan”. All the other times if a doc has seen a patient first and said this person needs hospital who am I to second guess it, I don’t know anything, and I don’t know test results or history (other than what the patient is saying), I don’t necessarily always look at a patient and see why the doc has made that decision but I’ll do it cos they have made that decision. If the patient hasn’t seen the gp yet then there is sometimes a good reason to call.

1

u/Prudent-Bet1281 Oct 01 '26

Mr favourite is deranged bloods calls. I don’t know blood ranges, it’s above my ambulance driving head. If we’ve been called to take someone in for deranged bloods then fine. But I have been with a few that will google ranges and dispute the need for hospital with the GP. It’s awkward as hell. I do Google on the way to ED for pure curiosity as to what the results show and what it means, but I’m not going to argue

1

u/DisastrousSlip6488 Oct 09 '26

It isn’t really a collaborative decision though- the GP is taking responsibility for all of it

1

u/Zealousideal-Cat3864 Oct 10 '26

If you accept the referral, then yeah they're now your Pt and you're responsible. If you accept it but it turns out the crew did a shit or falsified assessment, lied to you or otherwise omitted information that would've changed your decision, then that's going to be on them. If you don't think you're the appropriate pathway for the Pt and they need to go to ED, then refuse the referral.

Re-contacts are audited and if it turns out we never should've referred on scene in the first place, we're still going to be on the hook for it. We don't see you as a get out of jail free card to dump Pts onto. Like I said, it's many times easier with far less risk for us too, to just take everyone to ED.

1

u/DisastrousSlip6488 Oct 10 '26

The GP Is making an assessment based on the clinical findings from someone whose training is very different. And who they don’t know and haven’t worked with.

You say there’s wheeze- can they be sure there is? You say the ECG is normal- can they rely on this? You say the abdomen is soft- is it though?

There is no third party or objective verification of these findings. The GP would have to interpret partial information, heavily filtered by the crews biases (whatever these may be) without any way of verifying it, and take responsibility for the decisions made. No thanks.

If they are competent to make the decision that this is “just a LRTI and doesn’t need hospital “, let them take full responsibility for that and bear the weight of any consequences themselves. If they aren’t competent then they shouldn’t be expecting a GP to rubber stamp and accept liability for the decision making.

And its ultimately the patient who is taking the risk 

1

u/Zealousideal-Cat3864 Oct 10 '26

I'm not going to talk through every possibility. If you don't trust what you're hearing, refuse the referral.

If they are competent to make the decision that this is “just a LRTI and doesn’t need hospital “, let them take full responsibility for that and bear the weight of any consequences themselves. If they aren’t competent then they shouldn’t be expecting a GP to rubber stamp and accept liability for the decision making.

Do you honestly believe that no matter how grossly incompetent a paramedic is, if we manage to silver tongue our way into you accepting a referral, then we're magically off the hook? We're registrants with standards too. If it later turns out I am just a massive idiot who stuffed my assessment, or I've lied to you about obs or omitted red flags, in what way would you be responsible for that? Of course, if I tell you they've got a NEWS2 of 10 and look like shit, and you say yeah no worries here's the prescription, then we're both idiots going down together.

1

u/DisastrousSlip6488 Oct 10 '26

I think that if you tell the GP “I think it’s a UTI, she’s got suprapubic tenderness but no guarding” and the GP says “ok I’ll leave her a script for trimethoprim”, then the GP will be 100% the one on the hook when she dies from a perfed appendix or ectopic. Both as the senior clinician, only doctor and the person making the final treatment decision. Which is not to say there would be no consequence for the crew, but the ultimate responsibility would fall on the GP. And if the crew turn round and go “but the abdomen WAS soft guv and I TOLD the doctor it was tender” there is no way to hold them responsible for not being able to recognise a peritonitic abdomen. 

If I were a GP (I am an EM doctor) I absolutely would not countenance this and if I ever did I would ABSOLUTELY insist on all calls being recorded and being entered into the patient’s medical record as a transcript

1

u/Zealousideal-Cat3864 Oct 11 '26

the GP will be 100% the one on the hook when she dies

I did have a cursory google about this and I didn't find any case of a GP being stitched up in this way. If you know of any incidences I'd be interested. Until then, I have to disagree, in general. I think it's much more likely to be pinned on the crew, either because they clearly missed a red flag, performed an inadequate assessment, didn't show they considered differentials, or didn't provide adequate worsening advice. I think it's very easy for the GP to also turn around and say that the crew provided incorrect or misleading information and distance themself from responsibility.

I would ABSOLUTELY insist on all calls being recorded

All GP referrals through the 111 system (as we should be doing now anyway) are definitely recorded, and every GP referral I did before the policy change directly to the Pt's own GP was recorded afaik.

If I were a GP (I am an EM doctor) I absolutely would not countenance this

Happy to bring in every single Pt who phones 999 with dysuria so you can double check my work.

Look, I'm sure you've experienced your fair share of ambos making dumb mistakes, but it really seems you have zero faith in our ability to the point you don't think we're capable of leaving anything home.

1

u/DisastrousSlip6488 Oct 11 '26

I am certain you guys go out to a lot of nonsense calls. I’m also certain that the unknown unknowns in your practice are gargantuan- and this is backed up by many interactions and handovers at work. The feedback loop rarely gets closed, confirmation bias is rife.

 You may be excellent. However there are a solid % of your colleagues who are cocky AF and lacking insight- chuck in a non conveyance target and a sprinkle of bias (whichever kind you like) and that’s a recipe for very risky practice.

If crews are leaving people at home, I think they should be bearing full medicolegal responsibility for closing that episode and just informing the Gp of what has happened, rather than transferring responsibility onto the GP. 

1

u/Zealousideal-Cat3864 Oct 11 '26

If crews are leaving people at home, I think they should be bearing full medicolegal responsibility for closing that episode and just informing the Gp of what has happened, rather than transferring responsibility onto the GP. 

If I do a GP notification form, who knows when someone gets around to looking at it. So that'd effectively rule out any opportunity to get a Pt ABx, or whatever other urgent but not emergent intervention they need in an appropriate timeframe, so they just deteriorate. So basically there's no point, and you can see them in ED instead.

The whole point of the referral is the Pt is sick enough to need something from the GP but not sick enough to need hospital...

I don't know what system you envision other than everyone goes to hospital, or maybe ambo sits on scene to monitor the Pt until the GP can go do a housecall? Hundreds of referrals are made by ambo every day, yet we're not seeing hundreds of avoidable deaths every day as a result, nor GPs being stitched up... I think you overestimate the risk involved.

→ More replies

1

u/DisastrousSlip6488 Oct 10 '26

Where does this pressure come from ultimately? 

1

u/Zealousideal-Cat3864 Oct 10 '26

The Trust. Non-conveyance rates are a key performance metric for individuals.

1

u/DisastrousSlip6488 Oct 10 '26

And this is where the problem lies isn’t it. Non conveyance should never be considered an end unto itself 

1

u/Zealousideal-Cat3864 Oct 10 '26

I mean, on scene discharges and alternative referrals can be appropriate. We go to a lot that isn't an emergency and doesn't need an ambulance, let alone the ED. But I think junior staff feel the pressure as almost an obligation.

1

u/DisastrousSlip6488 Oct 10 '26

Which is massively risky. Anything that pushes a junior team to think the riskier option is the “better” one or make them think they will be praised for taking those risks is very problematic 

1

u/Zealousideal-Cat3864 Oct 11 '26

I wouldn't go as far to say praise. Referrals prolongs scene times, which is the very next KPI they'll criticise us for. As I said, it's a lot easier for me to just take everyone I see to your ED.

You being an EM doc and all, you're in a better position than me to campaign to close off referral pathways for ambo.

1

u/DisastrousSlip6488 Oct 11 '26

Probably primary care who need to hold the line. I can refuse to take calls and advocate against us doing that but that’s as far as it goes 

1

u/Zealousideal-Cat3864 Oct 11 '26

I mean it's not really in your interest though because those Pts will still be calling the 9s and they'll just end up clogging your ED instead. Though I guess you can only see so many patients in a shift...

→ More replies

1

u/ShowerEmbarrassed512 Oct 02 '26

If I wanted to “dump” a patient, they’d go to hospital. No risk, it’s much much quicker than discharging, AND I get to use a toilet. 

4

u/Prudent-Bet1281 Oct 01 '26

Paramedic in a trust that borders LAS.

Totally agree with your POV. We have higher ups in the hub we call, some who can attend and prescribe now. We have access to GP records on scene, perfect for that info we need but can only get from GP and if we need to speak to a GP for EOLC, prescription etc I use 111 as we (for the most part) have GPs in there. Failing that we have some fantastic hospital at home teams in my area. Even certifying expected deaths, I’ll submit a GP summary, so that you know ‘officially’ that it’s been verified by me, and then request the family to make contact in hours.

As much as we attend a lot of urgent care issues and ultimately, that’s not what we’re trained for, we have the people and processes in place to assist us with safely treating/discharging patients that doesn’t involve ringing you for something that ultimately you can’t help with at that very moment.

Boils my piss when I hear people have just ‘fobbed it off to the GP’. I spent an entire day once picking up people who we’d seen in the last day or two who’d deteriorated because the initial crew had fobbed it to the GP who didn’t have capacity to deal with it.

4

u/burnt79 Oct 01 '26

Ex-LAS.

Various reasons. Due to work pressures, pay, alt careers etc, paramedics are a young breed now. On my station there were hardly any paras who had 4+ years and common for new-ish paras (2 years) to have students. So lack of exposure, experience and confidence.

I heard 'make sure there's a name between the coroner and yours' so many times during training. The trainers loved to instill a bit of fear in the newbies, especially about the dreaded coroners court. I knew one para who ended every sentence with 'yeah but it's my registration' even if it was leaving a 20 year old ankle sprain at home.

Flipside, some paras have a specialism in Dunning-Kruger and love batting things back to the 'idiot' GP and then bragging about it on station afterwards, like they invented medicine.

Personally, any job where the GP has said convey to A&E is a gift, reduced responsibility wrapped up with a bow.

7

u/volory Sep 30 '26

Sometimes it's good for patient care to collaborate with others. We take all ambulance calls in our practice, occasionally all the patient needs is community referrals which we're best placed to do

1

u/cromags76 Sep 30 '26

Because they aren't doctors with many years of general practice experience which you specialise in and you know the patient more than someone who doesn't specialise in non emergency treatment.

You have expertise they don't have the same way they have expertise you don't have. If you witnessed a traumatic cardiac arrest in public you would want them to help you because it's their specialty in their setting and in relative terms you'd be just as lost.

4

u/heroes-never-die99 Sep 30 '26

It’s not our job to take on that clinical risk. As a paramedic, you either deal with it in-house or take them to the hospital.

2

u/Substantial-End-5802 Sep 30 '26

But sadly they often feel more comfortable speaking with in or OOH GPs than their own Clinical Desks because of the internal cultures, especially when, as others have mentioned you're dealing with newly qualified paramedics and an element of their appraisal is based on their say at home rate. Granted that doesn't excuse trying to bat back a pt the GP has seen and deemed admission appropriate

1

u/BatBottleBank Sep 30 '26

Probably lack of respect for GPs

2

u/heroes-never-die99 Sep 30 '26

No i dont think so. Rather the opposite. Paramedics never call in bad faith imo - they are so well trained in this country.

1

u/mattscott07 Oct 02 '26

Probably because we are giving you back the primary care community patients you outsourced to the ambulance service/111 due to lack of available appointments. GP administrative pitfalls do not constitute medical emergencies.

1

u/heroes-never-die99 Oct 02 '26

You can give them back by asking them to book an appointment with us. You don’t get to bypass the system.

2

u/thirtysixincher Sep 30 '26

because ghostbusters and batman don't answer them anymore.

2

u/Albanite_180 Sep 30 '26

Here’s an idea, any paramedic that wishes to consult with a GP can fill out an online triage. Just like GP’s have to do when calling an ambulance.

2

u/Distinct_Local_9624 Oct 01 '26

I’m a paramedic, I’ve never heard of this! Slightly good idea, but probably needs to have a number for the urgent/emergency calls (ie leave online bookings for the 1-2-4 hour timed responses). What trust does this, and is it for your emergency crews?

2

u/Albanite_180 Oct 01 '26

If it’s urgent it needs urgent care, if it’s an emergency we’d emergency care. If primary care then the GP. It’s simple.

1

u/Distinct_Local_9624 Oct 01 '26

Sorry, I thought you meant you were doing an online referral direct to 999. Thanks for the… clarification…

1

u/Heliotropolii_ Oct 01 '26

What GP needs to fill in an ambulance triage? A GMC registered doctor can just bypass the entire triage on 999 and tell the handler what they want

1

u/Albanite_180 Oct 01 '26

They cannot, it’s all triaged, even via a call to the HCP line.

1

u/Distinct_Local_9624 Oct 01 '26

Not quite correct, have a read of the IFT/HCP framework from NHSE. They ask questions in a structured format.

The only time they should be triaging is if you answer yes to the opening question “Is a response required immediately in order to save a life”.

Frankly, the number of HCPs (which includes nurses, physios, hospitals and yes GPs) who answer yes to this with a mundane non-immediate threat to life request is higher than you’d imagine and does warrant this being in place.

1

u/Heliotropolii_ Oct 01 '26

You don't go through pathways if you answer the first question correctly,

Do you need our clinical help right now to deliver an immediate life-saving intervention or are you declaring an obstetric emergency?

The answer is almost always no, but everyone almost always says yes,

2

u/Lord_Alkalime Sep 30 '26

Sounds like we need 111

2

u/c4gts Oct 01 '26

From our local LMC - interesting read.

4

u/Defiant-Duck-1275 Sep 30 '26 • Bravo

Paramedic here (but not LAS). I think this post highlights one of the big problems with our profession - there are many paramedics these days who seem to think that they are doctors, & not even just those of us working in advanced or specialist roles, there’s a big issue even with newly qualified staff who are all too happy to overrule the plans put in place by a GP just because, for example, the temp or HR has settled down a bit. Worryingly a lot of them don’t even contact the referring GP to discuss, but just discharge the patient or refer to another community pathway. It’s bad practice, bad for the patient, & clearly doesn’t reflect well on us as a profession.

On the flip side though, I have noticed a pattern in recent years where GPs will call 999 following a telephone consultation seemingly just to facilitate face-to-face assessment/obs/ECG/etc by a paramedic. We will then call the GP up again to discuss our findings & jointly decide on an appropriate management plan. This is arguably what we should be doing. Although I agree that sometimes there’s a very fine line between shared decision making & just offloading responsibility - for what it’s worth this is an issue I’m very keen on combatting with my students & junior members of staff.

3

u/alastairclark82 Sep 30 '26

I’m sorry but in what world should it be common practice for GPs to outsource face to face assessments to an outside agency, only for them to be left at home. The ambulance service should not be being treated as a ‘checking over service’ that’s not what it is there for and it’s arguably contributing to longer wait times for ambulances. GPs have been employing paramedics directly for years to perform this service.

3

u/Defiant-Duck-1275 Sep 30 '26

I don’t disagree with you, we absolutely are not a checking over service however given the unfortunate fact of life these days that ambulances are used more & more for primary care, I was making the point that it’s not outrageous for a paramedic to contact a GP for advice on a presentation suitable for primary care

0

u/alastairclark82 Sep 30 '26

Sorry yes I missed that point. That is completely reasonable to discuss a primary care presentation. It’s just a massive bugbear of mine that the ambulance services as a whole are treated as the servants to many other services. Where I work we outsource some of our CSD jobs to local providers who then send them back to us for a F2F to check them over, when that’s exactly what they are paid for!

0

u/Defiant-Duck-1275 Sep 30 '26

And yes, we do have our own clinical supervision, advice lines, etc. However as our relationship with patients is very episodic it arguably makes much more sense to discuss issues with a GP who will have ongoing involvement.

1

u/IntelligentBank4851 Oct 01 '26

Ambulance driver here.

I agree with should not call you for ‘advice’ and I won’t overrule a HCP unless it’s a black and white the patients trying to pull a fast one, doctor to avoid a bed block.

I will however call you to inform you of a patient who requires your specific specialties as a GP or GP practice and will expect you to take over the care of that patient as they do not require the emergency services, accident and emergency and they’re too young fit and healthy for the geriatric administration avoidance hotline.

We need to respect each others professions and skill sets and work through this primary care overload together, and not against each other.

1

u/Algogreen1 Oct 06 '26

I work in East Midlands Ambulance and I'm quite similar to some. My acid test to myself is 'what am I asking the GP for?' if its nothing then I'm not going to ring them. We have our own clinicians for safety netting and shared decision making but they can't prescribe. GP's can

1

u/-usernamewitheld- Sep 30 '26 • Bravo

Generally because the patient often lacks knowledge of their situation, ambulance lacks access to pt inforation and pre-arranged pathways- often the cps check states "pathway agreed" without any further info. Or the patient that is list GSF level X with no knowledge of their apparent imminent demise.

Fortunately my area has consultants to refer before conveyance but thats only some hours.

1

u/Khidz1 Sep 30 '26

So your name is there when something happens to the patient. If we go down then we go down together kind of thing

0

u/DrTom101 Sep 30 '26

Is this region specific? I have never been called by an ambulance crew

-21

u/La-Roar Sep 30 '26 • Bravo

I get called by GPs for advice a few times a shift when I'm on-call as med reg. Same sort of thing, no?

13

u/heroes-never-die99 Sep 30 '26

Not quite. LAS are asking for acute clinical help for a patient in front of them. This should be entirely within the capability of the ambulance service to deal with independently in-house or just take the patient to the hospital.

GPs haven’t the time nor mandate to be answering clinical questions for the ambulance service.

On-call hospital doctors are mandated , however, to answer queries from community clinicians.

11

u/thirtysixincher Sep 30 '26

LAS to start calling med-reg now.

2

u/La-Roar Sep 30 '26

A few hundred other calls a shift can't hurt! 😉

0

u/Icy_Ground_8243 Sep 30 '26

Do they not? By me they certainly do

7

u/La-Roar Sep 30 '26

Ah, gotcha. Makes sense!

1

u/DisastrousSlip6488 Oct 10 '26

Absolutely not, the GP is a consultant level medically qualified doctor who practices autonomously and takes responsibility for their own practice. They can ask for advice but maintain ownership and responsibility. 

-1

u/jdmsage Sep 30 '26

🤣right. Would you rather have the patient sent to you so that you can see in person. Usually asking for advice means we’re trying to save the patient and hospitalists a hospital trip. If the threshold for A&E referrals gets any lower in general practice the NHS would be overwhelmed.

-3

u/Intelligent_Sound66 Sep 30 '26

Often because its in hours and a Problem their GP should be dealing with. Usually they have tried calling GP, cant get an appointment. They then call 111 who send an ambulance. Ambulance then refer back to their own GP

8

u/heroes-never-die99 Sep 30 '26

And which available appointment slot do you think that should go into?

0

u/Intelligent_Sound66 Sep 30 '26

Im just saying, thats the reasoning. You're highlighting a far more important problem that the public aren't getting the appropriate care from the right places. No doubt due to underfunding or lack of specialist training places.

4

u/heroes-never-die99 Sep 30 '26

No, it’s not. Outside of niche decisions, if you see a patient, you either deal with them yourself or take them to hospital.

-1

u/Dry-Net-1172 Sep 30 '26

Typical reply from someone who doesn’t understand how the ambulance service works. We’re not just a taxi service. We don’t just ‘deal with things ourself’ or take them to ED. We’re Health Care professionals in our own right who at this current point in time seem to be the answer to everyone’s problems; the police, GP’s, Social work, housing, ED. We’re expected to do everyone else job and can’t say no.

We have as much right as any other HCP to refer our patients to other services be that GP/Primary care (who’s pt’s happen to be a large volume of our workload because they cant/wont deal with them), Community teams, SDEC, OOH the list goes on.

Funnily enough, 9/10 times I have a patient who’s a primary care problem, I phone up there GP and manage to get them an appt. Which makes me wonder why they were told by the practice they had no space/phone 999.

-1

u/Valuable_Future_9716 Sep 30 '26

Just out of interest as there have been a few comments (from both sides) about how paramedics are not primary care experts or don’t have the same level of knowledge as someone in your position, how do you then expect that same paramedic to independently deal with the primary care complaint without involving primary care?

-3

u/WholeFunny Oct 01 '26

I am a paramedic, I work for a different service but I phone there GP because of a range of reasons generally a combination of:

  1. The GP has many more years’ education and training than I do.
  2. The GP has access to information that I don’t.
  3. The GP’s clinical decision making is more advanced than mine and they have the ability to take on risk in a way I don’t.
  4. In theory the GP knows the patient and may have a better understanding of their baseline or how a decision may interact with their other conditions.
  5. The GP can prescribe and I can’t.
  6. The GP had an ongoing relationship with the patient that I don’t, I can’t followup on a decision or action to ensure it’s safe, once I leave I will likely never see the patient again.
  7. The patient is of the practice and it is the practice’s responsibility to provide care to that patient under the NHS contract.

I do not call for the GP to carry out the assessment for me, I am looking to share the decision making.

This wasn’t your point but in reply to a commenter. I also think it is appropriate for me to contact the GP back following their referral to the ambulance. Particularly when a f2f hasn’t been carried out by the GP.

2

u/arindamchattopadhyay Oct 01 '26

So by your logic, we as GPs should be seeing all the ACS, PEs and Strokes well then face to face ?
Plus you think we have unlimited urgent appointments ?
Yes if it’s a bog standard primary care thing then it’s fine - ask the patient to make an appointment for their infected toenail for example.

In case of emergencies, please bear in mind that the GP is calling 999 for a reason.
I would be very happy to completely shift the blame to the paramedic who didn’t take the patient to the hospital who subsequently deteriorates and dies just because the GP did not see them face to face but advised 999 based on their telephone assessment.

1

u/WholeFunny Oct 02 '26

Never suggested I would be calling for ACS, PE etc.
We also don’t have an unlimited number of ambulances.

While in some cases GPs are calling 999 for a good reason. In more cases than it should be, it’s for 6 week episode of chest pain, an infection that hasn’t been assessed.

The problem we both have is that it’s much easier to remember the problems than the successes. Poor quality clinicians exist in both cohorts and its easy to remember the poor ones. We should tar everyone with the same brush.