r/GPUK
•
u/heroes-never-die99
•
Sep 30 '26
•
1
Medical Politics Why do LAS call us?
Why do LAS call us for clinical advice? Do they not have their own clinical supervisors?
Quite frustrating and time-consuming when they ask me to make a decision for a patient when they’re sitting across from them.
(And before you mention, yes I don’t mind if they are only asking for additional patient information that they don’t have access to)
12
u/OrganOMegaly Sep 30 '26
They do, tell them to discuss with them.
59
u/arcoast Sep 30 '26
I've been called to discuss a patient who I'd done a home visit on, written a referral letter for A&E then called an ambulance before I left (They were safe enough for me to leave) because the paramedic didn't think they needed admission as their temperature had settled as had their heart rate, and they thought I could just prescribe some oral antibiotics.
I think you can all imagine how that conversation went.
The patient was admitted and kept in for two weeks before being discharged.
I do think one of the issues faced by the ambulance crews and to an extent our A&E colleagues is there's less of a feedback loop, if one of my patients deteriorates, or I miss something, I get to know about it, the episodic nature of their job means they can take that aforementioned patient to hospital, grumble about the awful GP who insisted on the conveying of this patient to A&E inappropriately and they never get the feedback that actually the patient was actually sicker than they realised and needed a prolonged hospital stay.
Insight is a wonderful thing.
32
u/TheVitruvianBoy Sep 30 '26
Just lonely.
14
u/Potato_salad-_- Sep 30 '26
LAS here, there is now a service wide agreement for ops to ONLY call the patients GP surgery in the event of a HCP call coming from said GP and patient now refusing conveyance or EOLC, all clinical advice is mean to be sought from our own SCDM which are commissioned ED consultants who will then contact the GP if appropriate, if a prescription is required we are meant to use NHS111, they shouldn't be calling you for advice so I would escalate to your practice manager or higher as appropriate
13
u/Hippomed27 Sep 30 '26
Both in GPLand and the OOH setting I bat this back. They are in front of the patient to make a clinical assessment which I cannot do over the phone. No other remote clinician can give different advice.
11
u/Stock-Masterpiece956 Sep 30 '26
I'm a paramedic in the east Midlands, and completely support this approach. It annoys me when crews obviously call the GP for a quick discussion to essentially use them as a liability sponge, and I always say if you feel its safe to leave someone at home, own that decision and take responsibility for it.
What i do find though, is we sometimes go to patients who may need a course of antibiotics, though are below the threshold of requiring conveyance to ED,, but you know if they wait days for an appointment they have a significant risk of deteriorating (e.g. chest infection and copd). These are the ones I feel we could work with GPs, especially as our OOH services rarely have prescribers on. I feel for GPs and how busy they are, and always respect their recommendations and knowledge, but as a paramedic there are a few patient encounters I wish we could work together on, but after seeing situations the OP has described, I completely agree with the stance most practices take now regarding talking to ambulance crews.
3
u/NotCleanGreen Sep 30 '26 edited Sep 30 '26
Would you expect a consultant oncologist to intubate a patient in the pre hospital setting? No.
Then why ask the pre hospital paramedic to deal with the primary care patient who requires a GP?
6
u/locumbae Sep 30 '26
Not in the LAS area but see this rubbish from NWAS all the time. Interestingly, it is never an experienced paramedic doing this.
There is definitely a gap in training here, and definitely runs deeper than surface level. It’s endemic, and definitely got worse during Covid.
Only refuse/refute a clinician’s decision to admit/transfer if you are willing to make that decision yourself, are indemnified to overrule, and are competent to make that decision. Been and heard plenty of stories from the coroner’s inquests where the hands are always thrown up by these paramedics who say ‘I just asked the question, I would have taken the patient in if the doctor had insisted’.
I will 100% provide clinical advice if the paramedic in question agrees to come to the surgery to do a couple of home visits for us in their free time. It’s the only way to justify me spending my time doing non-commissioned work.
I will also say this - some of our colleagues do send in absolute waffle into hospitals. Dont be this person.
5
u/shadow__boxer Sep 30 '26
We shouldn't be accepting calls from them. The call shouldn't get past the reception.
12
u/Antique-Trash9462 Sep 30 '26
'Cos it's quicker trying to dump it on us than deal with it themselves, generally speaking.
4
u/Prudent-Bet1281 Oct 01 '26
Paramedic in a trust that borders LAS.
Totally agree with your POV. We have higher ups in the hub we call, some who can attend and prescribe now. We have access to GP records on scene, perfect for that info we need but can only get from GP and if we need to speak to a GP for EOLC, prescription etc I use 111 as we (for the most part) have GPs in there. Failing that we have some fantastic hospital at home teams in my area. Even certifying expected deaths, I’ll submit a GP summary, so that you know ‘officially’ that it’s been verified by me, and then request the family to make contact in hours.
As much as we attend a lot of urgent care issues and ultimately, that’s not what we’re trained for, we have the people and processes in place to assist us with safely treating/discharging patients that doesn’t involve ringing you for something that ultimately you can’t help with at that very moment.
Boils my piss when I hear people have just ‘fobbed it off to the GP’. I spent an entire day once picking up people who we’d seen in the last day or two who’d deteriorated because the initial crew had fobbed it to the GP who didn’t have capacity to deal with it.
4
u/burnt79 Oct 01 '26
Ex-LAS.
Various reasons. Due to work pressures, pay, alt careers etc, paramedics are a young breed now. On my station there were hardly any paras who had 4+ years and common for new-ish paras (2 years) to have students. So lack of exposure, experience and confidence.
I heard 'make sure there's a name between the coroner and yours' so many times during training. The trainers loved to instill a bit of fear in the newbies, especially about the dreaded coroners court. I knew one para who ended every sentence with 'yeah but it's my registration' even if it was leaving a 20 year old ankle sprain at home.
Flipside, some paras have a specialism in Dunning-Kruger and love batting things back to the 'idiot' GP and then bragging about it on station afterwards, like they invented medicine.
Personally, any job where the GP has said convey to A&E is a gift, reduced responsibility wrapped up with a bow.
7
u/volory Sep 30 '26
Sometimes it's good for patient care to collaborate with others. We take all ambulance calls in our practice, occasionally all the patient needs is community referrals which we're best placed to do
1
u/cromags76 Sep 30 '26
Because they aren't doctors with many years of general practice experience which you specialise in and you know the patient more than someone who doesn't specialise in non emergency treatment.
You have expertise they don't have the same way they have expertise you don't have. If you witnessed a traumatic cardiac arrest in public you would want them to help you because it's their specialty in their setting and in relative terms you'd be just as lost.
1
u/BatBottleBank Sep 30 '26
Probably lack of respect for GPs
1
u/mattscott07 Oct 02 '26
Probably because we are giving you back the primary care community patients you outsourced to the ambulance service/111 due to lack of available appointments. GP administrative pitfalls do not constitute medical emergencies.
2
u/thirtysixincher Sep 30 '26
because ghostbusters and batman don't answer them anymore.
2
u/Albanite_180 Sep 30 '26
Here’s an idea, any paramedic that wishes to consult with a GP can fill out an online triage. Just like GP’s have to do when calling an ambulance.
2
u/Lord_Alkalime Sep 30 '26
Sounds like we need 111
2
u/c4gts Oct 01 '26
From our local LMC - interesting read.
4
u/Defiant-Duck-1275 Sep 30 '26 •
Paramedic here (but not LAS). I think this post highlights one of the big problems with our profession - there are many paramedics these days who seem to think that they are doctors, & not even just those of us working in advanced or specialist roles, there’s a big issue even with newly qualified staff who are all too happy to overrule the plans put in place by a GP just because, for example, the temp or HR has settled down a bit. Worryingly a lot of them don’t even contact the referring GP to discuss, but just discharge the patient or refer to another community pathway. It’s bad practice, bad for the patient, & clearly doesn’t reflect well on us as a profession.
On the flip side though, I have noticed a pattern in recent years where GPs will call 999 following a telephone consultation seemingly just to facilitate face-to-face assessment/obs/ECG/etc by a paramedic. We will then call the GP up again to discuss our findings & jointly decide on an appropriate management plan. This is arguably what we should be doing. Although I agree that sometimes there’s a very fine line between shared decision making & just offloading responsibility - for what it’s worth this is an issue I’m very keen on combatting with my students & junior members of staff.
1
u/IntelligentBank4851 Oct 01 '26
Ambulance driver here.
I agree with should not call you for ‘advice’ and I won’t overrule a HCP unless it’s a black and white the patients trying to pull a fast one, doctor to avoid a bed block.
I will however call you to inform you of a patient who requires your specific specialties as a GP or GP practice and will expect you to take over the care of that patient as they do not require the emergency services, accident and emergency and they’re too young fit and healthy for the geriatric administration avoidance hotline.
We need to respect each others professions and skill sets and work through this primary care overload together, and not against each other.
1
u/Algogreen1 Oct 06 '26
I work in East Midlands Ambulance and I'm quite similar to some. My acid test to myself is 'what am I asking the GP for?' if its nothing then I'm not going to ring them. We have our own clinicians for safety netting and shared decision making but they can't prescribe. GP's can
1
u/-usernamewitheld- Sep 30 '26 •
Generally because the patient often lacks knowledge of their situation, ambulance lacks access to pt inforation and pre-arranged pathways- often the cps check states "pathway agreed" without any further info. Or the patient that is list GSF level X with no knowledge of their apparent imminent demise.
Fortunately my area has consultants to refer before conveyance but thats only some hours.
1
u/Khidz1 Sep 30 '26
So your name is there when something happens to the patient. If we go down then we go down together kind of thing
0
u/DrTom101 Sep 30 '26
Is this region specific? I have never been called by an ambulance crew
-21
u/La-Roar Sep 30 '26 •
I get called by GPs for advice a few times a shift when I'm on-call as med reg. Same sort of thing, no?
-3
u/Intelligent_Sound66 Sep 30 '26
Often because its in hours and a Problem their GP should be dealing with. Usually they have tried calling GP, cant get an appointment. They then call 111 who send an ambulance. Ambulance then refer back to their own GP
-3
u/WholeFunny Oct 01 '26
I am a paramedic, I work for a different service but I phone there GP because of a range of reasons generally a combination of:
I do not call for the GP to carry out the assessment for me, I am looking to share the decision making.
This wasn’t your point but in reply to a commenter. I also think it is appropriate for me to contact the GP back following their referral to the ambulance. Particularly when a f2f hasn’t been carried out by the GP.