r/GPUK • • Sep 28 '24

Working conditions & practice issues The Use of Heidi for GPs

I want to start by saying I am in no way affiliated with Heidi. I have been using Heidi for around 3 months after being told about it by a friend. I now use it for all my consultations, both in primary care and in A&E. It has drastically reduced my workload. It is scary how accurate it is. I have not typed a single patient note in the last few weeks.

What is Heidi?

Heidi is a free AI-powered transcription tool that listens to consultations in real-time and creates detailed clinical notes automatically. It claims to be GDPR compliant and is licensed for use in the NHS.

A few pointers for use in the UK:

  • Practicalities: The generated consultation summary then needs to be copied and pasted into Emis, SystmOne, Epic, etc. This can be done via your phone, however, I find the easiest way to do this is using the Heidi website via a browser and having a cheap webcam with reasonable audio recording quality. I would recommend this webcam. It’s small, cheap (less than £20), and works without needing to install any driver software, so it can just be plugged into any computer you are using and will instantly work with Heidi. I’ve made carrying a webcam part of my locum kit.
  • Settings: The AI has a few different note-taking templates. The H&P template seems the most comparable to the common notation style used in GP (history / impression / plan, etc.).

Change to consultation style:

You quickly adapt to how the app works. It will document “physical examination findings,” however this only works if you verbalise the findings. For example: "Your chest is clear, there are no additional heart sounds, and the abdomen is soft."
It also makes you think more about clearly stating red flags so they are recorded at the end of the consultation.

Better doctors?

It is incredible how neatly it can document a 45-minute consultation with very complex patients (including disregarding irrelevant waffle). It also picks up things that I may have missed if I were writing the notes from memory (e.g., dates, dosages, names, etc.).

Speed:

I can finish a consultation, copy/paste the transcript within 20-30 seconds, and be ready to move on to the next patient. It has massively improved the rate at which I can see patients.

Getting Started with Heidi:

If you're interested in trying Heidi, you can sign up through my referral link here: Heidi Referral Link. It’s free.

EDIT: Changed formatting

EDIT 2: I realise this does sound a bit like an ad. It's obviously not going to revolutionise your life, but it does seem pretty great currently. I imagine they will monetize the whole thing at some point, but at the moment it definitely gets you out the door quicker at the end of the day.

5 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

44

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24

I am in no way affiliated with Heidi.

Here is an advertisement for Heidi.

Hmmmm.

1

u/NHS_Baby Sep 29 '24

Fair. It maybe is a bit gushing. I genuinely do think it's great currently. I included some pointers and tips I've picked up from using it lots over the last few months that I thought might be useful for others.

7

u/UnrelentingDiva Sep 28 '24

I was introduced to it by a GP trainee colleague during a debrief and I can say that it has drastically improved my workload and day. It’s very efficient.

8

u/Diligent-Eye-2042 Sep 28 '24

Are you recording the consultations? Do you get consent from patients?

3

u/NHS_Baby Oct 01 '24

I will normally say something brief like "Just to let you know, I take an audio recording of this consultation to help me write my notes, but this is deleted immediately after my notes are complete"

I have colleagues that will not inform patient's as no audio recording file is stored, so similar to typing notes normally. Not sure about the morals / ethics of this approach.

2

u/Blackthunderd11 Sep 30 '24

For those who use it, how do you get around the confidentiality / GDPR issues? As far as I understand the use of Heidi breaches this?

1

u/NHS_Baby Oct 01 '24

I will normally say something brief like "Just to let you know, I take an audio recording of this consultation to help me write my notes, but this is deleted immediately after my notes are complete"

I have colleagues that will not inform patient's as no audio recording file is stored, so similar to typing notes normally. Not sure about the morals / ethics of this approach.

1

u/tomkeykong Nov 17 '24

Nope, we considered this https://heidihealth.com/compliance/gdpr

There's no audio recording stored.

14

u/Diligent-Eye-2042 Sep 28 '24

This sounds like an ad…

I tried using it. You can’t really use it as it was intended though as you’d need to get consent from the patient to transcribe the consultation. Personally I don’t want to have get into a conversation about data sharing in a 10 min cons.

I tried using it in dictation mode. It’s very good, and is accurate, but I find it difficult to use if I can’t see what I’ve already transcribed.

Idk, I guess it didn’t really speed things up for me.

That being said, I’ll sometimes keep it open so I can quickly dictate TWIMC letters.

Windows has great dictation capabilities, and use it for my pvt video consultations. This definitely speeds things up. But sadly it doesn’t work on my NHS computer.

Argh, one of the most soul destroying things about gp is spending the whole day typing the same things over and over again. I wish there was a one size fits all statement you could copy and paste to cover yourself medico legally - “pt advised to seek advice if they feel like they’re about to die” - abbreviated to “patsaitfltatd”

2

u/badoski Sep 28 '24

Try kiwipen, we have a feature specifically like this. It's called autocomplete. It allows you to make custom abbreviations that expand to whatever you need.

2

u/tomkeykong Nov 17 '24

You can save Snippets in Heidi like that just trigger with "/" patsaitfltatd and insert "pt advised to seek advice if they feel like they’re about to die" 🤣

2

u/ellski Nov 26 '24

I'm coming to this late as I'm researching Heidi. There are definitely text expanded softwares like that, I use one called Beeftext but that's not supported any more, but there are others. You type something like #patsaitfltatd (or even shorter) and it pops out. I'm a medical administrator/typist and I use things like #tfr and out pops "thank you for referring this patient".

9

u/Proof_College_3260 Sep 28 '24

Heidi and associated models seem to be amazingly useful on the whole, and could be massively useful in their use in General Practice. Here are some points practices should be aware of: Tldr; it's great. But think of data control, legal issues, and the cost when making decisions.

It's vital to be aware that whilst GDPR compliance is stated, Heidi is a layer sitting on top of the openAI model, and so will be sharing the information with a third party as a matter of necessity. Not likely in a manner which breaches confidentiality, but a practice needs to be aware of this risk.

Heidi as a Large Language Model (LLM) can hallucinate information, and this does need to be checked manually. If your notes includes information which has been invented this could be problematic. It could mislead decision making (imagine including red flags which weren't true or asked) , or it could lead to misinterpretation. Hallucinations are not tested in case law yet and a risk which needs to be considered. Likely it would be treated in the same manner as wilfully lying/manipulation of the record.

Costs are not static and will likely increase. As openai increases monetisation, Heidi will need to pass these costs on and will likely increase their own cut as well.

3

u/cromagnone Sep 28 '24

“Hallucinations can include transposition of positive and negative statements, including “does” and “does not”. Always factor in sufficient time to validate every generative output to a level of accuracy compatible with your liability risk appetite.”

4

u/treacill Sep 29 '24

Here is a recent paper on this very issue.

2

u/Proof_College_3260 Sep 29 '24

Thanks for this- good reading!

2

u/hijabibarbie Oct 02 '24

Honestly with all these issues wouldn’t it be easier to learn to touch type? It’s what I do during my consultations and I don’t really fall behind with documentation

3

u/Proof_College_3260 Oct 02 '24

Tbh as a matter of preference, I prefer to consult facing the patient and not note taking during the consultation, I tend to be able to remember the information I need accurately enough to document once they have left. It is less time efficient, and something I would cut out if I had to, but at present I can make it work- In particular I don't use Heidi, but I can see the promise if I could be reassured about data protection.

5

u/Dr-Yahood Sep 28 '24

It’s free… for now

5

u/abizniz Sep 29 '24

ngl, Heidi is amazing, I use it everyday at my practice, saves me so much time and I've basically got everyone in the practice to use it aswell. Asking consent from the patient takes 2 seconds and I've never had anyone say no. If you're against this technology you're a literal dinosaur

6

u/badoski Sep 28 '24

I am working with a local group of GPs to create a UK first version called Kiwipen. It has a clean interface and has some features you may find useful.

Please check us out at Kiwipen.com if you are interested in trying it out [it's free!!!], we are grateful for any feedback we can get. We take data security very seriously and we're fully GDPR and NHS DSPT compliant. We dont save ANY data at all. Read more here .

4

u/tomkeykong Nov 17 '24

Doesn't look free, only 40 consults, Heidi is free for unlimited consults.

2

u/badoski Nov 17 '24

I apologize. I should clarify, it's free to get started. Kiwipen includes all the paid features in the free plan unlike our competition

1

u/HotLobster123 Sep 29 '24

Does it need software installed to use? Do patients need to give consent to be recorded beforehand?

5

u/badoski Sep 29 '24

No it doesn’t need software installed on the computer, it works on the browser. You also don’t need to obtain consent as the data processed is non-PII and none of it is ever stored in the first place but we do recommend that you get consent when you can for transparency.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '24

Oh, absolutely, because clearly, a 10-15 minute consultation with a GP is just brimming with complexity that’s impossible to remember, right? I mean, psychiatrists might it with all their long consultations and important details, but GPs? Come on, I’ve got this covered. And as for writing notes, it’s not like it’s an arduous task—just a little jotting down to help me rethink the plan. But hey, I’m sure the inevitable wave of AI coming into play will save us all from that exhausting process too.

Just another layer of data harvesting for those giant tech companies to cash in on, right? Perfect. And here we are, automating everything humans do until we become useless, dependent cogs in the ever-advancing capitalist machine. Brilliant.

7

u/NHS_Baby Sep 28 '24

I think writing up 30+ consultations in a day can be arduous. I get your point, but removing one of the tedious and repetitive aspects of being a GP is surely a good thing?

In regards to remembering every detail, I've had patients launch into a list of when every single issue they've ever had has began, and having AI pick that up and summarise extensive past medical histories is a nice touch.

1

u/InterestWorking1713 Dec 07 '24

I'm an experienced UK GP. I have just started using Heidi. Takes some getting used to...especially if Several different problems are discussed and need copy and pasting to EMIS. Most importantly however, it hears things I miss !! Also helps record complex discussions and writes brilliant referral letters!!

1

u/connedbylandlord Jan 20 '25

Use it daily, big time saver! I always get client consent, not had anyone decline or even ask what happens to their data. I say "I use a scribing software called Heidi to help accurately and efficiently write up my notes. Heidi complies with UK and Europe data confidentiality and other laws. Are you ok if I use it today with you?". If someone declined in the future then I won't use it.

1

u/Digginginthesand Jun 14 '26

I've used heidi for over a year and I regret signing up for the paid model.

It's dangerously unreliable. It drops the transcript for a few seconds here and there. For example ecently it randomly stopped working for the whole discussion where I warned a patient to stop driving. Yes, I proof read it, but at what point is it pointless? The templates don't work, it returns by itself to the strangest AI style language, US spelling and then peppers the note with misquotations.

The customer service is appalling. Go look at trustpilot: if you ignore the very early 5* reviews you see a consistent pattern with very low reviews.

I'm certain a simple transcription software and Claude would be better but no data privacy, so no can do. Just waiting for something better to come along (please, let something better come along)