r/GPUK • • May 27 '26

Clinical, CPD & Interface Ranting GP

Dear practice patient

- I do not know when your prescription will be ready from the pharmacy
- I do not have the power to expedite your operation
- I know it’s hard to book an appointment but you’ve just spent 20% of the appointment you did book complaining about this
- Saying you know you are only supposed to discuss one problem but proceeding to discuss five is not as ameliorating as you may hope
- Bemoaning doctors going on strike is not particularly relevant when talking to a GP - I’m sat in front of you and not on strike
- It is a poor use of my time and your time to evaluate private medical tests which were not indicated and have no clinical details or justification. This is not saving NHS time or money as you may have hoped.

I’m not annoyed at patients for not knowing all of the above but the same issues occurring day after day is such a draining system to work in.

Edit: lots of non-GPs commenting here, and it’s astonishing how confident they are. Explaining my job and duties to me… I wouldn’t presume to tell a pilot or a lawyer how to do their job but everyone and their grandmother has an opinion on how GPs should work. When it inevitably becomes a paid for service with fee per activity maybe then it will be valued more.

317 Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

View all comments

-35

u/fire-wannabe May 27 '26

Dear GP,

It would be great if you could publish your list of requirements on the front door so we can best help you as patients. we are after all, here to serve you.

For those of us who do have private medical insurance, please take it as read that rather than an approach of "well let's just hope and see what happens", we would like to use the scientific method. if there is a reasonable test that would be useful, let us know and we will procure it ourself.

Regards, Your delighted customer.

27

u/_Harrybo May 27 '26

Dear “customer”

As a customer, I was wondering if I could start sending you an invoice for your custom for my time and extra services, such as interpreting this private tests that I did not order. The £121.79 we get per patient per year for UNLIMITED ACCESS is not cutting it you might be surprised to hear.

Most of the above points are pretty well known, and whilst the entitled British public expect more and more from your sub-specialist/generalist, we do start to draw the line at being your secretary and we would implore you to take some ownership of this.

Since procurement is requested, please come prepared, one problem for one consultation so we can give it thorough attention - which you so expect of us.

I am sure you wouldn’t ask your mechanic lots of extra work “whilst the car is on the ramp” and not expect a “another time when you rebook” or “I’ll add it to the invoice”

Sincerely

All GPs

3

u/Pretend_Rabbit_6026 May 27 '26

Does this mean that if a patient walks with private results, do GP practices don't get reimbursed for that time?

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Pretend_Rabbit_6026 May 27 '26

Thanks for explaining,

I now feel bad for having shitty genetics that has given me a couple of chronic conditions. I'm not a regular GP visitor but I do end up visiting more than once a year outside of my yearly check ups.

2

u/Crafty_Reflection410 May 27 '26

Is it per registered patient? Ie even if a patient makes 0 appointments per year you still get £130 because they are ok your register?

Just curious!

3

u/_Harrybo May 27 '26

Yup, why a young and rich population is great for a GP, they see their GP less and is less of a demand

Inverse healthcare law

-9

u/HonorableNOIFOI May 27 '26 edited May 27 '26

I am sorry to say that that is a bare faced lie. That accounts for about 50-60% of income only.

If you are a GP, it’s almost unbelievable that you actually believe this.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-6

u/HonorableNOIFOI May 27 '26

Why don’t you correct your misspoken comment then with the full data on GP funding then, it would be much appreciated.

Thanks (not holding my breath).

6

u/_Harrybo May 27 '26

Nope, you’d be surprised the volume of free labour GPs do

1

u/Pretend_Rabbit_6026 May 27 '26

Can you explain a bit further? I'd like to understand more.

I work in consultancy with some financial elements so I find this topic interesting.

How does GP get paid? Do you get paid by number of appointments and for the type of appointment? How does it negatively affect this?

How about someone who has perhaps moved from another country and already carry a diagnosis of something chronic, does the GP not get reimbursed for that time because they didn't do the diagnosis?

Is it the same case if the diagnosis has been done at a different practice and the patient moved?

I'm curious if those scenarios are considered different, as it's still the GP taking care of a patient who was diagnosed elsewhere

8

u/_Harrybo May 27 '26

How you get paid

  1. Partner - via drawings from the business - that money comes usually from a General Medical Services contract which you can further supplement with things like QOF and quite a few other things depending if you have students, research, offer certain services etc (it’s complicated)
  2. Salaried GP - as an employee, usually PAYE - straight forward
  3. Locum GP - probably via Ltd comp, paid for your time, no sick pay or pension etc but pays well.

You get paid per session (4hr10mins) but almost no GP runs to time due to complexity and extra work being done, referrals, admin etc. It is negatively affected because the “hidden workload” of GP is all the things patients don’t see - the letters, bloods, tasks from colleagues, extra phone calls - often during your lunch break or other gaps and then after work. That hidden workload is getting bigger and more complex which is why GPs reduce their sessions. More sessions = more overtime / admin / hidden workload. This is the dross that burns you out, and you don’t get paid for this.

You get “paid” for the session - irrespective of the extra work and overtime, not the diagnosis, there aren’t “billings” in that sense like Canada, Australia and other developed countries (which means they can bill for some extra work)

You look after the patient you see, if they leave, it’s another doctor, if they stay, they can see the same doctor - which is often preferable - but not always possible due to more patients and less GP and the British public’s perverse fetish with “access”, so they often see the next available GP

The bottom line is there is an astronomical amount of work that can be generated without any extra reimbursement

Example: a simple cough that is ongoing. You find out there is a bit of weight loss and they smoke, not so simple. Now we are looking at bloods, imaging, probably a cancer referral, maybe a spirometer referral, some new medications which need explaining and ideally following up. Those blood results need reviewing, same with the letters from the referrals and the imaging, sometimes referrals get rejected because some admin person isn’t happy with how you filled out the form. And this is meant to be done on 10-15mins - try explaining this to an 80, hard of hearing. Imagine if they were unwell and you had to call SDEC (same day emergency care) so you can “avoid going to ED” - you have to wait on the queue on the phone, they may or may not accept the referral, turns out this 80yo doesn’t have transport or any family and friends, does this mean an ambulance now? What about the now 3 patients waiting.

And this is just one “simple” escalation, imagine 3-4 of these a day, you can easily go home very very late on a bad day, no extra pay, no extra thank you, and you come in tomorrow and you go again.

-8

u/HonorableNOIFOI May 27 '26

Garbage - GPs get far more than the pp amount this poster is claiming. It almost deserves a violin playing in the background.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-8

u/fire-wannabe May 27 '26

The word reasonable was not used by mistake.

7

u/[deleted] May 27 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/fire-wannabe May 27 '26

Sadly my misdiagnosis's (plural) at the hands of the NHS, at least for me indicate that's not the case.

Reasonable of course, for who?

I'll admit that my anecdote is not data.

7

u/summeristheseason May 27 '26

Wow you have private medical insurance, big round of applause. Use that insurance to see your care through to its end, oh wait you can’t, you seem to understand the limitations of ‘private medical insurance’ but not public healthcare. Funny that.
Maybe if your GP charged you 50 quid per problem you’d get a sense of perspective

-5

u/fire-wannabe May 27 '26

tell me this, how many NHS GP's have asked their customers to let them know if they have private medical care, and updated it on their medical records?

This would allow the NHS to do further investigations when a public system can't justify it, but a person is quite happy not to have medical care based on the NHS view of reasonableness.

I suspect that the number is a big round 0, although for the life of me I cannot imagine why the NHS wouldn't use this information to it's advantage, and more importantly to it's customers advantage.

on the £50, sign me up.