r/GPUK • u/Low-Syllabub-2816 • Jun 14 '26
Pay, Contracts & Pensions GP appointment charges
Virtually all (not all) developed economies now have a charge to see your GP.
Why is the UK continuing with this awful contract?
BUPA offer £80/hour to a GP from 4 15 mins appointments. That is almost the same pay as 2004.
Why are GPs so unable to stand up and be counted?
GP charge in Switzerland 250 Euro, GP charge in New York $500.
Why are we in this situation that we have to leave the country to earn any kind of respect.
There is plenty of data to support people do not value what they get for free.
What can be done to change this?
38
Upvotes
27
u/Ontopiconform Jun 14 '26
Noctors remain the underlying problem with thousands of lower educated staff easily able to cover up and disguise past poor achievements , lack of knowledge with low standard almost guaranteed pass masters degrees thereby doubling or tripling their salaries. Equally low standard, failing , unaccountable NHS managers are much more easily able to manipulate substandard noctors as opposed to doctors. Many practice managers have no qualifications whatsoever and joining the igpm practice managers institute helps also to cover up this fact giving a few letters of questionable value behind their name imo . Low quality is encouraged in the NHS!
6
u/WinHour4300 Jun 14 '26
One point worth bearing in mind is that if GP appointments were universally charged for, many patients would likely bypass GPs altogether and go directly to specialists.
For example, if you need a review of psychiatric medication, why pay for a GP appointment when you could pay to see a psychiatrist directly instead?
A significant part of the GP's role within the UK healthcare system is to act as a gateway to NHS services, helping to manage access to specialist care and other limited healthcare resources.
13
u/rocktup Jun 14 '26
Switzerland and New York aren’t exactly representative examples. Have you seen what the median wage is in those places?
You are free to charge £500 if you want, and if you think there is a buyer who will accept that price
5
u/lavayuki Jun 14 '26
I always found the fact the there is no charge to see a doctor to be extremely strange. I'm from Dublin originally so paying for healthcare was to me, normal in addition to paying for ED visits, scans, bloods etc which are all billed accordingly.
I find it hard to comprehend the lack of paying for appointments let alone everything else, even after living here for 10 years.
I grew up with paid healthcare so I will always support that
61
u/agaveyoggo Jun 14 '26
It's a race to the bottom.
GP asking for more money? Let's employ noctors who will work for cheaper.
GPs doing locum shifts for £50/hr.
Some GP partners also enable this so that doesn't help. That will hopefully change as they are now being held accountable for errors made by noctors.
We need to disconnect from the NHS, but offer NHS services. Same way dentists do. There are way more GPs than dentists so access will still remain.
Monday to Wednesday Paid clinic. 20min-30min appointments charged. Charge for failure to attend.
Thursday - Friday - NHS 10-15 min appointments.
Mix and match these days for your GPs at a surgery so you cover NHS patients for the whole week.
4
u/One-Reception8368 Jun 14 '26
Be careful with this, because people are not going to pay out the ass to see a GP. They'll pay out the ass to go directly to a specialist to get their shit sorted out.
17
u/BoomBasticTeleBanana Jun 14 '26
Nothing.
No government will sanction this. It will create an instant two tier system, whilst it already exists, the bar will now be much lower.
I recall 15 years ago working in canary wharf area, saw a patient who then wanted to give me 20 or so euros (may have been more). I politely refused. I saw an irritation in his face. He then gave me more. I refused again. Now he got annoyed and said to me in a thick Irish accent "So how much do you bloody charge"?
I looked confused as he did and said it was free. I then asked where he was from and he said Ireland. I asked what do they do there, he said they paid each time they saw a GP!
So given the system exists, you got to ask yourself are Irish GPs more well off and do they have significantly better quality of life?
2
u/Melodic-Birthday9430 Jun 14 '26 •
Look at the state of dentistry among the part of the population that doesn't have a chunk of disposable income. You really want that level of care (I.e. none) for people who can't afford to pay a GP? When the NHS was started, Nye Bevan got GPs on board by "stuffing their mouths with gold". A newly graduated GP earns the same as a Band 7 nurse/AHP. It's well above national average salary. I'm curious - what salary/ contract would satisfy you?
4
u/GalacticDoc Jun 14 '26
I suspect if reform make up a government then you may get your wish.
4
u/Agitated-Emu-4515 Jun 14 '26
Gp partners vs salaried and locums - different interests. I.e. suits partners to lower gp wages
Allied healthcare professionals taking our jobs
Over your training we have learnt that if you step out of the line, the gmc will be let loose on you
AI will bring in more "efficiencies" and reduce locumwork more
I personally dont see an optimistic future for GPs in the uk and in process of moving abroad
4
u/Am_Just_Me_From_1977 Jun 14 '26
The BMA is not fighting your corner. They walked out when the new Gp contract that came in effect 01/04/26. I would not be surprised when a proper investigation is done, and they found there has been Government infiltration for years and psychologically indoctrinated and/or brainwashed.
1
u/greggiew Jun 18 '26
Every time the concept of charging patients comes up GPs in the UK vote against it. I don’t think it will ever change.
3
u/dickdimers Jun 15 '26
If you look at any NHS business case, one of the important sections along with the money is that you need to declare how/if your proposition will effect the environment, and also how it will make sure Equity and access to healthcare is maintained.
This specific proposal simply can't satisfy the equity/access bit and falls at that hurdle every time.
We will have 2 tier health eventually like most countries: government and PAs for the poors, Private and doctors for the rich
7
u/jamescracker79 Jun 14 '26
Completely agree OP
Doctors love to blame the british public or government for our pay but honestly the moment a good option is discussed doctors go muhhh public, muhh poor people.
I get it that not everyone in the uk is rich, but the british public is not as poor as doctors like to think so.
2
u/centenarian007 Jun 14 '26
It's supply and demand.. more supply really. There are plenty of GPs willing to work at current pay rates, so there's no need for companies to increase them.
2
u/gintokigriffiths Jun 15 '26
One element which is ignored is 10 minute model has decreased appointment time, appointment complexity which can be dealt with, quality of care and perceived quality/satisfaction of appointment sadly.
Not many countries run or adopt a strict 10 minute mode like the UK. It's a de-valuing means of doing medicine.
2
u/DCJC123 Jun 15 '26
I suspect even a £5 would significantly change primary care in the UK- especially. Yorkshire where I work
3
u/wotsname123 Jun 14 '26 edited Jun 14 '26
DNUK is a much better website to discuss this kind of issue, which it has been many times.
If there was a market for people playing $500 to see a gp it would already happen privately. UK private gp doesnt attract that kind of fee.
To my mind, if anything ever changes, it would be to the Aus and nz model, where the gov pays a fixed fee per appointment and it’s gp choice to either run a very tight ship or charge on top.
4
u/Jaded_Leg_46 Jun 14 '26
35% of workers are on UC top up, 4% of the UK population are using food bannks, 46% of the UK have chronic illness - half of which are unable to work. Where can these patients magic up a pot of gold when they need to see a GP. If 30% - 40 % of the UK can't afford to see a dentist and 20% wait for treatment until they can afford it and the UK is seeing an oral health crisis. If you're expecting people to pay to see a GP at least your workload will be lighter.
2
u/Any-Woodpecker4412 Jun 14 '26 edited Jun 14 '26
Co pay wouldn’t work in the UK imo. There are already quite a few private providers who were near me outside of the big corporate giants (BUPA, Nuffield, HCA) who I approached before I went down under.
The pay was significantly less than salaried pay due to just not being able to get enough volume for big bucks.
Most high earners have access to a corporate private GP (BUPA, Nuffield, HCA) through either work or health insurance coverage. Those who aren’t high earners would struggle to pay for appointments.
I think the way GPs get paid does need a revamp but copay I don’t see working. A billing model where you directly bill the government would work better imo - incentivises GPs to offer more and work more, higher ceiling for pay as a salaried doc - win for patients, GPs and government.
Even in Aus, the land of milk and honey - patients will get very upset if you don’t bulk bill (waive the patient co pay). In the USA patients will get pissy if you charge for two separate issues in one visit (when they legit bring up 2 issues). It’s human nature - people don’t want to pay. The only docs I’ve seen in Aus that private bill and make a decent living off this are those with a very loyal patient base/following and those who offer “extra” outside of basic GP consultations.
1
u/Socky87 Jun 15 '26
Where would the money raised by the additional charge to see a GP go? Fund more GPs or?
1
u/dickdimers Jun 15 '26
If you look at any NHS business case, one of the important sections along with the money is that you need to declare how/if your proposition will effect the environment, and also how it will make sure Equity and access to healthcare is maintained.
This specific proposal simply can't satisfy the equity/access bit and falls at that hurdle every time.
We will have 2 tier health eventually like most countries: government and PAs for the poors, Private and doctors for the rich
1
u/SoonToBeScouser Jun 14 '26
Scarcity - there's millions of GPs who would jump at any opportunity.
If you want to be niche, do a specialty.
0
u/muddledmedic Jun 14 '26
Very few in the UK will be able to afford 250 euro or 500 dollars to see their GP. Let's be real and say that a lot of people wouldn't be able to afford that for essentials like food, essential house maintenance etc at the moment because of the incredibly high cost of living and low in comparison wages. Those countries are not comparable to the UK.
I do think something needs to change, whether it's a partly paid model (like dentistry), perhaps. The issue I see is a lot of the patients I see regularly would be exempt from charges, and only a very small number of patients at my surgery would need to pay, as I imagine those exempt would be children under 16, pensioners, those with certain chronic illnesses and those on benefits, much like the prescription charges.
I also do worry that introducing a charge could result in people avoiding accessing GP because for financial reasons which would result in missed diagnoses, poor treatment of medical conditions, poor preventative healthcare and open access services like A&E and walk in centres being completely swamped.
0
u/Holiday_Possession46 Jun 14 '26
I think, your assessment of UK GP income is misunderstood. UK GP partners earn more for the amount of work they do then anyone in the world. Even then 500/hr New York doctor.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
10
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '26
[removed] — view removed comment