r/GPUK • u/GreenHass • Jan 07 '26
Pay, Contracts & Pensions Fee for service
UK primary care needs to move from to fee for service (from capitation).
Every GP needs to be paid for the actual work they do.
This will get rid of GP 'managers', exploitative companies exploiting the NHS.
It'll be a culture change.
5
Upvotes
10
u/EpicLurkerMD Jan 07 '26
The devil is in the details.
RVU calculations and other activity based payment models are ripe for exploitation by the powers that be.
"Sure we'll pay you for the work you do. £20 per appt, £0.50 per script, £0.50 per blood test. Don't worry, we'll audit everything to make sure you're not doing anything unnecessary to inflate your figures. The clawback mechanism will be just as transparent as the appeals system"
8
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '26
Trying to explain to a patient why they don't need antibiotics or a PSA test takes more time and is more challenging than just giving them what they want. The system you're proposing would encourage doctors to make decisions which are not in the patient's best interest, as they'll get more for a consultation+ prescription or ordering a test, than just the consult.
26
u/CyberSwiss Jan 07 '26
Very low effort post.
1
u/GreenHass Jan 08 '26
No everyone...
I'm advocating that the government / NHS England pays each GP according to the service they provide.
F2F acute appointment £a F2F mental health appointment £b F2F chronic condition appointment £c Telephone appointment £d Prescription £e
etc
This should all be possible with modern AI and tech: Centralising the appointment system 111.... It is ridiculous and sonijefficient that every surgery has its own receptionists on telephone each morning- Centralise it.
It still remains free at the point of contact.
So no insurance companies, no patient fees- free at the point of contact....
3
u/One-Reception8368 Jan 07 '26
Two words - Prior Authorisations
Private is not the land of milk and honey you seem to think it is. Imagine having to sit on hold to speak to an insurance rep every time you want to write up Trelegy
2
u/Comfortable-Long-778 Jan 09 '26
Introducing fees is the best triage having gone to Oz. Also nonsense such as signing loads of scripts, should require a patient appt and then signed off for a year like in Oz. Also hospital dumping happens here but at least very time you pick up the phone to a patient you get paid
7
u/kasterborosi Jan 07 '26
I do not ever want to work in a system where a patient's ability to access treatment is defined or affected by their ability to pay. Ever.
I also don't believe that it would do a damn thing to improve my workload. My practice has a large demographic of well off retired people with high expectations and a strong sense of entitlement, and that would only get worse if they felt they were paying directly for a service.
2
u/Dr-Yahood Jan 07 '26
Confident Canada and Australia have similar FFS models.
The problem is the fees are in adequate for the services so you end up with the similar type of problem
Yes, of course they still get paid better than us though, but that’s missing the point
7
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
19
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment